News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @05:12PM (#47418395)
So which situation do you want instead of anonymous age verification:

A) 18+ content is behind a pinky swear

B) 18+ content is behind a parental control (what this bill would do)

C) The internet can't have 18+ content anymore

D) Some other system? Please describe it.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by gspetr on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:07PM (#47419004)
A), which is the status quo. I don't see any other option as realistic.

B) makes things worse in several ways, but primarily by stifling innovation. Only large incumbents will have no trouble paying for the measures required to ensure compliance.

There's also the cost of enforcement, which will likely have to be borne by the taxpayers. I don't think this is a good thing to spend money on.

C) cannot be enforced, and any good faith attempts will cost more than the damage from harm they're supposed to prevent.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:12PM (#47419069)
Option A isn't really the status quo. The status quo has a bunch of sites doing invasive checks and other sites region blocking users.

> Only large incumbents will have no trouble paying for the measures required to ensure compliance.

Oh my gawwwwwd. People trot this out any time any regulation is mentioned. Option B is a single easily accessible age category value. It's simpler than the status quo.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by fn-mote on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:32PM (#47419254)
> Option B is […] simpler than the status quo.

This bill FORBIDS platforms from operating in the state unless they provide age verification.

Forbid an OS for operating in Illinois? Sounds insane to me. When I bring my Linux laptop from California, what happens?

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:36PM (#47419300)
I'm not really focused on the exact wording of this bill. But mandating distros have a useradd and glibc with an extra couple functions is not a significant burden.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:28PM (#47420240)
So... a pinky swear then, right?

I mean, how is the OS going to actually verify the age of the operator?

I see how this helps Facebook - if you lie to the OS, and the OS tells Facebook that you're over 18, then it's not Facebook's fault if they provide you an 18+ service.

I don't see how this helps anyone else.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:32PM (#47420263)
It's set by the administrator of the computer, so a parent can set it for their child instead of hoping their child is honest to every single individual site.

That's the difference between a parental control and a pinky swear.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by cesarb on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:49PM (#47420368)
> It's set by the administrator of the computer, so a parent can set it for their child instead of hoping their child is honest to every single individual site.

You are assuming the parent is the administrator of the computer.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:51PM (#47420383)
I am not assuming that. That's why it's a "can". Parental controls are always "can".
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:53PM (#47420749)
The thing we want (well, that other people want, I have other views) is that large tech companies are not able to brainwash kids.

The thing this creates is liability on parents, or schools, or anyone who provides computer access to children. And access to PII for bad guys (who can ask your computer for your date of birth in this proposal, right?)

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @10:22PM (#47420918)
> The thing we want (well, that other people want, I have other views) is that large tech companies are not able to brainwash kids.

That has little connection with this law.

And having no age settings at all is where you'll have the most brainwashing.

> The thing this creates is liability on parents, or schools, or anyone who provides computer access to children. And access to PII for bad guys (who can ask your computer for your date of birth in this proposal, right?)

They're already responsible for controlling that. I think they should have more tools to help.

> And access to PII for bad guys (who can ask your computer for your date of birth in this proposal, right?)

Did you look at the law(s)? They get one of four age ranges.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by nickitolas on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:46PM (#47420354)
I have no experience with minors using Linux. Do they not typically have sudo access?
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by mittensc on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @02:21AM (#47422153)
so the kid boots linux off a usb stick and makes this pointless
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by sgarland on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @08:41AM (#47425027)
I hope the number of downvotes you’re receiving makes you consider the absurdity of your suggestion.

Have you seen distrowatch? Are you going to go track down maintainers from every distro - many of whom live outside of the U.S. - and demand they implement this? The smaller ones would probably ignore you or tell you to get fucked, the larger ones with funding might decide to drag you into court.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by ekidd on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @05:42PM (#47418719)
(A), honestly.

You might think you can keep 16 year olds from looking at porn, if they want to. You can't. You have never been able to. All you can do is teach them that the law is stupid and pointless, and they should treat rules with contempt. But they'll still be able to look at porn.

