News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by echelon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:09AM (#49197780)
I think a fragile world hypothesis is more interesting and scary.

Instead of a superintelligence killing any emerging intelligence, superintelligence is so smart that it can perturb spacetime in ways that easily kill itself.

Kind of like the idea that LLMs will give anyone with a garage the ability to create killer viruses (wild claim), a superintelligence might trivially create black holes that engulf it. If the intelligence is distributed across many agents (or nations), someone will try something stupid that kills the entire population.

It'd be even scarier if they could accidentally collapse the supposed vacuum state. Universal annihilation at the speed of light just because you got too smart.

Fragile world / fragile universe meets "too smart for your own good".

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:58AM (#49198452)
Leaving aside the fact that there's no evidence superintelligence is even possible, no amount of intelligence alone will let you "trivially" create black holes. Creating black holes requires a ludicrous amount of energy. Planet-scale energy, maybe solar-scale energy. Energy is conserved. You can't just think really hard and have it. At minimum you have to already have the energy and materials to build a machine that will let you (mostly build another machine that lets you) harness that much energy.

It's at least not something you'll do by accident.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by echelon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:00PM (#49198484)
You don't know any of that.

We are primitive apes. We are all uniformly dumb.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:05PM (#49198586)
It's inherent to the math that defines the entire concept of a black hole, or "spacetime" in general. So to the extent we can contemplate the question at all, we can be pretty confident that creating black holes is Very Hard.

There's a lot we don't know, but the fact that the universe is consistent means it has to be consistent with what we do know already. Don't be so openminded your brain falls out.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by echelon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:24PM (#49198849)
> the fact that the universe is consistent

We don't know this either.

We are very limited in detection. Our energies are small.

How "standard" are standard candles and other references? Are the facts that stand as the basis for our theories even correct?

We are too primitive to be dealing in absolutes.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:53PM (#49199239)
> > the fact that the universe is consistent

> We don't know this either.

See this is what I'm talking about as far as being too open-minded. Consider what it would mean for the universe to be inconsistent, particularly in relation to the astronomical observations that are the basis of this conversation.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by strogonoff on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:20PM (#49203426)
All we can say is that the universe has been consistent so far, during the brief time we observed a small part of it given the instruments we have.

We update our model(s) so that it keeps being consistent and predictable to us (that’s human nature), but no model can be probably correct and complete.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:37PM (#49204916)
You are not grappling with the full consequences of the universe being inconsistent. If the universe is inconsistent, science is dead. Why the fuck on HN of all places do I need to defend the idea that science is possible? Back to philosophy class, all of you.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by graceful6800 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:42AM (#49210268)
Because you're being too narrow minded. Hubble Tension exists, the universe is not consistent. We take cosmological homogeneity as an axiomatic assumption and we keep being proved wrong.

The only thing we can say with confidence is that the base laws of physics appear to be mostly consistent everywhere we've looked in the last hundred or two years. But also only across relatively recent history. The laws of physics were very different early on. The electic and magnetic field used to be separate things and now they aren't.

None of this is incompatible with science as a concept.

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by andrewflnr on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:56AM (#49210472)
In case it wasn't clear, I'm only talking about whether the universe is logically consistent.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by strogonoff on Sunday August 09, 2026 @02:09AM (#49228858)
Finding consistency goes hand in hand with modeling reality, and every model by definition 1) is wrong (incomplete/incorrect/unprovable) and 2) exists in your head only.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by ButlerianJihad on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:58PM (#49199306)
Origami Black Hole https://m.xkcd.com/3033/

"It Really Brings the Room Together" https://m.xkcd.com/1680/

M87 Size Comparison https://m.xkcd.com/2135/

Black Hole Moon https://what-if.xkcd.com/129/

Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by alansaber on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:15AM (#49197856)
Sounds logical to me. It's already remarkable that we haven't done this with fission weapons. It's not unreasonable to assume that within a century we'll have antimatter weapons. Destructive potential only goes up.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by WarmWash on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:26AM (#49198018)
Every year the IQ needed to destroy the world drops by 1 point.
Re:Tiny Black Holes May Be Exploding Stars Across the Milky Way by SoftTalker on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:01PM (#49199336)
We could not come close to destroying the world with fission weapons. We might make things very hard for humanity, but the world and life would continue, perhaps even benefit.