News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:19PM (#48788639)
Seattle here, and a real estate nerd.

This is almost entirely an artifact of the financial instruments used to pay for these buildings, regardless of any Seattle policy changes. The Seattle Times has always been a conservative rag, and their editorial board hates the new mayor, so they hit the "Seattle is dying" story as often as possible. They've got a long history of this whenever there's leadership they don't like, ask me about it!

In Bellevue, office vacancies are low because most have long term tenants - even if the spaces aren't full of workers, the companies paying for them can continue to do so.

In Seattle, most office space is leased by smaller companies. We have diversity in availability, which is great, we have tiny office leases available as well as big ones. I believe those smaller spaces also often had shorter leases.

There are some spaces in Seattle where an anchor tenant (Indeed with 11 floors in the 2+U building at 1201 2nd Ave is a good example) shrank the footprint they use, and quickly sublet floors they aren't using. Those sublets can be priced appropriately for the market, and the main tenant keeps paying the original lease price.

However, when a space loses a tenant, the bank can't just drop the price for the owner, the same as you can't just pay less on your mortgage if you get a lower paying job. That has to go through a long, painful process, and usually the building will end up sold before pricing can change.

This is lag. It's easy to correlate it with a choice by Amazon or with new taxes, but there's quite a bit of demand for office space in Seattle, just not at the prices the owners are forced to ask with their financing instruments.

We just saw another building turn over, US Bank Center. The new owner bought it at a price where they'll be able to lease it competitively, and it won't sit empty. We'll see that continue to happen.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by nighthawk454 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:39PM (#48788864)
This tracks with what I’ve heard around as well. What changed in the financial instruments?

My understanding is a lot of the loans have gone PIK or otherwise essentially aren’t serviceable at current prices. Do you think that’s resolvable somehow or just lagging implosion?

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:07PM (#48789109)
Nothing changed in financial instruments - we just don't usually have a lot of office tenants decide to walk away like we have with the advent of remote work. The loans will work themselves out. We've seen a couple of buildings trade for way less than pre-Covid numbers, and we'll see more.

In another 10 years downtown Seattle will be aligned with the rest of the market again.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lokar on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:37PM (#48788827)
And you have to wonder, what kind of boom in innovation could lots of reasonably priced office space support? What gov policy cold push landlords and banks to accept reality? Vacancy tax? Change to bank regulations?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:05PM (#48789096)
The timeframe of regulatory changes here is not worth any investment. The turnover will continue to happen, it's too complicated to try to change, and you'd probably create nasty unexpected side effects.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lokar on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:15AM (#48794898)
Some could be fairly simple. Require banks to re-calculate collateral values after 6mo of vacancy, with a large requirement to reduce.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:42PM (#48799476)
Can you think of two potential downstream effects that could have that you wouldn't want?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by pfannkuchen on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:48PM (#48788934)
Make usury illegal again?

(I mean the classical definition not the watered down modern one)

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by hyperrail on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:37PM (#48788832)
> This is almost entirely an artifact of the financial instruments used to pay for these buildings, regardless of any Seattle policy changes.

Why would this be different in Seattle than in other cities? Many downtown office towers are bought or built using a lot of debt throughout the U.S. What do you think makes Seattle special?

> We just saw another building turn over, US Bank Center. The new owner bought it at a price where they'll be able to lease it competitively, and it won't sit empty. We'll see that continue to happen.

The news story mentions the U.S. Bank Center example. What it says that you're leaving out is just HOW big that discount is:

> The new owner of the U.S. Bank Center, having paid just $280 million, or less than half of what the building went for in 2019, presumably can afford to lower rents enough to fill the place, which is now 45% vacant, according to CoStar.

A discount of more than 50% is a bubble bursting. It's great that the new owner can offer fire-sale rent, but where does that leave the old owner, if they were truly as leveraged as you suggest they were likely to be?

> The Seattle Times has always been a conservative rag, and their editorial board hates the new mayor, so they hit the "Seattle is dying" story as often as possible. They've got a long history of this whenever there's leadership they don't like, ask me about it!

OK, I'll ask you about it. This "Seattle Times = Blethen family propaganda" line has been tiring for the 25 years I've been hearing it. What exactly are they not covering about Seattle's downtown today that you think they should be? Why do you think that their opinion staff influence the news coverage so much? In short, if the Seattle Times has a conservative bias in its news coverage, why does the Wall Street Journal famously have a liberal-biased newsroom?

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:04PM (#48789087)
Why is Seattle impacted worse? Because so much of our office space was tech companies that decided they didn't need as much office space and can do their work remotely.