What you can do is allow the government and private companies to track everyone, everywhere, all the time. And you can create more gatekeepers that hold personal identity data, misuse it, and leak it.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:08PM (#47419012)
I'm not overly concerned with 16 year olds. But the tools for protecting younger children suck. A consistent account setting and header would do a lot to improve parental controls.

> What you can do is allow the government and private companies to track everyone, everywhere, all the time. And you can create more gatekeepers that hold personal identity data, misuse it, and leak it.

This is already happening. A central setting would improve privacy over the way things are right now.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:33PM (#47420268)
> A central setting would improve privacy over the way things are right now.

What? How? What improvement are you seeing that I'm not?

Putting all our PII into one huge repository and then letting corps and govts access it sounds like a dystopian nightmare. This is why we don't like Palantir.

What happens if a bad guy steals that data and your identity? They go and look at CSAM using your ID? The police turn up at your door and cart you off to prison? Are you really going to be able to argue that it wasn't you? If so, what is the point of the system? If we're relying on IP addresses and other evidence for access (so you can fight these charges) can't we just use them in the first place?

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:46PM (#47420349)
I don't know what you're talking about, but it's not what this kind of bill is about.

This kind of bill is about the OS telling things whether you're: 0-12, 13-15, 16-17, 18+

No databases, no stealable identity, only the barest sliver of 2 bits of PII.

As for how it's an improvement, we already have sites asking to see your driver's license or pictures of your face for much worse age verification paradigms. If most of those changed to a local age setting, privacy would go up.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:55PM (#47420758)
How does the OS know that you moved from the "13-15" bracket to the "16-17" bracket without knowing your DoB?

And this is the thin edge. Because in a few years there'll be a bill saying something like "too many children are lying about their age online. We need to verify their age" and then we're capturing IDs and storing them somewhere.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @10:18PM (#47420900)
> How does the OS know that you moved from the "13-15" bracket to the "16-17" bracket without knowing your DoB?

The OS has the birth date. Of probably 1-5 people.

> And this is the thin edge. Because in a few years there'll be a bill saying something like "too many children are lying about their age online. We need to verify their age" and then we're capturing IDs and storing them somewhere.

Those things are already happening. I see this kind of mechanism as significantly more of an alternative to privacy invasion than an enabler of privacy invasion.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @11:09PM (#47421207)
Requiring the central database is the scary part.

The political establishment used to be able to control what you read, through control of the media. Then 1995 happened and everyone got access to anything they wanted. The establishment have wanted to put that genie back in the bottle ever since. This is part of that effort.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @11:28PM (#47421317)
> Requiring the central database is the scary part.

Yes, agreed.

And this type of proposal has no central database, so it removes the scary part.

(Unless you're talking about the local accounts on each computer storing dates of birth for a single household as a "central database" in which case you're being ridiculous and please stop doing that.)

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by ThatPlayer on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @01:56AM (#47422009)
> How does the OS know that you moved from the "13-15" bracket to the "16-17" bracket without knowing your DoB?

No one says it has to be automatic. The OS could require the parent to manually update it.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by mittensc on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @02:19AM (#47422138)
So the kid boots up linux off a USB stick and makes it all pointless
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by watwut on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @06:44AM (#47423939)
Overwhelming majority of kids wont. The idea that the average teenager even knows what those words mean is not realistic.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by ChoGGi on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:42AM (#47425724)
They may not, but the friend selling porn sticks at school does.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @07:51PM (#47432856)
Heard exactly the same thing about VPN use (kids won't know how to set up a VPN). Then Australia age verification kicked in, and VPN use went through the roof [0]

And, of course, the response so far has included similar thoughts as the UK about banning VPNs [1]

[0] https://www.rmit.edu.au/news/media-releases-and-expert-comme...

[1] https://www.techradar.com/vpn/vpn-privacy-security/no-approa...

