News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:43PM (#47079908)
This kind of Level 1 analysis misses what is really going on. "Brain drain" is not really a concern.

There is a tremendous glut of talented biomedical researchers. We have been overproducing them for decades. Even before the cuts, it was incredibly hard to go from a PhD to a tenured professorship. 5-15% would achieve that, depending how you measured.

The cuts have made things worse, but European/RoW funding is even stingier. It's not like there's a firehose of funding drawing away researchers. There may be a few high-profile departures, but the US is still the least-bad place to find research money.

We need to produce fewer PhDs and provide better support for those we do produce.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tensor on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:53PM (#47080057)
This kind of analysis isn't much better. First, many countries are increasing funding substantially (e.g. [1]).

Secondly, it's about more than funding. The US is also no longer safe for a great many of the scientists that would normally choose come to the US to work. And even for those that aren't too worried about ICE, scientists tend to be very liberal and value freedom and democracy a great deal. The US has suddenly become a very undesirable place to live if you value these things.

Third, scientific freedom is under attack in the US. And there is nothing scientists value more than the freedom to pursue their research.

My take is that most Americans can't imagine a world where they are not number one. But that is a very naive idea.

[1] https://www.canada.ca/en/innovation-science-economic-develop...

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tick_tock_tick on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:04PM (#47081696)
> scientists tend to be very liberal and value freedom and democracy a great deal

What is the alternative? Canada and Europe don't even have free speech.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by aloha2436 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:25PM (#47081925)
This is, de facto, not really a differentiator any more. Only one of the countries in question asks to see my social media profiles at the border to make sure I'm ideologically appropriate.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by EdwardDiego on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:11PM (#47081772)
...not sure if you're being sarcastic.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by IsTom on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:27AM (#47086143)
> don't even have free speech

Only in ways that don't matter to scientists. Not many of them denying the holocaust.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:40PM (#47080702)
> many countries are increasing funding substantially (e.g. [1]).

This illustrates exactly my point. Canada is planning on spending up to CAD$1.7B over 12 years. That is equivalent to USD$100M per year, or 0.3% of the NIH 2026 budget. Maybe if Europe does something similar they can get to 2%!

> The US is also no longer safe

I agree that Trump's regime has made the US a less welcoming place for foreign scientists, and that budget cuts mean less research will be done. What I disagree with is the idea that "brain drain" is a significant threat to US science. We simply have such an incredible oversupply of biomed PhDs that we should welcome the prospect of other countries absorbing the supply.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by layer8 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:48PM (#47080802)
Horizon Europe is a €93.5 billion budget over seven years for scientific research. The EU allocated an additional €500 million from 2025-2027 to attract foreign researchers specifically.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:59PM (#47080940)
Horizon Europe funds everything — physics, engineering, social sciences, climate, agriculture, digital technology, space, and health. And its budget is still less than 1/3rd of the US NIH budget focused solely on health.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by shiroiuma on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:01PM (#47083552)
Maybe, but money goes much farther in Europe than in the US. The cost of living is much lower, so you don't need to pay people so much.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ProjectArcturis on Friday February 20, 2026 @03:58PM (#47093869)
Low European salaries are other reason why brain drain fears are overblown.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by juniperus on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:40PM (#47081422)
it's all about funding. for every 1 person nervous about intellectual safety in the US, there are 50–100 waiting to fill that spot, if not 1,000–10,000. Funding has been cut in academia, and less positions are available as a result. No country is remarkably filling this gap, aside from a hilariously few more availabilities and some more graduate student positions (who operate as the scientific labor in Europe and other countries, before graduating and having to come to the US for job opportunity).

As others have pointed out, presumably the outcome is that higher value scientists are favored, and higher impact research is demanded. When industry demands certain research, the funding appears because private entities will fund those positions and those grants. The widespread funding of all avenues of science is a great feature of American intellectual culture and hopefully it doesn't vanish. But it was a remarkably uneconomical arrangement and a total aberration of history, so I wouldn't hold my breath about it sticking around through the tides of history, it was more of a fluke, and many in academia wishing to regenerate that fluke are a bit delusional and a bit tied to the idea of a golden era like the boomers dreaming of the 1950s suburbs. A great deal of research is important science, but totally worthless for the foreseeable future on an economic basis. We might not yet conceive of why this research does have economic value, but it's so abstracted that as it stands, the value isn't tangible and it's thus impossible to defend reasonably.

