News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by tmnvix on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:22AM (#48625639)
We don't always have to consider the apparently very fragile and fickle motivations of investors. Social housing can and has worked very well in many cases.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by CalRobert on Monday June 22, 2026 @04:05AM (#48627192)
Unfortunately, most housing "investors" are people who bought a home 10-30 years ago and will be furious if they can't sell at a large profit compared to what they bought it for.

Sadly, a lot of places (Netherlands and Ireland come to mind) _discourage_ you from investing in things like stocks, and _encourage_ you to "invest" in a primary residence, making the problem even worse.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by tommica on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:26AM (#48625664)
Where has it been successful, and what counts as success in that? I genuinely do not know.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by BobaFloutist on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:33AM (#48625696)
It's been exceptionally successful in Singapore, for one.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by dreijs on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:50AM (#48626230)
I currently live in an HDB property in Singapore. It's great.

I'm originally from the Netherlands, which traditionally had a strong social housing sector: regions and cities would have their own housing corporations ('woningbouwcorporaties') tasked with building affordable housing. Those corporations were given government support after 1950 to help with the post-WW2 housing shortage, but were semi-privatized in the mid-90s, and in 2015 their scope was strongly curtailed.

It would be reductive to say that this privatization was the sole cause of the current housing crisis affecting the Netherlands -- rents and housing prices have also increased a lot in Singapore since Covid -- but it probably didn't help.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Monday June 22, 2026 @07:29AM (#48628751)
Rents and housing prices went down a lot in Singapore during Covid. So them going up again afterwards is just a reversion to the mean.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:02AM (#48626720)
Singapore doesn’t have social housing. HDB is government built and sold for 99 year lease hold.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by tovej on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:39AM (#48626996)
You're describing a form of social housing.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Monday June 22, 2026 @04:25AM (#48627345)
No. Because HDBs are not owned by the government.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by bluebarbet on Monday June 22, 2026 @07:48AM (#48628896)
Yes. Because "social housing" is a general term that implies subsidization and affordability rather than any one specific ownership model.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:21PM (#48634794)
No. Social housing is government owned and rented. Singapore is government built and sold. Singapore is a tiny island with little space. The government has to control what is built where and avoids it turning into Hong Kong slums.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by bluebarbet on Monday June 22, 2026 @05:24PM (#48636413)
You're being stubborn. From Wikipedia:

>Public housing, also known as social housing, is subsidized or affordable housing provided in buildings that are usually owned and managed by local government, central government, nonprofit organizations or a combination thereof.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:23PM (#48638479)
ITS NOT OWNED AND MANAGED BY THE GOVERNMENT.

You literally just quoted why it’s not public housing. Jesus Christ.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:09AM (#48640564)
Wikipedia says 'usually'. And, yes, you are right that the individual HDB flats are typically owned by individual families (though the government also owns some and rents them out, but that's the exception).

However, HDB still does a lot of the managing. Eg HDB manages the lifts and other common spaces. They organise getting the exterior repainted, or general upgrading works to plumbing etc.

HDB also subsidises the price of a flat when you buy directly from them. There's a reason they have maximum income caps for buying.

My unpopular opinion: HDB should declare victory and go home. They more than solved the original acute housing shortage they were created for.

---

Singapore does a lot of things right. And HDB is, as usually a lot more competent than pretty much any other public housing programme anywhere else in the world. But that doesn't mean everything Singapore does (including HDB) is automatically a good idea forever.

Just like our local recreational drug policy could probably be improved by moving closer to what we do with the casinos. And the ban on vaping is just silly.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @02:52AM (#48641282)
> However, HDB still does a lot of the managing. Eg HDB manages the lifts and other common spaces. They organise getting the exterior repainted, or general upgrading works to plumbing etc.

By that logic every apartment block is public housing.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:43AM (#48641641)
No, why? The condos in Singapore are run by private-sector management companies.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:49AM (#48641694)
Because someone manages the lifts lights and exterior. So it must be public housing by your logic.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @09:19AM (#48644566)
Huh? HDB, which is an arm of the government, manages lifts, light and exterior.

The condo management companies are not arms of the government.

What is so hard about this? Is there something I'm not understanding?