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by mittensc on Friday March 20, 2026 @06:11AM (#47452594)
kids would have time and motivation... they will learn pretty fast
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by godelski on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @11:28PM (#47434546)

  > The OS could require the parent to manually update it.
How is their age verified?

At some point one of two things is required:

  1) A promise that the user is a certain age
    - Which puts us exactly where we are
  2) Official identification is used to verify age
    - Which creates a PII nightmare
That's it. There's only those two options. You may not believe #2 is going to be a privacy nightmare but we're already seeing it happen with Discord/OpenAI/LinkedIn and everyone else that uses Persona[1]. They aren't doing the minimal security things and already aren't doing what they claimed (processed on device, then deleted). This "hack" couldn't happen if that was true

[0] https://cybernews.com/privacy/persona-leak-exposes-global-su...

[1] https://withpersona.com/customers

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by ThatPlayer on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @11:39PM (#47434630)
> Which puts us exactly where we are

The difference here is it can be set by the parent on the OS and locked. Requiring sudo equivalent to change.

The way it is now, there's nothing stopping a (18-) user from logging out of a 'parental control enabled' account and making a new account without those controls on any service from Facebook to Steam. So the only effective option at that point is to entirely block that app or service.

This gives more power to parental control software. And yeah moves the responsibility from the service to the parents, which is what the services want cuz COPPA and other similar laws.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by godelski on Thursday March 19, 2026 @12:24AM (#47434914)
That doesn't change anything I said.

But you do bring up another issue people aren't discussing. That the default setting is under 18.

So we protect the children from adults by... having no way to actually verify someone is a child?

The problem is less kids getting access to porn and more pedos getting accounts to spaces designed for children. Places like Club Penguin or very famously Roblox.

Here's the problem, you can't verify children. They don't have identification in the same way adults do. And worse, if we gave them that then it only makes them more vulnerable!

Then we have the whole problem of a global internet. VPN usage is already skyrocketing to circumvent these policies.

So the only real "solution" to this is global identification systems where essentially everyone is carrying around some dystopian FIDO key (definitely your phone) that has all your personal information on it and you sign every device you touch. Because everything from your fridge to your car is connected to the Internet.

But that's a cure worse than the poison. I mean what the fuck happens to IOT devices? Do we just not allow them on the internet? That they're assumed 18+? So all kids need to do is get a raspberry pi? All they need to do is install a VM on their phone? On their computer? You might think that kids won't do this but when I was in high school 20 years ago we all knew how to set up proxies. That information spread like wildfire and you bet it got easier as the smarter kids put in the legwork.

This is a losing battle. It's not a cat and mouse game it's While E Coyote vs Road Runner.

We're on HN FFS. If there's anywhere on the Internet that the average user is going to understand how impossible this is it should be here. We haven't even talked about hacking! And yes, teenage script kiddies do exist.

These policies don't protect kids, they endanger them. On top of that they endanger the rest of us. Seriously, just try to work it out. Try to create a solution and then actually try to defeat your solution. Don't be fucking Don Quixote.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 19, 2026 @02:55AM (#47435826)
> But you do bring up another issue people aren't discussing. That the default setting is under 18.

Some things do that. This law doesn't have a default. If the admin sets all the user accounts to 18+, then the users are stuck with the setting being 18+.

> I mean what the fuck happens to IOT devices? Do we just not allow them on the internet?

Sounds pretty good to me.

But yeah they need a different handling of some manner. Maybe a "give no access to anything age-gated" category, though is that really different from under-13 in practice?

> So all kids need to do is get a raspberry pi? All they need to do is install a VM on their phone? On their computer? You might think that kids won't do this but when I was in high school 20 years ago we all knew how to set up proxies.

Just delaying unrestricted access to high school would already solve most of the problem.

> These policies don't protect kids, they endanger them. On top of that they endanger the rest of us.

They do not. Some totally different system could endanger people, but this one doesn't.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by godelski on Thursday March 19, 2026 @06:52PM (#47447524)

  > Some things do that.
I think you're missing the point...

