"Because Snikket is designed natively as a tightly integrated suite of Docker containers built around the Prosody XMPP server, running it natively on FreeBSD is complex."
Holy shit
Snikket aimed to fill the gap for people who wanted an "out of the box" XMPP distribution kind of thing, and it's good at that. But shipping a bunch of software components with opinionated configurations doesn't really mesh well with distribution-level package management, and only really works with a container kind of ecosystem.
Both routes exist and are equally viable. Prosody has ports available for all the popular BSDs, and installing it should be a breeze. Just be prepared to then also set up a TURN server if you want calls, and potentially some web server stuff to if you want some of those features. After installing Prosody you can run 'prosodyctl check features' and it will tell you if you're missing any of the common stuff people want in a modern messaging app.
Hope this helps :)
There are still a LOT of things very much up in the air, such as message deletion, which work inconsistently from client to client, but message history is not it.
I'm not sure what you mean by not handling encrypted messages fully, it handles encrypted messages fine.
as a user you cannot, even if you self host, because you are not the one controlling message storage
> I'm not sure what you mean by not handling encrypted messages fully, it handles encrypted messages fine.
you can load encrypted messages (including keys if they are needed to decrypt them if necessary) using a fresh login such that you can read them again?
People don't use single browser and single email client, why IM should be different? It's a deficiency when you're forced to use a single "official client".
But most people seem to use Chrome on every device, no matter how much I wish they didn't.
Google has since spent the time making Chrome more locked down and user-hostile from a privacy perspective but the conventional wisdom for years was “just use Chrome” (for good reason) and that inertia continues :/
Also last I checked - on iOS devices even if you use Chrome, you're really using Safari - I believe apple forces all web content to be rendered using the built-in WebKit.
You sign up for Gmail, you get the Gmail app. You sign up for Outlook, you get the Outlook app. 1 service = 1 app.
For browser - on mobile most people use whatever the default browser on their device is. On desktop - Chrome. Pretty much everybody just downloads and uses Chrome.
This is both true and also flies in the face of what XMPP (and Mastodon-flavored ActivityPub-powered fediverse of microblogs-and-more) is supposed to be about—and it's both true and yet people understand what "email" means without managing to run into major issues when banging out a reply to [email protected] in response to a message that landed in the recipient's inbox @yahoo.com—nor worry too much about their SMSes being delivered by AT&T to their friend who uses Verizon (if they even know which provider their friend uses at all).
One thing that Jabber (and, later, Mastodon) did wrong was to take the unfortunate stance that it wouldn't be a big deal to adopt email-like identifiers without actually being/implying that Internet-standard email services are available because it was felt that users would just be smart enough to adapt to it. This was a mistake.
The confusion with email, though, can be leveraged and converted into something that the network has going for it, instead of a flaw.
If the author and the rest of the Jabber/XMPP community wants the public to "give Jabber/XMPP a shot", then it probably does need (a) a flagship instance (a la mastodon.social) that controls multiple domains (the way that many email providers like Runbox or Fastmail do) and requires the user to pick which one they want their handle to be associated with at signup, in order to introduce email-like decentralization to the userbase as early as possible, and that (b) raises the bar by setting a standard among Jabber/XMPP instances and actually offering email services to that userbase (prior art: Google married (XMPP-based) Gtalk with Gmail in the early days).
While undertaking all of this, an effort to update the XMPP protocol (a la JMAP, but in a backwards-compatible way) while simultaneously reconciling it with legacy email (also in a backwards-compatible way) wouldn't hurt—where "backwards-compatible" here means "to gracefully degrade and provide a fallback" (prior art: Delta Chat).
They've been working on a version 3 for years but no idea if that will ever happen.
As for version 3, yeah turns out that things take a very long time a tiny team that has zero financial support.
In short, I wouldn't recommend Pidgin for someone who wants a modern messaging app.
As for apps, people simply prefer instant messengers purposefully designed for their platform. There is genuinely a lot of platform-specific quirks around things like push notifications, which a non-iPhone developer not have the motivation to figure out. Besides that, a lot of these predate contemporary cross-platform technologies like Flutter.
Plus the reality of the fediverse is if you want to use multiple platforms, you wind up needing multiple accounts anyway. Like if I want to upload to Peertube, I need to make a Peertube account, so we're back to where we started of having multiple places to follow people since I can't use my Mastodon account to upload to Peertube. I'm able to have some cross-platform interaction, like commenting on videos from mastodon - but there's issues there like, Pixelfed only showing people posts with images.
When talking to most people I just call the whole thing Mastodon and treat it like its a single app/service, because that's what people are used to. If I start trying to tout how the fediverse is a decentralized platform of multiple applications and you can kinda/sorta interact across platforms - people's eyes glaze right over. They just do not care.
For apps - I've never met a person that picks a messenger because its tweaked for their platform. They just prefer whatever their friends are on. iMessage is something of a odd case since Apple just rolls you into it automatically and presents it via the default app.
It just so happens it splits into well-maintained projects supporting the concensus features, and dead or dying projects that don't, modulo a couple contrarians, with a couple more features floating in limbo, having finalized or draft specs that nobody really implements.
That sort of problem isn't best fixed by centralization on one client/server but just certification, which Conversations/ModernXMPP already leads.
As for apps, yes normal people aren't very conscious of what a native app is, but they do feel when their app lags on their older phone, doesn't recieve push notifications, or just looks a little odd in places, which can happen in a one size fits all app. Some of the most popular messengers, like WhatsApp or Telegram, to my knowledge use platform specific tooling, and normal people genuinely appreciate how snappy they feel.
But the issue is more so about developer time. Yes a cross platform app lets you reuse the same work everywhere, but the lead developer still has personal blind spots, and might simply not consider or be able to test things like bespoke Apple workarounds for non-iCloud/encrypted chat push.
Plus it's a communication protocol, like email; we should be expecting people reimplementing it in the weirdest of places. For software like this, the duplication of effort is what drives you to make an elegant design in the first place.
If you want xmpp to gain traction you need an app that exists on both mobile platforms. It can (and should) have per-platform tweaks and everything to be performant. But a person needs to be able to just tell their friend a single app, they need to be able to find it in their app store.
The question is "how does xmpp gain traction?" and the answer is having a single flagship app that runs on everything.
I can expect this from our parents and grandparents, but not from younger generations that were born with PCs and smartphones. They need to learn; we need to educate them. Otherwise they will stay being the perfect fodder for Big Corpos and their monopolistic tactics.
We need to start focusing on the protocols, not the platforms.
It just needs feature versions - you support this one, means you support all of the features deemed important for users, no partial mishmash.
It’s mostly whining that the world is too unfair because capitalism and people are dumb for choosing Signal, etc.
People don't really sign up for protocols, they download apps. Like I often refer to the fediverse as "Mastodon" even though I know that's not entirely correct, because it's the fastest, easiest way to communicate what I'm talking about - microblogging. So you really need a single, good app you can just tell people to download.