News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by BeetleB on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:21PM (#49675398)
> So they are claiming that ACR is done entirely through audio processing, and no visual data from the screen itself is used? That...doesn't seem plausible.

It apparently is.

Do you know the Nielsen Ratings? That's exactly how they know what people are watching these days. I've been contacted by them to be one of their subjects. They ship you a device that listens and recognizes based on content. They look for certain "fingerprints" in the audio and match against that - it's not capable of recording our conversations, etc (or so they claimed).

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by Wistar on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:34PM (#49675591)
The Shazam app on my wife’s iPhone can identify TV shows and movies very quickly, sometimes nearly instantly. Not sure how it does that.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by beached_whale on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:01PM (#49675924)
It is pretty neat and several resources online explaining it but it chunks the recoding and does a hash of the fft of each frame i think which reduces the data a lot. The server has a pre hashed database https://hackernoon.com/how-shazam-works-in-a-nutshell
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by beached_whale on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:50PM (#49678029)
I forgot the part about finding the dominant frequency in each chunk
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by dylan604 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:25PM (#49676201)
TV shows are completed and in the can well before air date. It is entirely plausible that the interested party in having the content identifiable by Shazam like services submit whatever needs to be submitted for new content
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by 3eb7988a1663 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:10PM (#49677248)
I have also wondered about the possibility of media emitting some kind of hidden identifier. Can normal speakers emit noise outside of human hearing that could contain a unique id? Would not even need to be a lot of data that could be broadcast.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by fc417fc802 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @07:17PM (#49678231)
Yes, it's possible. Some sports broadcasts do this. The ones I'm familiar with use a high pitched tone on the edge of human hearing but still audible to most people.

Streaming services watermark the video as opposed to the audio as I understand it.

But that's for tracing pirated content back to the originating user account. It's not particularly useful (also entirely unnecessary and overly complicated) if your goal is to ID a piece of content as opposed to an account.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by dylan604 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:19AM (#49680262)
Live broadcasts make it hard for Shazam type apps to ID something from a fingerprint, so they need something else to help.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by corysama on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:53PM (#49677593)
That's not necessary. If a service has access to the raw audio of a show, it can fingerprint each second of that audio in a way that can be matched in a tiny amount of computation even for a recording in a noisy environment.

That can't recognize what you say. But, it can ID where you are in a specific show out of zillions of hours of shows.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by lazide on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:14PM (#49677782)
Notably, the caught the TV also recording and transmitting recorded audio and transcripts from the microphone.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by gharper on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:38PM (#49677939)
Honestly, it doesn’t even need to be outside the range of human hearing.

A quick search for “audio steganography” should answer your question (and be a fun rabbit hole if you find that sort of topic interesting)

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by RobRivera on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:45PM (#49676452)
Signals analysis is pretty refined and not THAT compute intense.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by corysama on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:47PM (#49677540)
I know a guy who made a Shazam-like phone app that can listen to a few seconds of noisy audio and make a fingerprint that can be used to quickly ID those specific few seconds out of a pre-fingerprinted archive of an enormous amount of audio (zillions of hours of TV). Making the fingerprint requires a tiny amount of very smart code (in C with no dependencies). But, the fingerprint is not useful for understanding audio that's not in the archive.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by j45 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:13PM (#49676055)
Regardless of it being how it always was done, such a finger print can easily be injected into LG's advertising ecosystem to infer everything about your demographic and what your interests and income might be and hit you with more specialized ads.

What we watch is not OK to be fed ads, especially if I wasn't using their service to being with and its monitoring the audio from any input to do this.

In this way, smart tvs and smart home devices are effectively hostile devices behind your router at home.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by josephg on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:46PM (#49676463)
Yes. It’s also horrible that they have microphones in your home listening to your conversations. LG knowing what I’m watching is awful, but it seems even worse for LG to listen in to the conversation I have with my loved ones about it after. I don’t want to be under surveillance in my own home.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by lrvick on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:17PM (#49676752)
The good news is there is no good reason to plug the TV into the internet.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by dgellow on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:01PM (#49677654)
To watch movies from a streaming service?
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by allarm on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:36PM (#49677931)
Use Apple TV for that.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by abenga on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:26AM (#49680637)
I.e. spend more money to do things the TV can perfectly well do. We should make the spying illegal so we can use the devices we buy to their full potential without being sold to advertisers. "Give money to this other company that may or may not also be collecting data and may also sell you out in the future" is a suboptimal solution.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by allarm on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:24AM (#49681006)
I don't think we can do anything substantial. So I'm going to just use this "suboptimal" solution.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by account42 on Monday September 14, 2026 @08:23AM (#49695673)
No, we should decouple the display hardware from the playback device. Spying or not, the playback part will be obsolete long before the display part.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by drnick1 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:58AM (#49680836)
If you want true, verifiable privacy and control, it's not an Apple TV that you need. Any old laptop or desktop computer can be used to stream content from the Internet using a Web browser or other "apps."
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by allarm on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:26AM (#49681015)
E.g. Netflix doesn't let you to stream 4k video in browser afaik. So no, it's not a good option.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by dns_snek on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:32AM (#49681471)
Desktop OS also don't support Dolby Vision or fancy spatial audio formats.

