News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by easterncalculus on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:30PM (#50565922)
81 comments so far (82 as of now) and I haven't found one that is actually about the papers or even TFA. What are we doing here?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by LeoPanthera on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:35PM (#50565984)
The intersection between physicists and hacker news commenters is probably quite small.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by easterncalculus on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:42PM (#50566068)
I get that, but I think we can try. I know there are at least some physicists here, from other threads about AI and physics, but we could at least talk about what this article is.

For example, the metaphor they give about walking from Penn Station to the High Line comes off as somewhat out of touch.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by willyg123 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:45PM (#50566112)
There was a time not too long ago when I'd learn a lot from HN comments on posts about physics.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by numbsafari on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:51PM (#50566185)
There have always been a lot of armchair physicists on HN.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by fooqux on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:29PM (#50566662)
And now with the power of LLMs, we can all be armchair physicists! The future is now.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by jodrellblank on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:43PM (#50567567)
r/LLMPhysics is waiting for you.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by davrosthedalek on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:01PM (#50567065)
There is at least one non-armchair physicist on here.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by sunrunner on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:42PM (#50567560)
I'll have you know I only ever do physics while lying in bed.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by pwndByDeath on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:19PM (#50568492)
Inelastic collisions?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by cluckindan on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:48PM (#50568733)
3-body problem?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by sunrunner on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:52PM (#50568766)
Complex harmonic motion, with a little friction and the occasional loss of momentum.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by order-matters on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:15PM (#50567230)
when i first discovered this site i spent most of my time in the articles themselves because i had no idea how much or little to value the comments

nowadays i open the comments first and often dont open the article at all

i dont think this is a good thing, but i do find it interesting. I think a big part of it is how often i would read an article and develop a bunch of thougths about it and then come into the comments and see someone correct a fundamental premise of the article rendering all of my thoughts kind of useless as they are all based on misunderstanding and so i would start checking the comments to see if the article had been 'overruled' so to speak before i waste my time on it. this seems to have slowly shifted me to not knowing if the articles are even worth reading to begin with

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by car on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:05PM (#50567108)
All PhD physicists I know are hardcore coders, like AI and quantum. But you may be right in that they have better things to do than hang out here.

The German software giant SAP was jokingly dubbed "Sammelstelle arbeitsloser Physiker": agency for unemployed physicists.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by mr_mitm on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:17PM (#50567255)
I'm a PhD physicist and don't have better things to do than hang out here.

The article is still over my head though.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by lukan on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:34PM (#50568613)
"The German software giant SAP was jokingly dubbed "Sammelstelle arbeitsloser Physiker": agency for unemployed physicists."

Never heard that, but it explains some UI and UX choices.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by annzabelle on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:44PM (#50568698)
A ridiculously high proportion of Germans I have ever met in my life are physicists or other kinds of PhD educated researchers.

I'm not sure if that's sampling bias, but it's not true of the Dutch or Belgian or French people I have met.

As far as I can tell, the entire German economy is an agency for unemployed physicists.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by Quarrel on Thursday November 19, 2026 @08:47PM (#50569142)
Almost all the ones I know work for hedge funds.. sadly.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by tempest_ on Thursday November 19, 2026 @10:30PM (#50569802)
All the code I have seen written by academics, PhDs especially is some of the worst code I have ever seen aha. All finished the night before some deadline for submission and "works" on their machine.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by pamcake on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:37PM (#50566004)
Good, thanks. How about you?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by pbk1 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:18PM (#50566519)
OP said 'what are we doing' not 'how are we doing' :P
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by pfannkuchen on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:20PM (#50566534)
He's doing some kind of charity work.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by CoastalCoder on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:16AM (#50571670)
Well played.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by apsurd on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:00AM (#50570727)
how are we going?!

love the Aussies

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by waltbosz on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:22PM (#50566552)
Superman does good; you're doing well.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by ratelimitsteve on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:47PM (#50566919)
the question was "what are we doing?" and "good" is a valid answer.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by warkdarrior on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:53PM (#50566980)
Can confirm, I am Superman.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by waltbosz on Thursday November 19, 2026 @08:42PM (#50569101)
Yes, but "Good thanks, how about you?" is a typical response to the question "how are you doing?". One would not respond in that way to the question "what are you doing?". So I think it is a safe assumption that the respondent misread the original question as "how are we doing?", to which the pedantic response would be a grammatical correction as the one I provided. Although in actuality I was quoting a television program.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by vibebingo on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:31PM (#50567428)
Technically that makes you a do-gooder.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by scrollaway on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:38PM (#50566022)
Well, it's really simple.

Most people here care more about defining what AI is and whether what it can do really is "physics", than about the advance of humanity.