  > Sounds pretty good to me
Really? Be a bit more serious now. There are a lot of things that connect to the internet, and not just for stupid data harvesting reasons. I gave other examples. I think you can understand that this gets pretty hairy pretty quickly. If you don't, then dig in deeper to how the networking is done. You're an older account so I'm assuming you actually understand computers.

  > They do not.
They definitely do. I explicitly stated how that happens too. If you want me to take you seriously you have to respond with something better than "trust me bro".

There is no evidence that these companies are actually handling that data properly. There is a lot of evidence that they are handling it improperly. That data being leaked does in fact, endanger kids.

I'm also unconvinced these things even achieve the goals they claim to be after. Which is keeping pedos away from kids. i.e. the reason I said you're missing the point. So either it is not achieving that goal, or lulling people into a false sense of security. Imagine if Roblox was saying "we don't allow adults on the platform" and so now all the tech illiterate parents and kids think their kids are exclusively talking to other kids. That's just a worse situation than now.

So what do these laws even solve?! I'm serious

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 19, 2026 @07:07PM (#47447683)
> Be a bit more serious now.

The serious answer is in the next line.

> They definitely do. I explicitly stated how that happens too. [...] data being leaked

Again "Some totally different system could endanger people, but this one doesn't."

Any system that has companies handling personal data and able to leak it is not the system this kind of law talks about.

> false sense of security. Imagine if Roblox was saying

In that situation, Roblox is the problem, not the law.

> So what do these laws even solve?! I'm serious

If widely implemented, a parent can set a single toggle and then the accounts their kids make will all be appropriately restricted.

It wouldn't replace direct checks from the parent on what their kids are doing, but it would greatly reduce the risk profile. And making it simple and built-in means that non-tech-expert parents can set it.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by godelski on Friday March 20, 2026 @01:53AM (#47450979)

  >> Be a bit more serious now.

  > The serious answer is in the next line.
  > ...
  > Again "Some totally different system could endanger people, but this one doesn't."

  >> If you want me to take you seriously you have to respond with something better than "trust me bro".
I do have a hard time taking you seriously

  > If widely implemented, a parent can set a single toggle and then the accounts their kids make will all be appropriately restricted.
HOW
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 21, 2026 @02:34AM (#47464532)
> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47434546

Up here you wrote two options.

People keep telling you option 1 is the correct one, and that it's not actually useless.

You keep describing privacy problems that only exist with option 2.

This law is not option 2. Stop interpreting people as if they're badly defending option 2. They're not.

> HOW

They take an OS where only admins can change the age setting. They set the age on a non-admin account, which they give their child access to. The OS passes the age setting along to programs, which pass it along to services that need to restrict behavior.

This is not the same as how it works today. It's impossible for a parent to do this today. The best they can do is try to keep track of every account their child has and dig through the settings manually.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Spartan-S63 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @05:52PM (#47418844)
Yeah, I agree with this. I think age-related content moderation is a losing fight and one that will create more contempt for laws, more surveillance, and much more PII surface area that will be exploited.

There are really two "core" issues at play:

1. The prudish nature of US society

2. The fact that we don't have data privacy laws and restrictions on digital surveillance by private companies

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by genthree on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @04:11PM (#47430821)
Sixteen year olds? Sure, mysterious Forest Porn and the older brother who'd give you skin mags have always existed. And Cinemax at night, catching the odd frame that somehow gets thought the scrambler. Whatever.

But we can't realize all the supposed glorious promise of all this tech bullcrap for education and free exploration of younger kids if we can't at least come pretty damn close to guaranteeing that an eight-year-old won't stumble on Rotten.com or hardcore porn if an adult isn't looking over their shoulder constantly. And whatever that solution is needs to work for parents who don't have the know-how or time to be sysadmins for their household.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by rythmshifter on Thursday March 19, 2026 @12:40AM (#47435026)
I’m still trying to figure out why mysterious forest porn was a thing. I definitely encountered it.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by roenxi on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @05:24PM (#47418530)
Does "the government doesn't get to decide what people can look at on the internet" count as C or D to you? It is the situation we've been in technically for 20 years now anyway; the world hasn't ended and it generally seems to be pretty workable. The status quo isn't an especially radical one.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by fcarraldo on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:35PM (#47420278)
20 years ago was only 2006. The internet has been around for much longer. The first consumer focused ISPs launched in the early 90’s, 35 years ago, but CompuServe and others were providing access to chat and BBS’s in the 80s.