Scientific freedom doesn't mean the freedom to expect a subsidized career on the basis of non-lucrative research. It's more of a privilege to have such a lifestyle that is downstream of a wealthy empire. Since America is going bankrupt, the dollar-reaper is coming for the superfluous. So, there goes your funding for conure breeding or the health benefits of community gardens and expect more stability if you're researching crop diseases or livestock vector research.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by godsinhisheaven on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:27PM (#47080544)
"Scientists tend to be very liberal" well see that's your problem. (a little over) half the country voted for Trump in the last election, and pretty much every "scientist" with a public face is anti-Trump. Of course there is going to be a backlash! Shoot the backlash has been happening for the past 20 years, probably even longer.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pesus on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:47PM (#47080786)
Why do you feel scientists deserve to be punished for being against a political regime that is anti-science?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by SetTheorist on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:44PM (#47080750)
77,302,580 people voted for Trump in 2024. That is not "half the country".

Nor does he or ever did have the support of "(over) half the country". His maximum approval level in 2025 was at the beginning of his term at 47% "approve" and is currently around 36%, according to the Gallup poll.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by orochimaaru on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:08PM (#47081052)
Trump won the popular vote 49.9% vs 48.5% for Harris. It doesn’t automatically translate to half the country.

The popular vote does not matter in the US. The electoral college matters.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by shimman on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:45PM (#47082124)
It kinda does matter because it shows more than half the US are truly sick of the current batch of US politicians and aren't enthused enough to vote for their schtick.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by chipotle_coyote on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:02PM (#47080975)
Trump didn't even win 50% of the people who voted. He got the most votes (a plurality), but ~1.5% of the votes went to third party candidates, slightly more than the gap between Harris and Trump voters. One of the many reasons this "we have a huge mandate to reshape the country in the image of Project 2025" line is so infuriating; you have to go back to 1968 to find an election with a smaller non-negative popular vote margin of victory.

(Also, "non-negative" is carrying a lot of weight, since both Trump in his first term and George W. Bush in his first lost the popular vote. The idea that a wide majority of the country is conservative, let alone MAGA, is risible.)

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pessimizer on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:10PM (#47081070)
It's over half the electorate. Stop changing the standards for democracy and holding the current ex-wrestling valet and game show host to standards than literally no one has been held to in history. It's a desperate, dishonest way to cover up the failure of the opposition to be any better.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Aloisius on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:53PM (#47081572)
No, it was under half the electorate too (27% of the electorate didn't vote after all).

It was under half of the voters in the election itself as well. He won with a plurality, not a majority.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pchristensen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:46PM (#47081509)
There's a huge difference between "definitely won the election" and "a massive mandate for sweeping change".
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by nativeit on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:22PM (#47081225)
An electorate is only as good as the information it uses to make the choice. Fewer than 10% of Americans both stated they routinely read a newspaper (in print or online) yet still walked into a voting booth in 2024 and voted for Trump.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by nativeit on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:25PM (#47081258)
I’m not saying he shouldn’t have won, we have the system we have, but to then act like he’s got a mandate is unjustifiable.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by roger110 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:19PM (#47080414)
I've heard more than 0 people complaining that it's not safe, but not a whole lot. And not the productive people either. Also, unfortunately the same opinions that get you in trouble in the US will get you in trouble in western Europe. I'm not saying it's right, just that it doesn't seem to be actually draining brains.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by b65e8bee43c2ed0 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:05PM (#47080239)
>scientists tend to be very liberal and value freedom and democracy a great deal

two election results in the past ten years have apparently failed to teach y'all wholesome folx that many people around you are secretly unwholesome.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by vkou on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:13PM (#47080332)
My neighbours may be turds, but I can get over it... Up until the point when they start pissing in my punch bowl.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by engineer_22 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:08PM (#47080269)
What do you recommend
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by radioactivist on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:08PM (#47083173)
While I echo some of your points, [1] is bad example (as a Canadian).

Research money in Canada is harder to come by; a basic research grant is roughly ~5x-10x lower than a comparable American grant (students are cheaper here, so its not completely proportional, but equipment, travel, etc doesn't scale).

