News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by Aurornis on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:05PM (#49501151)
> What is different here?

I don’t understand how this is a question.

What’s different is that it comes configured this way out of the box, silently, without warning. It’s functionally equivalent to opting in to giving all user accounts root privileges, which is not what anyone expects the default configuration to be.

You can choose to configure your installs this way if you choose to do so. It should not come this way quietly by default.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by LinXitoW on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:10PM (#49501207)
It does warn you. It's an opinionated Linux for a modern developer/user. This modification absolutely makes sense in that context.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by Aurornis on Sunday August 30, 2026 @02:19PM (#49501307)
I hope this was an attempt at sarcasm.

The Omarchy team immediately fixed this because it was a security oversight, not an intentional opinionated choice.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by troupo on Sunday August 30, 2026 @03:47PM (#49502099)
There was no oversight and no security. It's vibe-coders pushing unvetted shell scripts and dotfiles.

They "immediately fixed it" after it blew up on X/Twitter. Just like all the other issues they've had in the past few weeks.

And now they formed a "security team" lol.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by treebeard901 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:28PM (#49503465)
DHH was on the Lex Fridman podcast talking about this recent release of Omarchy in that most of it is "vibe coded". It is mostly just a bash script to configure Linux, but his approach is interesting.

AI as a core part of the OS that can just change or add anything you want. Linux is great for this because it has access to the source code for everything.

He said he didnt review the code line by line, just looked at the shape of it. Whatever that means.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by troupo on Monday August 31, 2026 @03:24AM (#49506664)
> DHH was on the Lex Fridman podcast talking about this recent release of Omarchy in that most of it is "vibe coded".

> He said he didnt review the code line by line, just looked at the shape of it. Whatever that means.

Did... did you even read my comment before replying to it? We know it's vibe-coded, we know it's bash scripts, and we know what it means

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by treebeard901 on Monday August 31, 2026 @11:51AM (#49511208)
I was just adding more context than your post included
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by wojciii on Sunday August 30, 2026 @03:23PM (#49501915)
Opinionated choice?

I recently used Arch Linux because I have a 4 GiB Mac Air that I want to use for something but it has too little RAM for UI. The installer was user friendly and fast. I got exactly what I wanted.

I don't think that I need Omarchy.

I have only one answer to this:

I'm too old for this shit.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by teekert on Sunday August 30, 2026 @03:24PM (#49501920)
Imo they could have sold it like that, in this case. A warning would be in order though.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by 0x20cowboy on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:23PM (#49503825)
Ah, the opinionated strikes again.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by JeremyNT on Sunday August 30, 2026 @04:26PM (#49502420)
The whole point of Omarchy is for people who want to use Arch Linux but have it configured the way DHH does.

So I think it's a little different. Anybody using an opinionated respin should understand what they're getting.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by Aurornis on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:04PM (#49503706)
The Omarchy team admitted it was a mistake and corrected it quickly.

It’s strange that so many people are trying to call this security error intentional.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by maxlin on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:04AM (#49505435)
It might be a mistake but not a serious one, like it's a common setting they had on for convenience of development without being too insecure, but forgot to leave it out of public release.

So there's nothing weird. It being on originally was intentional and not crazy. Only it going all they way wasn't.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by troupo on Monday August 31, 2026 @03:26AM (#49506674)
> but forgot to leave it out of public release.

They didn't forget. They never knew it was there. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49502099

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by maxlin on Thursday September 03, 2026 @10:36PM (#49559874)
That's just stupid speculation.

Overly active analytics / tracing stuff is not uncommon during dev. Likely they just did it to be able to debug things better in the weirdest cases; doing a full session replay basically when you have the whole original state of the repo

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by matheusmoreira on Sunday August 30, 2026 @04:41PM (#49502552)
> people who want to use Arch Linux but have it configured the way DHH does

Then they don't actually want to use Arch Linux.

The Arch Linux way is to read the excellent wiki documentation, learn about all the choices available, and then make all of those choices so the system is configured the user's way instead of some celebrity's way.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by jadar on Sunday August 30, 2026 @05:11PM (#49502857)
Couldn’t you say that about any Arch spinoff? Seems to be the no true scotsman fallacy.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by matheusmoreira on Sunday August 30, 2026 @05:26PM (#49503002)
> Couldn’t you say that about any Arch spinoff?

I can, and I do.

https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Arch_Linux#User_centrality

> It is targeted at the proficient GNU/Linux user, or anyone with a do-it-yourself attitude who is willing to read the documentation, and solve their own problems.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by Dylan16807 on Sunday August 30, 2026 @10:01PM (#49504801)
Assuming you mean "they don't actually want to use Arch" as a criticism (rather than a truism), I think that's fair for a distro described as "Arch linux but configured X way". I don't think it's a good criticism for something like SteamOS which is configurable but is aiming hard for "it just works".
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by AuthAuth on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:31PM (#49503485)
Thats the old arch way. New arch is archinstall + AI
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by jaapz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @05:19PM (#49502936)
> Then they don't actually want to use Arch Linux.