I’d say nearly 50 years is precedent enough that government intervention is unnecessary.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by roenxi on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @02:11AM (#47422090)
Yeah but most people weren't on the internet access in the early 90s. It is more a 2005+ phenomenon.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Internet_usage

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by PostOnce on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:20PM (#47419151)
What about every other system where we rely on parents to parent?

Kids can turn apple juice into wine in their closet

they can drive their bicycle to a drug dealer

they can rub a butter knife against the sidewalk until it's pointy

Do we need govt AI cameras in kids closets and on their bicycles? How do we verify they're cycling somewhere safe? How do we make sure they're not getting shitfaced on bootleg hooch they made with bakers yeast and a latex glove?

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:43PM (#47419375)
This is more like a store being able to see their age just by looking at them, and make restrictions because of that. We don't rely on parents to prevent a 10 year old from going into a bar.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by card_zero on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @06:49AM (#47423979)
Which, unlike this, does not create issues, since the bar is a place staffed by people, employed to serve drinks, who can reasonably be required to look at their customers, while an operating system is some software, perhaps written by an enthusiast, which cannot reasonably be required to inspect its users.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by 2postsperday on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:10PM (#47420103)
If you asked the average parent, they'd probably be on board with adding cameras to their closets and adding tracking and cameras to bikes, allyways and sidewalks.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by matheusmoreira on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @07:00PM (#47419536)
D) Parents take sole responsibility for this.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by array_key_first on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @07:58PM (#47420019)
C and D, combined. New internet for kids-only. This internet would be WHITELIST only. We would not be wack-a-mole trying to catch porn sites (sigh...)

Rather, companies would have to submit a formal proposal to get their website listed on Kid Internet. This inverts the responsibility. It's not my cost, or your cost, it's their cost now. If they want kids, they better prove it.

Then, you can trivially configure your router or any computer, with any operating system, to use the Kid Internet DNS. It's now completely operating system and device agnostic. It can be organizational wide with the flick of a switch. It can be global, if we want.

The proposal we're seeing here is bad, bad, bad. Not just for privacy reasons, but because it will not work. Not might, will. This will not work. For many reasons:

1. Most operating systems are not going to implement some stupid ass bullshit.

2. Most websites do not give a single fuck. Porn websites will not care. Trying to play wack-a-mole is ALWAYS a losing game, no exceptions.

3. This is trivial to bypass.

4. If it's not trivial to bypass, it still will not work, but it will now be the end of computing as we know it.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:56PM (#47420410)
So we have some kind of control to stop your router from connecting to Adult Internet DNS? Because the difficult bit here is not allowing connections to the Kid Internet, but stopping connections to the Adult Internet.

How do we decide what sites resolve as part of the Kid Internet? Is there some process where a site submits itself for approval to be part of the Adult Internet?

How do we stop the government from using this to stop access to parts of the internet it doesn't like?

This proposal looks even less workable

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by array_key_first on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:04PM (#47420454)
> So we have some kind of control to stop your router from connecting to Adult Internet DNS?

Yes, all routers currently have this built-in. Most software outside of routers does, too.

Will it be perfect? No. But, for example, this is how content filters work at schools and just about every workplace. And it seems to be good enough for them.

And, this will work better than that. Because the key point is we're not blacklisting anything. Nobody has to maintain a list of banned websites.

> How do we decide what sites resolve as part of the Kid Internet?

Companies or people send an application. The website is reviewed by a human, and they get approved or denied. If you don't care to target kids, which most people don't, you do nothing.

