News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Pebble Device by pedalpete on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @04:57PM (#46211289)
We regularly get contacted by people in Europe who want to buy our product, but we haven't been providing support due to the cost of certs, and other regulatory needs (medical/wellness device).

We want to help people in the EU, but with laws like replaceable batteries, it's going to push us further and further away from being able to do that.

Our product is designed to be refurbished, but not user-replaceable.

At the same time, how many products do people give up on because of battery life, and is this a non-issue with future battery chemistries?

Do people replace their phones because the battery isn't good anymore, or is it more likely they've broken the screen, cameras, etc to the point where it doesn't make sense to replace those anymore? Or they just want the newest thing?

Re:New Pebble Device by wkat4242 on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @08:02PM (#46212807)
> Do people replace their phones because the battery isn't good anymore, or is it more likely they've broken the screen, cameras, etc to the point where it doesn't make sense to replace those anymore? Or they just want the newest thing?

This is why repairability isn't restricted to just the battery. And buying the newest thing every year is kinda frowned upon here in the EU now. I'm sure some people still do it but most people aren't flashing their new phone around anymore. And phones have become boring anyway. The latest Samsung S25 is mostly the same as the S23, exact same form factor, cameras. Just a bit faster and a bit more memory.

But the government sets a baseline here to stimulate sustainability. I really agree with it, this planet has to be usable for a lot longer. And economic growth isn't everything.

We have to move away from consumerism for the sake of it and I think we're making good inroads here in the EU. Not to mention it means there's more money left over for important stuff like doing things with friends.

Re:New Pebble Device by lurk2 on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @08:46PM (#46213101)
> And buying the newest thing every year is kinda frowned upon here in the EU now.

Is there any evidence that Europeans aren’t buying new phones at the same rate that they used to?

Re:New Pebble Device by sho_hn on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @10:59PM (#46213933)
Some sources say so, e.g. "Declining Replacement Cycles Among Consumers" on https://www.marketdataforecast.com/market-reports/europe-sma...

And https://www.unibocconi.it/en/news/disposable-smartphones-tri... has replacement cycles in Italy going up.

Anecdotally, 2023/24 all media in Germany was full of ads for shops trading refurb phones. Most of those talked lower prices, but some mentioned sustainability.

Re:New Pebble Device by lurk2 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:04AM (#46214927)
The first article does not look to be informative; it values the EU smartphone market at around 465 million USD, which is impossibly low. If you assume a smartphone is valued at $1,000, a market of that size would only amount to 465,000 devices sold; this is around 0.01% of the EU’s population.

The second article links to a paper which appears to be more informative (though it has not been peer reviewed):

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5117319

Notably:

> For example, in the United States, the average expected life span (replacement cycle length) of consumer and enterprise smartphones was 2.67 and 2.54 years, respectively, in 2023, while in the UK almost 30% of surveyed consumers use their smartphone up to two years and 41% up to 4 years.

and

> Furthermore, evidence shows that European, American and Chinese consumers have reduced the replacement rate of their smartphones, increasing their average life cycle (see Figure 1). These data suggest that consumer preferences are changing, and new opportunities arise for companies who want to find new profitable ways to meet the needs of their customers.

Re:New Pebble Device by ZiiS on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:38AM (#46215147)
It is standard to list market size data in units of $1,000; i.e. that report is 465 billion USD.
Re:New Pebble Device by lurk2 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:36AM (#46215451)
Those numbers would be more realistic, amounting to around a thousand dollars spent per each EU citizen per year; this seems a little high if replacement rates are hovering around 3 years on average, but not impossible like the other figure.

What I don’t understand is why it would be written “USD 448.87 million.” This convention is common in accounting and finance as well, but they usually make an indication of it in a column header.

Re:New Pebble Device by poulpy123 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @06:49AM (#46216694)
> Is there any evidence that Europeans aren’t buying new phones at the same rate that they used to?

I bet it is the case, not because it is frowned upon, but because tpeople have less money, the prices of phone increased a lot and the increase of performance and usefulness is plateauing.

Re:New Pebble Device by carlm42 on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @07:40PM (#46212661)
So it's 2025 and we're building more disposable electronics? I'm sorry but I think the EU is not the problem here.
Re:New Pebble Device by blitz_skull on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @10:15PM (#46213580)
That's an unfair representation of the situation. There's nothing about this device that implies "disposable". The EU is definitely the problem here. I think the problem is the EU loves legislating entrepreneurial creativity into the dirt.
Re:New Pebble Device by sho_hn on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @10:53PM (#46213888)
Not having a replacable battery - a part that wears predictably and is critical to operation - makes this device disposable.

There's more important things than "entrepreneurial creativity". Not everything that can make sense as a business plan makes sense for the world.

