News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Tzk on Thursday January 01, 2026 @03:32AM (#46452333)
No sane person would ever come to the conclusion that it’s a great idea to make the user click away numerous popups, (cookie) banners and modals just to actually see the content. And yet here we are.

Today most commercial or news sites use those plus dark patterns to make it go away as hard as possible. I usually just close the tab and never come back. My choice is “no” not “ask again later”…

Same for those annoying chatbot buttons which just take away screen space.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by f1shy on Thursday January 01, 2026 @04:18AM (#46452558)
The web experience, specially in the phone, reminds me of the 90, if not worst, because some of those cookies dialogs have “processing” time (just a 5 sec. Wait)

I have counted 20 clicks until I get a clean view of actual content with all possible distractions closed. And never EVER less than 5.

The thing is so awful, that I started trusting the sheitty Gemini extract, because at least pops up at once. If I open a site to check, I have to be prepared to about 10 annoying and slow, microscopic buttons to close all the sheit. Then you realize the site is LLM slope anyway… or just marketing BS… next site… rinse and repeat.

Specially EU and specially Germanay, the web is dead. (Was anytime alive?!)

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by elcapitan on Thursday January 01, 2026 @04:31AM (#46452646)
That was the big aha moment last year with Noscript for me. For a long time I avoided it because of the occasional case where I have to whitelist a site, which costs a bit of time.

Now every site has so much forced garbage interaction that with Noscript on average I have way fewer clicks.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by LoganDark on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:31AM (#46453955)
I've started to encounter news outlets / etc that use JavaScript to load most of the article. So if you don't have it enabled you get like one or two paragraphs and that's it. Usually I didn't care about the article that much anyway, but it's still annoying.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Tanoc on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:48AM (#46454084)
I've been using NoScript since 2016, and the number of things that get loaded in via Javascript has sextupled since then. This isn't an exaggeration, some websites like Wal-Mart's went from five extra domains to thirty. Going to Fossil's website to look at a watch for a Christmas gift this year, the domain whitelist panel for NoScript was so long I actually had to scroll down because there were just that many.

And there's no silver bullet to fix it, because there's three parts of it. The first is that these Javascript modules are literally drag and drop, so you can add new functionality in minutes. The second is that most of this stuff is being delivered offsite from a CDN anyways, so why bother doing anything like a static page? And the third is that it forces the users to enable Javascript so that trackers, fingerprinters, third party cookie loggers, and all sorts of other things get their filthy little digits into your window.

Javascript devs aren't going to change, because they don't want things to be harder and slower (putting side the mess that is the Javascript ecosystem). The hosts don't want things to revert, because then that's more money paid for bandwidth when that cost can instead be dropped in someone else's lap. And the little bastards doing the tracking definitely aren't going to change, because it's a source of money for doing nothing other than being a voyeur.

I still block Javascript everywhere just so that things will actually work and won't crash my browser by eating an entire gigabyte of RAM just loading fonts from some third party website. I still recommend other people to as well. Not because I think it will actually protect them, but instead to show them just how inefficient and predatory modern website design is. It spooks people when they see two dozen URLs that aren't the website they're currently on.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by zelphirkalt on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:20AM (#46453219)
In theory with GDPR conforming websites it should be 1 click and that is "reject all" or "accept only essential" cookies and a website would truly only ever set essential cookies, and not something else that is non-essential to reading the content.

In practice lots of websites are developed by people going to huge lengths to make it more cumbersome and sneak in shit that's not essential, and the websites do not actually follow the law.

Mind, this is talking about the not rolled back version of GDPR, that I read they are planning to roll back somewhat and thereby destroy the good it was.

In Germany the web is dead, because of laws, that require most websites to have the author's friggin address on the website. Like, who wants every idiot on the web to know one's address? Might as well not have a blog or website. There are websites which don't require it and you can sort of gray zone get around it, but that's already too much effort that inhibits a freely developing web. Instead people flock to abusive social media presences. Germany has managed to basically kill its blogging and web culture through this idiocy and thereby got rid of a lot of educational potential and skilled workforce.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by f1shy on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:09AM (#46453819)
> In practice lots of websites are developed by people going to huge lengths to make it more cumbersome and sneak in shit that's not essential

I feel it was from the begging a way of screw people so people say “fuck me as you like, but let me surf the web!” And they are getting away with it, sadly.

> In Germany the web is dead, because of laws, that require most websites to have the author's friggin address on the website.

