News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by dkdbejwi383 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:26AM (#48462372)
This is how it works in Australia, which means it's a pain for tourists as you need to provide a passport for ID and get it activated, as opposed to just grabbing one at an airport kiosk and being ready to go on your way to the taxi or train like most other places.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by dgellow on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:20PM (#48463144)
I mean. It’s the same, you just have to show your passport and fill a form. It takes 1minute to get it done, you can do it on your way to the taxi if you want. Though e-sim are more practical now
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by mothballed on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:22PM (#48463187)
I wonder what exactly are they hoping to achieve then? Anything that can be filled out in 1 minute in a taxi can be spoofed with an extra 30 seconds on the dark net buying dark IDs. So this does less than zero for crime, actually encourages more of it, while doing what exactly? It's madness.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by nemomarx on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:26PM (#48463237)
Who says anything about crime? the goal is just so they can associate phone numbers with id cards in some fashion right?

If they want to know what tourists are posting about their country that's good enough.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by voakbasda on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:33PM (#48463344)
Like so many laws, nothing to do with stopping crime, but an obvious push to strip the populace of its rights.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by philistine on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:18PM (#48465211)
You do not have the right to a phone number without providing ID. If you're an American, those unwritten rights that come from other firm rights written down in laws and constitutions can always be argued, they're always being whittled down.

Rights for everyone are achieved through blood and toil, and if you truly want a right to anonymity and the digital tools necessary to achieve it, you will need blood and toil. Until then, we'll have to squeeze through fast developments that governments have yet to address.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by mothballed on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:12PM (#48464059)
"Law enforcement" and national security is given as the verbatim headline justification when you reference Australia's Communication and Media Authority[] for rules on ID collection.

  Carriers and carriage service providers (CSPs) must help law enforcement and national security agencies.

  ...

  You must verify a customer's identity before you activate a prepaid mobile phone service. You can do this when the customer buys the service or when they try to activate it. The Determination on identity checks for prepaid mobiles lists the ways you can check a customer's identity.
Unfortunately I can't dig up the original debate from 1997 on the Telecommunications Act when the requirement appears to have been introduced. Would be shocked if it did not include similar language from the representatives shilling the requirement, though.

[] https://www.acma.gov.au/support-law-enforcement-and-security...

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by trumpdong on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @09:34PM (#48470160)
Can you tell me more about how to order and receive a fake ID on the dark net in less than 30 seconds? It does sound rather implausible.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by naturalmovement on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:15PM (#48463069)
> like most other places

Much of EU requires ID for some time now. France is a bit strange, requires registration after 23 days or something. Germany, Italy, Spain it's basically impossible.

The US is rather unique in that it does not require registration.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by joxdosba on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:19PM (#48463134)
Huh? At least in Germany, Spain and France all of the smaller shops fill in fake info without even asking.

EU countries have had these requirements for years and years and never moved to actually enforce them.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by naturalmovement on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:20PM (#48463152)
I wasn't taking blatant fraud into account. I'm sure that's possible everywhere. I'd bet you can buy cigarettes without the tax stamps in the same shop too.

Last I traveled the shop required a passport or uploading one to get an eSIM ahead of time.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by joxdosba on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:21PM (#48463169)
Sure, but if you’re a tourist in e.g. Barcelona trying to get a prepaid SIM, odds are the shopkeeper will not ask you for your ID despite being required to.

> Last I traveled the shop required a passport or uploading one to get an eSIM ahead of time.

Sounds like you went to a carrier boutique and not one of the million independent shops.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by naturalmovement on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:35PM (#48463374)
I would think most tourists would trust a carrier-branded store over Honest Jochen's Tobacco Emporium where you may or may not get a working SIM after paying cash.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by joxdosba on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:53PM (#48463735)
Trust? Sure. They’re still more likely to buy their prepaid SIM from the shop that also sells bongs, they are on every corner after all.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by lifestyleguru on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:26PM (#48463243)
Not a good example. In Spain they notoriously demand id/passport and make photo or copy of it, they do it "for the police".
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by joxdosba on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:28PM (#48463282)
That’s the legal requirement yes, I’ve never seen a shop insist on it. Most of them have autofill scripts for the KYC forms.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by naturalmovement on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:37PM (#48463411)
Isn't the main topic of discussion here a legal requirement?

