News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:04PM (#48185605)
Well, Zed is a text editor with some plugins, while JetBrains products are full-blown IDEs, with abilities Zed will never offer.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by wiseowise on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:08PM (#48185657)
> while JetBrains products are full-blown IDEs, with abilities Zed will never offer.

None of those matter if they just close the IDE before it indexes.

> When all of these tiny issues come together, it makes me NOT want to program. I don’t want to sit around and wait for startup times to get my ideas onto the screen. I don’t want to worry that my CPU or RAM is going to be exhausted and I am going to have to restart my machine. I want to open my editor and immediately enter a flow state. I want the tooling to assist me when useful, and stay out of my way when not.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:11PM (#48185692)
Yes I have read that, and whatever, some people rather walk straight away, because waiting for the car to warm up takes a few minutes.

I have IDE tooling experience since Borland products for MS-DOS, and plenty of programming editors as well, between PC, Amiga, Mac and UNIX clones.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by wiseowise on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:41PM (#48186089)
> because waiting for the car to warm up takes a few minutes.

If only it was this. Usually the car transmission breaks, there are random engine shutdowns, and after restart the car just doesn't function anymore. And when it actually does start, it moves so slow and consumes so much fuel that I can't justify using it. That's my experience with JetBrains IDEs.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by ryanolsonx on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:13PM (#48185719)
Idk what car you have but mine can drive right away, just like Zed.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by kstrauser on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:18PM (#48185780)
Side note: to a rounding error, all modern cars can be safely driven right away. Wait a few seconds for the sound of the engine to change, indicating that oil is now happily pumping through all the grindy bits, and then you're ready to go. I'm not saying you want to drag race your neighbor 10 seconds after starting the engine for the first time that day, but once you don't hear the tappets being tappety, it's OK to pull out of your driveway and start moving at a sane pace.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by rurban on Monday May 18, 2026 @11:50PM (#48188966)
> indicating that oil is now happily pumping through all the grindy bits

That's not a modern car. Modern cars do not pump oil through all the grindy bits. Modern cars need to wait for the BMC to stabilize its power.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by linsomniac on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:16PM (#48185763)
Not who you are replying to, but the new Lexus RX350h takes and absurdly long time to be ready to drive away, if you want to use the rear camera to help back out of the parking lot.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by 4ndrewl on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:22PM (#48185853)
Wait, don't you reverse into a parking space and drive straight out?
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pentium166 on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:40PM (#48186081)
Slow car computers aside, it doesn't really make a difference in the scheme of things. Spend the time backing up now or later. Also, maybe you need to use your trunk and you'd rather have it opening into free space instead of another vehicle or a wall.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by kstrauser on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:22PM (#48187243)
I contend it does. People tend to take way more time backing into a space than pulling into it, and hardly more time backing out of a space than pulling forward out of it.

I'm certain this isn't how they think of it, but when I see someone blocking traffic while they painfully back into a spot, I imagine them imagining themselves having to fly out of there without a moment to spare, like they plan on having a drastic emergency before they leave. And if that person isn't driving a police or fire department car or the like, I roll my eyes at the delusion of grandeur.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by djhn on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @12:14AM (#48189100)
Surely a big part of the reason is steering leverage relative to the kerb.

You are able to one-shot reverse parallel park into a much narrower gap without hitting the bumpers of the cars around you or getting onto the pavement.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by antonvs on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:51PM (#48186220)
I always wonder why people do this. What’s the reasoning?
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by smackeyacky on Monday May 18, 2026 @06:17PM (#48186547)
I wonder this too. It’s much harder to back into a cramped parking space than backing out into an open space. So they do it very slowly. Watching people do this is frustrating.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by robrtsql on Monday May 18, 2026 @06:52PM (#48186930)
They would rather back into a parking spot surrounded by stationary obstacles than back into a parking lot or road which may contain pedestrians or other drivers.

