News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Claude Design by nightski on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:18PM (#47808930)
Agreed on your take on the parent, although I have to say I feel that AI has had the opposite effect for me. It has only accelerated learning quite significantly. In fact not only is learning more effective/efficient, I have more time for it because I am not spending nearly as much time tracking down stupid issues.
Re:Claude Design by stronglikedan on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:15PM (#47810106)
Sounds like you're talking about research AI and not generative AI. You can't learn artistic/creative techniques when you're not practicing those techniques. You can have a vision, but the AI will execute that vision, and you only get the end result without learning the techniques used to execute it.
Re:Claude Design by apsurd on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:42PM (#47810359)
That's a really useful distinction to have explicitly articulated. It's also why plan mode feels like a super power. Research vs Generative AI are different: I'm going to use this.
Re:Claude Design by nightski on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:07PM (#47810571)
I guess I was more referring to just using generative AI when learning new subjects and exploring new ideas. It's a really efficient tutor and/or sidekick who can either explain topics in more depth, find better sources, or help me explore new theories. I was thinking beyond just generating code, which is incredibly useful but only mildly interesting.
Re:Claude Design by LordDragonfang on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:35PM (#47810849)
Okay, this is a pet peeve of mine, so forgive me if I come off a little curt here, but-- I disagree strongly with how this was phrased.

"Generative AI" isn't just an adjective applied to a noun, it's a specific marketing term that's used as the collective category for language models and image/video model -- things which "generate" content.

What I assume you mean is "I think <term> is misleading, and would prefer to make a distinction".

But how you actually phrased it reads as "<term> doesn't mean <accepted definition of the term>, but rather <definition I made up which contains only the subset of the original definition I dislike>. What you mean is <term made up on the spot to distinguish the 'good' subset of the accepted definition>"

I see this all the time in politics, and it muddies the discussion so much because you can't have a coherent conversation. (And AI is very much a political topic these days.) It's the illusion of nuance -- which actually just serves as an excuse to avoid engaging with the nuance that actually exists in the real category. (Research AI is generative AI; they are not cleanly separable categories which you can define without artificial/external distinctions.)

Re:Claude Design by javier2 on Friday April 17, 2026 @06:21PM (#47811225)
Well, the research is sometimes 10x quicker with AI assistant. But not always. Building phase is maybe 20-100% quicker for me at least, depending on the complexity of the project. Green field without 15 years of legacy that is never allowed to break is many times faster, always has been.
Re:Claude Design by CaptWillard on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:22PM (#47808976)
Big difference between gaining knowledge and building/maintaining cognitive skills.
Re:Claude Design by system2 on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:14PM (#47810098)
It is better than doomscrolling on Instagram for hours like the new generations. At least the brain is active, creating ideas or reading some text nonstop to keep itself active.
Re:Claude Design by monarchwadia on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:29PM (#47809045)
I assure you, working with LLMs is intellectually challenging, and becomes more so as the technology matures.
Re:Claude Design by tempest_ on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:44PM (#47809208)
It really really really depends on how you are using it and what you are using it for.

I can get LLMs to write most CSS I need by treating it like a slot machine and pulling the handle till it spits out what I need, this doesnt cause me to learn CSS at all.

Re:Claude Design by nightski on Friday April 17, 2026 @03:45PM (#47809791)
I find it a lot more useful to dive into bugs involving multiple layers and versions of 3rd party dependencies. Deep issues where when I see the answer I completely understand what it did to find it and what the problem was (so in essence I wouldn't of learned anything diving deep into the issue), but it was able to do so in a much more efficient fashion than me referencing code across multiple commits on github, docs, etc...

This allows me to focus my attention on important learning endeavors, things I actually want to learn and are not forced to simply because a vendor was sloppy and introduced a bug in v3.4.1.3.

LLMS excel when you can give them a lot of relevant context and they behave like an intelligent search function.

Re:Claude Design by lo_zamoyski on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:19PM (#47810144)
Indeed, many if not most bugs are intellectually dull. They're just lodged within a layered morass of cruft and require a lot of effort to unearth. It is rarely intellectually stimulating, and when it is as a matter of methodology, it is often uninteresting as a matter of acquired knowledge.

The real fun of programming is when it becomes a vector for modeling something, communicating that model to others, and talking about that model with others. That is what programming is, modeling. There's a domain you're operating within. Programming is a language you use to talk about part of it. It's annoying when a distracting and unessential detail derails this conversation.