Look up the old owner and you'll realize why it doesn't really matter that they're taking a massive loss, and why I don't really care. I left it out because it's already a long comment and that's not really relevant.

They could have written an article about how foreclosures on office buildings take a long time and that sublet offerings in Seattle are turning over at a healthy rate. And the owner of a company in media absolutely influences that coverage, why do you think everybody's worried about CBS, or for a long time Fox News?

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by BryantD on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:27PM (#48789261)
Think it's significant that Zillow's one of the few significant tech companies to maintain full remote working? They don't leave an Amazon-sized hole in downtown, but they had quite a few floors.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @06:22PM (#48789607)
I don't think they closed their office - have they reduced their actual leased footprint?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by BryantD on Saturday July 04, 2026 @08:56PM (#48790395)
They kept at least the main floor in Russell Investment Center. I don’t know if they have all ten+ floors any more. They were trying to sublease around 100K square feet right after the pandemic but I haven’t seen any news since then.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:58AM (#48791363)
Yeah, if they're subletting they probably can't get out of the space. I bet they were successful.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by unethical_ban on Sunday July 05, 2026 @05:05PM (#48797937)
>why does the Wall Street Journal famously have a liberal-biased newsroom?

Is this serious? I can't tell anymore.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by xnx on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:19PM (#48789202)
Is there any more to this story than "extend and pretend" that's been going on for 6 years?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:29AM (#48791261)
Tell me more? As commercial leases are ending the owners are finally having to accept foreclosure or sell.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by randsorex on Sunday July 05, 2026 @10:18AM (#48794466)
CRE also includes warehouses, multifamily apartments, retail, hotels, data centers, medical.

I think we kind of lucked out that we had the start of boom in 2023 instead of a recession.

The diversification has allowed the office space price to correct without a contagion.

As a general rule, any snappy memorable line like "extend and pretend" is almost always wrong and a distortion after awhile. The idea sticks around longer than it should because it is memorable, not because it has anything to do with reality.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by jmyeet on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:41PM (#48788880)
I'm not sure the bank has that much to do with it.

Commercial real estate valuation is based entirely on its ability to produce income. Lower the rent, lower the value. And that's a problem because most commercial leases are long (5-20+ years) so you're locking in an asset writedown for a long period of time. So it can be better to leave it vacant and pretend the value hasn't changed.

You can still run into problems with this (eg servicing the loan). So I don't think it's quite the issue that banks have to approve lowering the rent so much as the owner might lower their asset value and have problems with the LTV and DSCR so the bank may then require you to refinance or add capital.

By the way, we've gone through this before. Up until the 1990s, law firms were by far the largest tenants of office space because they had very large law libraries. Then that went online and they downsized. This was an acpolaypse in the 2000s combined with the dot-com bust.

I think the lag you're talking about is on banks essentially foreclosing on a building and selling it off, allowing the new owners to charge less because they paid less.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:00PM (#48789058)
Yes, that's exactly the lag I'm talking about. The banks won't allow the buildings to lease for less than they need to make per sqft to pay back their loans. They'd rather foreclose, apparently. There's some reporting around this recently, I'm not in a position to look it up today but it should be easy to find!
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by dlcarrier on Saturday July 04, 2026 @09:15PM (#48790479)

    In Bellevue, office vacancies are low because most have long term tenants…
Well yeah, Bellevue isn't trying to drive all of the office tenants out of their city.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by halestock on Saturday July 04, 2026 @11:47PM (#48791102)
I'll bite, how's Seattle doing that?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by thorncorona on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:27AM (#48791454)
Crime. Everyone moves from DT Seattle to the eastside when they start a family. It’s normalized at this point, where if you see a potential threat u just walk across the street and go on with your business.

Hostile business environment. Jumpstart, inflationary wage environment, etc.

Living in DT Seattle is just meh. Expensive and the food scene is terrible due to local labor policies.

Inability to get anything done from the local govt. Wilson spent her campaign promising to make it easier to build housing and just gave in to nimby interests again.

Local politics is lunacy. Constant issues with the the unhoused population but it’s ok let’s just keep pushing it to little Saigon / Chinatown! Close your eyes since it doesn’t happen if you’re in Wallingford, QA, or Ballard!

Fewer and fewer major cos investing into the area.

And then there’s 0 transit enforcement or even any attempt at it. We don’t even have fare gates on the link for gods sake.

It’s just completely absurd how mismanaged this city is, despite how much potential there is.