I'm not saying _I_ back into spaces. I generally drive into spots and reverse out of them. However, I admit that what I do is a tradeoff where I take on risk in order to have a mechanically easier time entering and exiting the space.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by lostmsu on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:18PM (#48187202)
This makes no sense. In either case the car traverses the same space once forwards and once backwards.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pegasus on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @01:24AM (#48189515)
That's true, but what GP is saying is that when you're pulling out, you are traversing the part of the space overwhelmingly more likely to contain passing pedestrians and vehicles with full visibility.

And then some parking spots require parallel parking which is best done via backing up anyway.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by lostmsu on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:22AM (#48190660)
I don't think you understood what my comment says. The whole point is that it covers your "but".
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by maratc on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:24AM (#48190673)
> It’s much harder to back into a cramped parking space than backing out into an open space.

With cramped parking spaces, your real options are (a) backing into it or (b) driving forward into it. When you need to have a 90 degree turn, option (a) gives you more control over the eventual position of your car, and is frequently the only option.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by TYPE_FASTER on Monday May 18, 2026 @10:01PM (#48188382)
I asked a former truck driver once and his answer was that it's easier to see what's in front of you than behind you. I wondered why people in our neighborhood backed into their driveways at first, then I realized this was indeed true. If I turn into the street and back into my driveway, somebody probably hasn't jumped behind my car. If I get in my car and back out of my driveway, somebody walking/biking along may not notice my car backing out of the driveway, and my old potato backup camera isn't always the best at illuminating people behind my car at night in bad weather.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by maratc on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:47AM (#48190458)
When you have a tight spot, getting into it in reverse is the only way to do it safely — your front wheels can turn but your rear wheels can’t.

However I always park with the front to the exit, since I might find myself in a situation where I have to drive away very quickly.

It might be anything from a dumpster truck about to block the street to some kind of family emergency.

I have the 20 seconds now but I can't be sure I will have them in the morning.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by linsomniac on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:58AM (#48193403)
In my cars, generally, yes. The Lexus in question is my MIL's car, and she prefers it parked at home nose-in. We were also running some errands that required access to the rear (groceries, returning a printer/fax machine).
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by za3faran on Monday May 18, 2026 @10:39PM (#48188579)
Can you elaborate more on why it takes a long time to be ready to drive away in reverse? How long are you talking?
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by linsomniac on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:02AM (#48193446)
I didn't time it but I'd put it at 30 seconds. It sits there for a while with the infotainment screen black, then it does this animated splash screen, then it loads the infotainment/cameras.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:05AM (#48191390)
Depending on the planet region, and season, you might actually have to wait before driving.

Frozen Winters, heavy snow, diesel pumps,....

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by xigoi on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:59AM (#48191727)
If a text editor is a car, an IDE is an airplane. You can get to more places with it, but you need a lot of space and time to even start moving and then it consumes a ridiculous amount of fuel.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by j_w on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:11AM (#48192883)
Horrible analogy. You can't "get to more places" with an airplane. An airplane can only go to very limited number of locations compared to a car.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by xigoi on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:18AM (#48192962)
That actually makes it a great analogy. An IDE allows you to make common edits like renaming a variable, just as an airplane gets you to any big city. But when you need to make an uncommon edit, it’s better to reach for Vim – just like you need a car to get to some random place in the middle of woods.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by j_w on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:53AM (#48195002)
This comment is so absurd I'm struggling to reply.

A car takes you to an "uncommon place in the woods?"

Taking a plane is a "common edit?"

For the majority of people a car would be the "common" usage and a plane would be the "uncommon" usage. Unless you're a billionaire taking your private jet between runways to then hop on a helicopter for the rest of your trip.

It's a terrible analogy.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by usef- on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:31PM (#48185967)
Exhausting the CPU and memory? I'm genuinely curious how he gets such a different experience to me.

Startup is definitely slower than vim though, but it's something that happens only once for me, then it stays open all day (unlike vim which I close and open repeatedly)

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by onehair on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @12:48AM (#48189283)
One can always use multiple editors for what they do besg.

Zed, helix, nvim for small files in gui or terminal.

A solid Slow start IDE for solid extended time work

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by shimman on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:17PM (#48185771)
I don't use Zed, but do use Neovim but people make similar arguments.

