News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Claude Delusion by ianm218 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:32AM (#50497310)
I find the authors point not very compelling.. Bill Gates was by all accounts an exceptional programmer at one point and then spent a long time evaluating software engineers. He seems like a natural person to gauge AI progress in coding?

Around when AI was getting much better at SQL I was writing SQL everyday at work and had been for years. I don’t think it would’ve been hubris for me to judge that it was getting really good and would shortly be super human at SQL. It would’ve been correct anyway.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:39AM (#50497370)
> Bill Gates was by all accounts an exceptional programmer at one point

Yes, but that point was in the 1970s, 50 years before he was evaluating OpenAI, and there were vastly fewer programmers in the 1970s, so "exceptional" then isn't necessarily exceptional now.

Re:The Claude Delusion by aaa_aaa on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:39AM (#50497371)
He was not an exceptional programmer.
Re:The Claude Delusion by StilesCrisis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:48AM (#50497465)
His code that we have seen has universally been good. It's written in a different era, with different constraints--"how much BASIC can one cram into 16K?"--but all computers ran on 8-bit microcomputer BASIC for a time, and Bill's was good.
Re:The Claude Delusion by PunchTornado on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:57AM (#50497536)
He wrote that about claude in 2025. Do you think now bill gates is an exceptional programmer? You take 100 random programmes today and bill gates would write better code than all? I doubt that he is now an exceptional programmer. Maybe he was, but certainly not anymore.
Re:The Claude Delusion by StilesCrisis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:02AM (#50497571)
I have no idea if Bill still dusts off the keyboard or not. I can't say. What I can say confidently: if you had a time machine and could pair up 25 year old me against 25 year old Bill, he'd win in a hacking competition.
Re:The Claude Delusion by xtiansimon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:18AM (#50497714)
> “You take 100 random programmes today…”

I’m not taking a side on Bill’s skilz. But you can’t compare the two populations so blithely.

There’s something like 6x growth in the industry from the 80’s to 2014 US Census alone. Worldwide growth is much greater.

That kind of growth speaks to public awareness. More and more young people aware of the industry and choosing a career in a known and established field.

I’m no statistician, but would it not be more like 1:7 in US. And by my little Google AI search, it might be 1:70 worldwide. Pick 10 programmers from 1980 and 700 worldwide today.

https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publicatio...

Re:The Claude Delusion by p-e-w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:49AM (#50497469)
I’d qualify this a bit by saying that in his time, it was exceptional to be a programmer at all. The barrier to entry was unimaginably higher than it is today.

I occasionally have to remind myself of that when I see 13-year-olds today do what I only did at 25. When I was 13, I was learning programming by typing in listings from flea market books, whereas today I’d use highly polished interactive tutorials. Of course people now progress much faster than at a time when it took 3 months of arcane research to make an Ethernet card work on Linux.

Re:The Claude Delusion by skydhash on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:01AM (#50497558)
Wasn’t Unix already a thing for years at this point? Also LISP machine and smalltalk.

Availability is a thing sure, which increase opportunities, but that’s not saying the talent spectrum is different.

Re:The Claude Delusion by smellf on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:20AM (#50497721)
Bill Gates was 13 in 1968, one year before Unix. I'm not even sure what it meant to be a hobbyist programmer in 1968. Writing Fortran on paper and taking it to a local university to run?

In any case the parent's point absolutely stands - I came up in the 90s too and learning to program or make computers do things back then was largely a matter of reading books and talking to people. You had to really want it, because you had to track down and sift through the information.

Re:The Claude Delusion by aerhardt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:57AM (#50497529)
He wrote software for controlling hydroelectric dams when he was still in high school. At a time where the tooling was incredibly worse than it is now.

What's your definition of exceptional? Because that fits mine.

Re:The Claude Delusion by caymanjim on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:12AM (#50497653)
Computers, programming languages, and software in general were simple back then. It didn't take much to program them. You couldn't do much with a few KB of memory and a single-core single-thread CPU with basic instructions.

It took some amount of talent to squeeze something useful into computers with those constraints, but the upper limit on complexity also put an upper limit on how exceptional anything could be.

Bill Gates is/was an exceptional businessman. His technical abilities were nothing special.