Nowadays more and more offices opening in Bellevue.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by murderfs on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:36AM (#48791498)
They passed a tax on basically just Amazon in 2018 and there were rumblings of Amazon leaving the city for Bellevue/Redmond. The city council repealed it within a month and things quieted down, but then COVID happened, they passed basically the same tax again, and this time it stuck. Since then, Amazon's been slowly leaving Seattle for the eastside by moving employees as their building leases expire: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/amazon/amazon-no-longe...
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by hx8 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:45AM (#48791536)
Bellevue has a few advantages over Seattle. Seattle imposes a city level payroll tax that isn't in Bellevue, and there are other tax implications. Seattle's minimum wage is higher. Seattle has a more visible drug/homeless problem.

Seattle can charge a premium for its advantages over Bellevue because they provide additional value, and the premium Seattle charges is actually less than most people make it out to be.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by naturalmovement on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:11AM (#48791192)
> The Seattle Times has always been a conservative rag

The Seattle Times is Left-Center with a high credibility rating. [1]

Such a deliberate distortion of the facts renders the rest of your screed null and void.

[1] https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/seattle-times/

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lukeschlather on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:17AM (#48791220)
They're looking at national politics, and on that score, yes, the ST is liberal. When it comes to local politics the Seattle Times is conservative. Your objection is a bit like people who object that the Democrats are conservatives, from a European perspective, except this is about the city itself. The current mayor is liberal, the previous mayor was conservative. They're both Democrats and would be defined as liberals by your factcheck, but that's a different rubric than the one we're talking about.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by hitekker on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:42AM (#48791521)
Using local labels to communicate to an (inter)national audience is a bit foolish, I think.

In SF, we have a wealthy clique who are locally labeled as “progressives” and who are also contradictorily against new housing. They even veto’d building a new apartment complex on a parking lot!

I’d personally call that clique “NIMBY” since their “progressive” label is essentially designed for propagating denialism among the credulous.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lukeschlather on Sunday July 05, 2026 @03:48AM (#48792125)
Using (inter)national labels when discussing local politics is incoherent.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by solid_fuel on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:15AM (#48791681)
> In SF, we have a wealthy clique who are locally labeled as “progressives” and who are also contradictorily against new housing.

Right, but a lot of those folks are probably supportive of gay marriage and women's bodily autonomy, which does make them progressive compared to huge swaths of America even if they have regressive politics on housing. I don't know if the national labels would really be any more useful in this case.

The Seattle Times is the relatively conservative paper in Seattle, but it's still "liberal" in the sense that it happily criticizes Trump and isn't calling for a "straight pride" month.

Realistically the local labels probably paint the clearest picture of the dynamics at play. Seattle Times was pretty strongly opposed to Katie Wilson in the run-up to the mayoral election, and I think that still affects their coverage.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by dualvariable on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:44AM (#48791816)
If you just focus on capitalism, the apparent paradoxes dissolve.

The wealthy clique in SF aren't really left-wing.

Neither is the Seattle Times.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by twoWhlsGud on Sunday July 05, 2026 @03:11AM (#48791946)
If you are bad enough at building coalitions you can lose almost any election regardless of how evil or corrupt the opposition, is too : )

"FRANCIS: Whatever happened to the Popular Front, Reg?

REG: He's over there.

P.F.J.: Splitter!"

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by siren2026 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:59AM (#48791364)
As a European, Democrats are absolutely not conservative from a European perspective. There are multiple dimensions but at least socially they push everything further to the left than in Europe. (Which is also in my opinion why they are losing elections)

Almost every social topic is pushed to the extreme left by the Democrats. Simply look at how many weeks abortion is allowed in blue state and compare with most European countries. Most European countries are way more conservative.

Economically yes, they are more conservative but even that is now changing as well (see: New York and AOC).

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by sterlind on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:02AM (#48791629)
and migrants? I think liberal parties in European countries seem to be much more supportive of refugees than Democrats, current Republican rhetoric aside. also, police, and guns. meanwhile, even with the issue you singled out, most red states in the US have enacted near-total abortion bans. do any countries in Europe ban abortion outright? are the conservative parties pushing for it?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by brookst on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:54AM (#48791584)
How do Democrats’ policies on health care, paid leave from work, unions, public funding of political campaigns, and public transit compare to European conservatives?

If you’re a single-issue abortion voter, yes the US democrats tend to propose fetal viability (22 weeks or so) as the limit, while most of Europe is 12 weeks. UK and Netherlands are 24.

But if you genuinely believe US democrats are wildly liberal, you must be that rare European Fox News watcher.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by philwelch on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:59AM (#48793490)
> If you’re a single-issue abortion voter, yes the US democrats tend to propose fetal viability (22 weeks or so) as the limit

No, the standard Democrat policy is to allow abortion on demand at any point prior to birth—40 weeks or so.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by 0x1d7 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @09:21AM (#48794129)
It’s fortunate we’re on HN to easily identify this comment as sarcasm, but can you imagine being so ignorant as to believe this? What kind of brainwashing is required to think one could get an “abortion on demand” up to birth?

