News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by eru on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:50AM (#49670009)
I'm not sure it actually makes a difference. OpenAI doesn't care about the million dollars in any case. And the judgement that they did it is independent of whether the Clay people agree: you can make up your own mind and so can everyone else.

Though it would be funny if no one ever bothers publishing the result in an appropriate journal, and thus the prize technically can never be claimed.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by c7b on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:33AM (#49670285)
Even funnier that it wouldn't even be the first time that happens: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grigori_Perelman
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by yen223 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:42AM (#49671003)
It's very likely that no one will claim any of the cash prizes, which is funny to me
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by thrance on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:40AM (#49670994)
And he also gave up his trophy, which is displayed in a random corridor of a random math museum in Paris, where visitors pass by without looking, lacking most, if not all, of the context. Only because I knew the story and the man did I recognize the object for what it was.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by peacefullmind on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:09AM (#49671984)
where is it displayed , in which museum ? As a mathematician it would be cool to visit it, but I can't find anything on google.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by thrance on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:45AM (#49672272)
It's at Maison Poincaré, in a kind of theater room with a looping movie. There's some neat stuff, but it's mostly targeted at children.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by pegasus on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:26AM (#49672111)
There can't be that many math museums in Paris...
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by jgalt212 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:50AM (#49672311)
Not including salaries, OpenAI spend $20MM to make $1MM. Very on-brand for a start-up.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by jacobrussell on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:57AM (#49672366)
I don’t think solving a millennium prize problem can be reduced to some DoorDash economics of “spent Y to make X.” What if it took someone their entire professional career to solve one of these problems, would it not be worth it by the same logic?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by jgalt212 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:58PM (#49676583)
Of course, you're right. I was making social commentary / joke.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by program_whiz on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:13PM (#49676720)
Surprisingly this is actually rather fitting in terms of time scale. When you consider it took ~10,000 agents 88 hours, or 880,000 hours to solve. That's 14.5 years in agent time of continuous 365/24/7 processing. Of course, humans solve things much more efficiently (and didn't also need the massive pre-training of every expert on the planet for 1,000,000,000 human years equivalent). But yeah, human researchers can solve a problem like this in a decade or so, while sleeping, teaching, traveling, and taking breaks, only working a few hours a day on the idea.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by nomel on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:54PM (#49677095)
How many people have worked on this problem? How many have failed? How many hours total?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by taneq on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:29AM (#49681447)
> But yeah, human researchers can solve a problem like this in a decade or so

None of them did, though, despite how many tried. So empirically, it seems unreasonable to say human researchers can solve ‘problems like this’.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by eru on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:44AM (#49681972)
Well, I guess we can say that human researchers have a certain probability of solving problems like this?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by program_whiz on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @08:27PM (#49734919)
The entire controversy was that researchers were about to release their proof which OpenAI claimed to simultaneosululy discover. The proof is the researchers in question.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by pvab3 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @10:51AM (#49672898)
Softbank stock is up 24% in the last 5 days
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by soperj on Saturday September 12, 2026 @10:58AM (#49672963)
He did it because he had principals.

OpenAI the opposite.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by MarkusQ on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:18PM (#49676760)
More likely it's because a million dollars one way or the other won't make a difference in the hole they are digging / mountain they are building.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by spott on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:38PM (#49676942)
It likely cost them more than a million in compute to solve it…
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by eru on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:43AM (#49681964)
We know that it did.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by pwdisswordfishq on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:53PM (#49677083)
He had principals, while OpenAI had agents?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by Aissen on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:53PM (#49675846)
> And the judgement that they did it is independent of whether the Clay people agree: you can make up your own mind and so can everyone else.

