News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by GodelNumbering on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:15PM (#49862352)
Georgism, or the tax on the unimproved value of the land, is the fairest tax I (and many others) can imagine. It directly counters one of the ugliest part of any economy/society - rent seeking.

Suppose you see an area in upward economic trajectory, you buy a bunch of land/properties, then do fuck-all for the next 30 years while the hard work of everyone around that land causes your land's value to increase. You contribute nothing, while benefitting from others' contributions. All this while someone who could have used that land/property for a more productive used is deprived of it. Georgism directly counters that by taxing any 'base land value' that you own.

Georgism and the 'taxing progressively higher any property a person directly/indirectly owns after first N properties' are seriously very much needed around the world, economic rent-seeking steals from future generations.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by vannevar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @10:16PM (#49862702)
>...the 'taxing progressively higher any property a person directly/indirectly owns after first N properties' are seriously very much needed...

I don't see it in the article, but the progressive nature of the tax is important. It makes it harder for large landowners to pass along the tax, since they must compete with smaller landlords. The net effect should also stabilize land appreciation, which will no longer rise with rapidly increasing wealth disparity as it has in the past couple of decades. And we won't need clunky, patchwork solutions like the ban on home ownership by private equity.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by GodelNumbering on Sunday September 27, 2026 @07:51AM (#49865877)
Right, it's not in the article but this is a problem I have spent disproportionate amount of time thinking so that leaked in. A lot of things that benefit the regulatory capturing class are presented as if they are good for the 'common man' and how we all won't even have homes to rent if it wasn't for generosity of landlords, such bs.
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by Buttons840 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @12:30AM (#49863370)
What prevents the landlord rent seekers from just charging more rent? Wont they all uniformly raise rent, because they are all uniformly having their taxes increased?

This is the argument again Georgism I have the hardest time countering.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by epistasis on Sunday September 27, 2026 @01:40AM (#49863655)
Landlords tend to raise rent to the maximum value they can.

If they could raise rents, why haven't they already?

And if their costs go up and they can't make ends meet, they will sell the property, possibly at a loss, and the lower value will lower taxes.

But this won't happen, because the landlord's taxes won't rise. They'll almost certainly fall, as shown in the abundant data. And if for some reason the landlord's property tax does rise, it's because it's a ridiculously underused parcel in an area of really really high value, like a duplex next to 10+ story buildings. Which means it may be best to let 100-300 people use that parcel rather than ~10.

The LVT shifts tax burden away from homes and businesses and towards empty lots and parking lots.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by Buttons840 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @03:59AM (#49864400)
Thanks. I like this response. I might phrase it a little more verbosely: what forces currently limit rent prices, and will any of those forces be lessened if land value is taxed?
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by efaref on Sunday September 27, 2026 @05:54AM (#49865137)
They haven't raised rents because they are in competition with other landlords. If all landlords' costs go up (e.g. taxes) then all landlords will raise rents to maintain the same previously optimal profit margin they were extracting.

To put it another way, why not raise taxes to $1M/sq.ft.? $1B/sq.ft.? If if were true that it wouldn't be passed on to tenants then you've found the magic money tree.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by epistasis on Sunday September 27, 2026 @10:55AM (#49867161)
Excellent point, and nobody has ever brought it up to me despite me talking this way many times! I think the "competition" angle is really good at pointing out why a land value tax is very different from a property tax here.

A property tax affects all square footage of apartments quite equally, which is very well correlated to rental prices, so a property tax is roughly equally a rise in all landlord's costs. So in the very few housing markets where rental prices have fallen to near the cost level, and there's very near zero profit in renting, property taxes could easily cause a rise in rents.

However when switching to a land value tax from the current property tax system, the incidence is quite different than a broad property tax increase. Some landlord's taxes fall quite a bit, some landlord's tax bills might increase.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by yellowapple on Monday September 28, 2026 @04:38AM (#49875179)
> If all landlords' costs go up (e.g. taxes) then all landlords will raise rents to maintain the same previously optimal profit margin they were extracting.

And then all landlords will see a surge in vacancies, and not all landlords are able to tolerate paying LVT on empty units for very long before they're forced to drop their rents back to the actual market value.

> why not raise taxes to $1M/sq.ft.? $1B/sq.ft.?

Same reason why landlords can't raise rents to $1M/sq.ft or $1B/sq.ft: because nobody in their right mind would pay that much.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by jwolfe on Sunday September 27, 2026 @12:45AM (#49863431)
A whole section of the article is about this. "Can Land Value Tax Be Passed on to Tenants?"
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by GodelNumbering on Sunday September 27, 2026 @07:55AM (#49865897)
> What prevents the landlord rent seekers from just charging more rent? Wont they all uniformly raise rent, because they are all uniformly having their taxes increased?

The first effect Georgism would have is, more effective utilization of real estate. If you go to any big city, there is simultaneously a shortage of properties while a significant number of vacant properties. This would disincentivize vacant properties, so more supply (or at least more tax collected on vacant properties that the city can use for better purposes).

Also, the reason for making progressive tax larger on larger landlords means renting out a few homes is significantly more economically attractive while beyond a certain number, it is no longer viable, which pins prices down.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by robocat on Sunday September 27, 2026 @12:40AM (#49863412)
> rent seeking

I would worry that you just substitute a rent seeking landlord with a rent seeking government (local?).

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by tonyedgecombe on Sunday September 27, 2026 @04:19AM (#49864500)
We already have that. The government is going to get its slice of your money one way or another.
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by psd1 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @04:52AM (#49864692)
Government already has the prerogative to set taxes, so you should worry about that exactly to the extent that you currently worry about it. LVT is orthogonal.

Broadly, government is not called rent-seeking because it does things to justify its keep: law, defense, roads, bins, etc etc.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by yellowapple on Monday September 28, 2026 @04:35AM (#49875146)
At least I have some influence over my local government and how it spends my tax money. Same can't be said about my landlord and how it spends my rent money.
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by nikanj on Sunday September 27, 2026 @02:51AM (#49864050)
The headlines would be more along the lines of ”Grandma Jones is losing her family farm, because she refuses to turn it into condos and now the land is taxed as if there was development on it”

Georgism ignores how many voters are vehemently anti-development. Just visit any hearing where housing is discussed, people really hate the idea of getting more homes built.

Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by hardbass on Sunday September 27, 2026 @03:20AM (#49864198)
We should agree and add in fact the place they live in is already too dense, we need to demolish some housing, starting with theirs.
Re:Does Georgism Work? Five Years Later by joshlemer on Sunday September 27, 2026 @02:17PM (#49869290)
> Suppose you see an area in upward economic trajectory, you buy a bunch of land/properties, then do fuck-all for the next 30 years while the hard work of everyone around that land causes your land's value to increase. You contribute nothing, while benefitting from others' contributions.

In a market economy, if it's a known fact that the area is in an upward economic trajectory, then the future increase in usefullness of that land will already be priced into the land today. You can't just make profit (in expectation) by going and buying land in an area that the market already knows is going to become more productive. Competition amongst investors will drive expected profit to 0.

The only way that you can actually make a profit as a speculator, is by bringing new information to the market. The rest of society thinks this area has no potential, but you have good insight that is costly to figure out, which tells you that the area is going to be more productive. You take a risk and purchase the property. You are compensated for the risk and effort you undertook, and if you're wrong, you are punished by losing money.