News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by Schlagbohrer on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:44AM (#49197423)
3-Body-Problem once again vindicated as the scariest possible explanation for the Fermi Paradox
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by 9dev on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:57AM (#49197631)
Many physicists have pointed out several flaws in the dark forest theory, which makes for a great read but doesn’t really carry over to the real universe 1:1.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by Schlagbohrer on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:08AM (#49197772)
Can you point me to more info on that or just tell me? I am curious about reasons to be more optimistic than that book lays out. I would much prefer the Carl Sagan view of the Cosmos as one where it simply makes no physical nor cultural sense at all to be aggressive toward other stellar civilizations.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by Vvector on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:17PM (#49201874)
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by xenophonf on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:27PM (#49205274)
That link is paywalled.

This might be a better one.

https://medium.com/predict/why-the-dark-forest-theory-is-pro...

This video is pretty good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0SvgT9Lc2M

This post attempts a formal refutation.

https://www.pgmusings.ca/journal/dfh

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by graemep on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:15AM (#49197858)
What flaws? Do they apply to variants such as Greg Bear's and related ideas such as berserkers?
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by pavel_lishin on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:06PM (#49199418)
Do Forge of God/Anvil of the Stars differ significantly from pretty bog-standard dark forest scenarios?

I don't remember any other of his books that might apply, but I haven't read all of them. (I probably should. What I have read was great.)

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by graemep on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:18PM (#49199565)
its a few years since I read Liu Cixin's books and even longer since I read Greg Bear's, but the technology was very different, and it was not as uniformly hostile. The primary technology used to destroy civilisations in Bear's books was self-replicating machines, and there was an advanced civilisation that tries to defend or rescue those attacked, and punish the aggressors - so its a bit less bleak.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by cyberax on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:43PM (#49204170)
"Dark forest" doesn't work from a game-theoretical standpoint. It assumes that it's cheap to destroy entire planets and solar systems. Yet no-one seems to be colonizing other systems.

The optimal strategy in this case is to expand as quickly as possible, before others can grab or destroy resources.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by idontwantthis on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:54PM (#49204264)
I think one idea is that there aren't very many habitable planets. The Trisolarians are coming to Earth because it's their only option, not because they want to destroy humanity.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by cyberax on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:02PM (#49204334)
Then it's even weirder. Detecting planets around stars is trivial, yet nobody is running to get that prime real estate?

Still makes no sense.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by aeve890 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:51AM (#49210396)
In the book, the trisolarans aren't coming to earth just because is the only habitable planet, it's because it's the closest one too. The don't have FTL and they spend the full resources of their dying civilization to build a fleet that will reach earth in ~400 years.

So yeah, a lot of prime real state but no way to reach it.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by cyberax on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:40PM (#49213807)
400 years is nothing. At this speed, all the Galaxy would have been colonized long ago.

This subplot in the book is at least reasonable. Somehow aliens capable of pico-scale engineering can't make a telescope to observe the nearby solar systems, but OK, whatever. Cultural blindness and all that.

It's the later plot with the "dark forest" that makes no sense. There are ships capable of moving at relativistic velocities and spacetime-altering weapons.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by Rover222 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:19AM (#49209969)
"no-one seems to be colonizing other systems"

seems like an odd thing to claim, given that we have no idea what's going on on any planet outside of our solar system

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by idiotsecant on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:24AM (#49211903)
How do we know nobody is colonizing every system we can see? How would you detect if earth was colonized?
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by krapp on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:29AM (#49212001)
Entropy and thermodynamics exist. It would be impossible to colonize every system we see without the tremendous heat energy expenditure needed to do so being obvious, and obviously not natural. The background temperature of space is so regular and predictable that any deviation is noticeable.

Barring some magical woo-woo technology that someone will probably insist must exist because we foolish humans are simply too stupid to understand anything, this isn't something you can just cheat. There ain't no stealth in space[0].

https://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/spacewardetect...