I dunno, I'm not one to say "HN was better before", but I did get bored a couple of years ago with all the "akshually, it's not real AI until it can solve [this problem], anything else is just sparkling inference algorithms".

(And of course the goalposts get moved so often, they need an amazon prime subscription just for the free delivery)

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by easterncalculus on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:41PM (#50566044)
> I'm not one to say "HN was better before"

I would make a comparison to illuminate the phenomenon I'm seeing in the rest of this thread, but unfortunately there is a specific rule artificially preventing me from doing so.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by badgersnake on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:56PM (#50566247)
Rules are for breaking and HN used to be better.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by mh- on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:44PM (#50567586)
Don't worry, we all see it. Just not much point in talking about it here, I guess. I still manage to get sniped by a subthread occasionally like this one, though.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by caraig on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:25PM (#50568031)
Can it at least fit in the margins?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by ToucanLoucan on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:14PM (#50566461)
I mean FWIW, I came here to see if this actually happened, or if it's yet more marketing where a prompt engineer managed to get Claude to spit out an unreleased paper/in-progress theory/whatever from it's training data, and they're now calling it a physicist, as has happened like four times that I can recall right now.

It'd be cool if that WASN'T the case, but reality is often disappointing.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by Dylan16807 on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:00AM (#50570363)
> than about the advance of humanity

This is a ridiculous comparison, because that wouldn't be talking about the paper either.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by Toynbeeidea on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:44PM (#50566099)
me too
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by _s_a_m_ on Thursday November 19, 2026 @03:57PM (#50566259)
i wonder at this point anyways if all HN is a bot network
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by EA-3167 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:17PM (#50566505)
The physics of black holes is far beyond the typical education or capacity of people here to understand or discuss intelligently. Outside of the occasional expert post most of the “technical” talk here is limited to development of software at varying levels of intellectual rigor.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by thechao on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:40PM (#50566823)
Wait... our discussion of software development is supposed to include intellectual rigor? Fuck!
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by MichaelZuo on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:17PM (#50567950)
Yeah even under the technical posts… maybe 1 in a 100 comments contain some kind of smart, logical, coherent, synthetic analysis.

And that’s being generous.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by rramadass on Thursday November 19, 2026 @11:48PM (#50570300)
Ha, Ha! Nice and pithy; have an upvote.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by sh56s6 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @04:47PM (#50566917)
Vibing
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by Bluestein on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:57PM (#50567747)
You are right to push back!
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by twoodfin on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:39PM (#50568166)
Compare, barely three years ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37123792

The hn comment guidelines say don’t complain hn is turning into Reddit, but if dang and co. still believe that’s an “illusion”, they’re not doing much to combat it.

[dead]
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by monster_truck on Thursday November 19, 2026 @11:29PM (#50570177)
Yep!

There are numerous classes of things, such as reimplementations of utilities that already work quite well, on some convoluted protocol that doesn't seem to actually address any of the standing issues, which get rocketed to the FP every time, it's the same people spewing koolaid in the comments every time. You can't even ask what problems it actually addresses without getting attacked. Very strange

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by mathisfun123 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @10:48PM (#50569902)
> but if dang and co. still believe that’s an “illusion”, they’re not doing much to combat it.

They actually encourage it with their authoritarian enforcement of decorum (you're not allowed to criticize people for being wrong and etc). The result is everything turns into exultant startup-y bullshit.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by staplehorse6553 on Friday November 20, 2026 @02:40AM (#50571395)
<stonetoss.png> "Combat it?"
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by Jach on Friday November 20, 2026 @08:44AM (#50574557)
I think anyone who's been here since 200x has seen the decline, but it's not monotonic in all ways and also not solely in the direction of reddit. (HN continues to avoid some common reddit failure modes.) Some styles of comments seem to crop up over time everywhere though, so that no matter whether you're here, or on youtube comments, or reddit, or twitter, or 4chan, you'll see a lot of the same junk. I also think dang et al are doing some good things. For example, despite probably getting a bunch of upvotes this meta comment thread is now towards the bottom instead of the top (which is probably correct as this meta commentary we're engaging in is pretty low value and not about the actual submission) and a somewhat interesting reply from a physicist and its thread was re-parented to the top level and is higher up. But they could do more... One of my own peeves are "me too" comments that used to be reliably downvoted to oblivion, with the related class of axe-grinding pile-on comments that mark the replies to your comment. (Recently this thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50556533 seemed very odd to me. Sooooo many comments whose content is just "wow, this article is nicely written and funny!" and basically nothing else. I'm convinced at least half the comments are bots.) The community does take care of some low value meta commentary on its own: what do commenters expect but to get downvoted and/or flagged to death if they just leave comments insulting a theoretical average HN user or the overall site. Personally I'll always downvote complaints about downvoting. The way to get better commentary is to comment better stuff, or at least avoid polluting further. Your comment is at least a better meta one because it provides a point of comparison that was interesting to browse. There have been lots of interesting physics discussions here over the years, I don't think they're over.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by chunky1994 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:23PM (#50568523)
This is just untrue? At the time of your writing my comment was the third root comment and was about the paper. (Yours is currently the first root comment and mine is 4th).

