Why did Andy Warhol hold the copyright on his painting of a Campbell’s soup can?
Reasonable people have been disagreeing about where human expression begins and ends for centuries.
https://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/four-factors/
It is fairly explicit in saying that what AI makes for your is not copyrightable, the vague comes from how much work you need to do to make it your output and not the AIs. Too many people seem to equate "asking for something to be made" with "I made this!", as difficult as it will be to make a prescriptive rule about that which pleases enough people (you'll never please everyone) it would appear to be necessary unless we just accept the free-for-all "no one owns anything because it can just be copied, and the copies copied too" option.
I’ve encountered (many times) people talking about the copyright office as if they don’t support copyright of things touched by AI and I’m constantly correcting them that their guidance is driven by human expression (and not the tools used). It seems like a lot of people don’t want to accept that a reasonable premise is set because it doesn’t fit their agenda or outrage engagement.
"Translate my very detailed pseudocode into Ruby: <pages of pseudocode>": probably.
"Write me a game about a horse. Don't stop until it's finished. Make no mistakes.": probably not.
And unfortunately for us engineers, there's a very big, fuzzy, not-precisely-definable range in between of "I'll know it when I see it".
So slop doesn’t qualify for copyright. I’m not sure why you didn’t emphasize this one.
Having said that, it's important to point out, at least as far as attorneys have advised me, that notebooks do not protect you from copyright claims if an LLM generates a section of your code that is a verbatim (or near verbatim) copy of already copyrighted code. So if you're using llm's to generate something similar to some open source project somewhere, tread lightly. I assume using llm's to generate something similar to some proprietary software package would be less of an issue since the llm would never have had access to that software's codebase in any case.
I guess both?
In this case, the "webpage" is ChatGTP and a trillion dollars of investor money or whatever, so I'm guess they won't be held responsible, but I might, even though I'm arguably guilty of a far lesser crime.
Thus in some sense it's like purchasing stolen goods in real life. Sure it's a lesser crime than stealing it yourself. But doing so knowingly is still a crime almost everywhere.
A pawn shop might be a better analogy. Potential to buy cheap goods that could be stolen.
That might actually be a good idea in the future:
Stay away from popular programming languages.
Which makes sense. I cannot translate Harry Potter to another language and claim it is an original work.
It would make it harder to prove perhaps.
Does creatively hitting RETURN count? Asking for a friend.
Sometimes I prompt simply to save me typing.
One precedent is that it's not unusual for artists to practice by going to art galleries and sketching or drawing the art on display. It's a standard art student assignment. If that's not a copyright violation, an LLM doing something similar isn't.
Why? An LLM isn’t a human. Why should the same rules apply to it?
objects don't have legal entity status
They don't sell that exact work verbatim. It's part of their training as an artist. They don't sell their student assignment. It prepares to them to go on and create their own works, which of course, then they can sell.
In the same way the LLM is synthesizing new works based on training, not a 1:1 copy.
I'm not endorsing a particular perspective but you need to at least understand the argument if you're going to dismiss it.
If I have legal access to copyrighted artwork, the law permits me to train my skills by copying that artwork as long as I haven’t agreed not to.
If you want to pursue this digression, I would just caution you. Given how much information is "available" today I just really don't think this is a very compelling point. It seems quite obvious to me LLMs are a child of the internet, that is, of widely available data. They would have gotten sufficient availability at more or less the same pace eventually. It doesn't address the question of the copyright status of their own works at all to bring this up as if it proves something, because I presume you believe there are sufficient cases of theft in the training data to damn the entire effort.
Instead what is happening is people who can prove such violations of their own rights are suing and will be paid out, and the show will go on. Just like if a student downloads a PDF we don't expect to garnish their wages in perpetuity.
If data for a computer program is literally "training," then I'd like to see a proof that going to college is literally updating weights in a matrix to be processed by a class of computer programs.
I'd also like to rename "shooting people who annoy me" into "paying my taxes in full." That would do double duty, because I'd get to shoot people and my taxes would be covered.
> In the same way the LLM is synthesizing new works based on training, not a 1:1 copy.
This has nothing to do with the "training" argument. I can't reprint Harry Potter if I change every mention of Harry Potter into "Harry Cobbler." I also can't trade zip files of copyrighted material freely, although these don't resemble the original works at all. I can also, as a person, be trained to reproduce 1:1 copies of things. That makes it both indisputably training, and indisputably copyright violation.
