Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by emidoots on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:10PM
(#50415087)
The brain asks:
> I am currently exhibiting overwhelming stress from deeply technical work being part of my every day life, and feel I am missing the 'nature' element of life. What should I do?
The brain responds:
> Gardening! A wonderfully complex system that will just 'live' without me! A delightful escape!
The brain asks:
> Yes, gardening! But how? There are so many variables! What are the parameters? Where is the specification outlining the success criteria? What defines a living organic system?
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by contingencies on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:14PM
(#50415120)
Hehe. I recently donated a whole bunch of plants to a school. It was amazing to me how naïve the principal and staff were about plants. I had to explain that, no, no preparation was necessary and yes, these plants would be fine once planted without any attention. In fact they had evolved for millions of years to live right here!
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by kokey on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:41PM
(#50415804)
Just pick one thing, learn to grow it for a season or two. It's incremental learning, a bit of making mistakes and learning from the mistakes and research along the way. The knowledge accumulates over time, and after a while you can manage food crops, flowers and timber if you want.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by mirpetri on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:23PM
(#50415193)
Gardening is expensive. Good I stopped at plants and didn't go for chickens.
Every year is different.
First you fight the snails on the strawberries.
Then the aphids on peppers and roses (this is each year).
Next the mold attacks the tomatoes.
And if you don't have enough, the starling will eat your blueberries.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by convolvatron on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:52PM
(#50419047)
I grow indoors. peppers, herbs, strawberries, tomatoes and cucumbers. snails might not get in, but once you get mites, and whiteflies and stinging gnats, its pretty much a constant struggle and a tradeoff between using really aggressive insecticides and chasing down infected plants. mites have been the worst, managed to stomp out the whiteflies and the gnats though.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by lukan on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:04PM
(#50419160)
Ideally I automate that part as well, with HD image processing and finding the source and either alerting me to do something or do it on their own (it probably will be a while, till I get to that level).
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by convolvatron on Monday November 09, 2026 @05:26PM
(#50433167)
with the mites, unless its a leaf that shows the bite marks very clearly, you really need to move the leaf and look underneath. actually even if the bite marks show, they mites are pretty clever, they like to live in little turned under sections so you really need to flatten it out and get in there. ideally you'd look for eggs which are pretty damn small. many plants will also self-interfere (tomatoes), so you get little tangles of leaves that provide great hidden living spaces for them.
>Crucially, there is a tradeoff between growth rate and growth quality. Higher temperatures can result in faster growth but also thinner stems, weaker roots, and less flavor.
Graphically, we should expect this quality optimum lies just uphill of the inflection point of the curve (between T_base and T_opt), yes?
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by johnthedebs on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:00PM
(#50415982)
I think the quote taken at face value is misleading, or may just be wrong.
In my own experience (quite a bit over the last ~8 years), if high temperatures (T_opt, not T_max) are accompanied by longer and more intense daylight as well as adequate water and nutrition, it will consistently result in thicker stems, stronger roots, and better flavor. And since higher temperatures in the summer typically coincide with longer days and more intense sunlight, this is the most common outcome. Lacking water or nutrition under these conditions, plants will usually stall their growth rather than grow thinner or weaker.
The only times I can think of that the quoted statement is true is with, eg, indoor seed starts that are given a warm environment with plenty of water and nutrition, but that lack sunlight or artificial light, or light-adapted plants grown outdoors in too much shade.
The clearest counter example that comes to mind is tomatoes, which IMO taste their best, and are by no means thin or weak, when they are growing the fastest.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by naejin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:29PM
(#50415722)
Growing food is very complex, probably too complex for our brains. And I believe we will have to learn again how to grow food without our current support systems one day. I'm building projectcanopi.com toward that goal.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by jack_pp on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:16PM
(#50416125)
maybe he means it's too complex for science to rediscover. maybe rediscovering/using ancient wisdom regarding this domain is better. but this is just intuition
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by naejin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:48PM
(#50417068)
To grow food in a truly sustainable way, we need to really understand the laws of biology at a macro and micro level (soil biology, water cycle, carbon cycle, etc...). If we don't do it correctly, in the end, we will end up in a dead end and join the 99% of species that disappeared since life exists on earth. Odds are against us but I'm working with scientists and professionals that are having incredible results.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by ghosty141 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:46PM
(#50417652)
> truly sustainable way
What do you mean by that?
> If we don't work on this correctly, in the end, we will end up in a dead end
We have over 10.000 years of agriculture already behind us so I think that's proof that it works well enough to support small communities in a sustainable fashion. It's simply not necessary to understand all the microbes etc..
