News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by s_dev on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @11:37PM (#46984948)
Irish here. It's a cultural thing.

Art is seen as a worthwhile endeavour even if it can't necessarily support itself as a private endeavour. It's for the same reason galleries and museums are subsidised by the government.

Anyone can call themselves an artist but to receive this money you would have to have a portfolio of work that is approved by the application programme.

Ireland already has a competitive economy. There is more to a country than economics and that includes promoting things like art to foster a sense of identity and promote Ireland on a world stage.

Milton Friedman wouldn't approve and we're okay with that.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by pash on Thursday February 12, 2026 @12:08AM (#46985097)
Milton Friedman wouldn’t have approved of restricting a basic income scheme to artists, because such a restriction might distort incentives around choice of profession in a way that would reduce social welfare.

He would have supported a broader scheme. His proposal in 1962 of a “negative income tax” (in Capitalism and Freedom) is the genesis of the movement to replace traditional social welfare schemes (which disincentivize employment and skew recipients’ consumption decisions) with simple schemes that just give money to poor people. (This eventually led to the Earned Income Tax Credit in the United States.)

Friedman’s negative income tax is equivalent to the contemporary notion of a guaranteed basic income (but not to a universal basic income, as only people earning below some threshold would receive it).

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by vintermann on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:23AM (#46985441)
It's not remotely a basic income scheme. It's a state stipend for acclaimed artists. Don't know about Ireland, but Norway has had this for over 100 years (kunstnerlønn). It's basically a court poet institution, ever so slightly broadened.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by p_v_doom on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:27AM (#46987438)
Friedman is also not someone anyone should be taking seriously in the year of our lord '26
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by Swizec on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @11:52PM (#46985023)
We have a similar scheme in Slovenia. Don't know the details but there's the concept of a "free artist".

At a minimum you need a registered business, regular exhibitions or performances in your field, you have to register with the ministry of culture, and can't have a job. Contract work is allowed and encouraged. Also you are expected to apply when the government issues a Call For Creatives.

I think you get paid minimum wage as long as you continue fulfilling criteria.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by pastage on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:50AM (#46985984)
Interesting concept, seems like it is a way to pay less taxes as an artist, not really a pay but it will make it easier to live. Not sure about the selection process though..

> Self-employed in culture can be given the right to pay social security contributions from the state budget.

https://e-uprava.gov.si/si/podrocja/izobrazevanje-kultura/za...

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by trinix912 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:25AM (#46986617)
The link is totally irrelevant, it's about filing taxes and the right to pay to the social security fund not about the income you receive while you have the status. Yes, you get an extra tax break (taxes aren't paid on the money you receive from the state), but that's not the main point.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by pastage on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:22AM (#46987401)
If there are other ways artists get support do you have a better definition one can search for? Considering it talks about supporting artists I feel it is relevant to the situation in my country. Getting help with social insurance is pretty important in many countries, and something I know many artists have problem with.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by ErroneousBosh on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:20AM (#46986581)
> Also you are expected to apply when the government issues a Call For Creatives.

I love the idea of having a list of "Registered Artists", where you get a basic income as long as you're prepared to Answer The Call of Your Country when needed.

"We need a nice cartoony figure for this public safety film! Find me some artists!"

"Here you go, boss"

"Naw, not those guys, have you got anything in a more Shel Silverstein-y kind of look? How about those ones?"

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by matevzmihalic on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:02AM (#46987263)
You don't actually get paid, but you don't need to pay taxes and social security fees (around 650€ per month) that you would otherwise have to pay as a self employed person.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by some_random on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:14AM (#46989816)
Having some kind of government employment scheme and having basic income are two different thing.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by tjwebbnorfolk on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @11:44PM (#46984979)
Soon: everyone is an artist.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by CalRobert on Thursday February 12, 2026 @12:44AM (#46985267)
This seems like it mostly funnels money to rich kids, to be honest. Nobody else can afford to already be an artist.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by Retric on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:09AM (#46985370)
Working artists, spouses, and semi-retirees are relatively common.

‘2,000 creative workers’ would make this quite competitive, even if it’s only 20k USD/year that could easily enable people to be artists who wouldn’t make a career of it on their own.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by CalRobert on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:25AM (#46985446)
Right, and it would be great if people who wished to become artists could avail of this, but now it only goes for people who already are artists.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by plastic-enjoyer on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:26AM (#46986623)
Who fucking cares. It is a good thing and most people who are mad about a basic income for artists are people that shit on art anyway, such as tech folks that have their personal rather one-sided beef with artists for a few decades now.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by Retric on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:22PM (#46996126)
Many people who are artists can’t afford to stay artists.

Pulling a 80 hour workweeks at 24, supporting yourself while doing something else is not sustainable. Similarly someone supporting themselves as an artist + a kid is suddenly a very different situation.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by fakedang on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:41AM (#46986732)
Anyone who can build an art portfolio in their spare time is quite comfortable in my books.

20k USD/yr is life changing for some people down on their luck.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by watwut on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:24AM (#46985786)
Poor people and middle class people produce art. They both work as artists or do art on the side as a hobby. It is not that expensive either.

Expectation that you have portfolio does not strikes me as outrageous either.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by jimnotgym on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:50AM (#46987179)
Exactly. A sketchbook and pencils cost next to nothing. But being able to take that and turn it into an oil painting on a giant canvas costs real money.

