News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by rob74 on Monday March 02, 2026 @02:56AM (#47215041)
After I read the title, I fully expected this to be about writing games using AI. But no, actually there is no mention of AI to be found in the text, not even in the "Miscellaneous Thoughts" section, which seems to be mostly answers to "why don't you use X?" questions. Refreshing...
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by oneeyedpigeon on Monday March 02, 2026 @03:41AM (#47215348)
The author is Noel Berry, creator of Celeste. They don't shout about it, but with that pedigree, I'm confident they'll be staying well away from AI.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by Vespasian on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:16AM (#47215536)
Or they'll take a look at what, if anything at all,they can use in their workflow as a useful tool not a magic solution.

No need to brag about that.

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by dwroberts on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:34AM (#47215656)
> can use in their workflow as a useful tool not a magic solution.

Like what? If you can already program your game and create art for it, what is it going to be doing?

People are so obsessed with using AI stuff for the sake of it, it’s nuts

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by rhdunn on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:54AM (#47215833)
I don't use AI for the sake of it, I use it where and when it is useful. For example:

1. advanced autocomplete -- if you have or paste the structure of a JSON or other format, or a class fields, it is good at autocompleting things like serialization, case statements, or other repetitive/boilerplate code;

2. questions -- it can often be difficult to find an answer on Google/etc. (esp. if you don't know exactly what you are looking for, or if Google decides to ignore a key term such as the programming language), but can be better via an AI.

Like all tools, you need to read, check, and verify its output.

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bandrami on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:20AM (#47216030)
Genuine question re #1: does your text editor not already do that?
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by rhdunn on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:59AM (#47216371)
Text editors/IDEs have simple autocomplete and the ability to do some expansion, e.g. a for loop with placeholders to fill in. Those work and are still useful.

JetBrains also has local line-based LLM models for various languages.

With the LLM-based autocomplete it a) generally autocompletes more code at once, and b) will often pick up on patterns in the existing code. E.g. if you have a similar method, list of print/string buffer write statements, or other repetitive code in the file it will often use that as a model for the generated code.

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bandrami on Monday March 02, 2026 @06:19AM (#47216515)
That sure sounds like you're describing customizable snippets, which AFAIK every major editor supports?
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bubblewand on Monday March 02, 2026 @08:56AM (#47218004)
Sitting here on the sidelines having never configured snippets or macros or any of that in any of my editors, which I could have done like 30 years ago but never bothered in all this time, doing quizzical-dog look at all these people thrilled about LLMs.

I guess they might finally get me to use those things since they take the “configuring” and “remembering shortcuts” part out, but so much of this doesn’t look new at all. Super old, actually.

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by truetraveller on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:14PM (#47227530)
In my objective opinion, almost all AI uses cases (coding or otherwise), are just because of people's extreme laziness in spending a little time setting up some "automated" workflow, be it canned templates or whatever. The non-AI approach has the added benefit of being precise!
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by rhdunn on Monday March 02, 2026 @09:43AM (#47218569)
Customizable snipping is a feature editors support (which I mentioned as they are related/similar to what the AI is doing), but is different to the AI autocomplete behaviour.

If I have a JSON structure, I can paste that into the file as a comment, e.g.:

    # {"foo": 1, "bar": "test", "baz"}
    @dataclass
    class FooBar:
        foo:
and the AI will/can autocomplete/generate that to:

    @dataclass
    class FooBar:
        foo: int
        bar: str
        baz: int
using the JSON example. Then if you type:

        def __str__(self):
the AI could then contextually generate, e.g.:

    return f'Foo(foo={self.foo}, bar={self.bar}, baz={self.baz})'
Or if you have a SQLAlchemy model:

    class Foo(Base):
        __tablename__ = 'foos'

    bar_id: Mapped[int | None] = mapped_column(ForeignKey('bars.id'), default=None)
typing `bar:` the AI can autocomplete:

    bar: Mapped[Optional['Bar']] = relationship()
picking up that you have a `Bar` class in the file. Especially if you have other similar id/object definitions in the file.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bandrami on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:52AM (#47219539)
Right, it's a less-flexible paste macro you don't actually have control over. shrug
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by direwolf20 on Monday March 02, 2026 @09:44PM (#47227306)
It's a DWIM button.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by meheleventyone on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:20AM (#47219082)
The JetBrains local autocomplete is hilarious but occasionally useful. I find it really hit and miss in terms of when it will decide to autocomplete and whether it will exhastively complete all elements, miss some out or get itself into a loop over several.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bandrami on Monday March 02, 2026 @11:33PM (#47228088)
The out-of-the-box stuff is supposed to be kind of stupid. Are you guys really not editing your own snippets and shortcuts? Have people really been typing out "def do_something(foo, bar, baz)\n\t" manually?
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by socalgal2 on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:54AM (#47216318)
Without ai my text editor auto completes letters into existing identifiers or adds a closing brace

With ai it add several lines of code at once as soon as it thinks it recognizes a common pattern.