If you are hinting on optimization so we can feed all of humanity, then I mean we are definitely not resource and knowledge limited but rather by more mundane things. I'd wager just the US defense budget is enough to feed to world without a problem.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by sophacles on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:21PM
(#50418035)
I don't really agree with the person you responded to, but there is a lot of agriculture that is dependent on mined input, having long depleted the soil of whatever nutrients were there when we started. There are many places that are abandoned and barren because we did agriculture there. Land is still being dramatically degraded by many types of agricultural practices.
Meanwhile there are forests that were forest (and other ecosystems as well) 10s of thousands of years ago and just as lush and fertile (if not moreso) than they were to begin with.
Sustainable generally means we can maintain the fertility of the land indefinitely without mined inputs. Whether or not it's a completely achievable goal, it makes good sense to strive for it... Mines will become spent, theres only so much land to degrade, etc.
Often when people talk about sustainable agriculture they are talking about systems that mimic biological systems that keep those forests lush for millennia. These types of agricultural systems frequently look similar to agricultural systems of the past with more human labor involved, but less damaging waste products and fewer externalities. (Reducing pollution of the water downstream and minimizing ecosystem impact).
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by ghosty141 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:49PM
(#50418340)
> There are many places that are abandoned and barren because we did agriculture there.
Totally but I'd argue nowadays it's not because we are missing the knowledge but rather ignorance and short-term economic gains.
Imo sustainability goes hand in hand with population (and lifestyle). We want a diverse ecosyaystem, this simply doesn't work if there are 10 billion people wanting to eat meat or produce tons of plastic. Our problem is not knowledge in agriculture that prevents us from sustainable living.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by naejin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:42PM
(#50416986)
I'm working with scientists and field practitioners to improve the tool to help them. And now it's growing thanks to my network: https://youtu.be/lC5ixsaGx-4 No one wanted to build that before AI because it was not cost effective.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by bevr1337 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:00PM
(#50417184)
I appreciate that your site even includes a bibliography. The UI is similar to the companion planting mini-game from Palia and that's appealing. The link between resilience and your project is still unclear to me. Is my perspective myopic or cynical? Thanks for clarifying.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by naejin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:12PM
(#50417302)
No worries. I have no ego in this project. The goal is to help future generations have food on the table even in countries that will have less access to oil and its byproducts like fertilizer. There is a growing movement in my country and others of people that are working towards being more robust. And they missed a tool to speed up design, sharing, learning and collaboration between researchers and field practitioners. They were mostly using pen and paper and custom excel sheets. I'm trying to fill that gap with a research approved database of plants, field oriented design tools, and now I'm starting to add algorithms to help improve hydrology using lidar data as this is one of the top features requested by users.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by bevr1337 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:27PM
(#50418093)
Thanks for walking me through the project. I was myopic. I was focused on "Can any future generation use this tool?" which is not as pressing as "Will we have arable soil?"
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by gamblor956 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:45PM
(#50418294)
So you read an entry-level college syllabus on farming and decided that makes you an expert on regenerative farming techniques?
That's some hubris you got there.
There are millions of farmers around the world that use traditional/regenerative farming techniques because they don't have access to the "current support systems" that make modern farming possible, and thousand in the U.S. and Europe that do so because they can.
And worse...you couldn't actually be bothered to build the website yourself so you outsourced it to an AI....
2. In your section on photoperiodism (https://jrcpl.us/contrib/2020/gardening-for-engineers/#photo...), it seems the examples are backwards. Ie, lettuce is a long-day plant that flowers when days are long, mung bean is a short-day plant that flowers when days are short.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by Joakal on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:10PM
(#50419213)
Watering is easy but one can overcomplicate it. Each plant has different water needs. Screw it up, you get likely get root rot or dry soil.
An engineer might analyse the soil and the plant water needs. Inject water to right levels, or set a timer. These settings need to be readjusted constantly without a hydrometer.
I found an ancient solution that worked incredibly efficient and required no electricity and far cheaper than spending hundreds on electronics. Ollas. The science is called capillary action.
I went a step further as an engineer, and did DIY terracotta pots + silicone. Added a testing stage, of course. Filled pots and sealed it over night. If leaking from seal, more silicone. For filling them up, I used irrigation fittings hooked up to a tank. If I wanted to, I could use rain water into tank (with overflow). That way watering is a fully automated pipeline.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by hxorr on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:34PM
(#50421098)
I somehow get weed grower vibes reading this
On a more serious note, I have found that choosing good easy to grow crops for your area makes a lot of difference. For example, sweet potatoes grow well here, the leaves go great in salads, they are relatively pest free and hardly need watering at all. You are flexible in terms of when you harvest the tubers and, and the tubers keep well over winter in the house.
Re:Show HN: Vegetable Gardening for Engineers
by kriskrunch on Monday November 09, 2026 @12:30AM
(#50421430)
Cool intro to hydro page.
Consider adding in some info about vapor pressure deficit (VPD). It's basically the effect of temp and humidity on the leaf surface. Engineers will love it.
