News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by JuniperMesos on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:18PM (#48497180)
> The culture was transparent and open to diverse discourse, and from the start it was made clear that, as Googlers, we were not only welcome but expected to bring our own identity and values into the job.

Google management lost its moral compass in 2017 when they fired James Damore for writing a memo critiquing their gender diversity efforts. They were never serious that employees were expected to bring their own identity and values into the job, they only thought this with respect to identities and values they were already mostly-aligned-with.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by throwa356262 on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:40PM (#48497392)
That was a crazy period when Google first fired him, then fired people criticising him, and then fired people criticising the people that just got fired.

But let's be honest, the guy was kind of unhinged. I would not have fired him, but neither would I have kept him in my team.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by lokar on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:43PM (#48497410)
I agree, internally, looking at a fuller picture of his activity, he was off. Constantly bringing the subject up out of context, starting fights, etc. but they should have just warned him.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by whatshisface on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:01PM (#48497598)
I'm sure he's just overjoyed to be tried without representation or evidence in the court of public opinion, a big step up from being punished with no process at all.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by dpark on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:02PM (#48498111)
> but neither would I have kept him in my team

Let’s be honest, though. That’s firing from your team.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by 3adk1a on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:48PM (#48497448)
He wasn't unhinged, he somewhat clumsily posted evolutionary biology literature fragments on a channel where it would offend parts of the readers.

In response to a "let a thousand flowers bloom and speak your mind" request from Google management snakes. The problem is that some tech people take these requests seriously.

Google of course has identified itself as Trump sycophants and hypocrites by now. Maybe they should invite Jordan Peterson, Gad Saad and Elon Musk to give keynote speeches.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by jensensbutton on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:55PM (#48498040)
No he was kind of unhinged. That wasn't the first weird thing he did. Should've been fired.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by tmoertel on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:08PM (#48498157)
What other things did he do to make you believe he was “kind of unhinged”? I know about the memo thing, but I think it was covered in an inflammatory way because the press loves to play up a controversy. What else besides the memo incident did he do that merits his firing?
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by UncleMeat on Thursday June 11, 2026 @10:02PM (#48498965)
Damore had been aggressively arguing about this stuff internally for some time in advance of his doc. The doc was consistent with a pattern of "makes a huge stink of things in every training and refuses to back down."
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by tmoertel on Friday June 12, 2026 @07:04AM (#48502518)
Okay, here's what I still don't understand. Were the things he was “making a huge stink about in every training” true or false? Reports at the time claimed that he was ”perpetuating harmful stereotypes,” but other reporting claimed that he was pointing out facts that inconveniently challenged the cultural orthodoxy and then wrote the doc to clarify his feedback, and so he became a target for internal activists. Are you aware of any specifics that would allow a reasonable person to lean one way or another as to the reality?
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by erq164 on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:07PM (#48498146)
That is hard for outsiders to know. Google however seems to foster cancel mobs.

Python core people like Thomas Wouters and Gregory P. Smith, since fired from Google, canceled and libeled people like Tim Peters. All that matters is having a mob on your side and preventing the other side from responding.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:37PM (#48498381)
By all means, explain what else he did. I've seen this claim made repeatedly on hacker news, but conspicuously noone seems willing to o substantiate those claims.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by NetOpWibby on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:59PM (#48497573)
In my experience, Big Tech's billboard to "bring your best self" was just to get super eager people with great skills into their ranks to help accelerate business. Once you're on the inside, it's quite clear that's a farce and in fact, you should keep your mouth shut and your head down.

Alas.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by annzabelle on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:45PM (#48497959)
Had a coworker at a bank that was trying to emulate Tech (Capital One - all in on AWS and PIPs) who bought into it. Ended up PIPed and then is doing a PhD in a completely unrelated field.

We had a mental health slack channel, and a racial politics one that rehashed Israel/Palestine daily.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by cucumber3732842 on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:52PM (#48498491)
>and a racial politics one

We had one of those. Not slack, self hosted internal stuff. Some "senior by tenure but not title" people decided the only thing that could come of it was people running their mouths to everyone's detriment and start trolling it until nobody took it seriously and then it was quietly "collateral damage" in a migration that was also arranged.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by annzabelle on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:56PM (#48498510)
HR ended up nuking that channel in 2023.