Amen! That is was one of the dumbest things. I would be ok to have it registered somehow. But just for everyone to know my private address because I want to share some stupid thing online?! Pretty strange, when we talk about privacy!

Another one was making the owner of a wifi spot 100% responsible for crimes committed by that connection. That made free wifi absolutely disappear.

That leaves us with sites than only try to make money. Which is ok, I guess. But the web could be much richer than just a virtual shop window.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by PaulHoule on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:51AM (#46454566)
Maybe if the US leaves the EU we can make those cookie banners go away. ;-)

But really I am so sick of Germans making excuses for their delinquent government, if I was elected the first thing I would do is unplug them from the global internet.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by zelphirkalt on Thursday January 01, 2026 @11:17AM (#46455233)
Unplug the government or Germans?
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by GoatInGrey on Thursday January 01, 2026 @12:20PM (#46455901)
Yes.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by throw101010 on Thursday January 01, 2026 @04:29AM (#46452635)
> My choice is “no” not “ask again later”…

My choice is uBlock Origin and enabling the Cookie Notices filter lists and other Annoyances filter lists (which block the Mobile app banners and such). Works pretty well.

Obviously using Firefox, since Chrome doesn't let me filter content my own computer renders locally these days...

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by nicbou on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:27AM (#46453567)
On iOS, Adguard does a decent job. It's the only way I would ever use the internet.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Tzk on Thursday January 01, 2026 @04:39AM (#46452684)
Couldn’t agree more. Also FF user and Ublock Origin works great. On mobile (iOS in my case) it’s not that easy though. I’m using safari with AdGuard which works for some annoyances, but by far not all.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by jahnu on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:09AM (#46453483)
Brave on iOS seems to work well. Ideally I would use Firefox on iOS but last time it didn’t seem to be as good.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by aucisson_masque on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:19AM (#46453213)
Ublock light is pretty good on Safari
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by ycombinatrix on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:04AM (#46453462)
Not compared to the uBlock Origin. You can't even import a filter list. Main reason I use Firefox.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by XzetaU8 on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:59AM (#46454169)
Something that [1] AdGuard Browser Extension can do, it make you wonder why uBOL can't include such a feature.

[1] https://adguard.com/en/blog/adguard-browser-extension-v5-2.h...

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by OptionOfT on Thursday January 01, 2026 @10:00AM (#46454639)
Firefox on iOS has 0 support for Adblocking, making it hell to use.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by ycombinatrix on Saturday January 03, 2026 @03:39PM (#46481291)
That's not Firefox, that's Safari wearing a fake mustache
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by plagiarist on Thursday January 01, 2026 @05:41AM (#46452995)
I have been having some success with wipr 2. The developer is respectful of privacy, so the blocking is split into regular content blockers (Apple claims cannot send data) and one extra (could send data). I enabled only the regular content blockers.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by apothegm on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:38AM (#46454461)
I’ve gotten good results from BlockBear, fwiw.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by FergusArgyll on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:38AM (#46453627)
I've enjoyed https://github.com/cavi-au/Consent-O-Matic/ it fills out cookie banner automatically according to your preferences.

Obviously alongside ublock origin for the rest of the minefields

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by mozarella on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:10AM (#46454260)
I also supplement it with the "Web Archives" extension to access paywalled and login-walled articles.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @04:59AM (#46452786)
> No sane person would ever come to the conclusion that it’s a great idea to make the user click away numerous popups, (cookie) banners and modals just to actually see the content.

Ads are content too, you know?

Without ad revenue, many sites would have no content at all.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Tzk on Thursday January 01, 2026 @05:22AM (#46452905)
> Ads are content too, you know?

Yes, and I’m not against ads in general.

It’s about the balance of actual content (the user wants to read and cares about) and ads/popups the site owner needs to run the site or generate some kind of income. If the user has to click away numerous things to be able to see any “real” content, then something’s clearly wrong. We’ve gone from showing ads to support the site to generating just enough content for the site to make the user visit and show them ads.

Sad times.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rkomorn on Thursday January 01, 2026 @05:41AM (#46452994)
Agreed that there are many sites that seem to have no other purpose than to get ads displayed.

Unfortunately, it's also getting harder and harder to tell them apart from the sites that have legitimate content supported by ads because the quality of the latter is nosediving.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:05AM (#46454212)
The reason you can't tell them apart is there's no meaningful distinction. Whether content is sufficiently "legitimate" to be worth the ads depends entirely on the particular user.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rkomorn on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:48AM (#46454544)
I don't entirely agree. Yes, there's subjectivity, but there's more to it, IMO.