The example for money for poaching international researchers also comes with the asterisk that while they found ~$2B for this, they also are cutting the base funding of the federal granting agencies by a few percent at the same time, atop of that funding being anemic for decades at this point. A big "fuck you" to the Canadian research community in my opinion.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by darth_avocado on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:56PM (#47080098)
While I agree, US is still the top destination for research, I don’t agree with “Brain Drain is not a concern” nor do I agree with “We need fewer PhDs”. The real risk of drain is people leaving their fields of expertise to never return. Pretty much all AI startups at the moment are coming from and being built by PhDs. The pace of innovation slows down and it can have huge long term economic impact. Having fewer PHDs also exacerbates that problem. If fewer people are looking for funding in the first place, you’d have even fewer ideas that could end up contributing meaningfully to society. The only solution to funding problems is more funding.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:51PM (#47080844)
>The real risk of drain is people leaving their fields of expertise to never return.

That is happening right now, all the time! Especially in the biomed field! Many, many PhDs spend 5-8 years getting their degree and receiving minimal pay, then 4+ years being nomadic postdocs, also making terrible money, only to eventually arrive at the end of the road and realize they have to do something completely different.

It is unsustainable for every professor to train 10 PhDs in their career, because there aren't going to be 10 professorships (or even 3) for those PhDs to fill. Funding has to grow at the same exponential rate as the number of researchers. It did, from roughly 1950s to 1980s, as the university system expanded to accommodate the Boomer generation. It has slowed since, and the PhD to professorship pipeline got longer and leakier. It's doing a tremendous disservice to the bright, well-intentioned young people who join PhD programs.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by janalsncm on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:59PM (#47080151)
Why does the fact that there isn’t enough funding for the PhDs that exist imply we should produce fewer of them? At least from what the article mentions, figuring out new and better ways to fight diseases seems like one of the most important problems a human could be working on. In my mind the solution is to provide funding and fix the funding process, not produce fewer scientists.

Also, those scientists already exist. If the US decides not to fund them, they will go produce patents and grow the economies of other places. Many countries wish they could attract the talent that the US does.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by iugtmkbdfil834 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:06PM (#47080250)
<< Why does the fact that there isn’t enough funding for the PhDs that exist imply we should produce fewer of them?

In most of the world, most humans have to move within the realm of available resources. One could easily say that if a manager of US sees too many PhDs, it is natural to conclude that since there is not enough resources to go around, adding more resource consumers is silly. We can argue all over whether it is a good policy, or whether the allocation makes sense, or whether the resources are really not there, but, how is is this a difficult logic gate?

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by janalsncm on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:03PM (#47080984)
The need for things exists independent of the standalone economic viability of those things. That is the entire point of public funding of various resources, including scientific funding. The “available” resources is a political decision.

Further, reduction in funds for public resources or increase in misery for scientists are not in and of themselves evidence that those resources were over-funded or too cushy. For the research discussed in the article it is quite clearly a political decision, not directly grounded in a need for less medical research.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by iugtmkbdfil834 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:15PM (#47081818)
<< The “available” resources is a political decision.

It invariably always is.

<< The need for things exists independent of the standalone economic viability of those things.

Sure, but there is only so long that can go on funding studying of rather pointless stuff[1] ( added UK example to not be accused of hating on anything in particular US-wise ).

[1]https://web-archive.southampton.ac.uk/cogprints.org/5272/1/g...

<< Further, reduction in funds for public resources or increase in misery for scientists are not in and of themselves evidence that those resources were over-funded or too cushy.

I am not suggesting that. I am literally saying: there is only so much money. That is it. And if push comes to shove, studies of whether chicken finds humans pretty take a back seat to more pressing matters.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by janalsncm on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:11PM (#47082365)
There is a (perhaps apocryphal) story of Michael Faraday showing his new invention of an electric motor to a politician in 1821. He had invented it after investigating strange twitching of a magnetic compass needle.

After seeing the motor, the politician asked “what good is it?” and based on what I can find Faraday either said “what use is a newborn baby” or “one day you’ll be able to tax it”.