Re:The Claude Delusion by wongarsu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:23AM (#50497753)
By your definition, is John Carmack an exceptional programmer? After all, Wolfenstein3d is also simple, if you ignore the challenges of limited hardware and of being an early mover with few established reference points. Who from that time period would qualify?
Re:The Claude Delusion by bossyTeacher on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:49AM (#50497965)
Exceptional is a relative term not an absolute one. I dislike Gates but you can't simply argue that he was not technically exceptional because the primitive tools he used capped how complex the software he wrote could be from a modern perspective of software complexity. It is ridiculous. By the same token, any software anyone living can possibly produce pales by the standards of a 2090 dev.

The reasonable take is that Gates was an exceptional dev for his era for the things he did with the things he had.

Re:The Claude Delusion by aerhardt on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:57PM (#50510666)
A defense contractor on a large contract was having problems finishing the project and sought Gates out when he was still in high school. By the time he got to Harvard, he was taking graduate-level courses in computing.

But I'm not going to insist any further because after arguing that it was pretty normal for kids to go around and program controlling software for a hydroelectric dam system, I don't think there's much to reason with you.

Re:The Claude Delusion by zero-g on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:58AM (#50497540)
How do we define “exceptional programmer”? What makes a programmer “exceptional”?
Re:The Claude Delusion by chunkyguy on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:01AM (#50497556)
The benchmark is Ken Thompson
Re:The Claude Delusion by dreamcompiler on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:37AM (#50497857)
Be careful. I wrote an emulator for the IBM 7094 so I could run and understand Thompson's grep. It was...painful.

It's full of self-modifying code, so my emulator had to handle that.

Thompson's code is incredibly clever, and back when he wrote it self-modifying code was pretty common. But by modern standards it would have been a maintenance nightmare.

https://dl.acm.org/doi/epdf/10.1145/363347.363387

Re:The Claude Delusion by TMWNN on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:15AM (#50497686)
Gates and Allen wrote an 8080 emulator on the Harvard PDP-10, then wrote Altair BASIC for the simulated 8080, which worked on the first try on a real Altair without their ever having seen one, after laboriously entering it with toggle switches at MITS in Albuquerque. <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43579471>
Re:The Claude Delusion by Citizen_Lame on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:41AM (#50497392)
He was evaluation biology test though. Reading comprehension zero.
Re:The Claude Delusion by ianm218 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:42AM (#50497907)
The author talked about programming specifically after biology. Even so, if you got a 5 on say AP Bio back in the day and have kept up with biology (professionally in Bills case or as a parent).. it seems like you would be a natural person to gauge how good AI is at AP exam level questions.
Re:The Claude Delusion by ForHackernews on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:44AM (#50497411)
The author's point is that "better than you" doesn't mean "superhuman", it just means "usefully good".

If we assume that you're 95th percentile at writing SQL, it's going to be amazing when companies can just copy-paste the 0.95 SQL dev instead of having to pay for that expertise -- but it doesn't really mean that AI improvement is going exponential, or that we've reach the singularity, or that AI will cure all disease and end human suffering or any of the other nonsense you see AI boosters predicting on this website every day.

Re:The Claude Delusion by ianm218 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:17AM (#50497702)
Yeah I think the authors just mistaken. If you are top 5% or so in some skill and you see AI over a few years go from median to surpassing your skill level, you can use common sense and realize it’s going to get past the next 5%, and it has.

It feels like the author is making a bit of a big deal about bill gates declaring superhuman in January when it might take a year or so before it’s undeniable?

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:48AM (#50497459)
> Bill Gates was by all accounts an exceptional programmer at one point

Perhaps, but that point was in the 1970s, 50 years before he was evaluating OpenAI, and there were vastly fewer programmers in the 1970s, so "exceptional" then isn't necessarily exceptional now.

Re:The Claude Delusion by bossyTeacher on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:52AM (#50497993)
The sentence "X was an exceptional programmer" surely indicates that the exceptionality was in relation to his time period.

Are you going to say that someone like Salieri and Chopin were not technically exceptional because not that many people in the planet had a piano available?

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:16AM (#50498199)
> Are you going to say that someone like Salieri and Chopin were not technically exceptional because not that many people in the planet had a piano available?

There's a crucial difference: music has not become significantly more complex over the past 200 years. As far as I'm aware, pianos themselves haven't changed significantly since then. In contrast, computers and programming have changed dramatically since the 1970s. Whatever Gates did in the 1970s, it's not clear how 2020s Bill Gates, who stopped programming full-time decades ago, is qualified to evaluate contemporary programming.