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by idiotsecant on Saturday August 08, 2026 @06:33AM (#49220482)
Ok great, but you didn't answer the central question. How would you detect earth civilization from interstellar distances?
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by cyberax on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:58PM (#49213280)
If you're colonizing systems so stealthily that it's not visible, then why bother doing that at all? Even a single solar system has more than enough resources.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by shagie on Saturday August 08, 2026 @05:40PM (#49226158)
David Webber - Safehold series. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safehold

The first book is Off Armageddon Reef - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off_Armageddon_Reef

    In the 24th century, 8 million people flee to distant Safehold after barely escaping from the destruction of civilization by a genocidal alien foe, the Gbaba. Because the enemy tracked signs of advanced technology to hunt down other emergency colonies, the plan is to enforce a pre-industrial society until the danger passes. Administrator Eric Langhorne, a megalomaniac and neo-Luddite, instead has the colonists' memories erased and replaced with the belief they are the first humans, "Adams" and "Eves," the creations of God upon Safehold with "Archangel Langhorne" anointed as prophet and leader of the Church of God Awaiting.
The first chapter can be read at the publisher's site: https://www.baen.com/Chapters/0765315009/0765315009.htm
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by bpodgursky on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:20AM (#49197938)
Why would physicists have anything useful to say about this theory?
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by 59percentmore on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:38AM (#49198154)
Because environment makes culture and physics are the environment at relativistic speeds and cosmic distances.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by Schlagbohrer on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:41AM (#49207107)
Culture at some level grows out of biology and physics, it's downstream of those things. The material basis of a civilization will have a tremendous long term impact on its culture.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by EA-3167 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:56PM (#49203164)
There are loads of issues with it as hard sci-fi, but the bigger issue is that it's meant as a political allegory far more than it's meant to be hard sci-fi. Where I think it shines to some extent in the latter case is its ability to explore scale and build intuition about the vast scales involved in space.

Otherwise though? Sophons destroy the entire premise of the "Dark Forest"! Still as I said the series is far more concerned with overt allegories (West vs East, Collectivism vs Individualism, etc), and more covert allegories that allegedly criticize the CCP's way of doing things.

I don't read Mandarin, but I suspect the ability to do so and the high context nature of the language, helps a lot in getting that across.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by criddell on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:55AM (#49197595)
Did you intend to say dark forest hypothesis?
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by istjohn on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:51AM (#49198326)
According to physicist Sean Carroll, "hypothesis" and "theory" are interchangeable as the words are used by practicing scientists.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by rigrassm on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:31PM (#49198951)
I love Sean Carroll (Something Deeply Hidden and From Eternity to Here are the root of my fascination with physics and endless pondering of the nature of time) but I have to disagree with his take on this.

Hypothesis - a proposed explanation for something (such as a phenomenon of unknown cause) that is tentatively assumed in order to test whether it agrees with facts that are known or can be determined.

Theory - a scientifically acceptable or plausible general principle or body of principles based on data and offered to explain phenomena

Just because those outside of scientific fields use them interchangeably doesn't change the fact that they carry different meanings in scientific contexts.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by criddell on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:39PM (#49199048)
Isn't Planck's hypothesis really a theory? Isn't string theory really a hypothesis?
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by marcosdumay on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:53PM (#49203740)
It seems to relate much more to the size of the proposal than to its confidence.

Even more because the confidence changes all the time, but people do go around renaming well known ideas

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by Schlagbohrer on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:07AM (#49197760)
Yes!
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by etangent on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:08PM (#49198621)
suspecting that star explosions are caused by nefarious super-intelligences is just Greek mythology with more steps.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:41AM (#49198189)
In what way? This is discussing, as far as anyone knows, an entirely natural phenomenon.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by echelon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:09AM (#49197780)
I think a fragile world hypothesis is more interesting and scary.

Instead of a superintelligence killing any emerging intelligence, superintelligence is so smart that it can perturb spacetime in ways that easily kill itself.