There are sites (eg along the lines of legacy print or established in the "early" internet days) that still try to generate news content for reading, but are seeking more revenue.

And then there are sites that are just modern click/impression factories that never tried to actually produce real content.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Friday January 02, 2026 @05:07AM (#46463281)
I don't agree that whether the content is "real" is anything more than subjective.

If content you see laden with ads was not "real" enough to earn from sufficient readers, you would not be seeing it.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rkomorn on Friday January 02, 2026 @06:00AM (#46463594)
If that were really the case, then nobody would be employed to try and understand SEO, ranking algorithms, virality, etc.

Edit: what I mean by that is: I think your comment implies there's some sort of meritocracy to content people see online that isn't easily gamed. My various feeds, search results, etc, convince me otherwise.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Friday January 02, 2026 @08:19AM (#46464448)
I did not say content was never gamed. But gaming doesn't make content unreal.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by PaulHoule on Thursday January 01, 2026 @10:35AM (#46454876)
From the viewpoint of Hirschman

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty

you don't have any "voice" about ads so your choice is to "exit" by running an ad blocker. Obnoxious advertising tactics, scam ads, and other problems in the advertising system lower people's responsiveness to advertising. We need to restore the responsiveness to weak signals (bidirectionally) that Vaughn talks about in The Challenger Launch Decision and her book about her divorce Uncoupling.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by aebtebeten on Friday January 02, 2026 @07:38AM (#46464175)
wrt GP: "generating just enough content for the site to make the user visit and show them ads" is how publishing has always worked, even way back when it all came on dead trees. My library had a book in the reference section that had, for various types of demographic, the maximal percentage of ads to run (ie, how much content you needed to pay for having sold a given volume of ads), but it would probably have been almost as quick, just as cheap, and likely more accurate, to empirically determine that percentage by visiting a local newsstand and sampling the ad density from your target section of the rack.

wrt Exit vs Voice: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46376098

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rglullis on Thursday January 01, 2026 @05:27AM (#46452926)
If people are willing to consume content but not willing to pay for it, then you have a very strong indicator it has no value at all and therefore no actual need to be produced in the first place.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by sunrunner on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:39AM (#46453318)
Or at least, not enough subjective value for that person to outweigh the cost. Paywalls are a great screening filter that actually tests if people want to spend any money or time on an article, or merely clicked through from force of habit.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Friday January 02, 2026 @08:29AM (#46464528)
So? Ads are a screening filter that tests if people want to spend time consuming ads to consume content.

What's odd is when people here complain of screening by ads because they'd think screening should instead be by money. It is proper that the choce for the publisher's site is made by the publisher and for the reader's visits is made by the reader.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:09AM (#46454245)
People willing to pay by consuming ads are indicating the content is worth that price - to them. The fact such people exist is proved by the fact such sites exist.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rglullis on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:32AM (#46454416)
This is not how it works. Ad-subsidized content is functionally equivalent to price-dumping. The more ad-subsidized content is out there, the less incentive there is to focus on quality and quantity of eyeballs become the only metric that matters.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Friday January 02, 2026 @08:22AM (#46464469)
On the contrary, content quality is a major driver of ad revenue.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rglullis on Monday January 05, 2026 @01:39AM (#46495936)
Then you'd have to explain why every reputable newspaper is putting up paywalls and all the quality sites that used to cover specific niches went out of business in the last 20 years.

Saying "revenue goes up with content quality" only makes sense if you compare one poor site with another, but when you put in terms of ROI, you will see it is a lot easier to set up hundreds of different content farms than to keep a sustainable source of well written, reputably sourced reports.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by dxdm on Thursday January 01, 2026 @05:16AM (#46452865)
Ads do not absolutely have to be delivered via pop ups or modals.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by RobotToaster on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:41AM (#46453655)
I was fine with ads when they were a text AdSense banner.

Now a lot of sites have scammy full page js-popups of the kind that were only found on dodgy websites in the 90s.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Anthony-G on Friday January 02, 2026 @08:27AM (#46464505)
As a life-long hater of ads (before the Internet, I would mute the TV during ad breaks), I must agree. Before AdSense, animated GIFs for advertising were obnoxious. When the “Don’t be evil” Google started doing advertising, I was so impressed with them. Even their advertising is tasteful - and relevant! They really seemed to have the Midas touch.

But I feel that their choice of advertising revenue as their predominant income stream set them on a trajectory that gradually and inexorably led them further away from their original principles.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by lelanthran on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:39AM (#46453317)
> Without ad revenue, many sites would have no content at all.