Re:The Claude Delusion by kalenx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:16PM (#50499343)
You conflate two different arguments:

1. Can someone _who haven't programmed for 50 years_ correctly evaluate current coding AI, and 2. Is what made a good programmer in the 70s the same as what make is good today to evaluate current coding AI.

If someone did competitive bike racing in 1970 and stopped since then, he probably forgot a lot of things and is not a good judge on current cycling. But if he were to be magically transported from that time, I don't see what he would lack. Sure, bikes are different (and better), nutrition is better understood, and so on. But the core job is the same.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:43PM (#50499609)
> You conflate two different arguments: 1. Can someone _who haven't programmed for 50 years_ correctly evaluate current coding AI, and 2. Is what made a good programmer in the 70s the same as what make is good today to evaluate current coding AI.

I actually don't. See my other comment: "You're conflating two different things, (1) difficulty in principle with (2) practical knowledge and experience." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498280

> competitive bike racing

You cherry-picked an activity that depends primarily on the physical limits of the human body, which as far as I'm aware hasn't evolved significantly since the 1970s.

Still, training and sports science has evolved, as you note: "nutrition is better understood". Thus, I suspect that an exceptional racer magically transported from the 1970s might not be as exceptional now. Moreover, the Earth's population is larger now, and bike racing has become popularized by TV coverage, attracting more enthusiasts, not to mention more money, so the competition is now tougher. You can see this even more clearly in sports that were traditionally very white, such as golf and tennis: more non-white people are now competing in those sports, opening to a global population. At the top, the bar has been raised.

Re:The Claude Delusion by fluidcruft on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:53AM (#50498007)
Do you think programers in the 70s would be considered unskilled nowadays?
Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:00AM (#50498064)
> Do you think programers in the 70s would be considered unskilled nowadays?

Yes. C++ was created in 1985. JavaScript was created in 1995. I could go on and on. If a 70s programmer frozen in ice was unthawed today, that person would be unable to get a programming job.

The funny thing is that contemporary professional programmers who rely on Claude are already complaining that they've forgotten how to program, so how much could Bill Gates possibly remember 50 years later?

Re:The Claude Delusion by siva7 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:19AM (#50498227)
Sure as we all know writing those Javascript CRUD apps like what the majority of today's programmers do is so much more difficult than what those losers in the 70s did.
Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:26AM (#50498280)
> Sure as we all know writing those Javascript CRUD apps like what the majority of today's programmers do is so much more difficult than what those losers in the 70s did.

You're conflating two different things, (1) difficulty in principle with (2) practical knowledge and experience.

Could Bill Gates learn contemporary programming if he put in the time and effort? Perhaps. The point is that he hasn't. Although he was a 1970s programming expert, he's a 2020s programming n00b.

Re:The Claude Delusion by adrian_b on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:26AM (#50498279)
Any competent and experienced programmer who has learned a few diverse programming languages, even if those are only languages of the 60s, not even of the 70s, e.g. ALGOL 68, IBM PL/I, APL, LISP, SNOBOL, SIMULA 67, will be able to switch in a week or so to any other programming language of today, and reach the same level of competence as a programmer who has programmed only in that language for 10 years.

The job postings that require things like "5 years of experience with C++" or "5 years of experience with JavaScript" are really dumb, because anyone who really understands programming can do that in any programming language, after a few days needed to memorize its quirks, to avoid checking its specification continuously.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:33AM (#50498336)
> switch in a week or so

> after a few days

I disagree but consider the response too dismissive to even argue with seriously.

Re:The Claude Delusion by kalenx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:20PM (#50498752)
I think you're saying the same thing. A good 70's developer would likely not have a lot of difficulties to fit in 2020 software world, precisely because software engineering and its challenges did not change much, even if the environment in which you have to do so did change a lot.
Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:26PM (#50498836)
No, I did not say that. In fact I said the opposite of that.
Re:The Claude Delusion by kalenx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:11PM (#50499295)
Sorry. I thought you made the distinction between "knowing how to program" and "get a programming job". I disagree, then.

To quote another of your comments, you don't _think_ there is timeless programming skill. I do. Sure, there are areas of expertise (embedded, parallel, graphics, etc.), but the basic abilities (pre AI) stay the same.