I think they were afraid of touching what had started as an anti racism channel until the vibes had shifted a bit.

There were both Palestinian employees and an IDF veteran Israeli employee who were seemingly spending half the workday discussing October 7th and the Intifada.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by raincole on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:18PM (#48497756)
Thank you. I was afraid that people will eventually forget about that point of inflection. I think for many of us, the specific event was what made us realize that you really can't separate technical issues from political ones.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by dekhn on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:08PM (#48498149)
I think if Damore had limited his criticism to the corporate DEI (which I found to be a bit heavy-handed and prone to critical theory groupthink) in a short doc, he probably would have been a bit more successful (in helping Google rein back its DEI training).

One rarely stated thing I learned over time working there is that managers read eng-misc and will prevent you from transferring to their team if they didn't like what you said, or how you said it, or who you said it to.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by hintymad on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:59PM (#48498081)
Did Googlers give lots of pressure to the management? I was wondering which side the management is closer to: being cowards, or being hypocritical
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by DashAnimal on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:01PM (#48498097)
I always hate the James Damore discussion because it's like the least interesting part. You have a company dealing with internal political mayhem trying to find the least disruptive, not only internally but now externally because this shit has leaked. It's a workplace, and youre trying to keep people effective and working. And some googlers got too comfortable with what they were sharing on a work machine, not just to their coworkers, but tens of thousands of employees.

The support of war efforts is clearly a change in moral compass that is much more fascinating though.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by pryce on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:21PM (#48498257)
100% agree. The James Damore flag was immediately taken up by major figures in transphobia (like Singal, Soh, etc) and pro-fascism campaigners (like Molyneux), both of which are political programs are absolutely incompatible with maintaining a non-hostile workplace environment for employees. (and not incidentally, both of which a premised on discredited bioessentialist pseudoscience)

I find it is a deeply cynical move, to be asked to place the James Damore "was it employer overreach-or-not?" episode in similar proportion to critiquing a company's actions regarding issues such as mass surveillance and/or assisting war efforts, especially when the accusations about those broader issues are tied to complicity in the 2020s resurgence in fascist politics. It is so cynical that I can't believe it isn't intentional.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:42PM (#48498423)
What is the "bioessentialist pseudoscience" you're referring to?
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by pryce on Thursday June 11, 2026 @09:14PM (#48498620)
One of them I refer to is "race essentialism" [1] which led to the long-discredited pseudoscience known as scientific racism[2], and its political associated program of eugenics,

and the other is "gender essentialism"[3] which has also been rejected by mainstream scholars across fields from biology to medicine to sociology to gender studies, and which acts in culture as a similarly pseudoscientific popular rationale for organizing society in ways that harm women and gender minorities.

The study of the field of racism is absolutely fascinating in that very quickly, the simple, obvious "commonsense" theories like "race exists as a meaningful biological category" turn out to be quite false.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essentialism#Racial,_cultural_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_racism

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_essentialism

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @09:28PM (#48498709)
What sorts of scientific racism (or gender essentialism) have Jesse Signal and Deborah Soh propagated? To be clear, I'm not asking for a primer on scientific racism, I'm asking you to substantiate the allegations you made against specific individuals.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by pryce on Thursday June 11, 2026 @10:15PM (#48499059)
You ought to read my comment carefully. Singal (not Signal) and Soh are "major figures in transphobia", and Molyneux is a pro-fascism campaigner. The former two (Singal, Soh) are advocates of "gender essentialism", and the latter travels internationally campaigning for the "race essentialism" and policies based on that. As you're aware of both of (Singal,Soh)'s first names already, is it a fair guess that you're already familiar with some of their transphobic work? Perhaps then, that is a good place to start. As just one example, Soh is actually so committed to gender essentialism that it's led her to advocate the approach that: your assigned male at birth teenager who tells you that they're trans and requests to transition is actually gay in my opinion so being affirming to them about that is homophobic ( from her article in reactionary online journal "Quillette").

Soh will of course try to dress that horrific construction from her article up in professional-sounding language, but our duty is in fact to address the thrust of her argument, not whether she attempts to frame it in polite language. You might also recognize Soh from her work in the atrocious Matt Walsh "documentary" that pretends to be about women but is entirely about invalidating trans people.