The selection of paintings to be copied is particularly convenient because paintings can't be copied exactly (not even a photograph is an exact copy of a painting; it's the image of a painting that can hold a copyright, not the painting itself.) Texts, however, can be copied exactly, and many programmers began their own training by typing in programs from books with their own hands, which we were told would give us an instinct that would help us write our own programs. Those programs were obviously still protected by copyright, even when we typed them up ourselves.
People are playing propaganda games in order to pretend that the copyrights of LLM training material aren't being violated. They're rarely making logical or legal arguments. They just say something about a human learning and a computer "learning," and say since humans learn and own things that they produce based on that learning than computers should be able to "learn," and own things that they produce based on that "learning." It's a motivated word game, not a serious argument.
> A student goes and trains on preexisting work.
point is already shaky. Some of them kind of do?
I suspect this applies more to audio/visual than it does text or code.
Model vendors know this isn't fair use, given that they're self-censoring the training and/or generation of copyrighted materials by entities big enough to hurt them. As usual, the rest of us have no recourse other than bend over and take it.
> Model vendors know this isn't fair use
Pick a lane dude. Either it's possible for us to make legal analysis and best guesses or uhh "we have no idea it's up for the courts to decide!"
Yes we know it's up for the courts to decide. And people are making argument about what those courts will do.
That's how legal analysis works.
Yes, it is perfectly possible to talk about fair use and follow existing guidelines on it and the government has already make statements that this stuff is likely transformative.
Bullshit.
"…the [Copyright] Office rejects two common arguments about the transformative nature of AI training. As noted above, some argue that the use of copyrighted works to train AI models is inherently transformative because it is not for expressive purposes. We view this argument as mistaken. […] Nor do we agree that AI training is inherently transformative because it is like human learning. To begin with, the analogy rests on a faulty premise, as fair use does not excuse all human acts done for the purpose of learning." — Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 3: Generative AI Training, United States Copyright Office
Several points in that opinion/report (not a policy document) from the USCO also seem to be contrary to rulings like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild,_Inc._v._Google,....
A court has deemed this fair use. The transformation is obviously mechanical, though, unless you think computers are people.
That means I can't know if my AI generated code can be copyrighted unless someone takes it to court?
• What about non-ai code generators (such as https://heyapi.dev/)?
• And what about a code generator that is a hybrid? (So: Something like heyapi but with LLM/agents intertwined)
By which I mean deterministic outputs, not necessarily deterministic processing.
So LLM-generated code is fine as long as the temperature is set to 0?
Like if a competitor literally copied all of Spotify’s AI generated music and offered it for free, Spotify would have no recourse.
Maybe Spotify doesn’t care, but it’s something I hadn’t considered.
Nobody would Napster and steal that music. And people can generate similar music for very cheap. Nobody will license that music, say, to use on their game or movie soundtrack.
Spotify only uses it to water down costs for the many eyeballs, or rather earlobes, they have.
This is the part that needs to be defined either via court ruling or legislation. What constitutes "purely AI-generated material"? If I ask claude code to write a new OS kernel, and then write one comment on one utility function, or change a single variable name, is the code mine? Patent Law lacks a fine-grained model for defining ownership of code bases which are often a plethora of licenses and ownership.
https://www.copyright.gov/ai/Copyright-and-Artificial-Intell...
An excerpt, with emphasis mine:
• Questions of copyrightability and AI can be resolved pursuant to existing law, without the need for legislative change.
• The use of AI tools to assist rather than stand in for human creativity does not affect the availability of copyright protection for the output.
• Copyright protects the original expression in a work created by a human author, even if the work also includes AI-generated material.
• Copyright does not extend to purely AI-generated material, or material where there is insufficient human control over the expressive elements.
• Whether human contributions to AI-generated outputs are sufficient to constitute authorship must be analyzed on a case-by-case basis.
• Based on the functioning of current generally available technology, prompts do not alone provide sufficient control.
• Human authors are entitled to copyright in their works of authorship that are perceptible in AI-generated outputs, as well as the creative selection, coordination, or arrangement of material in the outputs, or creative modifications of the outputs.
• The case has not been made for additional copyright or sui generis protection for AI- generated content.
I am sure there will be many more legal battles and probably legislation about this to come.