If everyone ignores it then what's the fuss about?

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by joxdosba on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:45PM (#48463551)
I’m just pointing out that in Europe the equivalent legal requirement is widely ignored, the same won’t necessarily repeat in the US, but it might.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ahartmetz on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @06:57AM (#48474438)
Is it that trivial in Germany? I live in Berlin, and the rumor that I heard years ago is that some kiosks in areas known for drug dealing sell pre-activated SIM cards. I never bothered to check.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ivanmontillam on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:36PM (#48463396)
Argentina doesn't also, you can just buy a SIM card off the newsstand.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ajot on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @06:41PM (#48468836)
In my experience, you then need to activate it using real data from real people. I lent my data to a colombian colleague a couple of years ago, as he did not have a DNI yet.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by wan23 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:25PM (#48465338)
> Much of EU requires ID for some time now

The US isn't in the EU

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by IAmBroom on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:44PM (#48465657)
No one implied it was.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:11PM (#48462992)
What problem were they hoping to solve with that legislation?
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by logicchains on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:18PM (#48463121)
The problem of citizens having anonymous internet connectivity.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by chopin on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:51PM (#48463663)
That's an illusion. Two days of location data and you can pin down the owner pretty well.

I thought about getting a SIM when Germany was about to introduce ID requirements. I quickly realized this being a moot point.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by tbrownaw on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:59PM (#48469468)
There a significant difference between "the user can be identified fairly well if you can get access to sensitive stuff" and "the owner is always explicitly recorded in a searchable database".
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @02:57AM (#48472477)
My burner would only be powered on for the duration of the call and the time to spin up gsm connectivity.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by rusk on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:23PM (#48463196)
The free anonymous internet was only ever a ruse to get people to use it so the CIA could spy on them. DARPA, folks, created a “free as in beer” global surveillance network and we all bought it.

Not that we didn’t get anything in return but the idea that the worlds foremost military industrial complex just gave this to the world because they loved us is laughable.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by mrexroad on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:53PM (#48471219)
Huh? DARPA created something to help retain communication and coordination capabilities for our government in event of nuclear attack.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by rusk on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @01:49AM (#48471962)
Indeed they did, at great expense and gave it away for free!
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by stackskipton on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:48PM (#48463616)
Most of time it's billed as law enforcement fighting tool. If people can't have anonymous cell phones, once you capture one criminal phone number, you can quickly look at who they call and since they can't be burners, you figure out the criminal network.

Also, if you have restrictions of speech in the country, it's great way to de anonymize any speech government says is illegal.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by Gigachad on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:40PM (#48469320)
Any situation you can imagine wanting a burner phone for, that's what the government wants to crack down on.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by mc32 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:42AM (#48462594)
Don’t eSIMs solve this problem for tourists?
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by naturalmovement on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:17PM (#48463096)
Apple — and now Google — have "solved" this problem for the government by removing physical SIM slots in US iPhones.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by TylerE on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:21PM (#48463170)
Thus eSIM
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by nickphx on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:46AM (#48462639)
Only if you do not require voice service.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by vfclists on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:39PM (#48463452)
Doesn't an eSIM link the SIM to the phone's IMEI which is usually logged somewhere?
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ezfe on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:56PM (#48464853)
Yes, eSIM doesn't really change this conversation
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ezfe on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:56PM (#48464866)
eSIM doesn't change local laws around cell phones - it's not magic.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by RankingMember on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:59PM (#48464912)
Yep, they'll still prompt for the info.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by lmz on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @10:05PM (#48470434)
It can if it's a roaming eSIM. I'm sure all the countries mentioned here e.g. Australia still handles US SIMs roaming there fine even when the US SIM dossn't have ID tied to it.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ezfe on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:12PM (#48470950)
A roaming eSIM would work the same way as a roaming SIM. Just because it's easier to set up (no need to get a physical SIM) doesn't change the regulations around it.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by lmz on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @01:26AM (#48471802)
I suppose this depends on how the law is written, but are roaming users subject to local SIM regulations for network use? I can't imagine asking for ID from tourists using their existing SIMs is going to work.

