News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by t-writescode on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:41PM (#49382238)
This matches historical precedent in other nations where copyright was not extended to a photographer when a primate took a photo of themselves.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disput...

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by randyrand on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:38PM (#49382620)
That was a terrible ruling. It should be about who got the camera there and set it up, not who pushed the button. With automated recording (dashcams) there isn't even "a button."

Hopefully no judge uses that as precedence.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by xoa on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:50PM (#49382705)
>It should be about who got the camera there and set it up, not who pushed the button. With automated recording (dashcams), there isn't even "a button".

I'm actually having a bit of trouble thinking of what sufficient societal good there is/would be in granting copyright on raw dashcam or security camera or the like footage? None of those purely mechanical automated systems need a subsidy or encouragement to generate more. Certainly someone can use that sort of thing in the creation of a copyrighted work but what would be the issue with the underlying material in that case being unprotected?

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by collabs on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:03PM (#49382808)
I am in favor of copyright reform so eventually it becomes something like two years automatic with a one time two year extension possible an I agree with you because of one key word — raw. Once the footage is used in a package, be it a movie, a news report, or a music video, that package can be copyrighted. The problem is there is no way the owner of a dashcam can prohibit commercial use of a video they own if it cannot be copyrighted in the US. In a way, we have conflated copyrights with other so called intellectual property (details). Maybe the solution is to strengthen privacy rights somehow? I'm not sure.

Details https://ftp5.gwdg.de/pub/gnu/www/philosophy/words-to-avoid.h...

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by butvacuum on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:04AM (#49383653)
people freqently spend more than two years trying to get something published.
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by bestouff on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:26AM (#49384490)
Not on YouTube.
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by dredmorbius on Friday August 21, 2026 @10:39AM (#49388859)
Two years might be too short.

The overwhelming majority of works have an effective commercial life of less than ten years.

Present-value analysis further reduces the individual benefit of long-lived copyright. That is warrented in only a minuscule fraction of all works.

(There are roughly 1 million books published in English annually, of which ... ten make the top-ten best-seller list. The situation gets worse if we consider this a conservative estimate, or include all other copyrighted works created in a year ... every one of the billion or so items posted to social media accounts on a near-daily basis is protected by copyright. Few if any of those have any real commercial value. The fraction of works fostered vs. works encumbered by copyright is parlous small.)

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by butvacuum on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:10PM (#49391870)
Honestly, I think we just need fo go back to life+75 or something that covers the next generation.

Copyright is a fairly basic protection on Work, and wanting to alter it to be based on percived value is catastrophic- On one end you'll deny copyright to security camera footage- nevermind it's of a meteorite and everybody is clamoring for a copy. Then, on the other hand you'll have micky mouse where it's such a big thing and Walt put so much effort into it that the copyright is perpetual. It'll tie up the courts, and give the Have's the power to remove the copyright or SLAPP the rightsholder into poverty.

We need patent reform far more than any complaint against Copyright that I've seen- and far too many people conflate the two. Lets not even talk about trademarks.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by somenameforme on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:45PM (#49383096)
Thinking more about monkeys, I think that case was made relatively easy because there was a normal living recipient for copyright, but that wasn't eligible for such. I'm fairly certain that dashcam footage, which is 100% automated, as you mention, is copyrighted by default. It's a fairly common source of footage of novel events like a meteorite, rocket impact, or whatever else. And that footage is licensed to media companies.

In any case, any country that decides neural network generated media isn't copyrighted then faces a major, and probably impossible, problem of trying to prove it wasn't made by a human.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by wahern on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:20AM (#49383749)
Theoretically, in the US dashcam, CCTV, and similar automated recordings are not copyrightable. In the US you can only copyright creative expression. However, the question hasn't been answered in court, yet, AFAIU.

That doesn't stop people from treating automated recordings as if they were copyrighted, though. Especially for media companies, licensing is standard operating procedure. Even if a media company's lawyers believe something isn't actually copyrightable, if the licensor and licensee believe it is, and especially if distribution outlets (e.g. YouTube) treat it as such, then it all works out.

In some other countries automated footage is copyrightable, AFAIU, but it varies.

> In any case, any country that decides neural network generated media isn't copyrighted then faces a major, and probably impossible, problem of trying to prove it wasn't made by a human.