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:04PM (#48649779)
If the criteria to be public housing is that someone manages the lifts, lights, and exterior. Then all apartment blocks are public housing. Condos and HDBs are all public housing.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by tovej on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:47PM (#48650338)
The criteria for social housing is that the government subsidized it.

That's all.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @08:41PM (#48653664)
Pushing the goalpost to justify your classification.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by tovej on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @03:34AM (#48656473)
Not really. The goal posts have not moved since the beginning. I'm still claiming the same thing, and the definitions are the same.

How about you read the wikipedia article on public housong in Singapore: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore

It says: "In 2025, close to 80% of Singapore's resident population was reported to be living in public housing,[1] down from a high of 88.0% in 2000."

Let's follow that reference, and take a look at what the Singaporean government says, at https://www.mnd.gov.sg/our-work/housing-a-nation/public-hous... , under the section title "Public Housing":

"Singapore has one of the highest home ownership rate in the world, due to the commitment of our founding fathers since the very beginning of nation building. Today, there are more than 1 million HDB flats across the island, home to close to 80% of Singapore's resident population. The schemes highlighted below help Singaporeans meet their housing needs at different life stages."

So the dictionary says that HBD housing is public housing, wikipedia says that HBD housing is public housing, and the Singaporean government says that HBD housing is public housing.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @02:48AM (#48656107)
Your logic is infallible. Of course, your premise is rubbish.

It's not about whether 'someone' is managing these things. Even an owner-occupier is managing their own lights and exteriors.

A useful criterion is whether the government (or an arm of the government) is managing these things. Like HDB, but unlike your typical condo management organisation. It's far from the only criterion, but it's a useful indicator.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by bluebarbet on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:00AM (#48641336)
The definition is qualified: "usually", "nonprofit organizations", "combination".

>Jesus Christ.

Sometimes I'm disappointed by the level of contributions here.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @06:41AM (#48642939)
I can say the same about your “contributions”

You can’t go calling things they are not.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by bluebarbet on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @07:03AM (#48643162)
For the benefit of any others (miraculously) still reading, I will repeat the statement of fact that you continue stubbornly to deny against all evidence: "'social housing' is a general term that implies subsidization and affordability rather than any one specific ownership model".

Others will make up their mind. Over and out.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by youre-wrong3 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:06PM (#48649801)
For the benefit of any others. Bluebarbet has never been to Singapore and ultimately doesn’t know what he’s talking about. HDBs are not public housing. It’s land control because Singapore is so tiny.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by inigyou on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:34AM (#48625701)
Primarily Vienna. There's nothing complicated about what Vienna did - other cities just prefer to please billionaires instead of providing services to citizens.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by Plasmoid on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:48AM (#48625812)
Do you actually know what Vienna did? Because the overwhelming number of people who reference the city basically just repeat a few dubious talking point about restricting rent.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by CalRobert on Monday June 22, 2026 @04:05AM (#48627198)
Have a massive empire and then lose it resulting in a capital city with surplus housing?
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by chadgpt3 on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:07AM (#48629048)
That was Berlin several decades ago. The gap has closed now and it's just another city.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:13AM (#48640585)
Well, Berlin's history was a bit more complicated. Between the 'losing the empire' bit and the 'surplus housing' was a whole generation or two of the city being divided and one part living under siege and the other under real world socialism.

But you are right, that surplus housing is no longer a thing in Berlin.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by raybb on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:11AM (#48626790)
I don't know about restricting rent but they certainly had a progressive tax on high rents, a 1% income tax to fund housing, and then used that to build a ton of high quality social housing with balconies and amenities for all. I also like to think it helped that they slapped a big sign on each to proudly let people know it was their tax dollars at work.

I didn't stay in social housing while I living there but I never once heard people complain about it. They basically just didn't think much about it at all and felt it was a good system and then would ask me why the US only makes it for poor people.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eli_gottlieb on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:03AM (#48625908)
I mean, to be fair, having your population semi-permanently depleted by two major wars and a fundamental loss of national economic centrality and prestige will help you keep a fixed stock of social housing lasting longer.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by oblio on Monday June 22, 2026 @02:07AM (#48626338)
Vienna's population has been growing constantly for the last 40 years.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by pyrale on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:16AM (#48625983)
Basically, all of Europe post-WW2. A significant share of new build in the 50s-60s was social housing.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by woodpanel on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:59AM (#48626281)
No one absolutely no one considers that to be remotely true. Look at French banlieues, German Plattenbauten or British Councils - they are synonymous with Crime and physical as well as cultural despair.