I believe some travel eSIMs are actually issued from outside the country you're going to.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by morpheuskafka on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @05:24AM (#48473702)
Typically not. Because they don't have local phone numbers nor IP addresses, so they cannot be used for scams or fake identities domestically. In China, roaming SIMs also bypass all internet filtering, it's basically a built in VPN back to your home telecom.

And as you said, ones marketed as "China travel SIMs" are typically issued from Hong Kong. Interestingly, Hong Kong also has an ID rule (though it allows self upload of ID anyway), but it exempts these roaming-only cards. If you want the card to work in HK, and it is issued from there, you must scan your passport to activate it.

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ezfe on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @11:44AM (#48478104)
Right, but that distinction is not because it's an eSIM - it's just how it's issued. There's no technical distinction, just a practical ease of issuance.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by izacus on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:07PM (#48465046)
In what way? Activating it still needs KYC.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by LawnGnome on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:03PM (#48463896)
Has this changed recently? I thought I heard about this several years ago, but the last 2-3 times I've visited (in the last couple of years) I've been able to pick up a prepaid SIM from Colesworth without any ID check.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ibejoeb on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:31PM (#48464374)
It has been like that for at least 8 years, and probably longer. There are still stalls at airports, but you must provide ID.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by LawnGnome on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:33PM (#48464420)
Interesting. Seems like this isn't very consistently enforced, then.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by ibejoeb on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:37PM (#48464488)
You may have bought the sim card but never activated it. It's not the device itself that is restricted, just using it.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by byhemechi on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:21PM (#48469177)
You can buy the SIM but can’t activate it without going through ID checks.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by timando on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:25PM (#48469206)
It used to be that you did the ID check when you bought the SIM, but now you have to do the ID check when you activate it.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by tarinedier on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @08:48PM (#48469817)
It's been like this since at least the late 90s, I remember having to fill out the paperwork manually when working at Target
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by flashman on Thursday June 11, 2026 @09:31AM (#48490120)
The current ID verification requirements for phones were introduced to Australia in 1997
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by MarkusWandel on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:13PM (#48465141)
Somewhat recently, tried to activate a SIM for a guest here in Canada, and while you could fill in anything you want for personal info, the only way to hook up (prepaid) billing was with a Canadian credit card number. Whoops. This was only for a month, so I put in mine and he reimbursed me in cash. Other carriers may still let you buy one-time payment cards for cash at retail; this one didn't.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by hinata08 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @04:21PM (#48467127)
Having a friend who lends you their credit card so that you pay it off at the end of your trip is such a premium !

Canada isn't the only country in which foreign cards don't work everywhere, and it seems like it's rarely tested

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by willhslade on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:18PM (#48465210)
I think this is where Airalo shines. I've used it while travelling and I think eSIMs, as annoying as they are, are the way.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by buellerbueller on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:48PM (#48465709)
I just tried a GigSky eSim on my Samsung Galaxy and it was an epic fail of an experience.
Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by hinata08 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @04:26PM (#48467212)
these "travel sims" are pricey !

You get better deals with local carriers if you actually use the potential of eSIM, which is to be able to switch ! Every other carrier in most parts of the world now supply eSIMs that you can sometimes activate from home before your trip

Canada has Lucky Mobile, central Europe has A1 mobile, France and Portugal have Lycamobile, Italy has Windtre, UK has no service,...

Getting a SIM is typically the thing on which you can save 20$ just by asking a local person

Re:FCC Wants to Kill Burner Phones by Forcing Telecoms to Ge... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @03:21PM (#48466270)
> This is how it works in Australia, which means it's a pain for tourists as you need to provide a passport for ID and get it activated, as opposed to just grabbing one at an airport kiosk and being ready to go

I don't see the connection. This is also how it works in China, which means... when you grab a SIM card at an airport kiosk, they take a picture of your passport. You obviously have your passport with you, because you just arrived in China and haven't left the airport yet.

What part of that isn't also true of Australia?