We can survive without rings that allow us to mutter voice notes into our fists while walking around.

Re:New Pebble Device by nasmorn on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:28AM (#46215775)
It does not have a rechargeable battery. I could even understand non replaceable in this form factor.
Re:New Pebble Device by daenney on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @05:58PM (#46211897)
> We want to help people in the EU, but with laws like replaceable batteries, it's going to push us further and further away from being able to do that.

We want to help people, but only if and when it’s profitable for us to do so on terms we decide for you.

Re:New Pebble Device by protocolture on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @07:11PM (#46212457)
> A market doesnt want our products, we wont provide those products to that market.

The terms seem at least, largely influenced by the laws euros seem happy with. Regulation has a cost.

Re:New Pebble Device by littlestymaar on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:56AM (#46215951)
e-waste also have a cost.

And regulations are here to make businesses internalize this cost instead of letting society as a whole pay it out.

Re:New Pebble Device by mannykannot on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:36AM (#46217557)
Sometimes the cost is that there is no viable product.
Re:New Pebble Device by darkwater on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:55AM (#46218378)
And that is perfectly fine!
Re:New Pebble Device by graeme on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:25PM (#46221423)
That's not what a lot of proponents of these laws argue. They often state that if a company is making something unavailable in the EU due to one of the laws that the company is throwing a fit or being spiteful.
Re:New Pebble Device by darkwater on Thursday December 11, 2025 @04:40AM (#46229406)
And it's also probably true, especially for $MEGACORP. But in general the concept of this kind of laws, as others mentioned, it's to make companies internalize the whole cost of their product impact on the environment. It is GOOD if it drives the price up. At some point people will find it too expensive and they will simply not buy it because it's not worth the cost.
Re:New Pebble Device by protocolture on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:33PM (#46224901)
Yes its perfectly fine, thats my point. They arent spiting the EU, they are just responding to the legislation by not entering that market. If EU voters are unhappy they can take it up with their government.
Re:New Pebble Device by mannykannot on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:48PM (#46240687)
Yes, indeed! But I don’t think Daenney gets it.
Re:New Pebble Device by sequoia on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @06:54PM (#46212328)
> We want to help people, but only if and when it’s profitable for us

If s/he is running a company and not a charity, this is responsible, understandable, and predictable.

Re:New Pebble Device by Epa095 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:14AM (#46214999)
Yes, and that's exactly why we need regulations, and can't leave it to the market!
Re:New Pebble Device by bojan on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:53AM (#46215933)
Of course, but that makes "help" a weasel word. They want to be able to sell their product, that they possibly strongly feel will help the buyers.
Re:New Pebble Device by widowlark on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @06:05PM (#46211962)
This is, I believe, the definition of a free market choice
Re:New Pebble Device by fao_ on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @07:05PM (#46212404)
And this is why regulation exists, QED lol
Re:New Pebble Device by wkat4242 on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @08:07PM (#46212844)
Yes, a free market isn't the answer to everything. It will never optimise for sustainability unless this is a conscious consumer choice factor. It's way too important to leave it to that though. Hence regulation.
Re:New Pebble Device by flawn on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:18AM (#46215704)
Just change the underlying economic incentives - but nobody is even barely there yet, except maybe the EU. Doughnut Economics, when are you going to save us (& the planet)?
Re:New Pebble Device by mannykannot on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:46AM (#46217634)
Fair enough, and I agree that regulation is often needed, but we cannot, in general, expect it to have only the consequences explicitly sought.
Re:New Pebble Device by blitz_skull on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @10:16PM (#46213589)
Uh... yeah. It's called a business.
Re:New Pebble Device by maest on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @05:27PM (#46211586)
> Our product is designed to be refurbished, but not user-replaceable.

Why?

Re:New Pebble Device by bigiain on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @05:59PM (#46211908)
I'm not who you asked that question, but I'd guess it's because it requires "proprietary tools, thermal energy, or solvents to disassemble the product."

It'd be hard to design/manufacture a device that reliably remains waterproof after a typical not-specially-skilled owner opens it up to replace a battery. It's really common to hear of people damaging watches due to water ingress after battery replacements, getting seals or orings seated just right isn't something every user is going to be able to do.

I can imagine some medical devices have similar sealing requirements, perhaps even more robust sealing methods since they might need to be exposed to regular disinfection grade cleaning with chemicals harsher then just water. I could easily understand why a company may design a medical device that its heat-glued together for sealing purposes in a way that can only reasonably be done (and redone) at the factory.

I killed an original Pebble when I Dremelled it open to replace the battery, and failed to hot glue seal it well enough and it got wet inside.