If I have access to a LSP and DAP, also do most of my refactoring through c tags and vim grep (or grug-far if I want to be fancy). What IDE specific features am I missing out on that can't be replicated?

Being earnest here because I always screenshare with co-workers doing a variety of things and there is nothing I ever see that is impressive or makes me want to switch.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by throwaway7783 on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:26PM (#48185903)
I'm in the java ecosystem, so YMMV.

- Automatic spring service detection

- Debugger (remote, local , with access to state, stack and ability to modify the state while stepping through), though I assume this is possible with neovm?

- built-in profiler

- can run individual tests seamlessly

- understands bytecode enhancers like Lombok

- Find Usage, find symbol, language specific navigation, showing class hierarchies, going up/down the hierarchies etc (maybe in conjunction with LSP, other editors can do a decent job?)

- Advanced refactoring (extracting classes, interfaces, inlining functions, extracting functions/methods)

- built-in database explorer

- built-in Git support (I have struggled mightily with VSCodes git interactions - but this might just be an individual preference)

- markdown/html previews

Basically, I barely have to get out of the IDE.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by giaour on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:51PM (#48186229)
> - can run individual tests seamlessly

This is the main one for me. If I am working on a large project with decent unit test coverage, the feedback loop in IntelliJ or Visual Studio is just much quicker than the alternatives because you can run and debug the specific tests you need.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by j_w on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:13AM (#48192903)
Why can you not run specific tests from neovim?

If you really wanted to you could add some trigger on save for a file that would re-run tests for said file. Maybe a plugin or key bind could run a specific test which you choose in buffer.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by giaour on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:32PM (#48270711)
I'm sure there is a way to use a step debugger with a specific unit test in Neovim or whatever, but it's one of the things heavyweight IDEs do with no setup or configuration.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by matttttttttttt on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:52AM (#48194990)
Characterizing Zed as a text editor is disingenuous.

Zed has documentation, go-to definition/usage, local/remote debugger, can run/debug individual tests, has git and markdown. Essentially all the core IDE functionality is there. All of these work as well or better for Rust in Zed than IntelliJ.

ByteCode decompilation is a very Java-specific thing and I've not used Zed for Java yet. I suspect that they'll get around to it eventually if they don't already have it.

I've never used database plugins in any IDE I've ever used so I can't compare/contrast between Zed and JetBrains products. However, as soon as I see an IDE gain a database plugin, I know it's the beginning of the end for that IDE. After the database plugin is the CSS minimizer, the JavaScript Bundler, I guess the AI plugin is the new hip thing. For the twilight years of my IntelliJ/CLipn usage, the first thing I'd do upon installation would be to go remove all the damn plugins.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by throwaway7783 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @12:58PM (#48195992)
I am not sure if you are replying to me or someone else. I never said I'm characterizing Zed as a text editor. Never used it, and have no opinion on it. My listing above was on why I am sticking with Jetbrains. Also did not say anything about AI.

IDEs/Editors ultimately are a very personal choice assuming they have sufficient features for a given language ecosystem.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by robhlt on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:44PM (#48186125)
My problems are mostly with the language servers. I've always found them to be slower, consume more resources, and provide worse results compared to the equivalent JetBrains IDE. I've tried Python, Rust, and Go within the last few months and found this is still the case. Go is the worst of them, on larger repos gopls will easily consume 3-4x more memory than GoLand with far worse responsiveness on completions.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by ElectricalUnion on Monday May 18, 2026 @06:11PM (#48186463)
Jetbrains IDE, sure, they take their sweet time indexing your project, but once per start.

The Java LSP is a egregious "thing" that takes 10 to 30s to read your whole project for the n-th time while eating 40GiB of RAM in the process. On a loop, EVERY time you view a new file.

Where is my goddam lsif/scip support?

