News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by dingaling on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:01PM (#47608297)
There is no technological innovation in the Artemis stack.

Three of the main engines are refurbished Shuttle engines. The fourth is a clone that cost more than the entire SpaceX Starship stack.

The boosters are derived from the Shuttle SRBs.

It's a late-60s technology rocket stack with a 2000s-era flight computer.

It's such a travesty.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:09PM (#47608352)
> is no technological innovation in the Artemis stack

Scaling is still engineering.

And the environmental control system, laser-optical communication systems and block-construction heat shields are new. For Artemis III, in-obit propellant transfer will be new and transformational.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by NetMageSCW on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:18PM (#47608449)
The block construction heat shield was new on Artemis I. Now we just know that it is an unfixed problem that will be done differently on future missions.

And Artemis III has nothing to do with in-orbit propellant transfer, that will be SpaceX and Blue Origin testing independently of Artemis III.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:38PM (#47608595)
> block construction heat shield was new on Artemis I. Now we just know that it is an unfixed problem

Unfixed problems on a new technology mean it’s still new.

> Artemis III has nothing to do with in-orbit propellant transfer

I may have fucked this up—isn’t the depot supposed to be up for III? Or is that punted to IV?

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Teever on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:28PM (#47608524)
All of this stuff is really great but it's not worth the cost that was spent on it.

The thing you have to keep asking yourself is "what could 100 billion dollars of non-pork barrel spending have bought instead of what we ended up with?"

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by noosphr on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:33PM (#47608555)
A month of war in the middle east.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:42PM (#47608618)
> All of this stuff is really great but it's not worth the cost that was spent on it

It’s building towards a system. If we get Starship and in-orbit propellant depots and a lunar nuclear reactor and then kill the programme, it will probably be judged by history as a success.

> what could 100 billion dollars of non-pork barrel spending have bought instead of what we ended up with?

Rien. This is the system we have, and it’s unclear such a program could have survived sans pork.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Teever on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @10:47PM (#47609420)
It may be building towards a system. Or it could all be cancelled in 3-4 weeks after these four explorers burn up on reentry.

And then all these hopes and dreams that you have will be gone, like that $100 billion dollars just up in smoke.

I can tell that you're as passionate about space exploration and colonization as I am, but this isn't the way my friend.

This program is coming at the cost of the Aldrin Cyclers and Von Braun Wheels that you and I know could and should have existed decades ago and while you may think that those things will come from this program I think you should consider the fact that root cause of this program's dysfunction is what is denying us this reality of humanity spreading across the stars.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @10:53PM (#47609447)
> It may be building towards a system

It may build. It is building.

> it could all be cancelled in 3-4 weeks after these four explorers burn up

We’d have wasted money. But we’d still be ahead. Artemis has funded a lot of development.

> can tell that you're as passionate about space exploration and colonization as I am, but this isn't the way my friend

In a perfect world? No. Is it a legitimate way? Absolutely. We’re still moving forward.

> This program is coming at the cost of the Aldrin Cyclers and Von Braun Wheels

Nobody is funding these. We’re beating the Chinese to land. That clicks. That sells. Space-based infrastructure is hallucinated competition.

> that root cause of this program's dysfunction is what is denying us this reality

The alternative is we spend NASA’s Artemis budget on Medicaid billing at autism centers in Indiana.

I’d prefer the vision you painted. But I won’t let perfect be the enemy of the good. This program moves us forward and funds roads to alternatives. Starship, for example.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by idiotsecant on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:31PM (#47608970)
What a simultaneously cynical and boring and completely useless attitude. Is it your position that if this hadn't happened 100b of otherwise more important spending would have happened?
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Teever on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @10:49PM (#47609432)
I think that $100 billion, spent effectively could have resulted in Von Braun Wheels in LEO. I think that it could have resulted in teleoperated lunar mining and smelting that would be allowing us to build human bases on Earth now instead of a single fly by that may end in the death of these four amazing explorers.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by NetMageSCW on Thursday April 02, 2026 @11:17AM (#47615623)
There is no world in which lunar mining and smelting economically produces anything useful on Earth.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Teever on Thursday April 02, 2026 @02:55PM (#47618669)
I was describing a scenario where the teleoperated machines were used to build a base on the Moon with in situ produced materials, not one where materials are sold as export to Earth.