Truly such a belief could only come from the lowest IQ amongst humanity.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by philwelch on Monday July 06, 2026 @11:02PM (#48813228)
That's the law in Colorado, DC, Maryland, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, and Vermont, all of which are blue states.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by aardvarkr on Sunday July 05, 2026 @09:30AM (#48794202)
Prove it
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by philwelch on Monday July 06, 2026 @10:58PM (#48813195)
Democrats opposed the Partial-Birth Abortion Act of 2003, and multiple blue states allow abortion at any point prior to birth.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by brookst on Sunday July 05, 2026 @04:16PM (#48797593)
This is false. Not sure if propaganda or ignorance of infowar, or lying for the fun of it, but 100% false.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by bragr on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:20AM (#48791710)
I think you have a particularly poor read on American politics.

>they push everything further to the left than in Europe. (Which is also in my opinion why they are losing elections)

No, the democratic electoral base is consistently and loudly complaining that after the primaries, most democrat candidates become moderates in the general election (even actively courting Republicans) and do not follow through on the primary election promises when elected. This has resulted in major democratic voter apathy and low turnout.

>Simply look at how many weeks abortion is allowed in blue state and compare with most European countries.

This is true, but you have to contextualize it to America, where people have poor or no sex ed, no access to socialized medicine, no time off from work for medical appointments, likely no public transport to the appointments, and very possibly now needing to travel out of state.

>Economically yes, they are more conservative but even that is now changing as well (see: New York and AOC).

That's very much TBD. First, NYC is not very representative of America as a whole. Second, while there has been a small wave of recent democratic socialist victories that has been well covered in the news, it is too soon to say that's a long term trend or just a Trump induced aberration. Mandani is making a splash currently, but he's just a mayor. I like AOC's politics, but she's too much of an outsider to have any real influence in Congress. She probably has more influence on social media than she does in Congress. I'm not aware of any legislation introduced by her actually becoming law. Maybe if this trend continues, there will be enough to form an influential caucus in Congress. However, as of now, no one is really listening to the extreme left in Congress and we've never had an extremely liberal president during my lifetime.

If you disagree, I'd be happy to have you point out some counter examples from party members with actual power (presidents, governors, state legislature leadership, senators, house leadership, committee chair persons or ranking members), but they all tend to be moderate.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by will4274 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @09:19AM (#48794102)
> No, the democratic electoral base is consistently and loudly complaining that after the primaries, most democrat candidates become moderates in the general election

Actually, about the same number of Democrats say their candidates are too liberal as not liberal enough. E.g. for Harris, both numbers hover between 10 and 15 percent.

The not liberal enough cohort is especially loud, particularly online, but the data shows candidates end up about at the primary voter average, as you might expect.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by inigyou on Sunday July 05, 2026 @06:56AM (#48793103)
Is this accounting for the fact that European countries with strict abortion laws don't really enforce them any more?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by philwelch on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:54AM (#48793457)
In Seattle you’re considered conservative if you’re not a Marxist.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by zeafoamrun on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:48AM (#48791557)
Just goes to show how loony politics are in Seattle for ST to seem conservative to people.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:03AM (#48794807)
It's very conservative - just along certain axes that are especially locally relevant. For instance, they've opposed both our 2008 and 2016 mass transit ballot measures (both of which passed with strong support). They were supportive, until we replaced the primary owner's express onramp on Interstate 90 with a train.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by SilverElfin on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:44PM (#48795638)
Seattle Times is left leaning. Just because your pet measure of transit was opposed doesn’t make it otherwise. Calling it conservative is simply unmoored from reality. It’s also a display of what Seattle politics are like and why it has declined so much on so many facets in a short 20 years. The rampant progressive extremism is the root cause of the issues affecting Seattle. There is no balance or practical governance.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by beej71 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:26AM (#48794978)
Fallacy of composition.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by IG_Semmelweiss on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:17AM (#48791219)
What are the financial "instruments" ?

The main claims from the article seem worrysome, IN particular, the 37% vacancy rate, as well as multiple buildings underwater[3], etc.

Now, lets dissect the claims that this is part of some cycle, and not the result of new city hall management. The reality is that with Jumpstart, and with the vacancy rate, enterprises are not renting. But, the owner is stuck with the asset in what is now a hostile jurisdiction. So, even if owner may not be able to change terms on their mortgage, they certainly can charge less for rent. Empty units do not contribute to cash flows to pay the building mortage. I understand there may be consequences to lowering rents, but those consequences are coming home anyway: The building will need to be sold, at a loss, by the bank to a new owner. And as you said, that process takes time. And the jurisdiction seems hellbent to make it harder.