So two points: One, you don’t always know things will have a high ROI from the start. Sometimes you just have to be curious. And two, politicians care about the next election in two/four years, not planting trees that won’t bear fruit for 30 years.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by danaris on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:26PM (#47080513)
We have vast amounts of resources. More than enough to supply the basic needs of everyone in the country.

The US is currently choosing to divert absolutely staggering amounts of those resources away from things we have traditionally valued—science, art, infrastructure, taking care of the least fortunate among us, etc—and using them instead to enrich the already-wealthy, in the most blatant and cruel ways.

There is no possible way this can be spun as being about "available resources". The grift is utterly, 100% transparent.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by iugtmkbdfil834 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:39PM (#47080697)
<< There is no possible way this can be spun as being about "available resources". The grift is utterly, 100% transparent.

Eh, I mean if you put it that way, I suppose all those budgets are just a show and not at all an indication of how utterly fucked we are as a country unless we both:

a) massively reduce spending b) massively raise taxes

In very real terms, there is only so much money. Some additional money can be borrowed, but we a slowly ( but surely ) reaching a breaking point on that as well.

The issue is: no one is willing to sacrifice anything. And I am sympathetic, but if hard choices are not made now, they will be kinda made for us anyway.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by danaris on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:14PM (#47081125)
Yes we have to massively raise taxes.

We need to claw back billions and billions and billions of dollars from people for whom it will make zero difference in their daily lives, so that we can spend it on people for whom $100 can change their month, and $10000 can change their life.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by iugtmkbdfil834 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:16PM (#47081836)
Lol. No. We have to massively raise taxes JUST to keep this country afloat financially. The poor people are still fucked. I know it is exactly massively popular to say, which is why you don't see major proponents sans rando online like me.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by danaris on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:22PM (#47091709)
Or, y'know, maybe the reason is more this:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47058280

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by iugtmkbdfil834 on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:08PM (#47092401)
Hardly, my advice is real, would have a long term positive impact, while, admittedly, inflicting a lot of pain in the process. If there is any benefit to it, it would be that at least the pain would be shared equally across the board allowing for some form of 'misery loves company'.

On the other hand, your advice, at best, is happy clappy populist advice that will, temporarily make some people happy, but will not change the trajectory of the country resulting in the exact same spot only few years from implementation; and that is assuming it can be done in a way that is not immediately subverted..

If anything, I am giving you a real good reason for not just being a cynic, but being a cynic, who can make a change that lasts.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mtsr on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:54PM (#47080068)
You are forgetting that tenured researchers often need lots of PhD students to actually do their research. So that ratio of 8 PhDs to a tenured researchers could actually be pretty good.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jltsiren on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:38PM (#47080686)
That's a result of the funding model focused on small competitive grants. You could probably get at least as good research with a funding model that replaces every three PhD students with a student and a staff scientist. But then the society would have fewer PhDs overall, which would have unpredictable consequences.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by 141205 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:33PM (#47081351)
You would forget that this would cause exponential growth: in a couple decades, a single lab could produce more people seeking tenure track than an entire country's worth of positions; there need to be smarter ways to provide the requisite labor for science, since this is clearly unsustainable praxis. Running a pyramid scheme of this magnitude is only going to cause an implosion—which we may already be witnessing.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:28PM (#47080557)
Pretty good for the professor, not so good for the students.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by lukev on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:55PM (#47080079)
Set aside the question of how we might implement this (which I grant is complex and path-dependent)... but imagine if 5% of the wealth of every US billionaire were instead allocated to research and development.

Ultimately I don't think even the billionaires would be unhappy.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pks016 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:20PM (#47083679)
One can dream. Capitalist society would never reduce their PhD slaves. Saying this as someone who's closer to finishing PhD.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Xeronate on Friday February 20, 2026 @03:32AM (#47085288)
Purely anecdotal, but my friend's dad was a professor at well respected university in California doing Cancer research and recently moved to China even though he didn't want to because the money was too much for him to pass up.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by eunos on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:52AM (#47085850)
> We need to produce fewer PhDs and provide better support for those we do produce.

You'll have gluts of Masters then and so on.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ikrenji on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:46PM (#47092083)
why produce less PhDs instead of fixing funding? in what world does the pentagon need 1 trillion dollars while NIH gets 10 billy or so?