No there's nothing wrong with asking for evidence/proof but there is something wrong with trolling by doing that. The intention matters and is not always clear. Shifting the burden of proof to ridiculous places is a very effective trolling strategy especially if you play innocent/civil while doing it
Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display
by JuniperMesos on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:21PM
(#50541829)
I do not in general believe people when they call people they are getting into an argument with trolls. I do not believe someone who says that their political opponents are shifting the burden of proof to ridiculous places. It's such an easy accusation to make, and so many of the people who make it are themselves badly wrong about the issue at hand and are clearly unwilling or unable to mount an effective counterargument.
There's nothing wrong with asking for evidence/proof while maintaining a pretense of civility. When a person labels this behavior bad-faith trolling, I don't take them seriously - indeed, I assume they have almost certainly lost the argument, and are mad about it, and this is why they're calling their opponent a bad-faith troll instead of calling them incorrect.