Now, as buildings sell, this in turn lowers the appraised value, which is key to the Seattle tax base.

So, the downtown core is going to produce far less in property taxes in the foreseeable future, with fewer tenants paying (at least in short term) occupancy taxes, etc. This is going to play out in a decade.

According to this, commercial property taxes are about 26 %[1] of the Seattle budget

Let's assume appraisals go down 50% for those impaired offices. This is not crazy, there's precendent for it[2]. That means the Seattle budget must be cut by 13%. This is not even factoring other losses from job loss, sales tax lost, etc. Maybe that's not "Seattle is dying" , but sound pretty bad ?

[1] https://www.seattle.gov/documents/departments/financedepartm...

[2] Seattle/downtown office properties lost ~$10–15+ billion in assessed value since 2020 (46–48% drop) . https://cdn.downtownseattle.org/app/uploads/2026/06/New-Repo...

[3] https://www.king5.com/article/money/business/downtown-seattl...

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:27AM (#48791245)
The financial instruments are commercial real estate loans.

Those loans often do not allow the borrower to charge lower rent.

Property taxes are not calculated that way. The property tax rate for a given year is backed into (a "mill rate") based on approved dollars of spending divided by total property value. If total citywide property value drops by 50%, the property tax rate doubles that year.

So no, the property value changes aren't really an issue.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by hedgehog on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:11AM (#48791409)
I'll add a few bits. Commercial leases are typically "triple net" so taxes are passed pretty much directly through to tenants and land lords don't need to worry too much about them. A very visible part of the "dead downtown" effect is due to small businesses that have terrible margins, high fixed costs (including rent), and don't survive losing 20% of their customer base. And finally, anyone paying attention saw that Seattle core downtown is a highly concentrated bet on office rental to the exclusion of almost any other use of space or reason to go there.

A few years back I did an art installation in one of the storefronts at the 2+U building and in the process got to study up on some of the issues and talk to a few people, the general theme was that everyone had a vested interest in focusing on possible causes that were external and fixable within a short time. I don't think that's reality.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lotsofpulp on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:40AM (#48791518)
>Those loans often do not allow the borrower to charge lower rent.

I have never seen it substantiated that a promissory note in commercial real estate has a clause that dictates how the borrower can price their products or services.

There will be terms for the borrower to be in default if they lose too much revenue or their expenses go up too much, such as leaving spaces empty:

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dscr.asp

Whether a lender wants to foreclose on a borrower in default is far from guaranteed. Often times, they are loathe to take over management of a building so they simply work out a new agreement with the borrower.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by bruce511 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:07AM (#48791649)
No there won't be clauses about rental amounts. It's not that straightforward.

It boils down to collateral for the loan.

A building has a value based on future rents. The owner borrows from the bank based on that value. The building is collateral for the loan.

The rental rate (not occupancy) determines the current building value. (Occupancy affects cash-flow, but not building value.)

Reducing rent improves cash flow, which may help paying the loan, but loan payments here are not important.

What is important is that the collateral covers the loan. Reducing the rent triggers a re-evaluation of the building value, which in turn affects the loan. There's no discretion here, it's just math.

On the other hand, as long as the owner continues to pay the installment on the loan, and as long as the building remains the same value, the banker doesn't have to do anything.

Yes, there are ways the price can be fudged a bit (bundling services, remodeling allowances and so on) but the "list price" of the rent can't come down without (automatically) triggering loan problems.

Since property companies tend to have multiple properties, cash flow is sufficient to pay the loan. So that's a lot better than triggering a revaluation.

In short commercial real estate does not behave like residential real estate.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by bombcar on Sunday July 05, 2026 @06:30AM (#48792963)
This is exactly the key - residential real estate is based on tons of pricing effects, and appraisals are much more "feels" than "reals", if you will (how people feel about the area, how they feel about the tower the previous owner added, how they feel about the location, etc).

Commercial real estate valuations are almost entirely a mathematical formula based on rents, current, whether they're collecting them or no. And if the rents drop (e.g., you start renting it at a lower square foot rate) the valuation drops, which can require recollateralization (e.g., unlike your house, the banks require that the loan NEVER be more than 50% LTV or something) so if the value of the property calculation makes it go above that, you have to pay down the loan or add additional property as collateral.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lotsofpulp on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:18AM (#48793234)
Residential real estate has a lot of sweetheart terms due to government subsidies, especially in the US. That is why you don’t see 30 year fixed rates anywhere else, and 0% down loans anywhere else.