So I don't have to do anything, nor do you. But Meta does. Google does. I'm fine with that.

And, this "board" or whatever who hands out Kid-Friendly certificates can also take complaints. Why not?

> Is there some process where a site submits itself for approval to be part of the Adult Internet?

No, this it the beauty of it. If you want to be a part of adult internet, you do nothing. You already are.

Every website is implicitly adult internet, and it naturally completely subsumes kid internet. So, if you're just making a blog or whatever, nothing changes. In fact, you don't have to update anything from right now. It will all still work. Because Kid Internet is new thing, and it's whitelist only.

> How do we stop the government from using this to stop access to parts of the internet it doesn't like?

Related to above, adult internet is what we currently have. Nothing changes. You and I won't notice, and we can't notice. There will be the free-range internet, and then the subset of the internet approved for kids.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by MidnightRider39 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:16PM (#47420534)
> content filters work at schools

Maybe they are vastly more sophisticated now but when I was a kid it was a sport for us to break these filters - and pretty easy too

It would imo be much easier to effect a culture change so that not every kid needs or gets access to the internet or internet capable devices.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by array_key_first on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:22PM (#47420577)
Yes, they are more sophisticated, or at least I'm assuming from how pi-hole and my workplace blocking works. Meaning, it works.

But those are not the best solutions, because of blacklisting. There are basically infinite porn websites. So, if you're going to try to block every porn website, you will lose, point blank.

So, even considering that, they do quite good. So if we just take the principle and invert it, it will be very good.

I mean, whitelisting vs blacklisting is why I am able to open my computer up to the internet via SSH. I'm not out here blocking 1 billion sites. No, I'm just allowing my laptop. And that gives me a lot of confidence, and it works.

And, I agree with culture change. But, culture change is very hard and I don't think it's something we can rely on.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:59PM (#47420789)
So, you whitelist Kid Internet sites, and you have a DNS server that handles Kid Internet.

And everything else is Adult Internet, and there are many DNS servers that serve Adult Internet.

You sign your household router up for Kid Internet, and it ignores Adult DNS servers, and only routes according to Kid DNS, is that right?

I can think of about 50 ways around this already, but let's assume we're not talking about anyone with any knowledge of how the internet works. So the entire household is signed up for Kid Internet, and there's no way an adult can view an Adult Internet site from this household, is that right?

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by array_key_first on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @10:20PM (#47420910)
Well most DNS can be done per-device, just like in an IT setting. For example look at iOS. The device controls DNS, so set up little Timmy's iPhone to do Kid DNS.

That sounds an awful lot like this proposal, right? Well yes and no. No because this would actually work. Just letting the iPhone say "im a kid" does fuck all, because all the websites we're targeting with that will just ignore it.

And of course there are ways around this. Wanting a solution with no ways around it is dystopian. But is it a better solution than this? I think yes, it is.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by marcus_holmes on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @11:06PM (#47421195)
So we're locking a per-user DNS choice in?

If Little Timmy signs in then OS chooses the Kids DNS, but if Uncle Bob signs in then it chooses the Adult DNS?

As you say, I can see a few ways around this ;)

Again, this feels like it just moves the responsibility for everything onto the parents, without meaningfully giving them any control. If something screws up and Little Timmy gets to see some boobies, who gets blamed? Is it the OS provider, the hardware provider, or the parents? Did the parents actually configure this themselves? If so, who taught them how to do that? Or did they buy the machine pre-configured? So does the vendor take responsibility?

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by array_key_first on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @08:14PM (#47433052)
> So we're locking a per-user DNS choice in?

Sure, or per-device, or per-network, or per-organization. It depends on how each particular person wants to implement it.

> As you say, I can see a few ways around this ;)

Yes, notably less than the current proposal. Which, again, will just straight-up not work.

> f something screws up and Little Timmy gets to see some boobies, who gets blamed?

I think this really hit the nail on the head. None of this is about solving problems or helping little Timmy. It's about accountability management.