To make this more clear: Soh's need to provide an explanation for femininity in a person who is assigned male at birth while denying the validity of trans people is only necessary for a person operating from a bioessentialist lens. The need in Soh is so strong that it leads her to make totally unfounded and ridiculous claims in that article, and it also drove her promotion of the discredited (and retracted!) pseudoscientific 'Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria)' invented by Lisa Littman.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @11:11PM (#48499443)
I'm not aware of Singal ever saying that all children who express identification outside their birth gender are actually just same-sex attracted (I'm less familiar with Soh's work). Rather, his point is that the guidance given to parents to identify signs of gender dysphoria is often rooted in gender essentialism. For instance, playing with the "wrong" toys for their birth gender is promoted as a sign of gender dysphoria [1].

Surely you'd agree that if a natal male says he is a boy and when asked why he replies "because I'm attracted to boys", then the responsible reply is "it's okay to be a gay boy", and not "yes, because you're attracted to boys you are a girl." It's certainly possible that a child will persist in expressing and opposite-sex gender even after exploring identity as a gay boy and will follow through with transition. But surely the responsible thing to do is to make sure that the child first understands that there's nothing wrong with being a boy attracted to other boys. First, eliminate the possibility that the boy is identifying as a girl out of a gender-essentialist belief that boys are only attracted to girls and he has to be a girl to attract boys. If after that, if the child still expresses a cross-sex gender identity then explore transitioning.

I don't think Singal has ever said that all - or even a majority - of children expressing a cross-sex gender identity are actually just same-sex attracted cis people. He only takes issue with legislation in some jurisdictions effectively prohibit medical professionals from exploring a gay male identity in this scenario, and effectively mandate social affirmation the moment a patients expressed a cross sex gender identity.

Even if you disagree with the above, surely at least you understand why I'm confused about the allegation that Singal is promoting gender essentialism. His concern is that gender essentialism is being misdiagnosed as gender dysphoria, and people aren't doing enough to accept boys wearing dresses, being attracted to other boys, and behaving in "feminine" ways, and being too quick to say "well, you're a girl". Even if you don't agree with his claims about misdiagnoses, it's abundantly clear he is against gender essentialism.

1. https://resources.healthgrades.com/right-care/childrens-heal...

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by perching on Friday June 12, 2026 @04:17AM (#48501341)
> incompatible with maintaining a non-hostile workplace environment for employees

More commonly, this happens the other way around. For example, in Monica Helms' autobiography, he writes:

> Shortly after one of the training sessions had finished, I held back from leaving the training room and watched all the women make their way to the third-floor restroom. I had to pee too, so I went into the restroom I had become accustomed to using. The other women made it immediately clear they didn't want me there. Some gave me the evil eye while others rushed out when they saw me. I did my best to ignore them, stepped into a stall and did my thing. Then I went back to my desk to carry on with my work. Twenty minutes later, HR called me into their office.

> The new head of HR told me, "Some of the women have complained that you went into the third-floor restroom after today's training session."

Showing no empathy whatsoever for the women he imposed his presence on, he then goes on to explain how the company caved to his demands to use the female restroom, and that women who complained were given short shrift.

Clearly, this approach creates a hostile workplace environment for female employees.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by jensensbutton on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:59PM (#48498086)
Nah, James Damore just did a stupid thing at work and wasn't talented enough for it to be overlooked. He deserved to be fired. Morals don't need to come into it.

They lost their moral compass a while ago, but it had nothing to do with Damore.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by mempko on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:52PM (#48498011)
James Damore was a poorly educated person. He didn't understand how to use statistics and decided to use them in a hateful way. Just because numbers are involved doesn't make a viewpoint objective.

Creating a hostile workspace for others is not a smart move.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by tmoertel on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:18PM (#48498227)
> James Damore was a poorly educated person. He didn't understand how to use statistics and decided to use them in a hateful way.

What statistical argument did Damore make?

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by JuniperMesos on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:09PM (#48498169)
I think there's a lot more political will now than there was a decade ago for explicitly repealing the sections of American civil rights law that define what a "hostile workplace" is, in order to make sure that something like Damore's memo would not count. Certainly, this is something I think about when evaluating political candidates.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by pryce on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:26PM (#48498292)
What are the major historical examples where protecting employees from a "hostile workplace" is important? Racism? Misogyny? Homophobia? Do protection from these things look expendable to you?