I don't see why a good biologist, pianist, mathematician or scientist taken out of the 70s couldn't be good today. You seem to believe in some exceptionalism for computer science and software development. I don't see good foundations for this argument.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:25PM (#50499419)
> I don't see why a good biologist, pianist, mathematician or scientist taken out of the 70s couldn't be good today.

I would note that you've moved the goalposts from "exceptional" to merely "good".

> You seem to believe in some exceptionalism for computer science and software development. I don't see good foundations for this argument.

It's simple: computing changes and advances much more rapidly than any of those other subjects. I addressed this point in another comment: "music has not become significantly more complex over the past 200 years. As far as I'm aware, pianos themselves haven't changed significantly since then." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498199

When Bill Gates cofounded Microsoft in 1975, personal computers did not yet exist; the Apple II arrived in 1977. LLMs did not exist, smartphones did not exist, the world wide web did not yet exist, and the precursor of the internet was just getting started. The computing world was entirely different. Bill's previous programming expertise is now obsolete.

Re:The Claude Delusion by kalenx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:33PM (#50499491)
I still don't get it. I don't try to be obtuse, I just don't get it. Sure, internet wasn't a thing. What does it change? Is learning the concept of a socket so hard that an exceptional (or good, whatever) programmer of the 70s could likely fail at this? Are the web languages impossible to master for someone who did not grow with internet? Sure, no smartphone. And? Embedded was already a thing, and resources were infinitely more constrained. I guess you didn't have to write touch-enabled UIs. Again, something that an exceptional (or good) programmer of the 70s would likely not be able to learn?

How did exceptional (or good) programmers managed to stay relevant through those 50 years (which is just slightly longer than a typical career length)?

Note that LLMs are, in my opinion, a different thing. Similar to what cars did to horseshoes makers. You cannot pivot around this, however good you are.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:56PM (#50499725)
> Are the web languages impossible to master for someone who did not grow with internet?

Of course not. Everyone programming today was born ignorant of the internet, and of everything else.

"Could Bill Gates learn contemporary programming if he put in the time and effort? Perhaps. The point is that he hasn't. Although he was a 1970s programming expert, he's a 2020s programming n00b." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498280

> How did exceptional (or good) programmers managed to stay relevant through those 50 years (which is just slightly longer than a typical career length)?

By putting in the work to keep their skills current.

They were not "magically transported", as you put it in another comment, from the beginning of their career to the end of their career. They had to go step by step, methodically.

Re:The Claude Delusion by tuesdaynight on Monday November 16, 2026 @07:56AM (#50517110)
[delayed]
Re:The Claude Delusion by ponector on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:23AM (#50498255)
Today's programmers definitely would be considered unskilled in the 70s.
Re:The Claude Delusion by adrian_b on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:17AM (#50498205)
There were vastly fewer programmers in the 1970s, but there is no evidence whatsoever that the median skill or the top skill were lower than today.

The extra programmers of today have filled the voids in the distribution of programmers vs. skill, but in the best case for the present programmers they have not shifted the distribution towards a higher skill. If there was any shift in the distribution, it seems more likely that it was towards a lower skill.

I am pretty certain that any programmer who was exceptional in the 1970s would still be exceptional today.

Several decades ago, when I was very young, I reverse engineered a few Microsoft programs for CP/M, including the BASIC interpreter, the FORTRAN compiler and the FORTRAN run-time library.

At least the BASIC interpreter is likely to have included code written by Bill Gates. Given the hardware constraints, those programs were well written. They also included a lot of assembly language tricks that would not be used today, but which were justified in a program that had to run on very weak CPUs and using very little memory.

At that time, I considered those programs very instructive.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:39AM (#50498377)
1) Although I think there is timeless inborn ability, I don't think there is timeless programming skill, irrespective of advances in technology. We clearly disagree about that, though: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498336

2) With regard to timeless inborn ability, I think it's obvious that you will end up with higher achievers if you start with a much larger population all working on the same activity.

Re:The Claude Delusion by bihla on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:06AM (#50497607)
He also tries to dunk on Gates by saying he claimed he produced novel problems in science to test AI.

I don’t think the author realizes that “AP” is an exam for American high schoolers. Gates is only claiming he made new test questions at a high school+ level that wouldn’t have been in the training set for AI. I don’t see how it’s so unbelievable he could do that.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:37AM (#50497860)
> Gates is only claiming he made new test questions at a high school+ level that wouldn’t have been in the training set for AI. I don’t see how it’s so unbelievable he could do that.