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by mike_hearn on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:10PM (#48196985)
You shouldn't be seeing indexing once per start. The indexes are stored to disk. You might see the IDE scan files to figure out if anything changed whilst the IDE was stopped.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by ElectricalUnion on Saturday May 23, 2026 @03:28PM (#48250561)
How did you manage to get the Java LSP to do that? Mine just insist on re-parsing the entire codebase every time I view a file.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by mike_hearn on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:58AM (#48276082)
Ah sorry, I've never used that. I was talking about IntelliJ and related IDEs.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by jghn on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:51PM (#48186221)
The built in debugger & profiler are the big thing above LSP equivalence for me. I know it can be done, but it's not the same.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by kstrauser on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:21PM (#48185831)
We're not missing anything, or at least not anything I actually miss. I had a previous supervisor who chided me for "not using an IDE" because I was using Emacs -- Emacs! -- and insisted I should use something more featureful.

First, that doesn't exist, and the notion's laughable.

Second, I have every feature I actually want to use in Emacs (and Zed and even *vim), and have no reason to believe that any random bullet point someone might come up with 1) doesn't exist in those editors, or 2) that I'd use it anyway.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by ozim on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:56PM (#48186292)
Debuggers are much better in JetBrains or Visual Studio than using just an editor.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by kstrauser on Monday May 18, 2026 @06:14PM (#48186517)
Had you honestly imagined that Emacs doesn't have excellent debugging tools?
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @01:52AM (#48189716)
No it doesn't, unless it magically got them since XEmacs, with someone taking the effort to duplicate all features in ELisp.

Running gdb as subprocess, with breakpoints, step, run, continue, is the basic stuff.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by kstrauser on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:59AM (#48190156)
It has. GUD is pretty good. Emacs itself has improved vastly since XEmacs was popular.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:08AM (#48191407)
Looks pretty much the same from the docs.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by aki237 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:38AM (#48190000)
Recently been using emacs' inbuilt debugger. Honestly it is nuts, how good it is.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:13AM (#48191448)
Now try to visually display all the threads being executed and the dependency graph who launched each thread.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/debugger/usin...

Followed by doing some code change and hot reloading it into the debugging session.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/debugger/edit...

While using binaries compiled in release build by default,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YnbO140OXuI

All of it in C++.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by cptmurphy on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:54AM (#48218443)
Can it be done using standalone debuggers? I don't mind switching between a text editor and a debugger
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by ozim on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:40AM (#48190017)
I imagine that just way more work was poured into VS/Jetbrains debuggers and that they have better UX and better features.

I don’t have to offer my soul to make it work just pay money ;)

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by kstrauser on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:01AM (#48190169)
> I imagine that just way more work was poured into VS/Jetbrains debuggers

I'm fascinated at how vastly different our perspectives are. From my POV, I'd be shocked if VS/Jetbrains had a fraction of the work poured into them that Emacs or Vim have.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by delta_p_delta_x on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:31AM (#48190366)
VS and JetBrains IDEs have very good sane defaults. They're usable out of the box. In VS I load a .sln file, or a project containing CMakeLists.txt, press F5, and I am debugging with a full-fledged data structure visualisation, CPU and heap profiling, and I can even add in time-travel debugging with a couple of clicks.

I have to manually set all of this up in Vim or Emacs, and frankly the debugging experience in GDB or LLDB is worse than it really ought to be. People actually need to use good tools to understand how nice things can be.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:12PM (#48197023)
Try to debug a CMake file, do hot code reloading for C++, or debug release binaries with Emacs/vim.

Just three examples out of many others.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by lenkite on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:26PM (#48212794)
I think you need to try the Jetbrains debugger first - anyone who has used it would never compare it with neovim or emacs.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by giancarlostoro on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:15PM (#48185745)
Zed is also insanely capable for the short span its been around, and very responsive. I love JetBrains and used them for over a decade now, but I think I will likely cancel next year since I find myself only using Zed these days.
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by Dayshine on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:19PM (#48185814)
Is it? For the three languages I tried to use it for it was terrible.

It was like it only had the basic language support plugin I wrote for myself at uni: basic syntax and current file/directory only source files loaded into context.

So any referenced projects, tooling, even packages in one language, and you have false positive errors everywhere.

Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by moritzruth on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:38AM (#48192028)
Re:No More JetBrains Products for Me by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @01:53AM (#48189727)
For a programming text editor.