The 2011 Optimus Popularis keyboard [0] also had a very similar LCD screen innovation [1], and I think was the earliest good implementation of this sorta idea.
I think you can argue that it was largely derivative or reasonably innovative based on the fact that it had been done before (with even worse execution), but it hadn't ever been done at such a large scale, so it still felt very new to consumers.
[0]: https://arstechnica.com/staff/2014/01/stop-trying-to-innovat...
Apple did not invent or even popularize smart watches, fingerprint readers, Bluetooth earbuds, smart home hubs, VR/AR headsets, self driving, mobile payments, foldable phones, etc.
About 2/3rd of the Apple versions of these aren’t even the most popular in their category.
iPhone is maybe the only one that seemed wholly novel.
Previous generation going nowhere, just like that French hard drive music company, Arcos?
Palm and Blackberry, despite seeing the original iPhone and having 3 to 4 years to respond, they were utterly clueless and the same applies to Nokia. and Motorola. It was the OS. Google with the help of Eric Schmidt understood.
What was novel to Palm, BlackBerry, Nokia was the OS at the time within the iPhone all three were dumbfounded…
What the iPhone brought to the table is a UI optimized for using your fingers instead of styluses.
You could argue the exact opposite, iOS released as a more restrictive and limiting OS than pretty much everything from that era. The j2me apps scene was vibrant in its own geeky niche. What the iphone did was to show the non-geeks what their phone could do, only by pretending that only the iPhone could do it, and billions in marketing succeeded in that.
It was an incremental choice, but it was a bold choice that nobody other than hard-headed Jobs would have done. Common knowledge at the time was that tactile feedback was necessary for any serious use. Analysts thought it would fail because of the keyboard.
Even a year later, Google’s response with Android still stuck with a hardware keyboard.
That, like the GUI in desktop computing, is something Apple sniped the credit for: the LG Prada had an all-screen form factor, capacitative touch screen, and somewhat similar UI to the first iPhone, and was released four months earlier.
Not saying the iPhone didn't do it better or doesn't deserve its success. It just was the most popular, not the first.
Except it wasn’t. That form factor existed long before the iPhone (I had many such devices).
I’m looking forward to one company taking Linux and their own hardware, combining it as one, and selling it to the public as an easy to use product, and no, I do not mean being a parasite on someone else’s hardware.
If it was easy why is Microsoft failing to expand their reach in fact, Microsoft has problems when the playing field is level, how’s their team ups going? With Qualcomm/Nvidia going why are they laying off 60,000 people? Why do so many of their acquisitions go into the dumper in comparison to Apple.
Why is Apple the only big tech company or one of the few big companies that didn’t fall for what Sam Altman was selling AI wise who is making the rounds???
Apple has a tendency to want to try to make the best device and be the most profitable. They’re not interested in having the absolute market share (Wall Street still believes they should be cheap and sell clones) if they were they could be Samsung, HP, Dell or Azus.
I'd say Tim's biggest successes were Apply Pay, the Apple Watch (although this was originally targeted as a luxury item instead of a health/fitness device), AirTags and probably AirPods. Apple Pencil seemed inevitable. Vision Pro? Um, AR is kinda dead. Duo? I think the jury is still out on this in terms of reliability. But we've had other folding phones for years.
I'm still mad Apple has largely abandoned Touch ID. I despise Face ID. Give me, the user, the option. Put a sensor on the back of the phone, you know like Samsung has been doing since the Galaxy ~S8.
The tech community likes flashy gadgets but that’s just not going to cut it anymore.
It’s easy to forget that Apple’s services like TV+ are a huge success and an innovation in the business school case study sense. It’s not going to make gadget enthusiasts happy but Apple makes more of their money on services than on Macs and iPads combined, and the profit margins are higher.
Also, what Tim Cook did for Apple was turn Apple from a luxury/enthusiast/niche brand into a brand for everyone, and that is an innovative accomplishment in its own way. Again it just doesn’t look like product innovation because it’s business school case study type of innovation, largely in operations and product planning.
PA semi from 2008 to the time of Jobs death is really not at all what paved the way for Macs running on Apple Silicon. What paved the way for Apple Silicon is the subsequent decade of shrewd management of the bones of that acquisition, mostly after Jobs’ death, that allowed those chips to be worth putting in computers. You also don’t get Apple Silicon without Cook expanding marketshare enough to justify custom orders.
For the product lineup, the real Tim Cook era innovation were the less flashy products like the Apple Watch SE, MacBook Neo, the MacBook Air M1 being in Walmart’s inventory for $600 a few years back, the $329 iPad, iPhone SE, 16e, 17e, etc.
You can be mad about FaceID, though it’s ironic for you to complain about one of Apple’s legitimate proprietary innovations under Tim Cook, which can’t be replicated by other manufacturers, while you’re simultaneously wishing Apple would innovate more. No other manufacturer has a more secure form of biometric authentication. Maybe you don’t like it personally but it’s clearly well-received by consumers.
Rear-mounted devices are totally gone, two (2) in the last two years: https://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?nYearMin=2025&nYearMax...
Apple Pencil: 4 years after S Pen
HomePod: 4 years after Alexa
Vision Pro: 5 years after Oculus Quest
iPhone Duo: 7 years after Z Fold
You can say the Apple ones are better than the stuffs they copied from in whatever fanatical metrics you use, but those aren't evidence of innovation.
That said, any company would kill to have a product like the Apple watch, but Apple sold more iPhones last year than Apple watch has sold in its entire lifetime.
A lot of what you mention while cool that Apple have done those things, aren't particularly "WOW!" level stuff, they are just neat things.
I would argue that more damage has been done by having Metal in that it has ended up creating a moat between them and Vulkan software that came along a year later.
Also Apple silicon was started under Jobs when they purchased PA Semi in 2008.
Jobs wasn’t the person who spent a decade taking PA Semi’s heritage and turning it into a chip that beat Intel. That took years of consistency in engineering management, where every single year that team was pushing out annual improvements.
> but Apple sold more iPhones last year than Apple watch has sold in its entire lifetime.
This is not because the Apple Watch sells poorly, it’s because smartphone product volume is absolutely insane.