So perhaps you are seeing what you’re biased towards, or you didn’t scroll past the first root comment?

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by turzmo on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:43PM (#50568683)
Physicist here. I don't have time right now to read the papers in depth, nor are the results directly in my area, but I would say a few things.

One is that there are a near-infinite number of "open problems" in physics because the surface area of research programs in theoretical physics is extremely large. Before I was in the world of physics, I would have thought that "solving an open problem" meant that physicists around the world would be rejoicing and discussing the result. In reality, other than for the big, field-defining questions, only a small handful of people might care about any problem being solved. That holds true even for the Millennium problems.

Even if I were to read these papers in depth and understand them, without talking to somebody that knows the area and what has been done in it already, I would have no sense of the significance. The way to assess significance is to see how the community responds. Only time will tell whether people care about these results enough to cite them, incorporate them in future work, etc.

And so, like many other people I know, I plan to ignore all of these results until somebody I know comes and tells me to check one out: the cost of assessing any of them is too high, and there are too many other papers to read.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by sashank_1509 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @08:41PM (#50569093)
Why is it so different in maths compared to theoretical physics?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by yk on Thursday November 19, 2026 @09:18PM (#50569370)
In physics if you have a important open problem, you can probably just throw numerics at it to compare theory with experiment. The mathematical insight on the other hand is there to illuminate what's going on in nature, which is a much more amorphous target than the lists of very concrete problems mathematicians have just lying around.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by hershkumar on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:05AM (#50570756)
I would actually argue that many open problems in physics are open because we cannot throw numerics against them to compare against experiment, and the major difficulty lies in developing methods that sidestep severe computational difficulties. (This is the foundation of much of modern nuclear physics for example)
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by mr_mitm on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:33AM (#50571798)
Many open problem in physics are open because we lack experimental data. No amount of numerics is going to help you. Finding a way to probe the right energy scales is usually the obstacle, or observing enough events of something, collecting enough data, to get a statistically significant result. Either that, or the equations are so complex that numerical calculation are completely unfeasible.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by yk on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:41AM (#50572829)
Yes, I wanted to describe the contrast within theory.If there is no experimental data then there is nothing to describe.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by utopiah on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:59AM (#50570718)
Funny you asked that, I was literally going to comment on how closed it seemed with https://github.com/teorth/erdosproblems/wiki/Disclaimers-and...
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by hershkumar on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:01AM (#50570735)
Is it? I’m pretty sure most mathematicians working on research level math are similarly tucked into specializations. perhaps the only major difference is that in physics the language and jargon differs (and this is purely anecdotally) more across subfields.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by _mjk on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:47AM (#50572864)
Maths starts from axioms / existing proven work, and extends knowledge with newly proven facts.

Theoretical physics starts from (incomplete) observation and compatible theories plus targets an open question. There often are many solutions, but the real question is, which one holds up if the broader field is examined?

Consider what happened to the observation of the Higgs boson? There were numerous string theory flavors, all (more or less) consistent with current observations, but predicting different mass for the Higgs. Clear path for elimination of a lot of previously "correct" models.

In that empirical approach, making experiments and comparing to old/current/future work is a necessity to judge a models in a given regime. In fact, it is the differentiating factor in maths and theoretical physics.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by bluerooibos on Friday November 20, 2026 @02:52AM (#50571472)
> significance

Presumably Anthropic wouldn't have chosen to work on these if the problems weren't significant?

This seems carefully timed with their IPO.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by okintheory on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:27AM (#50572717)
We're talking about it here. That's the point, right? Not whether physicists are happy.
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by j16sdiz on Friday November 20, 2026 @07:05AM (#50573574)
If I were them, I would choose to work on something headline grabbing, yet approachable.

Would spend some token on searching existing opening question for something easy, but very few people works on (i.e. the low hanging fruit).

I guess we can easily do thousands of low hanging fruit.

Next, sieve through them, try to find something headline grabbing and bundle them together.

Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by Pxtl on Thursday November 19, 2026 @08:43PM (#50569115)
But what color should we paint the bike shed?
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by mathisfun123 on Thursday November 19, 2026 @09:52PM (#50569572)
hn is a gossip column for years now
Re:Claude Fable 5.2 solves two open problems in the physics ... by netfortius on Friday November 20, 2026 @02:22AM (#50571272)
Yours included. And now mine