Pure vibe coding is lazy, but I see no problem with AI assistants. They're not a difference in kind, but of degree. No one argues that we should throw away type checking, because it reduces the cognitive load needed to infer the types of expressions in dynamic languages in your head. The reduction in wasteful cognitive load is precisely the point.

Quoting Aristotle's Politics, "all paid employments [..] absorb and degrade the mind". There's a scale, arguably. There are intellectual activities that are more worthy and better elevate the mind, and there are those that absorb its attention, mold it according to base concerns, drag it into triviality, and take time away away from higher pursuits.

Re:Claude Design by skydhash on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:25PM (#47810746)
I agree with your definition of programming (and I’ve been saying the same thing here), but

> It's annoying when a distracting and unessential detail derails this conversation

there is no such details.

The model (the program) and the simulation (the process) are intrinsically linked as the latter is what gives the former its semantic. The simulation apparatus may be noisy (when it’s own model blends into our own), but corrective and transformative models exists (abstraction).

> No one argues that we should throw away type checking,…

That’s not a good comparison. Type checking helps with cognitive load in verifying correctness, but it does increase it, when you’re not sure of the final shape of the solution. It’s a bit like Pen vs Pencil in drawing. Pen is more durable and cleaner, while Pencil feels more adventurous.

As long as you can pattern match to get a solution, LLM can help you, but that does requires having encountered the pattern before to describe it. It can remove tediousness, but any creative usage is problematic as it has no restraints.

Re:Claude Design by lo_zamoyski on Sunday April 19, 2026 @11:41AM (#47825106)
> there is no such details.

Qua formal system, yes, but this is a pedantic point as the aim - the what - of a system is more important than the how. This distinction makes the distinction between domain-relevant features and implementation details more conspicuous. If I wish to predict the relative positions of the objects of our solar system, then in relation to that end and that domain concern, it matters not whether the underlying model assumes a geocentric or heliocentric stance in its model (that tacitly is the deeper value of Copernicus's work; he didn't vindicate heliocentrism, he showed that a heliocentric model is just as explanatory and preserves appearances equally well, and I would say that this mathematical and even philosophical stance toward scientific modeling is the real Copernican revolution, not all the later pamphleteer mythology).

Of course, in relation to other ends and contexts, what were implementation details in one case become the domain in the other. If you are, say, aiming for model simplicity, then you might prefer heliocentrism over geocentrism with all its baroque explanatory or predictive devices.

The underlying implementation is, from a design point-of-view, virtually within the composite. The implementation model is not of equal rank and importance as the domain model, even if the former constrains the latter. (It's also why we talk about rabbit-holing; we can get distracted from our domain-specific aim, but distraction presupposes a distinction between domain-specific aim and something that isn't.) When woodworking, we aren't talking about quantum mechanical phenomena in the wood, because while you cannot separate the wood from the quantum mechanical phenomena as a factual matter - distinction is not separation - the quantum is virtual, not actual with respect to the wood, and it is irrelevant within the domain concerning the woodworker.

So, if there is a bug in a library, that is, in some sense, a distraction from our domain. LLMs can help keep us on task, because our abstractions don't care how they're implemented as long as they work and work the way we want. This can actually encourage clearer thinking. Category mistakes occur in part because of a failure to maintain clear domain distinctions.

> That’s not a good comparison. Type checking [...]

It reduces cognitive load vis-a-vis understanding code. When I want to understand a function in a dynamic language, I often have to drill down into composing functions, or look at callers, e.g., in test cases to build up a bunch of constraints in my mind about what the domain and codomain is. (This can become increasingly difficult when the dynamic language has some form of generics, because if you care about the concrete type/class in some case, you need even more information.)

This cognitive load distracts us from the domain. The domain is effectively blurred without types. Usually, modeling something using types first actually liberates us, because it encourages clearer thinking upfront about the what instead of jumping right into how. (I don't pretend that types never increase certain kinds of burdens, at least in the short term, but I am talking about a specific affordance. In any case, LLMs play very nicely with statically-typed languages, and so this actually reduces one of the argued benefits of dynamic languages as ostensibly better at prototyping.)

> As long as you can pattern match to get a solution [...]

Indeed, and that's the point. LLMs work so well precisely, because our abstractions suck. We have lot of boilerplate and repetitive plumbing that is time-consuming and tedious and pulls us away from the domain. Years of programming research and programming practice has not resolved this problem, which suggests that such abstractions are either impractical or unattainable. (The problem is related to the philosophical question whether you can formalize all of reality, which you cannot, and certainly not under one formal system.)

