Are you going to say that someone like Salieri and Chopin were not technically exceptional because not that many people in the planet had a piano available?
There's a crucial difference: music has not become significantly more complex over the past 200 years. As far as I'm aware, pianos themselves haven't changed significantly since then. In contrast, computers and programming have changed dramatically since the 1970s. Whatever Gates did in the 1970s, it's not clear how 2020s Bill Gates, who stopped programming full-time decades ago, is qualified to evaluate contemporary programming.
1. Can someone _who haven't programmed for 50 years_ correctly evaluate current coding AI, and 2. Is what made a good programmer in the 70s the same as what make is good today to evaluate current coding AI.
If someone did competitive bike racing in 1970 and stopped since then, he probably forgot a lot of things and is not a good judge on current cycling. But if he were to be magically transported from that time, I don't see what he would lack. Sure, bikes are different (and better), nutrition is better understood, and so on. But the core job is the same.
I actually don't. See my other comment: "You're conflating two different things, (1) difficulty in principle with (2) practical knowledge and experience." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498280
> competitive bike racing
You cherry-picked an activity that depends primarily on the physical limits of the human body, which as far as I'm aware hasn't evolved significantly since the 1970s.
Still, training and sports science has evolved, as you note: "nutrition is better understood". Thus, I suspect that an exceptional racer magically transported from the 1970s might not be as exceptional now. Moreover, the Earth's population is larger now, and bike racing has become popularized by TV coverage, attracting more enthusiasts, not to mention more money, so the competition is now tougher. You can see this even more clearly in sports that were traditionally very white, such as golf and tennis: more non-white people are now competing in those sports, opening to a global population. At the top, the bar has been raised.
Yes. C++ was created in 1985. JavaScript was created in 1995. I could go on and on. If a 70s programmer frozen in ice was unthawed today, that person would be unable to get a programming job.
The funny thing is that contemporary professional programmers who rely on Claude are already complaining that they've forgotten how to program, so how much could Bill Gates possibly remember 50 years later?
You're conflating two different things, (1) difficulty in principle with (2) practical knowledge and experience.
Could Bill Gates learn contemporary programming if he put in the time and effort? Perhaps. The point is that he hasn't. Although he was a 1970s programming expert, he's a 2020s programming n00b.
The job postings that require things like "5 years of experience with C++" or "5 years of experience with JavaScript" are really dumb, because anyone who really understands programming can do that in any programming language, after a few days needed to memorize its quirks, to avoid checking its specification continuously.
> after a few days
I disagree but consider the response too dismissive to even argue with seriously.
To quote another of your comments, you don't _think_ there is timeless programming skill. I do. Sure, there are areas of expertise (embedded, parallel, graphics, etc.), but the basic abilities (pre AI) stay the same.
I don't see why a good biologist, pianist, mathematician or scientist taken out of the 70s couldn't be good today. You seem to believe in some exceptionalism for computer science and software development. I don't see good foundations for this argument.
I would note that you've moved the goalposts from "exceptional" to merely "good".
> You seem to believe in some exceptionalism for computer science and software development. I don't see good foundations for this argument.
It's simple: computing changes and advances much more rapidly than any of those other subjects. I addressed this point in another comment: "music has not become significantly more complex over the past 200 years. As far as I'm aware, pianos themselves haven't changed significantly since then." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498199
When Bill Gates cofounded Microsoft in 1975, personal computers did not yet exist; the Apple II arrived in 1977. LLMs did not exist, smartphones did not exist, the world wide web did not yet exist, and the precursor of the internet was just getting started. The computing world was entirely different. Bill's previous programming expertise is now obsolete.
How did exceptional (or good) programmers managed to stay relevant through those 50 years (which is just slightly longer than a typical career length)?
Note that LLMs are, in my opinion, a different thing. Similar to what cars did to horseshoes makers. You cannot pivot around this, however good you are.
Of course not. Everyone programming today was born ignorant of the internet, and of everything else.
"Could Bill Gates learn contemporary programming if he put in the time and effort? Perhaps. The point is that he hasn't. Although he was a 1970s programming expert, he's a 2020s programming n00b." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498280
> How did exceptional (or good) programmers managed to stay relevant through those 50 years (which is just slightly longer than a typical career length)?
By putting in the work to keep their skills current.
They were not "magically transported", as you put it in another comment, from the beginning of their career to the end of their career. They had to go step by step, methodically.
The extra programmers of today have filled the voids in the distribution of programmers vs. skill, but in the best case for the present programmers they have not shifted the distribution towards a higher skill. If there was any shift in the distribution, it seems more likely that it was towards a lower skill.
I am pretty certain that any programmer who was exceptional in the 1970s would still be exceptional today.
Several decades ago, when I was very young, I reverse engineered a few Microsoft programs for CP/M, including the BASIC interpreter, the FORTRAN compiler and the FORTRAN run-time library.
At least the BASIC interpreter is likely to have included code written by Bill Gates. Given the hardware constraints, those programs were well written. They also included a lot of assembly language tricks that would not be used today, but which were justified in a program that had to run on very weak CPUs and using very little memory.
At that time, I considered those programs very instructive.
2) With regard to timeless inborn ability, I think it's obvious that you will end up with higher achievers if you start with a much larger population all working on the same activity.
Perhaps, but that point was in the 1970s, 50 years before he was evaluating OpenAI, and there were vastly fewer programmers in the 1970s, so "exceptional" then isn't necessarily exceptional now.