Kind of like the idea that LLMs will give anyone with a garage the ability to create killer viruses (wild claim), a superintelligence might trivially create black holes that engulf it. If the intelligence is distributed across many agents (or nations), someone will try something stupid that kills the entire population.

It'd be even scarier if they could accidentally collapse the supposed vacuum state. Universal annihilation at the speed of light just because you got too smart.

Fragile world / fragile universe meets "too smart for your own good".

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:58AM (#49198452)
Leaving aside the fact that there's no evidence superintelligence is even possible, no amount of intelligence alone will let you "trivially" create black holes. Creating black holes requires a ludicrous amount of energy. Planet-scale energy, maybe solar-scale energy. Energy is conserved. You can't just think really hard and have it. At minimum you have to already have the energy and materials to build a machine that will let you (mostly build another machine that lets you) harness that much energy.

It's at least not something you'll do by accident.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by echelon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:00PM (#49198484)
You don't know any of that.

We are primitive apes. We are all uniformly dumb.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:05PM (#49198586)
It's inherent to the math that defines the entire concept of a black hole, or "spacetime" in general. So to the extent we can contemplate the question at all, we can be pretty confident that creating black holes is Very Hard.

There's a lot we don't know, but the fact that the universe is consistent means it has to be consistent with what we do know already. Don't be so openminded your brain falls out.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by echelon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:24PM (#49198849)
> the fact that the universe is consistent

We don't know this either.

We are very limited in detection. Our energies are small.

How "standard" are standard candles and other references? Are the facts that stand as the basis for our theories even correct?

We are too primitive to be dealing in absolutes.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:53PM (#49199239)
> > the fact that the universe is consistent

> We don't know this either.

See this is what I'm talking about as far as being too open-minded. Consider what it would mean for the universe to be inconsistent, particularly in relation to the astronomical observations that are the basis of this conversation.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by strogonoff on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:20PM (#49203426)
All we can say is that the universe has been consistent so far, during the brief time we observed a small part of it given the instruments we have.

We update our model(s) so that it keeps being consistent and predictable to us (that’s human nature), but no model can be probably correct and complete.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:37PM (#49204916)
You are not grappling with the full consequences of the universe being inconsistent. If the universe is inconsistent, science is dead. Why the fuck on HN of all places do I need to defend the idea that science is possible? Back to philosophy class, all of you.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by graceful6800 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:42AM (#49210268)
Because you're being too narrow minded. Hubble Tension exists, the universe is not consistent. We take cosmological homogeneity as an axiomatic assumption and we keep being proved wrong.

The only thing we can say with confidence is that the base laws of physics appear to be mostly consistent everywhere we've looked in the last hundred or two years. But also only across relatively recent history. The laws of physics were very different early on. The electic and magnetic field used to be separate things and now they aren't.

None of this is incompatible with science as a concept.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:56AM (#49210472)
In case it wasn't clear, I'm only talking about whether the universe is logically consistent.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by strogonoff on Sunday August 09, 2026 @02:09AM (#49228858)
Finding consistency goes hand in hand with modeling reality, and every model by definition 1) is wrong (incomplete/incorrect/unprovable) and 2) exists in your head only.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by ButlerianJihad on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:58PM (#49199306)
Origami Black Hole https://m.xkcd.com/3033/

"It Really Brings the Room Together" https://m.xkcd.com/1680/

M87 Size Comparison https://m.xkcd.com/2135/

Black Hole Moon https://what-if.xkcd.com/129/

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by alansaber on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:15AM (#49197856)
Sounds logical to me. It's already remarkable that we haven't done this with fission weapons. It's not unreasonable to assume that within a century we'll have antimatter weapons. Destructive potential only goes up.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by WarmWash on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:26AM (#49198018)
Every year the IQ needed to destroy the world drops by 1 point.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by SoftTalker on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:01PM (#49199336)
We could not come close to destroying the world with fission weapons. We might make things very hard for humanity, but the world and life would continue, perhaps even benefit.