News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by idiotsecant on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @03:09PM (#47238213)
It's socially acceptable to make white people jokes because white people on average enjoy an elevated position in western society. It's viewed as 'punching up'. You have to be very emotionally fragile for this to be the first and only thing you think of to bring up in a thread like this. It's also supremely uninteresting cable news talking point slop.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by SgtBastard on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @03:48PM (#47238756)
Friend, I bet those folks living rural West Virginia are super happy that, on average, a group whose only shared characteristics is the colour of their skin are enjoying an elevated position in western society. Super happy. All racism is gross.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by gammarator on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:10PM (#47239044)
Ever heard of people complaining about being pulled over for “driving while West Virginian”? Why or why not?
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by jbeam on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:11PM (#47239052)
I bet they are happy. It means ICE won't harass you.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by duskdozer on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:16AM (#47243797)
Contrary to non-white people, yes. Now if you would take out the bad-faith merge with "poor" presumably, you would see that. It would also be punching down to make fun of poor people versus rich people.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by I-M-S on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:32AM (#47245582)
I just asked ChatGPT to write 3 jokes making fun of poor people and it happily obliged:

1. Being broke is when your bank app sends you notifications like, “You good?” 2. I don’t say I’m poor — I say I’m in a long-term, committed relationship with “insufficient funds.” 3. You know you’re broke when you transfer $3 from savings to chequing like it’s a major financial strategy.

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by idiotsecant on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:12AM (#47257823)
Yes, white people in West Virginia enjoy an elevated social position over black people in West Virginia. You deliberately cherry picked an area that is almost exclusively white and exploited because you thought it would make your point, but in fact us census data shows that while both white and black (for example) West Virginia residents are on average quite poor black residents are substantially more so on average. Social position is based on more than just income, but it's a decent proxy.

But you knew that this was an example of a disadvantaged group already. ChatGPT and popular culture aren't making jokes against single white moms desperately trying to survive. They're making jokes about stereotypical white suburban culture. This is a distinct social and economic class

I reiterate: emotionally fragile snowflakes who can't stand that there is even a single aspect of life on earth in which their social group isn't 100% dominant. It's jokes dude. You'll be ok.

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by vel0city on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:01PM (#47238931)
> It's viewed as 'punching up'

Shouldn't we be building systems that don't punch anyone in racist ways? Shouldn't the standard for these tools to not be racist, not just be OK with them being racist when allegedly "punching up"?

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by sejje on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:06AM (#47249524)
Imagine this obviously noble idea getting downvoted.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by BJones12 on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:28PM (#47239292)
> You have to be very emotionally fragile for this to be the first and only thing you think of to bring up in a thread like this

No, I just don't like racism.

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by cpill on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:45PM (#47239489)
Try norther Ireland.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by ph4rsikal on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @05:31PM (#47240028)
Because these are our societies. We build them. If this door were to swing both ways, I would not have an issue. But it never does. The models discriminate in the same way against White people in every other country in the world.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by nozzlegear on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @05:58PM (#47240311)
I'd also posit that the jokes just aren't racist. Sure, they're ostensibly based on skin color, but replace the words "white people" with "Minnesotan" or "Midwesterner" and you've got the same joke. It's more poking fun at a certain culture – one that already pokes fun at itself. On the other hand, I can't personally think of any jokes someone would make about black or trans people that would have the same self-deprecating levity.

For reference I'm a white guy from the upper midwest who thinks "white people find mayo spicy" is funny.

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by latentsea on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @09:07PM (#47242087)
Don't make jokes about me, it's not ok.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by pantsforbirds on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @11:03PM (#47242908)
I don't care if we have that standard for people, but I think it's a VERY bad idea to bake into AI's any sort of demographic-based biases. Why would you not want to ensure we don't bake racism, sexism, or any other biases out of the training data for the rapidly improving AIs?
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by Orygin on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:17AM (#47245470)
It's impossible not to bake racism sexism and any other bias into AIs since they are trained on human input which is always biased in some way.

Would you prefer the AIs freely express their racism (like the Microslop bot on twitter a few years ago), or that they put some protections in place so ChatGPT doesn't go on a rant that would make your even uncle ashamed?

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by spiderice on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:37AM (#47243520)
Or, now hear me out, we don't be racist. Have you considered that?
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by Sabinus on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:50AM (#47243600)
At what point will white people be average enough as a group that it's no longer acceptable to make racist jokes about them?

Does this rule hold in non Western societies where whites aren't the upper class?

Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by duskdozer on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:19AM (#47243824)
Yes, it's about the specific society, it's just that most of these conversations happen in the context of the US. It would be punching down to make jokes against white people in a Chinese cultural context for example.
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by Razengan on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:13AM (#47245436)
Revenge mentality. F off with that shit
Re:GPT‑5.3 Instant by imtringued on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:57AM (#47259313)
This only works if you actually 'punch up' and lie about using skin color as the factor that you used to decide who to target. In other words, you're not racist, but you're pretending to be racist.

Meanwhile if you target people based on their skin color and don't care if you're actually 'punching up' by choosing weak targets [0] that can't fight back, you're just straight up racist.

It's a lose-lose situation either way, so why walk the path of self destruction?

[0] It takes 18 years to become an adult.