Trifecta: Piracy + Local media server + Streaming device, either Apple TV/Android TV (without internet access).

No loss of quality, devices that could spy on you, don't, and those that would spy on you, can't. The only trade-off is some convenience.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by int_19h on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @07:10PM (#49720108)
It does let you do that, but only on platforms where they can enforce HDCP. So e.g. Edge on Windows or Safari on macOS work fine, and I think Chrome recently joined the list too. But not on Linux.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by j45 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @07:19PM (#49678244)
Always, and only use an external device for streaming services, never the software built into the TV.

Apple TV, Android TV or other devices are perfectly capable and better integrate with mobile and other devices in your network.

The tradeoff consumers are sold is trading convenience of in device apps for security.

Smart home devices like TVs, and thermostats should be treated as default hostile and isolated on a guest wireless network instead of your main one.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by j45 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:13PM (#49676723)
Both are unacceptably egregious and done for zero benefit of the customer and a disproportionate and asymmetric benefit for the manufacturer.

I've been trying to learn how to secure LG TVs, and saw that some people do seem to jailbreak them withan open version of webOS.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by josephg on Saturday September 12, 2026 @08:37PM (#49678723)
> I've been trying to learn how to secure LG TVs

It’d be wonderful if we had a grapheneos equivalent for tvs. They’re very capable Android devices. Such a pity “we don’t own the glass”.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by prasadjoglekar on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:41PM (#49675680)
It's how things were always done. The content from broadcasters has/had audio watermarks...frequencies which humans can't hear.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by grvbck on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:37PM (#49676351)
As far as I know, watermarks never took off because the technical complexity and lack of standardization. Nielsen researched and developed ACR technology but it never required watermarks.

When Nielsen first started collecting data (1950s), they handed out diaries to a group of around 5 000 selected households. Nielsen would then collect these diaries and extrapolate viewing patterns across the entire population.

After that came phone surveys. Next step (1980s) was the "people meter", a small box attached to the TV that could automatically detect which channel was tuned and which household members were in the room.

In the 1990s the set-top box made all of that redundant as the cable and satellite providers could directly see which channel every single box was tuned to at all times.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by salawat on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:44PM (#49676434)
Broadcasters: the cutting edge of streaming information is ours! Now let's make it so everyone unknowingly broadcasts as much info back to us as possible!

Poor Farnsworth. He just wanted edutainment, man.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by rozab on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:05PM (#49677191)
I have a friend who got a Nielson device recently and they were told it relies on watermarks. Their website says a combination is used: https://www.nielsen.com/insights/2023/how-to-measure-tv-audi...
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by fortran77 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:21PM (#49677333)
A long time ago (~1998) I did some consulting for VEIL and Neilson was definitely talking to them...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Encoded_Invisible_Light

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by fc417fc802 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @07:21PM (#49678264)
> watermarks never took off because the technical complexity and lack of standardization

Both audio (sports) and video (netflix et al) watermarks are alive and well. They are used to trace piracy (ie account ID), not for content ID (at least AFAIK).

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by fn-mote on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:28PM (#49675512)
This seems like a credulous argument based on no facts you have provided.

If you explained how the box was hooked up, it would be easier to judge whether there was a chance you were correct.

As it is, your description isn’t even clear whether or not the box contains a microphone.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by spydum on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:35PM (#49675617)
nielsen's ACR method is embedded into millions of devices and vendors. No need for a microphone, it's processing the audio signal being sent out. A microphone would be a wasted conversion..

(your car infotainment also likely has nielsen tech in it most likely, as they bought arbitron and gracenote)

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by lazide on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:15PM (#49677789)
Notably, the TV was caught making audio recordings and transcripts of conversations, and sending them to LG, independently of all this.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by margor on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:44PM (#49675729)
Nielsen is global Company that is used for pricing ads on TV stations around the world. Their way of doing it from what I know personally is that they sign up people to put this ACR boxes voluntarily and then based on extrapolation of data - they can tell you pretty close what was the viewership across demographics. Similar to how election polls are done - you just need a good sample.

It's been done for at least good 15 years.

Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by s1artibartfast on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:06PM (#49675982)
You know you can look it up if you are skeptical, right?
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by BeetleB on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:14PM (#49677780)
LMGTFY was made for people like you.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by mitxela on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:31PM (#49676884)
Also, they didn't claim that.
Re:LG responds to TV spying allegations by ssl-3 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:25PM (#49678985)
Is that how they do it lately?

I participated once or twice a good number of years ago, and it was kind of a pain: It involved keeping a paper ledger of what was watched, and when. Correspondence was all handled by regular mail.

(As I recall, they included a small amount of cash ~every time they sent more correspondence and this was a primary motivator to keep going with it.)