But I'm curious to hear why you think that it will always be uneconomical to produce refined metals on the Earth and transport them to Earth for further manufacturing?

It seems like a logical near term thing that we're going to have to do to reduce carbon emissions and other environmental damage. Mining and refining ores are both energy intensive and highly ecologicaly damaging.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:37PM (#47608581)
It isn't moving forward. It's an ill-conceived Apollo 1.5 with the MIC calling all the shots and a lander that is MIA. China is doing Apollo 2.0 which is fine considering this is their first attempt. The US needs a modular launch system with orbital booster tugs that can be mixed in various combinations for different mission profiles. One big booster with all of the risk stacked onto billion dollar launches is not the future we should be working toward.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:41PM (#47608613)
> US needs a modular launch system with orbital booster tugs that can be mixed in various combinations for different mission profiles

This is what the propellant depot is building towards.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by dylan604 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:00PM (#47608755)
> in-obit propellant transfer

I'm hoping they can do it in-orbit. We've had enough NASA obits

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:10PM (#47608816)
Hehe. Obits to be avoided in obisular orbits.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by MattGrommes on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:13PM (#47608390)
It's silly to say there's no innovation here. These aren't legos that you just snap together. I'm sure there are innovations up and down the whole thing, using the old technology they have easily available to them.

No, it's not the most modern Rocket Lab or SpaceX project but they have immense drag on their process that those companies don't have and they still got the dang thing up and headed toward the moon.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:13PM (#47608844)
That old technology wasn't remotely "easy" and the reason the top minds aren't going to NASA is because nobody wants to work on tech selected for maximum pork.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by GaryBluto on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:09PM (#47608355)
It's not about the Orion unit specifically but the fact that this is happening in the first place. This is simply a precursor to future missions and the construction of the Artemis Base Camp.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by NetMageSCW on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:17PM (#47608431)
I believe the fourth is actually built from left over STS engine parts and they haven’t gotten to the clones yet.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by general_reveal on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:14PM (#47608400)
So, are you suggesting we should not misunderstand “just business” as “glorious human achievement”?
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by feyman_r on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:37PM (#47608590)
Its true that innovation isn't clearly shown in this mission; we also haven't flown humans out that far in more than 50 years either and while we have memories of it, our ability to even execute something like this must be built again. I'd rather see us doing this and 'pick up from where we were last time', than giving up on it or just using a stack that's not currently set to do this.

What Artemis is doing is not impeding innovation: its building our muscle back to work on such things; the discipline, rigor, scale, and attitude needed to execute such missions is unimaginable and orthogonal to the technical innovation and stack used. I also believe that its completely fine to use a 2000s-era flight computer, if that suffices for this purpose. Somehow, for such critical missions, my mental model is to use at least 10 year old technology that has stood the test of time, before going into space. If there's a need for the latest technology - then yes, it should be leveraged.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by m4rtink on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:43PM (#47608621)
Not impending innovation is IMHO debatable - Artemis has definitely potential to motivate a lot of lay population & young people to go do space stuff and tech in general.

On the other hand SLS and Orion have gobbled insane amount of money that could have been invested to other science missions or even more efficient human space flight.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:52PM (#47608693)
> our ability to even execute something like this must be built again

Why? Because "dreams"? "Reach for the stars"?

You know what I remember from the shuttle launches as a kid? I remember my school not being able to afford textbooks but apparently we had enough to spend billions on putting people in space for no reason.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by teepo on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:52PM (#47609114)
I really resonate with this. I remember watching Comic Relief with Whoopie Goldberg as a kid, the whole show focused on homelessness in America, andshe said somthing like "why are we spending billions launching shuttles when people are sleeping on the streets?" That hit me hard. Especially because I was also the kid who was obsessed with space. It felt like a contradiction I couldn't square - I wasn't homeless, I think my school had books, but who remembers...