I'm sure either of us could quickly find a bunch of people who would like to one or several of those acceptable again, yet us finding that such people exist would not tell us a damned thing about whether dismantling those protections is a good idea. Or supposing it does, then one might even make the case that those people existing is an excellent reason for having such a law in the first place.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by GlacierFox on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:59PM (#48498080)
It's depressing to see there's still people roaming around in the ideological echo chamber you're currently existing inside. I thought we were past this garbage...
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by ashleyn on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:21PM (#48497207)
Considering they rolled back DEI along with everyone else after Trump's second victory, it's difficult to view those previous "values" as anything other than cynical kissing-up to the previous holders of power.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by acdha on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:19PM (#48498241)
You have to remember that most companies _chose_ to setup DEI programs: it was a routine recommendation from lawyers because it gave them a string defense in lawsuits — the next time some manager abuses their position, they can cut that person loose and point to their various programs as evidence that whatever happened was limited to that manager and not company culture.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by CMay on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:26PM (#48497818)
For what it's worth, I think for an organization that size that needs the best talent from anywhere, It's probably much better to discourage political activism at work. It can tend to turn away the most logical and reasonable well grounded people who want no part of it. The people who _need_ work to be political can go get hired for explicitly political organizations where that is the job.

Creating a distaste in people without like minds has been an intentional goal to cause exodus after exodus on various platforms, in companies and so on. If you let that get out of control, you can poison a culture almost unrecoverably. We can't let that happen to our critical tech companies for national security reasons.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by bryrei on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:10PM (#48498174)
Most people don't force politics into work as much as they have it forced upon them by, you know, living in a society. And the idea of "political activism" causing "distaste in people without like minds" is a misattribution, putting it mildly. But yeah, keep people quiet and heads down so the work can get done, regardless of what the work is or what it will be used for.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by rayiner on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:04PM (#48497627)
> Considering they rolled back DEI along with everyone else after Trump's second victory, it's difficult to view those previous "values" as anything other than cynical kissing-up to the previous holders of power.

The previous policies simply reflected the culture of employees and HR managers that had graduated from universities that openly practiced race-conscious admissions after Grutter v. Bollinger. The change in policy likely came not from the new administration, but the Supreme Court's SFFA decision in 2023 that reminded everyone the civil rights laws require race blindness.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:24PM (#48497236)
It’s the cost of buying goodwill and lower regulatory burden from the administration in power at the time of implementation. DEI? Non DEI? Like an umbrella, just depends on the weather, its business as usual regardless.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by rayiner on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:32PM (#48497863)
I agree with your broader point, but DEI versus no DEI is a bad example. That's not an example of companies sucking up to the preferred policies of whatever administration is in power. Instead, they are responding to decisive legal decisions. There is a clear legal principle at issue: the civil rights laws are symmetric as to race. The Supreme Court held that in SFFA in 2023, and again in Ames in 2025 (which was a 9-0 decision). Most "DEI" programs create unacceptable legal exposure because they involve literature or practices as to white people that would be held up as evidence of racial discrimination in a Title VII lawsuit if the races were switched.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:04PM (#48498121)
The clarification and specifics are welcomed.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by rayiner on Thursday June 11, 2026 @09:13PM (#48498615)
Yeah, Or crypto, AI, all sorts of things.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by jordanb on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:05PM (#48497639)
And it didn't even stop the antitrust suite so they threw in with Trump and then started sucking up to him. He's giving big tech everything they want so there is pretty much nothing he can do that will upset them.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by mystraline on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:18PM (#48497753)
Ive directly complained against the latte liberals screaming DEI.

Ive had them demand my pronouns. I really dont care, but saying that is absolutely not acceptable. Ill use your pronouns. I really do not care.

Ive been in meetings with 'land acknowledgements' with whatever former indians/native americans who were there. Its not like we're giving them the land back.

DEI and what it turned into was a big for-public-show that you knew the buzzwords and the antiwords. And if you didnt, or woukdnt play along, theyd ruin you.