The DSCR equivalent for residential real estate is debt-to-income ratio. In a free market, it is conceivable that lenders offer lower interest rates for borrowers who periodically prove their DTI is sufficient. That is basically what refinancing is, and what people with adjustable rates mortgages have to do.

> residential real estate is based on tons of pricing effects, and appraisals are much more "feels" than "reals",

If you have looked at a residential real estate appraisal, there is a very real process of gathering comps, evaluating the structure, discounting for wear and tear of major maintenance items such as roof, HVAC, etc. If anything, because residential real estate sales volume is so much higher than commercial, residential is more “reals” than “feels”.

> if you will (how people feel about the area, how they feel about the tower the previous owner added, how they feel about the location, etc).

Who are these “people”? Because if we are talking about appraisers, this should disqualify their license to appraise. Appraisers should be mostly looking at competitive sale prices, per sq ft construction costs of major house components, and other objective criteria. Why else would a lender pay them to evaluate a property?

>Commercial real estate valuations are almost entirely a mathematical formula based on rents, current, whether they're collecting them or no

This is not true. Try calling up a lender and asking to borrow money without showing them cash flow, and they will hang up on you.

> And if the rents drop (e.g., you start renting it at a lower square foot rate) the valuation drops, which can require recollateralization (e.g., unlike your house, the banks require that the loan NEVER be more than 50% LTV or something)

They literally do this, via DSCR. If you stop renting space, your operating income goes down, which causes the DSCR to go down, which triggers a default, which means the lender can negotiate new terms, which could involve the borrower putting up more money, extended loan terms, change in interest rate, anything.

The alternative to a loan with a DSCR is usually a 5 year adjustable rate mortgage, which usually has a higher interest rate and then in 5 years, you still have to use your cash flow to qualify for another loan, so eventually someone will want to see income for the property

This is a good guide:

https://www.occ.gov/publications-and-resources/publications/...

On page 21, for underwriting standards:

> Effective CRE lending policies generally reflect the following for each type of loan or property:

>• Minimum standards for borrower or project net worth, support provided by guarantees (if applicable), borrower and guarantor cash flow, and debt-service coverage ratio (DSCR).

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by aardvarkr on Sunday July 05, 2026 @09:23AM (#48794139)
Residential real estate appraisals are done by under employed real estate agents. They’ll always find a way to justify the number that you paid, like during Covid when I bid $200k over asking for a $1M house, the appraiser didn’t bat an eye and got to that number. That was totally based on vibes.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lotsofpulp on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:55AM (#48795228)
I don’t know what “under employed real estate agents” means, but the appraiser that the lender cares about is in no way associated with the real estate agents. The lender picks the appraiser (a licensed professional usually working as an independent contractor) who submits a report to the lender, who then determines whether or not they want to use it.

Asking price also has nothing to do with market value, so offering $200k more over asking would be irrelevant to the appraiser. You should have received a report showing recently sold houses similar to the one you were buying and other physical features that justified the appraisal.

There is even an appraisal contingency in most purchase agreements that outline what to do if an appraisal comes in lower than what a buyer offers to pays. Typically, the buyer can exit the purchase and get their earnest money back, or they can put additional money down to cover the gap between the appraisal and the offer price.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by consensus1 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:40PM (#48795597)
If a house is getting so many bids that it sells for 200K over asking, then that is pretty clearly the market price as determined by auction. Of course the appraisal would sat that is the value because it is.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by consensus1 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:38PM (#48795589)
This sounds like a conspiracy theory. Why would a bank be willing to accept a valuation based on a fictional rent number?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by lotsofpulp on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:04AM (#48793147)
> Reducing the rent triggers a re-evaluation of the building value, which in turn affects the loan. There's no discretion here, it's just math

What is “the” rent? The building has multiple tenants (usually), at various prices. It makes no sense that there is a specific price that the landlord cannot rent at to any one tenant that “triggers” a re-evaluation.

If the lender wants a continuous view into the collateral’s value, which any lender with two brain cells to rub together would, then it would require a minimum DSCR, which they do.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dscr.asp

>On the other hand, as long as the owner continues to pay the installment on the loan, and as long as the building remains the same value, the banker doesn't have to do anything.

This is not sufficient for most CRE loan covenants.

https://www.cohenandsteers.com/insights/the-commercial-real-...

> And 75% of CMBS office loans have a debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) greater than 1.5x (Exhibit 9). This helps to mitigate the risk of term default (i.e., a default prior to a loan’s maturity) since the net cash flow on the properties sufficiently covers interest payments. Generally, term default risk is more of a concern when the DSCR falls below 1.25x. But only 15.5% of CMBS office loans currently have a DSCR in this range.