What shifted my thinking over tim was the actual numbers. NASA's entire budget during the shuttle era was roughly 1% of federal spending [1]. We chose to de-institutionalize heathcare which really impacted homelessness. We didn't have to, but it was choice. And we could of done both. The failure was our leaders choosing not to, and that choice had nothing to do with NASA.

And the shuttle era, for all its problems, gave us Hubble. That single telescope showed us the universe is 13.8 billion years old, that expansion is accelerating, that nearly every galaxy has a supermassive black hole at its center. The shuttle crews serviced it five times to keep it running. I think it's hard to overstate what that one instrument did for our understanding of the universe.

I don't think the instinct you had as a kid was wrong at all! - And thanks for helping me re-activate some neurons- Whoopi made a real impession on me came from a real place. But I think we're lucky enough to live in a world where people fight to fix things on the ground and also point telescopes at the sky.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by WaterRun on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:19PM (#47608888)
Developing something like this would push the frontiers of human technology. Without the Apollo program, not to mention anything else, the personal computer boom in the 1970s might have been delayed by a long time.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by krapp on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:27PM (#47608938)
We're redoing things we did before most people in this thread were even born, how would any of this "push the frontiers of human technology?"
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by WaterRun on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:36PM (#47609010)
The Space Shuttle’s technology is indeed quite old, but by today’s standards it is not exactly outdated. What matters is that we have lost the ability to carry out that technology — or even the ability to organize and coordinate a project like that. Otherwise, the price of the SLS as an “off-the-shelf product” would not be so outrageous, and it would not keep getting delayed again and again. Technology gets forgotten and capability is lost as people and suppliers disappear. The fact that we could build the Saturn V half a century ago does not mean we could still build it today; even the fact that we could build the F-22 twenty years ago does not mean we could still produce it now once the production lines are gone. Restoring that capability is always a good thing, considering the indirect effects.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by mulmen on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:31PM (#47608976)
Because we have gone backwards so any advancement requires some repetition.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by p-e-w on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:43PM (#47609061)
Strange that SpaceX doesn’t seem to be suffering from that limitation. Could it be that the real problem is pork barrel spending and government wastefulness?
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Larrikin on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @11:30PM (#47609663)
Which mission went to the moon?
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by p-e-w on Thursday April 02, 2026 @01:17AM (#47610250)
Why would they go to the moon? They’re far too busy doing things that actually matter, such as slashing launch costs by 80% or more, while achieving the highest reliability of any launch system ever.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Larrikin on Thursday April 02, 2026 @11:25AM (#47615738)
So a bunch of things every other space program does.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by mulmen on Thursday April 02, 2026 @04:48AM (#47611719)
What are you talking about? SLS is on the way to the Moon now. Starship is still in development. SpaceX only exists because of massive NASA subsidy. Any success from SpaceX is thanks to NASA.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by NetMageSCW on Thursday April 02, 2026 @11:15AM (#47615588)
NASA provided SpaceX some money as a startup to bet they could just start commercial space, and they won to the tune of saving millions of dollars. There was never massive subsidies and there isn’t any subsidies at all today.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by mulmen on Thursday April 02, 2026 @03:13PM (#47618871)
This is a lie. SpaceX has received at least 3.5 billion dollars from NASA for contracts. You can claim these aren’t subsidies but they are direct funding that allowed SpaceX to build up revenue streams like Starlink using the launch vehicles paid for by NASA. It’s the exact same funding model that Boeing takes advantage of. SpaceX would not exist without NASA. They’re collaborators, not competitors.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by dirasieb on Thursday April 02, 2026 @12:23AM (#47609957)
>We're redoing things we did before most people in this thread were even born

oh really? show me a picture of the dark side of the moon then

not a reconstruction, not touched up crap based on data like that black hole pic that went viral a few years ago, an actual photograph taken by an astronaut of the dark side of the moon

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by krapp on Thursday April 02, 2026 @06:30AM (#47612470)
The first orbit of the moon by a manned spacecraft was Apollo 8 in 1968.

The first photos of the dark side of the moon were taken by the Soviet Luna-3 probe in 1959.