And while Vienna or Stockholm are often cited as Utopias, the citees often intentionally leave out the negative side effects (ie. Waiting-times of years, housing black markets, etc) that are eventually coming full circle to the thing they were proposed as a solution against. Just with much less transparency.

There have been social housing projects that paint a more nuanced picture, eg Hamburg-Steilshoop, where a giant block (for EU standards) has been erected in the 1970s and was basically divided into three sections: one to be run by existing housing coops, one by owner occupants, and one by the city. Needless to say that those parts run by the city were quickly becoming a prime example of a German „banlieue“ while the other parts became a prime example for those eager to dismiss any criticisms.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by pyrale on Monday June 22, 2026 @02:46AM (#48626606)
> Look at French banlieues, German Plattenbauten or British Councils - they are synonymous with Crime and physical as well as cultural despair.

Sure, because what existed before was absolutely fine [1][2]...

The truth is that these policies worked so well that pepole completely forgot what existed before. The alternative to housing projects wasn't a country without crime or despair, it was more crime, shanty towns, people displaced by war and unable to get back to normal life, and young workers unable to move to places of employment in the postwar economic boom. That topic was so uncontroversial that every european government, leftwing or rightwing, did it.

I agree that a social housing project alone isn't enough to fix every problem, but that doesn't make it the source of other unsolved problems.

[1]: Nanterre's shanty towns, https://www.defense-92.fr/exposition/la-vie-des-bidonvilles-...

[2]: pre-war shanty town, https://www.theguardian.com/cities/gallery/2019/jul/04/how-p...

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by woodpanel on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:36AM (#48626987)
Sure, areas where aggressive migrants create a law-less area, where race based gang violence is a daily occurrence, each country now and then “discovers” its own rotherham-style ethnic rape-ring and police cars are sometimes burned down with the officers being locked in on purpose, are totally normal, so much better than before and were happening before anyways
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by pantalaimon on Monday June 22, 2026 @04:18AM (#48627284)
This was aggravated by modern city planning with it's separation of function that left these new districts with no third spaces, barely any shops and large spaces of 'no man's land' between buildings.

In classics European cities there were shops on street level and dense blocks that generated demand for those.

The post war developments followed the 'high rise in the park' concept, lots of greenery and parking lots between buildings to create a mid density neighborhood.

But there is no life in the streets and you have to walk a lot through repetitive environment but to do anything you still have to go to the 'old city'.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by pyrale on Monday June 22, 2026 @05:10AM (#48627712)
High rises were far from being the only, or even the dominant model for social housing in Europe. Different plans such as low rises, semi-detached houses and single homes also got implemented.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by pantalaimon on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:52AM (#48628472)
Those are even worse - you need a certain density for urban life, otherwise you'll just create large empty spaces that belong to no-one, so nobody feels responsible for them.
Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Monday June 22, 2026 @07:34AM (#48628787)
Seems like a non sequitur?

If you want people to be able to live in a place without paying rent, please just outright gift that to them and make that official policy. That may or may not be good policy, but at least it's honest.

But if the deal that people agreed to is to pay rent, then the courts should also enforce that.

You can get from one regime to the other, by eg buying out the landlords or outright expropriating them. But if you want to do that, please just advocate so outright.

Social housing may or may not be a good idea. But it's a completely separate issue from non-enforcement of existing rental contracts.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by tmnvix on Monday June 22, 2026 @02:49PM (#48634350)
Not a non sequitur. I was responding to this specifically:

> In the longer one, you need building and renting out shelter to be reasonably profitable, so that people do it.

Re:Rent collections are down in New York by eru on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:05AM (#48640545)
Maybe. That narrower focus definitely makes your remark more defensible.

On a tangent: along with most economist, I generally prefer giving poor people money that they can spend on goods and services as they please; instead of having some pencil pusher decide what they need and giving that to them in-kind.