> Yes, there are ways the price can be fudged a bit (bundling services, remodeling allowances and so on) but the "list price" of the rent can't come down without (automatically) triggering loan problems.

>Yes, there are ways the price can be fudged a bit (bundling services, remodeling allowances and so on) but the "list price" of the rent can't come down without (automatically) triggering loan problems.

DSCR cannot be fudged this way, without engaging in fraud. That’s the whole point, looking at cash flow for the specific collateral gives the lender insight into how well the collateral is being managed and market conditions.

>Since property companies tend to have multiple properties, cash flow is sufficient to pay the loan. So that's a lot better than triggering a revaluation.

Nothing I am reading indicates this is the case. The idea that lenders would want to pretend a business is fine just because they stop selling rather than sells at a lower price than at some point in the past is not passing the smell test. If lay people on the internet can figure out the folly in this concept, then surely the people betting millions and billions can.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by twoodfin on Sunday July 05, 2026 @10:47AM (#48794690)
The discourse about commercial real estate in downtowns (well-beyond this thread) has taken on a kind of “one neat trick” wishful thinking.

If only the greedy owners or banks would recognize their massive investments had lost hundreds of billions in value due to declining demand, then… the underlying causes of that decline in demand and the consequences if it persists can be waved away?

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by kilotaras on Sunday July 05, 2026 @05:16AM (#48792579)
Aren't same instruments being used in Bellevue as well?

"No lowering rent" rules are making downturn worse, but the trigger is something else.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:43PM (#48799492)
I tried to cover this in my original comment - Bellevue hasn't lost as many tenants because they're usually larger and have longer leases. They may yet have an increase in vacancy rate.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by IG_Semmelweiss on Sunday July 05, 2026 @09:11AM (#48794039)
>>> Property taxes are not calculated that way. The property tax rate for a given year is backed into (a "mill rate") based on approved dollars of spending divided by total property value. If total citywide property value drops by 50%, the property tax rate doubles that year.

When the LLCs that own the commercial buildings declare themselves bankrupt, and walk away from the asset and throw the keys on the table, who pays the 50% increase ? The banks?

Will banks own a 50% increase in property taxes ?

What about residents ? Renters ?

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:47PM (#48799512)
I think you're starting from two flawed assumptions.

1. Most of our largest buildings are owned by large companies. For instance, Gaw Capital owns Columbia Center. Blackstone owned US Bank Center, until it was bought by Spear Street Capital.

2. You could delete downtown and citywide property value wouldn't drop by 50%. Nothing's moving that fast, I'm just using simple math to explain mill rate.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by opo on Sunday July 05, 2026 @04:56PM (#48797866)
>...If total citywide property value drops by 50%, the property tax rate doubles that year.

This claim is simply not true. Even in a budget based system like Seattle, there are hard statutory limits on how much the tax could increase.

If total citywide property value drops by 50%, the tax rate would hit its legal maximum ceiling, and the city would have to make up the money somewhere else or cut spending.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:43PM (#48799485)
The only statute I'm aware of is a limit on revenue increasing more than 1% a year. Not a limit on percentage. Can you point me to this statute?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by opo on Monday July 06, 2026 @01:20AM (#48800902)
One big limitation is RCW 84.52.050 (Limitation of levies) which I think implements the 1% constitutional max allowed levy. I read somewhere that Seattle is at a levy of about 9.4, so that would be a hard limit right there.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Monday July 06, 2026 @11:32AM (#48806117)
That's a limit on total revenue, not percentage.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by opo on Tuesday July 07, 2026 @12:20AM (#48813624)
The 1% limit is a limit on the level of the property tax. If property tax values somehow fell by 50%, in theory, the property tax rate would double to ensure city operations remain funded. However, Seattle is almost at the statutory limit right now so there isn't much room to increase the rate - I this scenario the city would hit the 1% limit and be forced to get the money somewhere else or cut its budget instead. As I initially wrote:

>...If total citywide property value drops by 50%, the tax rate would hit its legal maximum ceiling, and the city would have to make up the money somewhere else or cut spending.

And the city wouldn't even get all of the increase it is allowed as there are other tax districts who would also want a higher rate. The tax increase that would be allowed would be prorated with the other tax districts.

(The 1% revenue growth cap you referred to earlier is a different statute and a different issue.)

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by toast0 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:29AM (#48791464)
> So, the downtown core is going to produce far less in property taxes in the foreseeable future, with fewer tenants paying (at least in short term) occupancy taxes, etc. This is going to play out in a decade.

> According to this, commercial property taxes are about 26 %[1] of the Seattle budget

In WA state, the property tax collected isn't related to the total of the assessed value. The total tax billed across all existing properties typically goes up 1% per year (the "levy lid"), unless voters have allowed a "levy lid lift". That total is apportioned amongst the properties by value.