The current MAGA MAHA meritocracy crap is also just the opposite, but the same games as DEI folks. They have their buzzwords and antiwords. Although, theyre a whole lot stupider and easier to manipulate and deal with.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Tuna-Fish on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:38PM (#48498390)
They were not cynical kissing up to previous holders of power, they were desperate attempts to cover their asses against EEOC lawsuits. And they didn't end because of Trump's second victory, they ended because the Supreme Court defanged EEOC (and half the rest of the federal regulatory agencies).

The actual reason for the "corporate DEI" in tech was that since Griggs v. Duke Power Co. (1971), EEOC could sue companies that had lower minority proportion than population norm for discrimination, and could could prove the discrimination in court using nothing but the racial makeup of the employees, and some policy at the company that could in theory have disparate impact. And under their standards, literally any policy has disparate impact.

This hit other sectors first, to which they responded by hiring more minorities. But tech had the problem that schools were consistently producing fewer minority engineering grads than the population proportion, and in a world where approximately every engineer got employed, some US tech companies would have to have lower minority representation than the population no matter what they did. And because the disparity between engineering grads and racial population proportion was so high, in fact most large companies would fail to meet the necessary minority proportions.

But EEOC would not instantly file suit against every offender, instead they would file ~40 such suits per year, targeting large companies that they considered particularly bad. And so companies that felt they might get hit soon started doing DEI programs, at first to attract more minority engineers (from other companies in the same sector, which would then fall under the limit, making it zero-sum), but then they realized that the EEOC didn't really sue the companies that were the loudest at touting their DEI credentials, and it all became extremely performative, no longer trying to attract minority talent but to be the loudest company talking about the subject. Iterate over that for a few decades and it got really weird.

It ended because Trump named 3 SC justices on his first term, and in a few important cases between 2023 and today, the new SC tore the whole thing down, and suing a company for disparate impact is now considered unconstitutional.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by asadotzler on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:36PM (#48497342)
Google management lost its spine back in 2008/9/10 and its soul soon followed. It was over long before your pet issue showed up.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by snypher on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:31PM (#48497855)
Your comment reads as _your_ pet issue showed up in 08, with no mention of it. So what was it?
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by acdha on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:20PM (#48498249)
They bought Doubleclick and turned into an ad company. They haven’t launched a good or popular product since.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by 4MOAisgoodenuf on Thursday June 11, 2026 @06:46PM (#48497438)
Google exists to make money and is happy to change their opinions to suit the current force in power.

But that “critique” of gender diversity efforts said that the lack of women in CS was due to some innate difference in women (rather than a social division that is neither innate nor universal across time or cultures) While also decrying the lack of affirmative action for conservatives.

It’s neither the tipping point for Google, nor is it a hill worth dying on

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Friday June 12, 2026 @07:22PM (#48510539)
The gender disparity in computing is largely universal across cultures, though. That's why the assumption that it's culturally determined is on shaky ground
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Ardren on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:14PM (#48497730)
Out of everything Google has done, James Damore...

> Ex-Google engineer Damore sues alleging discrimination against white, conservative men

> “In the gender category, it is only men who are being discriminated against,” Dhillon said. Currently in tech companies "it’s okay to disparage, smear, belittle or discriminate against conservatives and white men. That’s not acceptable.”

https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2018/01/08/ex-googl...

I would not like to have to work with someone like James Damore. Firing him was correct.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by azinman2 on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:16PM (#48498220)
> “In the gender category, it is only men who are being discriminated against,” Dhillon said.

Painfully and ignorantly wrong.

> Currently in tech companies "it’s okay to disparage, smear, belittle or discriminate against conservatives and white men. That’s not acceptable.”

Yet this is true, deserved or not. Or at least that was the case while aligned with the modern left that's all about power dynamics, historical imbalances, colonialism, and an us-versus-them mindset. Now SV is headed rightward, but I suspect that's more at the leadership level than the rank-and-file.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by GlacierFox on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:12PM (#48498198)
"Firing him was correct."

In your opinion.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by danpalmer on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:09PM (#48497677)
There's a difference between bringing your own identity, and publicly condemning others because of theirs. James Damore was intolerant of women in the workplace.

