yes, at least for the billionnaires who won't have to worry about cancer any longer.
Regardless... All that is a huge "if", and I'm personally skeptical.
Kurt Vonnegut (Jr) wrote about this in more than one book. Someone good at dancing or singing or storytelling or sketching goes from performing that work for grateful family, friends, and community members, and maybe even making extra money or a living at it, to doing it alone (assuming motivation doesn’t collapse when nobody else cares) and always feeling like they’re bothering and being patronized by anyone they show their work to. The need for that kind of thing was scaled from enormous and constant, to so rare and small that it’s more something indulged than eagerly enjoyed.
Vonnegut seemed rather worried about what psychological harm this had done to countless people who’d love to feel their work, even if not world-class, was really wanted or needed.
I do feel like you can take this kind of thinking too far. Like, I am glad that we don't live in the kind of dangerous world where wandering into an unfamiliar forest could lead to all sorts of ways of dying, even though that means I also don't need close personal relationships with warriors. Incidentally this is one reason I think that Tolkien's work still feels so relevant; it's a world that on a slow and inevitable decline which makes the characters struggling against that to carve out something decent for a while feel paradoxically more heroic.
I like to think that we can choose to do bigger, more beautiful, more ambitious things with our time when we don't have so many basic needs that we're spending our time taking care of. I guess we'll see.
The agent would not care about you specifically anymore. Does nature know what you want to build? Does nature care? It doesn't.
Enjoy your little reign while it lasts. Everything points into the direction that humans prompting AIs will just be a temporary thing.
Who is speaking about this? Why is this relevant to bring up here at all? We don’t live in a world where this is a live possibility. We currently live in a world where a terrible job market is slowly destroying people’s lives, people who very much still need money to live and will for the foreseeable future.
I agree that death of meaning is a tragedy, but I also think a lot of us can find plenty of meaning beyond our jobs.
In an optimistic theoretical world where AI took my software dev job but I was sustained through some form of UBI I'd spend all my time doing things I do now in my spare time like volunteering at animal rescues and I'd be perfectly happy and find plenty of meaning in that volunteer work.
Alas, I do not think it is likely that that is our future. Politically and economically we've shown no movement toward that, just empty words from some AI Lab heads trying to quell people's nerves...
So if/when AI takes my job I'll probably have to spend less time than I do now volunteering and spend the majority of the rest of my days trying to cobble together a meager living doing whatever I can. Or perhaps I will turn to a life of crime.
This is shortsighted and dumb, but in highly capitalistic societies like US its the ideal thing. Poor get even poorer and more desperate, middle class moves to poor and those few rich can have armies of modern slaves for next to nothing... what is there not to love right.
Every single person working on it in those labs is guilty. Stupid amount of money can blind even quite moral folks but money only gets you so far.
This a question I'd like to see the answer to. Or at least an attempt. Is anyone seriously trying to track software jobs, or knowledge jobs in general, to see trends that might be attributable to LLMs?
Our current modern society benefits from the suffering of things like the Industrial Revolution or world war 2 but I would have hated to live through those transitional times and, if I had a magic wand choice I'm not sure I'd force others to do so in my place in order to have the benefit built upon their suffering.
I suspect these companies will fare just as well, only with far compressed timelines. Things move much faster nowadays.
It means that I've seen the ruins. They're high-end flats now. I guess people who were working in SV in 2000 can say the same thing.
If you read about life in the early industrial revolution it was a nightmare.
That is certainly not a time you want to be born. There was also no real payoff for your kids or grandchildren. The payoff was so long after.
Almost surely people 100 years from now around the globe will have higher standards of living because of technology but this level of change we are all going to have to deal with is not going to be fun.
You can always find another sense of purpose, take up a sport or something. Become good at fishing. Maybe you’ll be a bit listless for a couple of years - much better than wasting away from bone cancer.
If I'm a subsistence farmer in Burkina Faso I will get far more meaning from my work than any western white-collar worker - if I don't do what I do then my whole family will starve to death - but that doesn't mean that it would be bad if they got the money to not have to do that.
And being listless is a best case scenario when you lose your career. It's far more likely that they'll end up homeless, especially in the US where there's no real social safety net. That's not even mentioning health insurance, which is life or death for many. Bring any children in and the scenario is even more grim. I'm not seeing how this is worth it.
I don't think that there will be widespread permanent unemployment and homelessness from AI. Politicians need to win elections, it's political suicide (or potentially actual suicide if they let it get bad enough) to simply let there be another Great Depression. If AI takes someone's job exactly there is still the same amount of economic activity being generated - there will be far more appetite for redistribution, or at least some kind of new WPA.
As with the destruction of journalism. It bites you in the ass in ways you never expected. The people get angry.
I would love nothing more than to be a househusband, to take care of the kids, to keep the home clean and tidy, and to cook dinner for the entire family.
If you're my age or a bit older, the statement would have been true before 2020. Just replace "AI companies" with "SW companies". Or even just "technology."
My (now retired) math professor hated computers. "In the old days, I'd write my tests/exam on paper, and the department secretary would type it up (with appropriate math symbols). Now I have to do it myself on the computer."
Phone operators at switchboards were a thing.
Humans, and many animals at that, need some purpose. Without purpose we wither and die.
The 40 hour braindead and soulless job will not be missed, but many other jobs will be missed. Remember the famout mouse experiment. Give the mice colonly everything they want and need, and they will eventually die out of a kind of boredom.
My own hope was re-established on Open Weights AI levelling the playing field, but they've managed to steal the global chip supply, undermining that too.
I'll go out on a limb and say, even if AI does cure cancer (a big if), was it really worth the loss of meaning/purpose for millions of people along the way?