It’s unbelievable because Gates is neither a biology exam author nor a biology textbook author, so how would he even know what‘s in the training set for AI?

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:57AM (#50498041)
> Gates is only claiming he made new test questions at a high school+ level that wouldn’t have been in the training set for AI. I don’t see how it’s so unbelievable he could do that.

It’s unbelievable because Gates is neither a biology exam author nor a biology textbook author, so how would he even know what’s in the training set for AI? To know, you would need to be an experienced biology teacher and survey the pedagogical literature.

Re:The Claude Delusion by ianm218 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:20AM (#50498229)
If you did well on AP Bio in the distant past and have kept up with the field of biology like Gates it is normal you could ask some high school exam level questions.

When I was studying for AP Calculus or Literature etc I’m sure I could’ve made decent sample questions.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:29AM (#50498298)
Nobody is disputing whether Gates could come up with some exam questions. They're disputing whether Gates could come up with novel exam questions that weren't in the AI training data.
Re:The Claude Delusion by Systemerror7A69 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:44AM (#50498413)
Especially because good questions are more than simply asking about factoid X in Book Y. Good questions test if you really understood something and can transfer knowledge.

Coming up with such questions is not easy, and just because you did well on a test or "kept up with the field a bit" does not mean you can ASK such questions very well.

Re:The Claude Delusion by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:38PM (#50499550)
Maybe he was into biology for a hobby. Would fit his character, much like half of HNers. And would fit the fact that he funded biotech R&D too.
Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:45PM (#50499619)
> much like half of HNers are probably near-experts in some random field they haven't had formal training in

More like half of HNs believe they're near-experts in some random field.

Re:The Claude Delusion by arw0n on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:24PM (#50499952)
This is the crux though, isn't it? Are people as overconfident as the article claims, or are there many 'hobbyist' experts milling around? I did a Bachelor's in philosophy before switching to CS, and have been fascinated by IR/political theory since high school. While I could not hope to learn it all, I can hold a good conversation with a researcher in either philosophy or IR, especially if it intersects with a topic of my core expertise.

To flip it around, I have friends who I would consider (hobbyist) experts in CS. The geneticist is much better at C++ and OOP than me, the geologist knows a lot about 3d modelling and the whole GIS world, and the economist knows way more about DS, AI and statistics. Who am I to say they aren't experts? This kind of rigid division of field and expertise made no sense in university, and it only breaks apart more as we get older and more experienced.

Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:45PM (#50500123)
> Are people as overconfident as the article claims, or are there many 'hobbyist' experts milling around? I did a Bachelor's in philosophy before switching to CS, and have been fascinated by IR/political theory since high school.

Heh, well, by coincidence, before I became a programmer I spent (too many) years as a PhD candidate in philosophy, and I'm skeptical about the extent to which undergraduates can be considered experts. ;-)

That was a long time ago, though, and despite my experience, I've undoubtedly fallen far behind the current work in the field.

Re:The Claude Delusion by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:17PM (#50502519)
Surely even undergrads know something, and knowing more than high-school curriculum - which is the bar we're discussing - isn't some particularly difficult achievement.
Re:The Claude Delusion by lapcat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:40PM (#50502703)
> Surely even undergrads know something

I should hope so, after paying so much tuition!

> knowing more than high-school curriculum - which is the bar we're discussing

No, that's not the bar you were discussing. Originally you said "near-experts", but now you've lowered the bar way down.

Re:The Claude Delusion by keeda on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:17PM (#50499900)
What if we flip this question around. Given what we’ve seen LLMs achieve today, if Bill Gates actually got an accurate read on their capabilities back then, what does that say about his expertise in biology? Maybe he got Dunning-Kreuger’d and made a lucky guess… or his assessment was accurate.

Given his track record and the state of AI today, I know which one I find more likely.

Re:The Claude Delusion by verdverm on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:13AM (#50498173)
> I find the authors point not very compelling. Bill Gates...

The message was more abstract, why focus on one (poor) example?

Re:The Claude Delusion by graeme on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:46PM (#50503493)
The article is a case of choosing and using an example so poorly, at length, that it casts severe doubt on the reasoning.

Take the claim of superhuman for example. If an AI is as good as Bill Gates at coding, but is relentless and tireless, then that is fairly called superhuman, the same way a drilling machine was superhuman relative to John Henry.