I'm fine with that. An ad-laden site with ads I cannot block won't have me as a visitor anyway, so I'm not really going to notice if they are gone.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:11AM (#46454267)
Can you really not conceive of some content sufficiently valuable to make it worth you consuming those ads?
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by lelanthran on Thursday January 01, 2026 @11:04AM (#46455110)
> Can you really not conceive of some content sufficiently valuable to make it worth you consuming those ads?

Honestly, no.

Perhaps I am just lacking imagination; can you think of any content compelling enough that a) I am not prepared to pay to get it and b) I am still prepared to view ads to get it?

I can't imagine any type of content that I both don't want to pay for and feel it is worth sitting through the ads.

I expect the ratios matter as well; the average webpage/site has more ads than content that I specifically want. If I had to sit through a 10s ad to see a 90m movie, I might do it. As it stands, right now on youtube, there is a 30s-60s ad shown between 5-minute videos.

So, when I am not using Firefox, I simply don't go to youtube.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @01:56PM (#46456894)
I don't know how much you can afford to pay. But I do know many users can afford to consume ads more than pay money.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by lelanthran on Friday January 02, 2026 @01:09AM (#46461918)
> I don't know how much you can afford to pay.

I didn't say anything about content I can afford to pay for. I am talking specifically about content that I am unwilling to pay for, yet am willing to put up with ads for.

Like I said in my previous post, the ratio matters a lot, here.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by barnabee on Thursday January 01, 2026 @10:12AM (#46454717)
To me this sounds like “can you not conceive of some content sufficiently valuable that you’d let someone get you addicted to their brand of cigarettes so you could get it for free”

If it’s that valuable, just let me pay a fair price to see it.

In general, I’d like to see personally targeted ads banned entirely and a legal requirement for a fairly priced (i.e. same order of magnitude as the lost ad revenue) ad free option.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @01:57PM (#46456901)
Ads are addictive?? News to me.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by plagiarist on Thursday January 01, 2026 @05:45AM (#46453011)
I would care if they were at all capable of respecting people who allow ads.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by delis-thumbs-7e on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:09AM (#46453159)
> Ads are content too, you know?

I agree. Why there isn’t this technology implemented on film streaming, movie theaters, even games? I think ebooks should stop you reading every five minutes just to show ads. I’m sure it could be implemented in to PDF pretty easily.

Internet and all medias point is to make money for jesus christ, what are we, a charity? Why don’t book publishers put ads into printed books, they are goving away content for free!

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by sznio on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:31AM (#46453596)
I'd be fine with a whole web free of revenue.

There would be much less stuff around, but what would stay is the things people created for fun, not for profit. SEO spam, AI slop - these are all solved by removing money from the web.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Friday January 02, 2026 @05:17AM (#46463356)
I doubt you'd say tha same about films and music. Why should the web be different?

Web ads exist because they are one option that serves the needs of content providers and consumers alike.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by appreciatorBus on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:26AM (#46453909)
If the content is so worthless that people will not voluntarily pay for it, then this outcome would be no great tragedy.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by chrisjj on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:10AM (#46454252)
People voluntarily pay by consuming the ads.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Gareth321 on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:51AM (#46454107)
But what would humanity do without garbage LLM content slop? How would we survive?
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by amanaplanacanal on Thursday January 01, 2026 @12:30PM (#46456012)
The content was better when it was posted by hobbyists for free than it is now posted by people trying to make money off of it. So... fuck 'em.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Yokohiii on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:35AM (#46453294)
It's so lazy and dumb. The wildest thing about it, is that they could mostly delay required cookies to the second contact, first interaction or at the time it's actually required. Raw first contact engagement can be tracked cookieless.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by k__ on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:45AM (#46453363)
Brave made this more bearable for me, by blocking cookie banners by default.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by MetaWhirledPeas on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:47AM (#46453371)
Ad delivery services don't care about the user experience because it's not their site, so anything goes. The host justifies their decision because hey, look, money. That money is quantifiable while user experience is less so.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by kamma4434 on Thursday January 01, 2026 @07:54AM (#46453727)
Speaking for myself only, but I find it easier to click ‘back’ than waste time on my ‘consent’.

Lately, I’m asking some llm to fetch it and summarize, so the one sentence content that was expanded into a full page article goes back to its original form.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by cheschire on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:57AM (#46454148)
I’ve noticed some LLMs lately aren’t pulling the page and try guessing the content from URL SEO.