Nothing being done here is revolutionary.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by esnyder9 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @10:11PM (#47609222)
If we're going to be idealists and say that the money that'd come out of space exploration would go into education, there is an awful lot more money being spent on the business of killing people that you could also say should go elsewhere.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by twoodfin on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:46PM (#47609079)
Have you looked at US per pupil K-12 spending growth & absolute comparisons vs. peer nations?

The problem with US public schools is not funding.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by nirav72 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:59PM (#47608749)
Do you honestly believe that by repurposing money from missions like these would suddenly free up money for text books? That’s not how it works. Especially not in 2026.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by heavyset_go on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:06PM (#47608797)
I don't see them insinuating that, just that it certainly raises a question about what we value and how we allocate resources.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by idiotsecant on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:26PM (#47608935)
I guess probably we should stop spaceflight until we can go back in time and buy you a textbook.

Spaceflight is cool. Its a awesome thing that people can exist outside our gravitational well. We don't need to solve every possible problem before we do anything cool.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by p-e-w on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:38PM (#47609028)
Almost all of what makes spaceflight “cool” today is inherited excitement and nostalgia, most of it unearned by the current generation of space endeavors.

Apollo was a humanity-defining undertaking. Repeating the same 60 years later with outdated technology at outrageous costs for pork barrel spending, while far superior launch systems have been available for a decade, is about as far away from being “cool” as I can imagine.

The average ESA environmental observation satellite is a lot cooler (and a lot more important) than this launch.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by m4rtink on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:38PM (#47608599)
IIRC there are some hydrogen powered APUs on the SLS core stage, replacing the Hydrazine powered ones used on Shuttle (both on orbiter & SRBs). The solar panel control on the Orion also seems coo and useful, not to mention having cameras on the arrays for self-inspections.

I am sure there are more subtle innovations like this that would hopefully be useful on more sensible rockets and space vehicles in the future. :)

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by titzer on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:44PM (#47608627)
It's in orbit. I for one love the fact they recycled some well-designed engines and made this mission a success (so far).
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by longislandguido on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:46PM (#47608649)
We'll be sure to give you a ring when the Moon base needs food delivery apps in the year 2347.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by Keyframe on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:48PM (#47608657)
This read like one of those "I could've done this in a weekend" replies to app launches.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by dylan604 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @08:59PM (#47608750)
While that might be true, it is on course to the moon now. Starship hasn't really done anything close. So while cheaper might be on the way, it doesn't exist now. When Starship can do now, we can talk about if the Shuttle Leftover System is ready to be retired
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by WaterRun on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:21PM (#47608898)
Starship is not designed for high-orbit deep-space missions; it is more like a cargo truck for low Earth orbit.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by dylan604 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:36PM (#47609006)
Fine, but you're dodging the actual point here I think
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by mulmen on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:41PM (#47609048)
So you agree that SLS provides useful functionality and that Musk lied about Starship being a Mars bus.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by NetMageSCW on Thursday April 02, 2026 @11:19AM (#47615646)
That’s incorrect — it is both. That’s why orbital refueling is so important to Starship’s future.
Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:03PM (#47608772)
The Artemis was a pork barrel project to feed federal tax money to all the states that had huge space shuttle contracts.

That and NASA is pathologically terrified of anything resembling innovation.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by neya on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:23PM (#47608908)
Yeah, fuck the engineers who worked full time and ran many simulations tirelessly and worked out the best stack for this mission, right?

Most of the combustion engines in your car are still from designs late 60s - 80s (Eg. Renault). Does that mean it's a travesty too?

Let me guess, a bunch of dudes sitting in SF in a garage could have made a better rocket that runs on ReactJS, right? Because NASA BAD.

Give me a break.

Re:Artemis II lifts off: four astronauts begin 10-day lunar ... by hsuduebc2 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @09:39PM (#47609038)
Well what are they suppose to do other than continue where they left it? As far I understand purpose of Artemis mission it is to build a pernamently occupied base on the moon not to build better and better rockets now. I mean, it's not the best solution but it is proven to work and they perceive it as enough for now. I think it's very similar to some critical systems still running code written in cobol sixty years ago.