If we implement the OS syscall, then Meta gets to point their grimey finger at someone else while they continue to fuel genocide in Myanmar.

> Did the parents actually configure this themselves? If so, who taught them how to do that? Or did they buy the machine pre-configured? So does the vendor take responsibility?

Well, um, both. You can configure your router, sure, or your Linux computer. But I imagine a new iPhone would just come with a checkbox you can check at account creation time. Again, very similar to this proposal, except it works.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by davidhyde on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:24PM (#47419190)
D) Parenting
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:46PM (#47419397)
I think parents should have access to easy to operate parental controls to help them do their parenting.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by newdee on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:23PM (#47420200)
Yes, parental controls already exist. You’re up and down this thread advocating for this particular bill, but what does the technical solution actually look like to you beyond the controls already available? And with regards to account creation specifically, what do you see as a workable solution that isn’t defeated by a “pinky swear”?
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:41PM (#47420320)
Can you name a piece of parental control software that tells relevant apps and sites whether I'm above 13/18?

I'm sure there's plenty of software that can block sites entirely, but that's a lot less useful.

And how much should I trust the popular products on a scale of 1-10? An OS setting doesn't need much trust.

> And with regards to account creation specifically, what do you see as a workable solution that isn’t defeated by a “pinky swear”?

I'll copy a different reply: "It's set by the administrator of the computer, so a parent can set it for their child instead of hoping their child is honest to every single individual site. That's the difference between a parental control and a pinky swear."

The idea of something like this isn't to replace parents, it's to give them a simple centralized tool. The parent has the admin account.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by SecretDreams on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @07:14PM (#47419638)
Is D) parenting what they do for cigarettes in stores today as well?
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by panny on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @07:11PM (#47419616)
The Illinois bill is not about 18+ content. It's about controlling who your children can talk to on social media. The OS age check is just a means to that end. The end is blatantly unconstitutional. The bill of rights doesn't mention age limits. Freedom of assosiation applies to kids just as much as it does to adults. If the bill passes, then any racist parent could block all comms from kids of a different color for example.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by nazzzi on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:01PM (#47420437)
To be fair, as a parent I don’t want my under age children hooking up with literal nazis on social platforms, whoever that might be. The current tools and controls are lacking. A lot.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by true_religion on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @04:29PM (#47431021)
I get what you’re saying but it’s a false premise. In today’s era, racist parents already block their children from even attending school with someone of a different color. Merely blocking comms would be a step before that in severity of control.

Parents have always had the ability (though maybe not explicitly the right to) control their children’s environment for the purposes of teaching personal beliefs. So long as the belief itself wasn’t deemed harmful to the child, society would allow it to continue propagate that way. Racism unfortunately has never been seen as innately harmful. It’s looked down on, yes, but not to the point of making it illegal to enforce in family life.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by cucumber3732842 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:20PM (#47420174)
>A) 18+ content is behind a pinky swear

Things were way, way, way sketchier in like 2005 than they are now and those people turned out mostly fine.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by kristopolous on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:28PM (#47420241)
Every system intended to protect children ends up patronizing everyone as a child.

Protect people's rights and don't get tricked in to giving them up just cause someone has a story about a child.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by carefulfungi on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:45PM (#47420342)
E. Platforms that want to serve violent, sexual, predatory, scammy, snake oil content in the most addictive way possible to exploit minors and other vulnerable populations for profit should save some of their revenue for lawsuits when they hurt people. Hold products that cause harm responsible.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by robocat on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:49PM (#47420373)
This can only work if the damages cost less than the business is worth.

And there's plenty of examples (J&J, oil titans) escaping financial consequences by other means.

Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by dmix on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:08PM (#47420480)
E) parenting
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by seany on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @11:34PM (#47421348)
A. Not even a thought required.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill by phendrenad2 on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @04:07AM (#47422954)
The spin control on this story is intense. Saying that it's "just parental controls" when we've had fscking parental controls since the 1990s is disingenuous as hell. Obviously it's something new, but that's really all they have got to try to spin it back into their favor.