News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grok 4.6 by Someone1234 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:14PM (#49274759)
I'd start here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grok_(chatbot)#Controversies_a...

And here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grok_sexual_deepfake_scandal

I think polarizing is a generous way of describing the problems. My organization has outright banned Grok, because we don't trust SpaceX to hold up to contractual agreements vis-a-vis data-privacy/training. That's the level of reputational damage we're talking about here; and we use Chinese models (*hosted by US providers) for context.

Re:Grok 4.6 by everfrustrated on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:59PM (#49275456)
The US govt trusts SpaceXAI for defense and high security missions. The idea they are lying about contracted AI services is absurd. They're also a public company which beings even more oversight than openai / anthropic.
Re:Grok 4.6 by Someone1234 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:11PM (#49275625)
I think using the current US Government, and their corrupting relationships with SpaceX/SpaceXAi/et al, maybe isn't quite the positive argument you believe it to be. I'd suggest that relationship is why it is unlikely the DoJ wouldn't/hasn't gone after SpaceXAi for some of their existing controversial actions.

Nobody else wants to be in the blast radius for whatever SpaceX/SpaceXAi does next, or whatever their next controversy is. It is easier, when asked, "Do you use Grok?" just to be able to answer no, instead of having to explain why you aren't embroiled in whatever is going on this week.

Re:Grok 4.6 by UberFly on Thursday August 13, 2026 @01:48AM (#49282164)
"existing controversial actions"

Please elaborate. Details would be appreciated.

Re:Grok 4.6 by bakies on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:30PM (#49278133)
Running separate services for the government is very common in software services. Being public doesn't bring any technical oversight at all. I haven't actually heard of grok being used for the government security ive only ever heard Claude being used.
Re:Grok 4.6 by vrganj on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:35PM (#49278184)
Their closeness to the current US government is a cause for concern, it doesn't alleviate it.
Re:Grok 4.6 by jayd16 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:57PM (#49280557)
Is this top tier satire or pure naivety? You're arguing that military contractors or public companies couldn't possibly be corrupt or nefarious?
Re:Grok 4.6 by danso on Thursday August 13, 2026 @02:24AM (#49282383)
SpaceXAI has huge incentives for not reneging on its commitments to the U.S. government, and those incentives do not exist for entities that lack the power of the purse and guns of the U.S. government.

Furthermore there are plenty of examples of the Trump administration contracting for millions/billions of dollars with companies that aren’t at the top of their game. Are Intel’s fabs best in class because the U.S. bought 10% equity? Are Trump hotels and resorts the best in class because the government expenses for its employees to stay there?

Re:Grok 4.6 by ralusek on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:59PM (#49275461)
Can someone help me understand the deep fake controversy? That's like making photoshop illegal.
Re:Grok 4.6 by gazebo2 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:20PM (#49278032)
It was always possible to modify images to produce inappropriate or insensitive content, but plugging a turbocharged state of the art image generator with virtually no guardrails into every Twitter reply and then failing to address the issue long after it was obviously being used for CSAM or deepfakes of real people against their will.. well that's worse
Re:Grok 4.6 by Amezarak on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:53PM (#49279113)
Notice the Wikipedia link says the problem was "put her in a bikini." The claims about "Grok just lets you undress people" were massively exaggerated because people hate Elon (perhaps for good reason) and not worse than other models.
Re:Grok 4.6 by AlecSchueler on Thursday August 13, 2026 @09:33AM (#49285677)
Having clothes removed to the point of wearing a bikini is "being undressed" and I feel you're choosing not to understand the impact of being publicly sexualised in a bikini can have.

Grok is directly tied to Twitter in a way that other models don't have, so the use of Grok to do this stuff is inherently more public and traumatising for the targets.

You're right that people hate Elon and that they have good reason to do so, but you might be falling for the trap of underestimating the legitimate and unique concerns about Grok because it's easy to assign them just to "Elon hate."

Re:Grok 4.6 by dbbk on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:20PM (#49278034)
It generated CSAM what's not to get
Re:Grok 4.6 by BeetleB on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:32PM (#49277472)
Think of it this way:

If you install Photoshop locally (ignoring that it's now cloud based), and made deep fakes locally - that's probably fine. If something goes wrong as a result, only you are liable. It's a general purpose tool - the tool author isn't liable.

If you instead set up a server, and let users create deep fakes on that server, then as the operator of the server you have some level of culpability.

AI safety is a tricky topic. At some level, having it is a pain. It's a general purpose tool! Why limit me? The answer is that I don't control the tool, and am not the one running the tool - the provider is. If I don't want AI safety, then I need to run the model on my own machines (or on rented servers).

If an LLM provider is going to sell the service on the strengths of the benefits you get from it, they should take responsibility for the downsides.

Re:Grok 4.6 by numpad0 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:55PM (#49277723)
A lot of AI users are profoundly stupid and intently malicious. That changes perception of the tool... IMO it's because generative AI data is inherently toxic and contains elements that incite primal rage, but that's just my gut theory.
Re:Grok 4.6 by theshrike79 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:14PM (#49277252)
Doing a good "deepfake" Photoshop requires skill.

With an AI model it requires the ability to speak or write, not much more.

Re:Grok 4.6 by victorbjorklund on Thursday August 13, 2026 @04:44AM (#49283230)
Most people are against CSAM.
Re:Grok 4.6 by pmarreck on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:23PM (#49277350)
So basically, nothing that actually affects working with it in August 2026. Got it.