> I am currently exhibiting overwhelming stress from deeply technical work being part of my every day life, and feel I am missing the 'nature' element of life. What should I do?
The brain responds:
> Gardening! A wonderfully complex system that will just 'live' without me! A delightful escape!
The brain asks:
> Yes, gardening! But how? There are so many variables! What are the parameters? Where is the specification outlining the success criteria? What defines a living organic system?
In my own experience (quite a bit over the last ~8 years), if high temperatures (T_opt, not T_max) are accompanied by longer and more intense daylight as well as adequate water and nutrition, it will consistently result in thicker stems, stronger roots, and better flavor. And since higher temperatures in the summer typically coincide with longer days and more intense sunlight, this is the most common outcome. Lacking water or nutrition under these conditions, plants will usually stall their growth rather than grow thinner or weaker.
The only times I can think of that the quoted statement is true is with, eg, indoor seed starts that are given a warm environment with plenty of water and nutrition, but that lack sunlight or artificial light, or light-adapted plants grown outdoors in too much shade.
The clearest counter example that comes to mind is tomatoes, which IMO taste their best, and are by no means thin or weak, when they are growing the fastest.
Can you expand on this?
I'm no expert, and I fully agree that growing food at scale can be difficult, and usually requires significant space.
But what do you mean by saying it's "too complex for our brains"?
What do you mean by that?
> If we don't work on this correctly, in the end, we will end up in a dead end
We have over 10.000 years of agriculture already behind us so I think that's proof that it works well enough to support small communities in a sustainable fashion. It's simply not necessary to understand all the microbes etc..
If you are hinting on optimization so we can feed all of humanity, then I mean we are definitely not resource and knowledge limited but rather by more mundane things. I'd wager just the US defense budget is enough to feed to world without a problem.
Meanwhile there are forests that were forest (and other ecosystems as well) 10s of thousands of years ago and just as lush and fertile (if not moreso) than they were to begin with.
Sustainable generally means we can maintain the fertility of the land indefinitely without mined inputs. Whether or not it's a completely achievable goal, it makes good sense to strive for it... Mines will become spent, theres only so much land to degrade, etc.
Often when people talk about sustainable agriculture they are talking about systems that mimic biological systems that keep those forests lush for millennia. These types of agricultural systems frequently look similar to agricultural systems of the past with more human labor involved, but less damaging waste products and fewer externalities. (Reducing pollution of the water downstream and minimizing ecosystem impact).
Totally but I'd argue nowadays it's not because we are missing the knowledge but rather ignorance and short-term economic gains.
Imo sustainability goes hand in hand with population (and lifestyle). We want a diverse ecosyaystem, this simply doesn't work if there are 10 billion people wanting to eat meat or produce tons of plastic. Our problem is not knowledge in agriculture that prevents us from sustainable living.
You've AI generated an application. How are you executing your mission statement?
That's some hubris you got there.
There are millions of farmers around the world that use traditional/regenerative farming techniques because they don't have access to the "current support systems" that make modern farming possible, and thousand in the U.S. and Europe that do so because they can.
And worse...you couldn't actually be bothered to build the website yourself so you outsourced it to an AI....
A couple points of feedback that I noticed so far:
1. I wrote a comment here in response to what you said about the tradeoff between growth rate and growth quality: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50415982
2. In your section on photoperiodism (https://jrcpl.us/contrib/2020/gardening-for-engineers/#photo...), it seems the examples are backwards. Ie, lettuce is a long-day plant that flowers when days are long, mung bean is a short-day plant that flowers when days are short.
An engineer might analyse the soil and the plant water needs. Inject water to right levels, or set a timer. These settings need to be readjusted constantly without a hydrometer.
I found an ancient solution that worked incredibly efficient and required no electricity and far cheaper than spending hundreds on electronics. Ollas. The science is called capillary action.
I went a step further as an engineer, and did DIY terracotta pots + silicone. Added a testing stage, of course. Filled pots and sealed it over night. If leaking from seal, more silicone. For filling them up, I used irrigation fittings hooked up to a tank. If I wanted to, I could use rain water into tank (with overflow). That way watering is a fully automated pipeline.
I don't have a picture on hand but others have done it like this: https://www.abc.net.au/gardening/how-to/olla-watering-pots/1...
On a more serious note, I have found that choosing good easy to grow crops for your area makes a lot of difference. For example, sweet potatoes grow well here, the leaves go great in salads, they are relatively pest free and hardly need watering at all. You are flexible in terms of when you harvest the tubers and, and the tubers keep well over winter in the house.
Consider adding in some info about vapor pressure deficit (VPD). It's basically the effect of temp and humidity on the leaf surface. Engineers will love it.
If it helps, here's a calculator I made a while back: https://globalgarden.co/calculators/advanced-vapor-pressure-...
Hydro (indoor growing) was my life for 15 years.