> Also the dirty secret of WebAssembly is that it's not really faster than JS.
That is near purely due to amount of work it took to make that shitty language run fast. Naive webassembly implementation will beat interpreted JS many times over but modern JIT implementations are wonder.
V8 is a modern engineering marvel.
There is no reason why WASM couldn't be as fast, or faster than JS, especially now with WASM 3.0. Before, every programs in a managed language had to be shipped with its own GC and exception handling framework in WASM which was probably crippled by size constraints.
Any language with advanced GC algorithms, or interior pointers, will run poorly with current WASM GC.
It works as long as their GC model overlaps with JS GC requirements.
Some of the real GC tests will be strings support (because immutability/interning) and higher-level composite objects, which is all still in various draft/proposal states.
The WASM runtime ended up from something that ingests pseudo-assembly,validates it and turns it into machine code, into a full-fledged multi-tiered JIT, like what JS has, with crazy engineering complexity per browser, and similar startup performance woes (which was one of the major goals of Nacl/Wasm to alleviate the load time issues with huge applications).
Starting from not only single-threaded but memory-limited target was... weird decision
I don't think you need conspiracy theories for that. DOM involves complex JS objects and you have to have an entirely working multi-language garbage collection model if you are expecting other languages to work with DOM objects otherwise you run the risk of memory leaking some of the most expensive objects in a browser.
That path to that is long and slow, especially with the various committees' general interest being in not requiring non-JS languages to entirely conform to JS GC (either implementing themselves on top of JS GC alone or having to implement their own complex subset of JS GC to interop correctly), so the focus has been on very low level tools over complex GC patterns. The first basics have only just been standardized. The next step (sharing strings) seems close but probably still has months to go. The steps after that (sharing simple structs) seem pretty complex with a lot of heated debate still to happen, and DOM objects are still some further complexity step past that (as they involve complex reference cycles and other such things).
Some joker who built Solana actually thought Berkeley Packet Filter language would be better than WASM for their runtime. But besides that dude, everyone is discovering how great WASM can be to run deterministic code right in people’s browsers!
No, WASM is deterministic, JS is fundamentally not. Your dislike of all things blockchain makes you say silly things.
https://takahirox.github.io/WebAssembly-benchmark/
Js is not always faster, but in a good chunk of cases it is.
But that is really only common in small computational kernels. If you take a large, complex application like Adobe Photoshop or a Unity game, wasm will be far closer to native speed, because its compilation and optimization approach is much closer to native builds (types known ahead of time, no heavy dependency on tiering and recompilation, etc.).
Webassembly that was supposed to replace it needs to be at least as good, that was the promise. We're a decade in, and still Wasm is nowhere near while it has accumulated an insane amount of engineering complexity in its compiler, and its ability to run native apps without tons of constraints and modifications is still meh as is the performance.
Also, Native Client started up so fast because it shipped native binaries, which was not portable. To fix that, Portable Native Client shipped a bytecode, like wasm, which meant slower startup times - in fact, the last version of PNaCl had a fast baseline compiler to help there, just like wasm engines do today, so they are very similar.
And, a key issue with Native Client is that it was designed for out-of-process sandboxing. That is fine for some things, but not when you need synchronous access to Web APIs, which many applications do (NaCl avoided this problem by adding an entirely new set of APIs to the web, PPAPI, which most vendors were unhappy about). Avoiding this problem was a major principle behind wasm's design, by making it able to coexist with JS code (even interleaving stack frames) on the main thread.
I don't see an issue with shipping uArch specific assembly, nowadays you only have 2 really in heavy use today, and I think managing that level of complexity is tenable, considering the monster the current Wasm implementation became, which is still lacking in key ways.
As for out of process sandboxing, I think for a lot of things it's fine - if you want to run a full-fat desktop-app or game, you can cram it into an iframe, and the tab(renderer) process is isolated, so Chrome's approach was quite tenable from an IRL perspective.
But if seamless interaction with Web APIs is needed, that could be achieved as well, and I think quite similarly to how Wasm does it - you designate a 'slab' of native memory and make sure no pointer access goes outside by using base-relative addressing and masking the addresses.
For access to outside APIs, you permit jumps to validated entry points which can point to browser APIs. I also don't see why you couldn't interleave stack frames, by making a few safety and sanity checks, like making sure the asm code never accesses anything outside the current stack frame.
Personally I thought that WebAssembly was what it's name suggested - an architecture independent assembly language, that was heavily optimized, and only the register allocation passes and the machine instruction translation was missing - which is at the end of the compiler pipeline, and can be done fairly fast, compared to a whole compile.
But it seems to me Wasm engines are more like LLVM, an entire compiler consuming IR, and doing fancy optimization for it - if we view it in this context, I think sticking to raw assembly would've been preferable.
> I don't see an issue with shipping uArch specific assembly, nowadays you only have 2 really in heavy use today,
That is true today, but it would prevent other architectures from getting a fair shot. Or, if another architecture exploded in popularity despite this, it would mean fragmentation.
This is why the Portable version of NaCl was the final iteration, and the only one even Google considered shippable, back then.
I agree the other stuff is fixable - APIs etc. It's really portability that was the sticking point. No browser vendor was willing to give that up.
In practice, WASM codebases won't be simply running a single pure function in WASM from JS but instead will have several data structures being passed around from one WASM function to another, and that's going to be faster than doing the same in JS.
By the way, if I remember correctly V8 can optimize function calls heuristically if every call always passes the same argument types, but because this is an implementation detail it's difficult to know what scenarios are actually optimized and which are not.
This is an entirely unnecessary jab. There’s a whole generation dealing with stuff like this because of economic and other forces outside their control.
Theory and practice doesn't match in this case, and many people have remarked that companies that sit on the WhatWG board have vested interest in making sure their lucrative app stores are not threatened by a platform that can run any app just as well.
I remember when Native Client came to the scene and allowed people to compile complex native apps to the web that run at like 95% of native speed. While it was in many ways an inelegant solution, it worked better than WebAssembly does today.
Another one of WebAssembly's killer features was supposed to be native web integration. How JS engines work is that you have an IDL that describes the interface of JS classes which is then used to generate code to bind to underlying C++ implementations. You could probably bind those to Webassembly just as well.
I don't think a cross-platform as in cross CPU arch matters that much, if you meant 'runs on everything' then I concur.
Also the dirty secret of WebAssembly is that it's not really faster than JS.