No I cannot, and I'd argue most people can't either. We rely on mathematicians, peer review, and letting the scientific process run its course.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by soerxpso on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:20PM (#49676144)
It's formalized in Lean, isn't it? Do you also rely on a community of C++ experts to tell you whether a program compiles or not?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by tired-turtle on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:39PM (#49676378)
"Beware of bugs in the above code; I have only proved it correct, not tried it." — Knuth, 1977
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by mpardalos on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:53PM (#49677092)
Yes, but there's still the possibility that it's either exploiting a bug in Lean, or that the theorem statement is not set up correctly (i.e. it's actually proved a different theorem).

My understanding is that the theorem statement is quite simple, so i guess the latter is not very likely, but the former is very much a possibility in a proof this large, and it will take some human eyeballs to go over it before convincing mathematicians.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by rawland on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:56PM (#49678082)
I ran the proof 3 days ago.

They do a Comparator Challenge to validate that they actually solved the correct theorem from the result, which they copied from Google/DeepMind: https://github.com/openai/NavierStokesAndEuler/blob/f9e8bc5b... - this is valid for both Euler and NS. Also, they validated with an external kernel from the Lean Kernel Arena. That way bugs in the Lean kernels were found in the past already, iirc.

Having said that, I strongly believe a positive result with the challenge above is the reason why they published it. I highly doubt anybody at OpenAI (or anywhere else) fully gets the proof after such a short time since publishing. This is also what Terry Tao criticized the most in my opinion.

Independent of the remaining drama [0], from my point of view, the proof is correct and an achievement.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49661928 - I am pretty much on the critical side, however, one can not ignore that it is an achievement. Esp. the unforced result.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by HotHotLava on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:57PM (#49679182)
Take a look at https://github.com/leanprover/comparator which was used to verify the result. It's of course not impossible that they're hitting some bug, but way harder than one would intuitively think. For starters, they'd have to hit two bugs in two independently written Lean kernels.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by gerdesj on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:12PM (#49677261)
"It's formalized in Lean, isn't it?"

If that's the current burden of proof required in your world for maths then that's fine! 't'ain't in my world: I want to see peer reviewed and published. Surely that's not too much to ask. Its not perfect but generally works rather well for maths.

I'm not a sodding programmer so please don't assume everyone here is one. I'm not a mathematician either but I do have standards: Your counter argument is a poorly constructed and inappropriately deployed example of "proof by whataboutism".

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by HotHotLava on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:44PM (#49677522)
In what world is peer review a higher standard than formal verification in Lean?

Not in the world mathematicians have been living in for the past decades at least. Nearly all big theorems that have been formalized so far had been published beforehand, and it was usually regarded as a step up in rigor. Wrong results get published in peer reviewed journals all the time.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by aarstid on Saturday September 12, 2026 @08:21PM (#49678626)
I find it really strange the way “peer-reviewed” is used by the general public as some gold standard of truth. As a former academic who has been there, the process is extremely arbitrary and variable. Are people aware that the “peer” refers not to a community or a committee, but literally to one random guy or maybe a couple with zero accreditation? And that the journal editor can do whatever they want with this peer’s “review” including completely ignoring it?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by rcbdev on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:05AM (#49680517)
I keep thinking the exact same thing every time I'm asked to peer review a paper.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by gerdesj on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:43PM (#49689032)
"I find it really strange the way “peer-reviewed” is used by the general public as some gold standard of truth."

OK but this member of the general public has at least subscribed to New Scientist since 1987, nine O levels, two A levels, two AS levels and a HND in Civ Eng. All pretty mediocre but I have a fair idea on how sciencing is supposed to work and how it ... actually works. Obviously, I ended up in IT.

I should also point out that maths "peer reviewed" is a bit special. For example Mr Wiles went through quite a maelstrom before his proof of some dodgy marginalia was accepted as "true".