Facebook has a far longer (and worse) laundry list of offenses and I'm sure you still use it. Or Threads, or Instagram.

> My organization has outright banned Grok

That's too bad, as it's currently the only model that won't consistently flag honest good-actor security questions, in my experience. So I'd ask you who you work for, but I wouldn't want to expose them to extra security scrutiny. ;)

Oh, there's also this: https://artificialanalysis.ai/articles/grok-4-6-benchmarks-a...

Re:Grok 4.6 by Manfrednotfunny on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:18PM (#49278009)
You are only strawmanning around.

Apparently you are unable to coprehend that other peole have values.

Re:Grok 4.6 by pmarreck on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:05PM (#49278543)
*comprehend

*people

Also, that's not what strawmanning is. I never denied that Grok didn't act bizarrely offensively over a fucking year and a half ago (so did other LLMs, btw... and so have many other experiments over the years, remember Microsoft's?), which is an eternity in this space. I know Musk is polarizing, but give me a fucking break. Don't assume malice when social incompetence serves as an exculpatory factor.

Apparently, you are unable to comprehend that your opinion of things has been tainted away from the truth by an algorithm incentivized to outrage you. That what you call your "values" are, in fact, driven by someone else's greed for eyeball attention. Do you think civilizations that become anti-Western-values over time are more driven by facts and empiricism, or by catchy slogans that twist the truth and a media that uses cherry-picked examples which immediately trigger emotions?

Re:Grok 4.6 by Manfrednotfunny on Thursday August 13, 2026 @04:11AM (#49283043)
So i do care that Elon Musk is responsible for USAID shutdown. The richest man on the world shuts down human support so abruptly that he causes real humans to die.

Elon Musk, as the richest person on the planet, bought himself a propaganda platform he controls and started to finger around in democracy.

Its a lot more than 'just' CSAM.

Re:Grok 4.6 by pmarreck on Thursday August 13, 2026 @11:23PM (#49294438)
It disheartens me that if I want to find the most objective lowdown on the USAID and governmental meddling thing, I can get it trivially from an AI, and people will immediately dismiss it as slop, even if it provides receipts for all of its assertions:

https://chatgpt.com/share/6a7e8991-399c-83ea-bc65-2cf9a536fa...

Why don't more people do this, or trust it? Do they not want to get upset when their sacred cows are toppled? Do they not realize that getting their cows toppled actually makes them more correct? I don't know, and I'm starting to not care.

My statement to you is: I don't care what you believe or care about. I only care if you have actually faced the evidence against your beliefs and care. If they still stand after that from a good-faith point of view, then you can have them. Otherwise, they are just "partisan", and I have zero interest in partisan politics anymore, because it's way too bullshit-infused at this point, driven by a media whose profit only comes from outrage, and mired in people who are obsessed with identity politics.

(A friend once told me, "you are the most persuaded by evidence and argument of anyone I know... and that's a sad thing for humanity," so there's that.)

That said... My personal take (since I find this particular point unaddressed by the larger conversation around this) is that a lot of intangible value was lost by USAID going away, such as American goodwill. This then turns into fodder for terrorists... Which is, of course, very nearsighted. And the bill for that may come due one day.

Re:Grok 4.6 by kibac on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:40PM (#49277572)
The chinese are also mostly fine with good-actor security questions. Maybe even to comfortable.
Re:Grok 4.6 by pmarreck on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:03PM (#49278522)
too*
Re:Grok 4.6 by sigmarule on Thursday August 13, 2026 @01:00AM (#49281940)
Your experience is not reflective of mine at all, or my colleagues’, so I would check out the better SOTA models out again. I use codex extensively for security-related work - much of which is _overtly_ offensive - without issue. Same for Claude, minus Fable, after going through their approval process. I also went through OpenAI’s, but theirs was just basic KYC and instant. GPT-5.6 in Codex has produced full chain RCEs, ASLR bypass and all, in ubiquitous software with nothing more than a prompt and a few days of crunching. Things you’d be paying $$$ for just last year, now produced on not much more than a whim & a prompt. I can’t speak for Grok’s abilities wrt these types of things, but for your own sake, take the 5 mins it takes to complete the verification processes for OAI/Anthropic if you work in security.

Also, assuming people use Meta/FB/Instagram here, of all places, is certainly an assumption - very poor fodder for a “gotcha”. I find Elon’s political activities and the social beliefs he uses his purchased platform to spread loathsome and daft, and it will take a lot more than “almost as good on benchmarks but cheaper” to let my fiscal tendencies outweigh my moral ones. I’ve held similar beliefs for Zuck for far longer and have cut everything marred by the slime of his tentacles out of my digital life for years, as _many_ here have also done. Accusing someone of uneven application of moral influence over their decisions when you only have information relating to a single decision is poor argumentation.

If you find what Musk spreads palatable, or maintain distance and a lack of awareness, or just don’t care - fine. But don’t confuse the hill you chose with a moral high ground. Any snark you launch from such a position is likely going uphill, and then back down.

Re:Grok 4.6 by pmarreck on Thursday August 13, 2026 @11:14PM (#49294409)
> after going through their approval process

Are you really trying to compare my experience as a NON-certified security professional, with yours?

Mostly understood re: the rest. Musk knows what damage he caused, and he knows it likely because it hit him in the dollars.

Re:Grok 4.6 by wyldfire on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:18AM (#49286347)
And here https://www.npr.org/2025/07/09/nx-s1-5462609/grok-elon-musk-...

... which must be just a coincidence, right? Nothing to do with this:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=e2bbb-6Clhs