I'm very open to arguments like the author of this post, but they are completely different to preventing intolerance spreading.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by socalgal2 on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:20PM (#48497770)
Sounds like you're responding to incorrect summaries? He was not intolerant of woman in the workplace. His memo was specifically in support of women in the workplace.

https://web.archive.org/web/20170813080340/https://www.theat...

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by danpalmer on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:23PM (#48497801)
No, I read the memo. What I was not doing is taking him at his word that he "values diversity and inclusion", I was reading his actual words and the sexist dogwhistles. Stating acceptance does not absolve other intolerance.

We must also look at the effect of his memo, which was to alienate many, and which caused a backlash that led to his firing. The company did not make a big deal of it just to fire him, it was individuals who were personally impacted and offended by it who made it what it was.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Jensson on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:39PM (#48497920)
Google did fire a lot of people when this happened on both sides, seems like they were just tired about the whole thing and wanted political fights out of the company. Damore since he started it, and anyone that got too upset about it and said things they shouldn't have was also fired, as were the people who got too upset about those that got upset.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by GlacierFox on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:07PM (#48498143)
"What I was not doing is taking him at his word that he "values diversity and inclusion", I was reading his actual words and the sexist dogwhistles."

Oh, so just inserting out own bullshit to sway it in to something it isn't so you can straw man it on the Internet. Got it.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:46PM (#48498448)
"dog whistles" are, more often than not, a thinly veiled way of putting words in other people's mouthes.

Damore's thesis amounted to "maybe women are 20% of software developers not because they're being discriminated against, but because they're exercising their own agency and choosing other fields."

Given that about 20% of CS grads are women, it seems like a pretty reasonable stance.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by danpalmer on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:58PM (#48498514)
In isolation, it's a very naive, oblivious, and incurious stance.

Taken alongside the rest of the content, it's a rejection of the idea that there is systemic bias, and much of his memo is dedicated to ways in which that bias can be propagated and solidified.

At best, the memo paints Damore as someone who is radically uninformed and parroting old and invalid talking points that others have given to him. At worst it implies that he knows what he's doing and is trying to dismantle processes and culture that are improving women's access to the workplace.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @09:26PM (#48498699)
So merely contesting the notion that systemic bias is the main driver of the gender disparity in tech is grounds for instant termination? Well, that's rather troubling given that the empirical evidence on the bias in tech company hiring doesn't support the narrative of anti-female bias: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3672484

Hn discussion of the paper: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25069644

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by danpalmer on Thursday June 11, 2026 @09:56PM (#48498931)
Not at all. A good faith discussion in the right forum is fine.

That's not what the memo was. It ignored the evidence we have that there is systemic bias, it relied on tired and debunked tropes, and has explicit goals about preserving and elevating the privilege that perpetuates that systemic bias. That done in front of a large company filled with people personally affected by it is just a terrible idea. I'm open to discussion about this, but from the right people (those affected, with the experience) in the right context. James Damore was neither.

But honestly, if you read the memo and think it sounds reasonable, I'm not going to be able to change your mind. These biases are deeply rooted and take decades of introspection to overcome. I've been on that journey for probably 15 years and I've still got blind spots.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 11, 2026 @10:45PM (#48499251)
And what evidence of systemic bias would that be?

The experiment I linked above sent monitored the callback rates of applicants sent out to Bay Area tech companies for technical roles, and saw higher callback rates for women. This is the sort of prototypical evidence we use as an example of systemic anti-Black bias where Black applicants are called back less frequently than white applicants.

Is Google, specifically, systemically biased against women? Cross-referencing the diversity reports they publish [1], with employment statistics [2] does not show an underrepresentation of women. Google has also taken controversial steps, such as tying executive performance reviews to the representation of "underrepresented groups" - that term has included women at every company I've worked at, but if that's not the case at Google please correct me. When Google conducted an investigation into whether women were underpaid, they discovered that the disparity leaned the other way [3].

Perhaps maybe some introspection is warranted on your part into the assumptions you have about gender bias at Google and in the tech industry in general.

1. https://kstatic.googleusercontent.com/files/819bcce604bf5ff7...

2. https://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat11.htm

3. https://www.npr.org/2019/03/05/700288695/google-pay-study-fi...