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by jjk166 on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:47AM (#49698929)
Admittedly, peer review originally referred to the fact that the journal being published was read ("reviewed") by your peers, and thus there would be the opportunity for them to provide rebuttals after publication. The process the term now refers to in academia only emerged in the 50's and 60's (Nature for example wasn't "peer reviewed" until 1967). It was literally a marketing ploy to make journals sound more prestigious which got legitimized when certain grant agencies and regulatory bodies started including it in their requirements. All the best science is published in journals that describe themselves as peer reviewed, the government says science not published in such journals isn't up to snuff, and taken literally it seems useful. It's no wonder the public thinks it's an important and long established part of the scientific process.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by jltsiren on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:23PM (#49677847)
Verification with Lean is a piece of empirical evidence that the proof is correct. The paper passing peer review would be another. But even together, those two would be insufficient to establish the claim.

While it's a convenient to assume that mathematics deals with logical statements, any attempt to evaluate those statements relies on physical processes with both known and unknown failure modes. There cannot be a test that establishes it unambiguously whether a claim is true or false. In all nontrivial situations, mathematical truth is based on expert consensus. When a new claim is made, people will try to raise and resolve objections, until a consensus emerges one way or another.

As for C++, all compilers are different. For any given compiler, there are valid C++ programs the compiler fails to compile and invalid programs it compiles without any errors or warnings. And now that I think of it, a new version of a compiler crashing with valid code earlier versions used to handle is the only class of compiler bugs I see with any regularity.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by shakna on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:50PM (#49678031)
Formalized in Lean, just five months ago [0], resulted in discovery of bugs.

Just because Lean can compile it, does not mean it is safely proven. It is the start of a process to check whether something actually holds, not the end.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47759709

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by senordevnyc on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:22PM (#49676169)
Sure we can. I’m already convinced they solved it. You’re free to believe whatever you wish.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by solid_fuel on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:22PM (#49687662)
How revealing. Have fun believing whatever makes you feel happy, the rest of us are busy living in the real world.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by senordevnyc on Sunday September 13, 2026 @07:45PM (#49689985)
So just to be clear, you don’t think they solved it? So is the proof flawed, or do you think they stole it (from an incomplete solution to a weaker problem)?

Looking forward to what your cope will be when they solve the next one.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by avs733 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:50PM (#49677045)
Can't and shouldn't are at odds here.

Many people, see prior conversation on HN, have already decided that AI solved it. The standards of reasoning and rigor in academia are complex enough that we all argue over them and harumph as we epistemically trespass on each other's domains.

The public, really humans if care for Herbert Simon, are much more apt to evaluate knowledge emotionally and by other standards. We may see them as wrong but standards only matter in context. The NYT, HN, and Annals of Mathematics will always have different standards of truth.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by Humorist2290 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:35AM (#49681072)
In a way, this task is perfectly suited for LLMs. To even understand the problem statement, much less the proof or Lean, is an extremely specialized skill. The overwhelming majority of people who are aware of this news simply don't have the capacity to call BS. Maybe there are a few thousand people in the world who could, and it seems they haven't yet, but indeed it's only been a few weeks.

The more familiar analogy was when I look at the code that Claude spews for my partner. They take it at face value and hope it works. I usually find it very problematic, but only because I knew what to look for.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by eru on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:41AM (#49681952)
> We rely on mathematicians, peer review, and letting the scientific process run its course.

Granted for the sake of argument. But for this process, there's no requirement anyone from Clay needs to be involved, nor that anything has to be published in a traditional journal.

Terrence Tao can download the pdf, think it over, and publish on his blog, and it would be just as valid. Then some other mathematician can write something on 4chan or whatever. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpermutation#Lower_bounds,... for 4chan.)

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by znnajdla on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:54PM (#49675857)
It does make a difference because the only reason OpenAI cares about these problems in particular versus any other random problem in math is because of the prestige associated with official recognition, not just claiming something as marketing.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by eru on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:45AM (#49681982)
Maybe. But the prestige requires that the Clay people have offered the prize money, it doesn't require that OpenAI claims the prize money.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by jacquesm on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:01PM (#49677155)
Why would that be funny? Years of people's work appropriated and they end up without even the recognition?

I'd be furious.