I don't claim that LLMs don't have drawbacks or tradeoffs, or require new methodologies to operate. My stance is a moderate one.

Re:Claude Design by baq on Friday April 17, 2026 @03:40PM (#47809752)
This isn’t necessarily a bad thing. I know a little css and have zero desire or motivation to know more; the things I’d like done that need css just wouldn’t have been done without LLMs.
Re:Claude Design by rTX5CMRXIfFG on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:43PM (#47810934)
Yes but that’s why you ask it to teach you what it just did. And then you fact-check with external resources on the side. That’s how learning works.
Re:Claude Design by xienze on Friday April 17, 2026 @06:45PM (#47811386)
> Yes but that’s why you ask it to teach you what it just did.

Are you really going to do that though? The whole point of using AI for coding is to crank shit out as fast as possible. If you’re gonna stop and try to “learn” everything, why not take that approach to begin with? You’re fooling yourself if you think “ok, give me the answer first then teach me” is the same as learning and being able to figure out the answer yourself.

Re:Claude Design by tevli on Friday April 17, 2026 @06:18PM (#47811196)
This exactly. My css designs have noticeably gotten better without me,the writer getting any better at all.
Re:Claude Design by sanex on Friday April 17, 2026 @08:44PM (#47812172)
I would consider this a benefit. I've been a professional for 10 years and have successfully avoided CSS for all of it. Now I can do even more things and still successfully avoid it.
Re:Claude Design by unsignedchar on Friday April 17, 2026 @09:17PM (#47812352)
But were you trying to learn CSS in the first place?
Re:Claude Design by DaiPlusPlus on Friday April 17, 2026 @03:53PM (#47809861)
/s/intellectually/emotionally
Re:Claude Design by leptons on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:02PM (#47809965)
I find it intellectually exhausting to describe to a machine what I want, when I could build something better in the same amount of time, and it isn't for lack of understanding how the LLM works.

It takes a lot of cajoling to get an LLM to produce a result I want to use. It takes no cajoling for me to do it myself.

The only time "AI" helps is in domains that I am unfamiliar with, and even then it's more miss than hit.

Re:Claude Design by skydhash on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:34PM (#47810834)
> I find it intellectually exhausting to describe to a machine what I want, when I could build something better in the same amount of time, and it isn't for lack of understanding how the LLM works.

I don’t even bother. Most of my use cases have been when I’m sure I’ve done the same type of work before (tests, crud query,…). I describe the structure of the code and let it replicate the pattern.

For any fundamental alteration, I bring out my vim/emacs-fu. But after a while, you start to have good abstractions, and you spend your time more on thinking than on coding (most solutions are a few lines of codes).

Re:Claude Design by vehemenz on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:46PM (#47810961)
My experience is mostly the opposite. Provided the right context and prompt, CC will generally produce code, even in domains I know, 10-20x faster.

Quality is a different issue, sure.

Re:Claude Design by lo_zamoyski on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:04PM (#47809983)
> I have more time for it because I am not spending nearly as much time tracking down stupid issues.

It is a truism that the majority of effort and time a software dev spends is allocated toward boilerplate, plumbing, and other tedious and intellectually uninteresting drudgery. LLMs can alleviate much of that, and if used wisely, function as a tool for aiding the understanding of principles, which is ultimately what knowledge concerns, and not absorbing the mind in ephemeral and essentially arbitrary fluff. In fact, the occupation hazard is that you'll become so absorbed in some bit of minutia, you'll forget the context you were operating in. You'll forget what the point of it all was.

Life is short. While knowing how to calculate mentally and/or with pen and paper is good for mastering principles and basic facility (the same is true of programming, btw), no one is clamoring to go back to the days before the calculator. There's a reason physicists would outsource the numerical bullshit to teams of human computers.

Re:Claude Design by nightski on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:13PM (#47810626)
Just wanted to say you put it really well, that's exactly how I feel.
Re:Claude Design by camillomiller on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:12PM (#47810083)
Are you sure that is not the illusion of learning? If you don't know the domains, how can you know how much you now know? Especially consider that these models are all Dunning Kruger-inducing machines.
Re:Claude Design by qingcharles on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:27PM (#47809021)
Agree on that too. And I use these as tools. I don't think I'm missing out on anything if I use this drill press to put a hole through an inch of steel instead of trying to spend a day doing it wobbly with a hand-drill.