There are a few “social media famous” cybersecurity folks really worth their salt who didn’t immediately dumpster their morals and skills at the first sign of an ego boost.
People like Krebs, Allison Nixon, Joanna Rutkowska.
Most of them though are just addicted to likes as it’s become a core part of their self worth.
Both of them are well known in cybersecurity but are very different people with very different reputations.
The people you hear from are famous personalities... That's the nature of being a famous personality. There are plenty of us who are just normal people with opinions of our own and no desire to cultivate a public name or face for ourselves...
Obviously, there are also some people in cybersecurity who oversell not for the greater good, but only to further their careers... and even those who are honest and would prefer not to self-promote like that, are sort of forced to, because visibility can matter as much (if not more than) expertise when trying to find a job in cybersecurity, as you'll look like an underachiever if you don't oversell yourself like everybody else.
It took me five minutes to realise that this was something of an nothingburger. As the author states, you basically have to have PHP running as root, and allow an attacker to upload and then execute malicious code on your server already - and if you’re there already the house is already on fire.
I think the problem that "coordinated disclosure" has too many people and companies with conflicts of interest.
For example, this PHP "coordinated disclosure", you have:
- OpenAI, Wiz etc. no doubt looking for ways to sell you a subscription to the highest tier
- Chainguard with a vested interest in selling their wares and being "first" with a patch.
- etc. etc.
Then governments probably have various "pro alerts" subscriptions so they get all in a panic because the company sending out the alerts starts ringing the alarm bells.Meanwhile the rest of the world with good-old LAMP (Linux Apache Mysql PHP) installations ? Meh ... a mere afterthought to the money-making opportunities. Some posts on HN suggest there was a 2 month delay between discovery and "coordinated disclosure" ?
Historically you might have written this off as an un-necessarily cynical view. But sadly I think it is a valid reflection of the world we live in today.
The fact that this particular CVE doesn't have an easily exploitable path has meant very little, historically, in the modern threat landscape. AI has proven it's able to pull off chaining multiple exploits that are very difficult or hard to pull off, but a machine does not care for "ease" or "difficulty".
All that is to say, the security community is currently a little gun-shy, but with good reason.
Nobody listens to experts. Maybe you mean cybersecurity influencers? Actual experts, like in most industries, are not the most visible.
You are basically correct in your estimate of the severity. Exploitation, at least now, requires knowing exact PHP config and a lot of tweaking.
There was a complete panic on the internet and in all HN threads, with people claiming insane things like "this is already exploited everywhere in the wild" (it was not), "it took me 10 minutes to replicate this vulnerability from a public information" (yeah, sure) or "there is a public blog post with a writeup" (it was hallucinated AI slop). Voices of people who knew more, while present, were drowned in fake news. It didn't help, that in the first threads people who knew more (and were serious about coordinated disclosure) couldn't say much, so people sharing the most, knew the least.
I wish I could help, but honestly there were so many people parroting incorrect information that it's impossible. Signed, someone who got information about this vulnerability before it was publicly known, and worked to remediate it.
To me, it seems more more akin to broadpwn, technically severe, wide scope (millions of iphones), yet will never be a one-size-fits-all-PWN-button.
Even in the age of AI, I don't think this is going to be weaponized down the line like how Eternalblue was... but I'm not the social media cybersec guy with 15000 followers, so don't take my words at face value ;)