No, they want to use Arch Linux as configured by DHH

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by xyzsparetimexyz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:23PM (#49503430)
installing arch is enough of a pain that I've been putting off installing it on my desktop for months.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by qudat on Sunday August 30, 2026 @08:15PM (#49504209)
archinstall comes preinstalled on the official iso. It’s a normal install flow and takes 5 mins.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by matheusmoreira on Sunday August 30, 2026 @06:46PM (#49503591)
It's something you do literally once.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by xyzsparetimexyz on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:26PM (#49503851)
Yes and?
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by matheusmoreira on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:50AM (#49505715)
Yes, and Arch is probably not the right distro for you if you think installing it is a "pain".
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by maxlin on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:07AM (#49505451)
Actually we do. I like pacman for example. And don't mind going thru archinstall for a test install once to learn. But my workstation, I'd not like to have to develop, even if I do like configuring minimal installs for other uses like kiosks.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by osigurdson on Monday August 31, 2026 @01:30AM (#49505964)
I like and use Arch daily. My "way" was just to get past the fdisk squirrel catcher. After that it was as easy as Ubuntu. I'm not bragging, I wish I'd read the manual but was too impatient for that. I suspect I'm not the only arch user that arrived at it using similar approaches. I might even be a target user for DHH's distro but the bloat (and to some extent the vibe coding) holds me back.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by Ikatza on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @05:21AM (#49519766)
I didn't realise there was a correct way to use Arch, or that there were people authorised to explain what it is. Is that an Arch-exclusive service, or is it available for other distros as well?

You say the whole point is ending up with a system configured the user's way instead of some celebrity's way, and then you go on to tell us what we are actually allowed to want. That's a bit rich.

Starting from someone else's config and then changing whatever annoys you is making the choice, it just skips the part where you spend a weekend reading about display managers to arrive at the same place. That is what dotfiles have been for since roughly forever.

By your standard, anyone who used archinstall from the official ISO isn't really using Arch either, and I suppose the truly enlightened path is Linux From Scratch, compiled this morning, on hardware you soldered yourself.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by zer0zzz on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:42AM (#49505674)
What exactly is special about rolling a custom arch in this instance? Like, why does this get so much attention? Do web developers really care about what DHH does that much?

Like, I get it if thats the case. Say, if Chris Lattner or Andrej Karpathy rolled some ML GPU programming distro I'd probably care about it and try and see if it made me more productive.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by osigurdson on Monday August 31, 2026 @01:19AM (#49505894)
DHH made Ruby on Rails and lots of people love it (not for me, personally).
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by zer0zzz on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:22AM (#49509462)
Everyone knows that, but that was 20 years ago. Why do people still care?
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by teekert on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @03:07AM (#49518919)
Care should age? At what rate, do you propose?
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by zer0zzz on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @01:37PM (#49525178)
I thought that’s pretty much the way all technology goes. Just seems silly to take promotion an operating system that’s essentially a lot of config files atop existing work seriously from someone that made a popular web development framework 20 years ago. That’d be like me caring about a distro Gavin king made because he made hibernate in the 2000s at jboss.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by JeremyNT on Monday August 31, 2026 @09:39AM (#49509681)
He leveraged his past success as a web developer to get into online culture war punditry. Now he's a prominent race-baiting reactionary.

There's a sort of cult of personality around him at this point. His acolytes follow him for his nativist views, and then adopt his technology unthinkingly.

I don't know why my comment was downvoted above. This isn't a serious distribution and you shouldn't expect it to be. It's a vanity project of a niche alt right tech bro, and this is the level of rigor you should expect.

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by zer0zzz on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @01:33PM (#49525130)
Yeah that’s exactly it. Seems he’s manufacturing a lot of culture war bullshit just to bring attention to a less than interesting distro. If it wanted to be the “hyperland“ distro as so many distros are (built to bring one de/wm to users prepackaged) that’d be one thing. If he wanted to show people how to roll their own opinionated distro the way gentoo or lfs kinda did that’d be another too! But seems it’s neither of these, and purely vanity to me.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by BobbyTables2 on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:06AM (#49505447)
More like a company that had hundreds of millions of dollars and a couple decades should have fixed it by now.

If only Podman could beat Docker in advertising…

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by 0xbadcafebee on Monday August 31, 2026 @12:32AM (#49505598)
First they should try making a solution that works as well as Docker. Every time I use Podman or Podman Desktop I run into the most basic problems. Docker works out of the box everywhere.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by osigurdson on Monday August 31, 2026 @01:16AM (#49505873)
I don't use Podman desktop but I haven't had any issues at all with basic Podman. It just seems like a better overall design. It would be great if Docker copied the rootless / daemonless approach if possible.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by teekert on Monday August 31, 2026 @02:33AM (#49506308)
For me the problems are always when I pull some image (like GitLab) and try to get it to work with podman. Or the hoops you have to jump through with podman-compose (user lingering, systemd services, privileged ports (80,443) [yeah I know it's a feature]). Docker just works, Podman (I feel) still requires stuff that makes it less declarative (to get to a running infra).

Still, having a gitlab runner with a docker in docker setup that can access the host docker socket is not something you do lighty, so I am eyeballing buildah etc.

I guess what really grinds my gears is that I'd use podman a looooot more if it could nicely coexist with Docker. I'd use Docker for the big services and podman for all my own stuff. But that is just not possible (at least not afaik), so it is also difficult to switch step by step (yes VMs, bla bla, but it's all complicating).

Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by osigurdson on Monday September 07, 2026 @06:22PM (#49603641)
Makes sense. I never use podman compose and instead just use k8s like yamls. I find it easier anyway.
Re:Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root by trap0xcc on Thursday September 03, 2026 @12:27AM (#49545924)
Exactly.