It’s not perfect and it can get in the way but it’s amazing when it guesses right and spits out the next 3-4 lines I would have typed

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bandrami on Monday March 02, 2026 @06:19AM (#47216511)
I'm trying to think of a text editor that doesn't support customizable snippets and templates, and failing
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by ses1984 on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:23AM (#47219124)
Those two things aren’t the same at all, they’re so different it’s hard to believe you’re not being intentionally obtuse.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bandrami on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:50AM (#47219507)
I mean, in the sense that customizable snippets are more flexible and can cover a wider variety of use-cases, I guess?
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by bluefirebrand on Monday March 02, 2026 @01:04PM (#47221635)
Personally I find this workflow is jarring. I get into flow typing code and then the AI autocompletes the next four lines on a tab input. Now my flow is screeching to a halt because I have to switch from flow mode to review mode to make sure it actually autocompleted what I wanted
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by segh on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:43AM (#47215721)
I can do long division manually but I still reach for a calculator.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by dwroberts on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:56AM (#47215847)
Do you also spend a lot of time maximising calculator utilisation in other places? Maybe trying to write letters with it or composing music with it?
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by hjkl0 on Monday March 02, 2026 @06:20AM (#47216527)
Won’t you get much better results trying to maximize utilization of some sort of LLM? For many people, you’d get faster and better results trying to optimize for LLMs than for any standard word processor or music composition tool.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by anonnon on Monday March 02, 2026 @02:17PM (#47222700)
> but I still reach for a calculator

Does the calculator give you a slightly different answer each time, even with the same inputs?

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:44AM (#47216217)
Speaking for myself (who can program and all that), AI solves some of the tedium in my day job (building UI components). Most of that work nowadays is boilerplate.

But at the moment it's also helping me solve more complex issues with building applications - it's JS, so you can imagine how complex it can be.

I yearn for a simpler workflow to be honest, I don't want to rely on SO or LLMs to solve build issues. I want to work in Go but there's only a handful of companies using it in my country, plus my CV basically says I mainly did front-end in the past ~15 years.

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by truetraveller on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:57AM (#47216349)
"People are so obsessed with using AI stuff for the sake of it, it’s nuts".

This is a GREAT observation. Thank you!

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by tumdum_ on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:44AM (#47215743)
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by MasterScrat on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:45AM (#47215748)
Why would a game development pedigree correlate with rejecting AI? As Carmack said:

> AI tools will allow the best to reach even greater heights, while enabling smaller teams to accomplish more, and bring in some completely new creator demographics.

Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by jsheard on Monday March 02, 2026 @07:03AM (#47216927)
Carmack isn't exactly a neutral observer here, his main gig since quitting VR has been as the founder of a VC-backed AI startup. He has a clear financial interest in joining the chorus of AI boosters.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by indy on Monday March 02, 2026 @07:31AM (#47217177)
A less cynical interpretation of his actions would be that he's never shown to be motivated by money and is working on technology that interests him and that he can make an important contribution to
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by tkel on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:31AM (#47216113)
Because they are clearly a talented and successful developer and don't need to rely on slop generators to program or think for them
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by MasterScrat on Monday March 02, 2026 @06:13AM (#47216468)
Are you saying Carmack isn't a "talented and successful developer"?
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by coldpie on Monday March 02, 2026 @12:15PM (#47220889)
I hate to say it but honestly, kinda, yeah... I do think that. Has he done anything significant since the early 1990s? All I've known him for since then is wasting a bunch of years spinning wheels at a virtual reality toy company and posting on Elon Musk's child pornography platform.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by yarn_ on Sunday March 08, 2026 @03:23PM (#47300293)
With respect to Carmack I completely agree. There is too much appeal to authority with respect to him solely based on him making an impressive game (with the help of some other genius level programmers eg abrash) nearly 40 years ago.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by Cthulhu_ on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:42AM (#47216195)
Slop is a garbage in, garbage out deal - in the hands of a competent developer who can review the changes, AI generated code is fine.
Re:Making Video Games in 2025 (without an engine) by mock-possum on Monday March 02, 2026 @11:25PM (#47228031)
Because Celeste is left-aligned, and deriding AI as planet-destroying slop stolen from poor artist is a left position to take.