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by danpalmer on Friday June 12, 2026 @12:24AM (#48499889)
And this is why I said that I'm not going to change your mind.

The gender bias is clear in individual experience and data, all it takes is talking to women (or people of colour, or whatever under represented group you want) to see it.

I think Google does pretty well on this, largely due to the diversity programs that Damore was calling to have abolished.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by Manuel_D on Friday June 12, 2026 @12:28AM (#48499925)
And what is that data? Again you've referenced data or evidence for anti-female bias, and yet again you neglect to share it.

Data could definitely change my mind: what percentage of applicants to software developer roles at Google are women, and what percentage of offers extended for those roles go to women? If the former is substantially smaller than the latter, that would definitely sway me.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by JuniperMesos on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:46PM (#48508642)
> The gender bias is clear in individual experience and data, all it takes is talking to women (or people of colour, or whatever under represented group you want) to see it.

Nonwhites are not actually underrepresented at tech companies like Google, and the fact that you casually claim they are in an aside should cast serious doubts on other arguments you make as well.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by sgentle on Thursday June 11, 2026 @07:47PM (#48497966)
Would the National Labor Review Board's legal opinion count as an incorrect summary?

https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4380791-NLRB-Advice-...

> statements about immutable traits linked to sex—such as women’s heightened neuroticism and men’s prevalence at the top of the IQ distribution—were discriminatory and constituted sexual harassment, notwithstanding effort to cloak comments with “scientific” references and analysis, and notwithstanding “not all women” disclaimers.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by dekhn on Thursday June 11, 2026 @08:11PM (#48498184)
That is not a remotely accurate representation of what he wrote.
Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by tomhow on Friday June 12, 2026 @08:51AM (#48503492)
Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by JuniperMesos on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:34PM (#48508508)
> Unfortunately, times have changed. Google management has quietly abandoned its goals to become carbon-neutral because of the AI model energy usage. Worse, Google management is now signing deals with the US Ministry of War—where “any lawful purpose” by the current US government has already been repeatedly demonstrated to be in violation of international laws. None of this is being debated or communicated within the company. It is just decided by top-level management (I was part of the management chain before, and I hadn’t heard of any of these changes through internal channels). With my moral and ethical principles, I cannot—explicitly or implicitly, directly or transitively—support the current and ongoing actions of the “Maximum lethality, not tepid legality” US Ministry of War.

This entire article is already engaging in political and ideological battle - René Mayrhofer is explicitly saying that he's unwilling to work at Google because he has a political problem with some of the decisions Google is making, namely abandoning earlier stated carbon-neutrality goals and being willing to make deals with the US military.

My contention is that if he considers this to constitute Google losing its moral compass but not the James Damore incident, which happened the same year he started working at Google; then there's no particular reason to think that his notion of a "moral compass" is any different from object-level agreement or disagreement (or simply not caring), about any particular decision that Google makes. Someone similar to Mayrhofer might well be willing to work for Google because they make a different judgement than he does about the political importance of AI model energy usage; and throwing terms like "moral compass" around is exactly equivalent to having an object-level disagreement about a political issue.

Re:Why I'm Forced to Say Farewell: Google Management Has Los... by tomhow on Sunday June 14, 2026 @06:05AM (#48525778)
> This entire article is already engaging in political and ideological battle

Hence we don't really want articles like this on HN, and checking the stats now, I see it only spent about two hours on the front page, which was more than enough.

Articles like this are bad for HN as they use a major current issue as vehicle for the writer to make a public expression of their political grievances, and the discussion thread then becomes a vehicle for others to express their own alternative political grievances, many of which have nothing to do with the topic of the original post. So the whole thread just becomes a battle between people expressing their own conflicting political grievances, which is precisely what we don't want on a site whose primary reason for existing is to cultivate curious conversation.

As I wrote in my first comment above, the guidelines specifically ask us to avoid using HN this way. Your comment counts as a generic tangent, because it introduces an issue that's only very tenuously linked to the central topic of the article, then sets off a whole new subthread debating that topic, taking the thread further and further away from the original topic.

I understand this topic is important to you and I'm not telling you it shouldn't be. I'm upholding the HN guidelines and asking you to make the effort to observe them, because it's only by upholding the guidelines that we can have any hope of keeping this place from going up in flames.