So if everybody's property values drop in half, their property tax rate doubles (plus a little) and their tax bill stays about the same.

Of course, if commercial property assessments drop and residential assessments stay the same or go up, commercial bills will drop and residential bills will go up. But the total tax bill will still be 1% more than last year.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by adam_arthur on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:33AM (#48791284)
An increase in vacancies across the board is reduction in demand, plain and simple.

That the new equilibrium price to re-tenant all the buildings is lower is evidence of that.

But the OP is correct that when enough of the building owners default on their debt, the building will be foreclosed, sold for less and asking rents will go down towards the new equilibrium price.

Thus occupancy is likely to improve again down the line.

But, yes, this is not a bullish situation for Seattle. Office generally hasn't been doing well nationally, so it's more of a question of relative performance.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Monday July 06, 2026 @11:36AM (#48806167)
Honestly, I think is a bullish situation for Seattle.

With vacancy this high we're likely a more attractive place to start a small company, as recollateralization and foreclosure put square footage on the market at competitive prices.

For those who compare to Bellevue - in 2025 we grew population at 0.8% to Bellevue's 0.2%. You'd never know that from the vacancy reporting.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by adam_arthur on Monday July 06, 2026 @04:06PM (#48809786)
Drop in rents is drop in demand, plain and simple.

Fewer businesses want to invest and move into Seattle at the price it used to cost.

It's true that if occupancy is poor, then a recovery in occupancy will bring more activity.

It's bullish in the same way that cheaper housing due to increased crime and decline in quality of life draws in new residents.

Again, office is doing poorly nationally, but it does seem particularly worse in Seattle than other hubs.

If I'm not mistaken, Seattle has the worst office vacancy in the country by a decent margin, aka the most demand destruction.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Monday July 06, 2026 @07:35PM (#48811904)
If you look back at my original comment, you'll note I mentioned that sublets at appropriate pricing are filling quickly. Occupancy isn't appropriate for current demand. Occupancy is depressed by owners avoiding recollateralization.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by adam_arthur on Thursday July 09, 2026 @12:26PM (#48848498)
You seem to be missing that if prices are lower, demand is lower. Price is a function of demand.

If rents go from 10000/month at 100% occupancy to 5000/month at 100% occupancy, demand has been materially reduced.

That occupancy will recover does not support your point in the way you seem to think it does.

It's a natural market function that a drop in demand will lead to a drop in prices, and eventually, a commensurate increase in consumption (at lower prices)

This happens everywhere, and out of everywhere Seattle is doing the worst.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by edg5000 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @12:56AM (#48791355)
Your argument is that it's simply because of dropping prices. Maybe that does explain the bulk of it. But the article seems to suggest it's the WFH transition. How much of the vacancy rate would be explained by that?
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by carljungslabtek on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:43AM (#48791813)
I can tell you specifically that Indeed dropped its footprint because of WFH. They moved into that building during covid, then shortly after introduced permanent work from home / hybrid.

The other person’s point about rents probably explains the continued emptiness but WFH definitely drove the abandonment. And that newspaper does suck.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by brookst on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:44AM (#48791535)
Is there any reason to think WFH rates would differ between Seattle and Bellevue?

I’m not super knowledgeable in this area but GP is right the The Seattle Times is a very partisan outlet that spins confirmation bias into everything. Left-leaning politicians elected? The rain is their fault. Centrists (because this is Seattle)? They’re doing the best they can, maybe give more money to Amazon?

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by Schiendelman on Sunday July 05, 2026 @09:16AM (#48794078)
"Explained by" is complicated - 100,000 square feet of empty space that is leased to a company and unused is not vacant.
Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by expedition32 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @06:55AM (#48793095)
Cities don't die they just go into hibernation for a few decades only to wake up and grow stronger.

The whole office real estate thing operates on a boom bust cycle.

Re:As downtown Seattle offices empty, city facing years of '... by carlosjobim on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:32AM (#48793322)
> However, when a space loses a tenant, the bank can't just drop the price for the owner, the same as you can't just pay less on your mortgage if you get a lower paying job.

You can always pay less on your mortgage or any other debts if you are in a crisis and negotiate with the lenders. They prefer this immensely over not receiving anything at all. And in the long run they also receive more interest this way.

It's very common especially for businesses to enter these kind of negotiations with the banks, and not very uncommon for individuals either.

So it makes much better sense for everybody involved to sublet these spaces for market value, even if that income doesn't cover the original mortgage, because something is better than nothing. Somewhere there's a giant perverse incentive in situations like this.