In the US the initial burden is on the person claiming a copyright violation. In court that is met by simply showing a certificate from the Copyright Office. In fact, it's actually a requirement--you can't sue in court to enforce a copyright claim with a certificate. But in getting the certificate you would be making a declaration that it was made by a human.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by enquirewithin on Friday August 21, 2026 @01:04AM (#49384009)
Copyright is automatic upon creation.

Registering a work provides additional benefits.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by dannyw on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:00PM (#49382789)
A dashcam could be a safety tool for most people, but it could also be a strategically placed B-cam for a videographer on a shoot.

For what it’s worth, dashcam footage can absolutely be copyrightable.

The ruling is more about “only humans can get copyright protection”, not so much anything about whether a button is pressed or not.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by gnopgnip on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:25PM (#49382958)
There is a spark of creativity in the monkey case that very often doesn’t apply to dashcam footage
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by enquirewithin on Friday August 21, 2026 @12:26AM (#49383781)
Somebody exerted effort.

That’s it.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by trickypr on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:47PM (#49382688)
What if it was a human who took the photo, would the copyright still be owned by the equipment owner / person who set it up?

What if this applied in a photography class? The instructor owns the equipment and helped “set up” the photo. Does the instructor own the copyright?

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by tossaway0 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:06PM (#49383265)
After this ruling, I had an idea for a photo where I set up the entire set, camera, etc, but the photo entailed the model clicking the shutter while we were both in the shot. Just in case, I had the model write a quick note ceding the rights.

It's fine, I guess. How does it work in cinema? A director who is the creator of the project must have to get rights from every camera/mic operator.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by M95D on Friday August 21, 2026 @05:54AM (#49385922)
> A director who is the creator of the project must have to get rights from every camera/mic operator.

No, because they're already paid to do that job. And a director is paid too - he doesn't have any copyright for his work. The employer does.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by voxic11 on Friday August 21, 2026 @08:56AM (#49387412)
In cinema it works the same as in software engineering. There is an exception to normal copyright law where works made in the course of employment are treated as if the author is the employer rather than the actual author of the work. Its known in copyright law as a "work for hire" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work_for_hire

> In the United States, United Kingdom, and several other jurisdictions, if a work is created by an employee as part of their job duties, the employer is considered the legal author or first owner of copyright.

> It is an exception to the general rule that the person who actually creates a work is the legally-recognized author of that work.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by tossaway0 on Friday August 21, 2026 @11:29AM (#49389629)
So then a film project where no one is paid would need all operators to cede their copyright to the person spearheading the project, correct?

If employment is an exception, I wonder what would happen if an animal that you owned pressed the shutter on a camera.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by voxic11 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:27PM (#49439325)
Not paying anyone would be a violation of minimum wage laws. Or it would mean they are truly equal partners in the project who have no "employer" they are working under. In which case it does seem most fair that they would all own the copyrights to their contributions absent some other agreement to assign copyright.
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by kccqzy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:03PM (#49382805)
Dashcams and security footage definitely don’t have copyright protection. Are you seriously thinking that the construction worker who set up the camera would then have copyright over everything it records?
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by tossaway0 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:12PM (#49383300)
Really? Regardless of the debate on what should and shouldn't be copyrighted, in the current system there is no way to set up a continuous camera with intention to create something and not be afforded the same rights as if I took a snapshot?
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by randyrand on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:08PM (#49391837)
Yes the security guard’s footage would have copyright protection. However, a security guard is also typically paid and under contract. It’s a commissioned work.

Same as when hiring a software engineer.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by somenameforme on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:34PM (#49383004)
I think the issue you then run into is imagine another human came, picked up the camera, and used it to take a picture of whatever. It'd be fairly self evident that that the photographer would own the copyright to that work, but in your take - it'd be the camera owner.

So you're more of trying to create a special rule where if the normal recipient of a copyright would be invalid, then it slides to the 'nearest' most appropriate individual, but that seems extremely fragile and difficult to define.

Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by leobg on Friday August 21, 2026 @01:47AM (#49384257)
All this talk of animal rights, and then this! /s
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by RegardPointer on Friday August 21, 2026 @02:28AM (#49384503)
Haaaahahahahah this is the smart humor we all come for here lmao!!!!
Re:Copyright does not protect AI-generated content in EU by rho138 on Friday August 21, 2026 @04:43AM (#49385441)
Yeah not funny.