Writing a few songs on a guitar from Facebook marketplace is cheap. Turning that into a live show is expensive and time consuming.

Writing some Irish language poems on your lunchbreaks is cheap. Doing public readings as an unknown poet is not.

Well done Ireland.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by stephenbez on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:22AM (#46989908)
> Writing some Irish language poems on your lunchbreaks is cheap. Doing public readings as an unknown poet is not.

How is doing public reading of poetry not cheap?

I have friends who do standup comedy and they just show up at open mic nights and it doesn’t cost them anything. One is good enough that now the venues are paying him a little bit.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by maleno on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:51AM (#46990317)
I'm an Irish artist, living in Ireland. I'm very far from a rich kid. Like most Irish artists, I make some of my living from my "artistic" work, and some from what others here might call "real work". Sometimes there's not a clear division between the two, and anyway the ratio of one to the other changes every year.

Because of the cost of living here, particularly in Dublin, there is no way that the Basic Income would provide me with anything like what most people here would consider a decent standard of living. (It would currently leave me with about €200 left over every month, after I pay just my rent. That's before any bills or groceries or anything.)

Plenty of people find a way to continue to make art that other people value, even if the cost of living continues to spiral ever upwards. This payment is simply a buffer to make making art a little easier, for a fraction of the many people who contribute to the social, cultural, and intellectual life of this country. For some it pays their rent or mortgage, for some it pays for childcare so they have time to work, for some it facilitates research or purchase of materials, for some it allows them a workspace outside their home.

It's not perfect, as no public arts funding is perfect but, to me, the kind of cheap cynicism displayed in this comment comes from a place of deep ignorance and bitterness.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by inglor_cz on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:15AM (#46986549)
Is there a tradition of rich Irish people supporting Irish artists privately?

In other places (like Italy) there is.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by mike_hearn on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:46AM (#46986763)
> Ireland already has a competitive economy

Ireland's economic statistics are so badly distorted by US companies routing money there that there is an entire subfield of economics dedicated to trying to figure out what Ireland's real economic state is, called "Leprechaun economics". A common adjustment made by economics researchers when studying the EU is to just subtract Ireland entirely.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leprechaun_economics

https://www.cfr.org/articles/leprechaun-adjusted-euro-area-g...

https://democracychallenged.com/2025/05/14/irelands-phantom-...

> The key to understanding this disconnect is a number few outside Ireland pay attention to: Modified Gross National Income, or GNI*. Unlike GDP, which counts all activity happening within Ireland’s borders, GNI* adjusts for the distortions caused by the huge presence of foreign multinationals. And the gap is enormous. In 2023, GNI* was just €291 billion — meaning more than €219 billion of Ireland’s reported output never truly flowed into the Irish economy at all.

When looking at Ireland's own economy without the influence of US tax transactions, the economy shrinks by nearly half.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by s_dev on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:16AM (#46987362)
I'm 38, I was fully aware of this when I was 15 years old in Economics class. This is simply a problem for people who go around measuring everything with GDP and demand the world adjust to that. You've run in to the limitations of GDP.

There is no single indicator of wealth, measuring wealth requires a number of measures to provide context and contrast. The Irish economy is largely comparable to the Danish economy. I'd say the Danes sneak in just ahead of us but well behind Norway and Switzerland.

Ireland for example is wealthier than either the UK or France on a per capita basis. The GDP of Alabama and Bavaria, Germany per capita is largely the same, yet you would be insane to think Alabama was in anyway wealthier than Bavaria.

I stand by my comment.

The Irish economy is competitive and your little 'gotcha' that is a common trope across various shallow sub reddits, increasingly at an alarmingly peevish rate simply doesn't persuade me or others who are interested in understanding these things at a deeper level. There is a time and place for that discussion and it really isn't this thread.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by mike_hearn on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:05AM (#47000994)
If you know that you should make it clear when you talk about the Irish economy, because most people don't.

Danish GDP per capita is about $71k nominal. According to the Irish Central Bank mGNI per capita is a fair bit less than that at around $65k.

https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-mip/measu...

However, that assumes the modified GNI measure is accurate. If you believe these numbers the Irish became nearly 40% wealthier between 2020 and 2023. That would be a truly unprecedented spike in wealth never before seen in history, and I don't think anyone believes it. It's much more likely that their attempts to subtract the distortion of American corporate success from the Irish numbers aren't successful. Tech firms did great during the COVID period whilst the average person... not so much.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by direwolf20 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:43AM (#46987139)
It's nice that they still get taxes on that money, and use it to support artists.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by wooger on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:40AM (#46987521)
They don't get the appropriate taxes on that money, which is the whole reason those US companies route money there in the first place.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by haritha-j on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:01AM (#46986869)
> Ireland already has a competitive economy

Well it has a competitive tax haven.

Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by probably_wrong on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:21AM (#46987396)
Po-tay-to, po-tah-to.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by bagacrap on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:56AM (#46989609)
To need to already have a portfolio of work kind of defeats the purpose, no? It kind of proves you didn't need this money to make art. I would have thought the point was to unlock potential artists who hadn't the time to develop their practice.
Re:Ireland rolls out pioneering basic income scheme for artists by tomcam on Thursday February 12, 2026 @08:23PM (#46997769)
Can you name a government-subsidized Irish artist who has been successfully promoted on the world stage?

I don't give a shit about Milton Friedman. I do give a shit about wage earners in Ireland who are being forced to pay for an artist welfare program. Ireland has a competitive economy.