In fact, it is possible to decide to do something, like decline to have dealings with someone whos actions you find ojectionable, without any tribe having told you to do it.
I don't care how great someone's cakes are, if I also know that person kicks a puppy every day on the way to their bake shop, I will just get some other cake somewhere else or maybe even just live without cake altogether if that is the only source of cake in the world and I can survive without cake.
I'll tell you, there is no "tribe" telling me what to think about comments like this trying to present terms like "product-related" and "just tribal" as probably their favorite word "rational" they love to use any time they actually just want to be assholes but not suffer the stigma of it.
Totally laudable to stop giving money to people who will spend it destructively, and publicly openly hateful individuals essentially invite the boycott.
But more generally, I have the right to respond to whomever I wish, as many or as few times as I want. I am a busy person and don't have time to reply to every single comment. I'm not the main character here, with some sort of obligation to field questions or something.
I'm glad you recognize that I am being polite, however.
> Totally laudable to stop giving money to people who will spend it destructively, and publicly openly hateful individuals essentially invite the boycott.
Out of curiosity, how do we know that he will spend money destructively? Is this just an assumption that someone who has opinions you don't like will give money to politicians who share those opinions?
The big-corpo language about boards, leadership positions, etc is hilariously out of touch with how such businesses actually operate.
I don’t know why people on HN like to split hairs over this stuff. Technically this, actually that, free speech blah blah. This isn’t politics, go read some of the stuff he wrote in his post about Charlie Kirk. There’s a reason he deleted it and then has it removed from the internet archive. It’s embarrassing.
That's a function of who owns your company and who works for it. If the employees and customers didn't have a problem with what he said, the board wouldn't remove him.
Also, it's important to realize that some people would work for someone who says wild stuff on the right even if they don't fully agree with them. That's because most of the alternatives involve working for left-leaning companies that may force/coerce celebration of things that center-right people do not want to celebrate. People who don't have close relationships with people on the right don't understand how much people who are right of center on any issues dislike the forced conformity that exists in many/most large companies.
Can you make a real world example of this ever happening?
Seems to me the usual MAGA talk of getting mad about something completely made up.
I'm completely open to the possibility that it would affect the products, but here it seems like people just don't want to do business with someone that is politically unpalatable to them. That's their right, and I appreciate their making that clear here.
https://www.michaelnugent.com/2014/11/06/on-satire-sea-lions...
https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/of-course-the-sea-lion-is...
As well as an acknowledgement of those critiques from the original artist himself:
There's a trolling behavior wherein the troll makes constant bad faith requests for evidence/proof while maintaining an insistent pretense of civility. It's a common tactic and the word "sealioning" has come to be the word we use to label that behavior.
Do you have a better suggestion for a label?
There's nothing wrong with asking for evidence/proof while maintaining a pretense of civility. When a person labels this behavior bad-faith trolling, I don't take them seriously - indeed, I assume they have almost certainly lost the argument, and are mad about it, and this is why they're calling their opponent a bad-faith troll instead of calling them incorrect.
There are people who hold views so antithetical to mine that I feel no compulsion to reward them with my money.
People have a responsibility to not empower awful people by giving them their money.
be honest with yourself
interestingly the r-slur for the differently abled was considered MORE offensive back when he posted the tweets than it is now. the slur has made a big comeback for some reason.
I guess people who would refer to that as "protecting women's/girl's rights" would then be somewhat more likely to buy from his company?
Also, I would be shocked if a few percent of his company's revenue made it through his salary to his donation pool to the portion of his donation pool that goes to political causes.
The real question, I think, is does that disgust translate into causing effects in the world against their human rights.
Practical example: I find trans people almost exclusively weird and off-putting and I choose to support their human rights every time that's on the ballot. I wouldn't write a blog post about any of that though.
When people tell you who they are, believe them.
So you have to ask yourself: Do you want to increase this person's ability to influence the politics of your country?