Having said that - I dislike this design choice for the Index 01. I can see myself becoming reliant on this right before they sell out to Garmin or whoever and tell all their customers to FOAD again. Trust is very hard to win back.

Re:New Pebble Device by randallsquared on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:08AM (#46217860)
> I can see myself becoming reliant on this right before they sell out to Garmin or whoever and tell all their customers to FOAD again. Trust is very hard to win back.

This product is perfect for that case, though: you have to decide to buy another one each time the battery runs down, which aligns seller incentives with the user/purchaser. The danger cases are mainly when the seller gets up front money and then has to provide something indefinitely.

Re:New Pebble Device by Tempest1981 on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @05:45PM (#46211777)
Design inherently involves trade-offs. Size, weight, cost, water resistance, etc.
Re:New Pebble Device by lawn on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @08:00PM (#46212792)
I guess Core use the same excuse to only provide 30 day warranty, using a loophole to avoid the annoyance of having to provide a proper warranty?
Re:New Pebble Device by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @06:56PM (#46212350)
I may not be a typical user, but I've run my last few iphones and macbooks until the battery gave up the ghost. I haven't really needed more features or raw horsepower for quite some time, so the battery ends up being the limit I hit.
Re:New Pebble Device by leephillips on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @07:37PM (#46212636)
I use Android, but this is me, too. I keep it until the battery goes bad or until it breaks.
Re:New Pebble Device by dandellion on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:21AM (#46216126)
In my last two phones I had to replace the battery 2 and 4 years in. One because it swelled, the other because it couldn't hold charge. Both cases I got a few extra years of usage from the phone. I'm in the EU, and I support this sort of regulation.
Re:New Pebble Device by torton on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @09:38PM (#46213399)
iPhones and MacBooks can be serviced to replace the battery.

My iPhones typically get a fresh battery around the 3-year mark, or whenever the battery health dips below 80%, and do a second tour of duty with someone in the family. In all cases so far, the OS goes out of support and apps stop working before the second battery degrades.

Re:New Pebble Device by fragmede on Thursday December 11, 2025 @04:11AM (#46229209)
fwiw, Al dente on macOS will help your battery live longer
Re:New Pebble Device by daemonologist on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @11:01PM (#46213941)
Speaking personally, I've never broken/damaged a phone. Since the Pixel 1 started requiring removal of the screen in order to swap the battery, 100% of my phone replacements have been because the battery isn't good anymore. (Granted, I would've gotten a new phone eventually regardless, when the old one stopped receiving security updates.)

Currently trying to stretch a Pixel 7 until 2027.

Re:New Pebble Device by littlestymaar on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:59AM (#46214912)
> (Granted, I would've gotten a new phone eventually regardless, when the old one stopped receiving security updates.)

And that's why the EU also mandate a 5-years software support period (and I wish it was even more).

Re:New Pebble Device by ra on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @12:47AM (#46214512)
Regs aside; I'd more likely be a buyer if you offered a discount on replacements when customer returns "years" old expired ring.
Re:New Pebble Device by Loic on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:12AM (#46214986)
My personal experience: Electric toothbrush and razor. I especially hate the razors, you can replace the head, they could last a lifetime, but the battery is practically dead after two years. Toothbrushes are improving, the last one has 3 years of service and still work ok.
Re:New Pebble Device by yencabulator on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:07PM (#46234815)
I'm using an Oral-B electric toothbrush from 2009. The (non-replaceable) battery needs to be charged about every 3-5 days now, which is not a problem because it sits in its charging stand every night.

My wife bought some cheap electric toothbrush that runs on AA batteries, which can be rechargeable and have a lifespan independent of the gadget.

Re:New Pebble Device by atwrk on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:19AM (#46215719)
BTW this also works the other way: I find myself to avoid US products more and more because they tend to come with inbuilt obsolescence, or, for digital products, with dark patterns preventing subscription cancelling.
Re:New Pebble Device by julian_t on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @06:28AM (#46216559)
> Do people replace their phones because the battery isn't good anymore

Yes. I'm not bothered about the latest thing, and every phone I've replaced has been because of two things: the battery has degraded until it's unacceptable, or it no longer gets OS updates.

Re:New Pebble Device by poulpy123 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @06:53AM (#46216721)
> We regularly get contacted by people in Europe who want to buy our product, but we haven't been providing support due to the cost of certs, and other regulatory needs (medical/wellness device).

I understand your point but being safe is not an option

> Do people replace their phones because the battery isn't good anymore

I just had to change the battery of my phone, and I wish that it would have been just a swap to do. Actually because it wasn't, I add to buy a temporary phone the time I needed to have the parts and the tools

Re:New Pebble Device by swiftcoder on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @07:27AM (#46216952)
> Do people replace their phones because the battery isn't good anymore

Pretty much exclusively? The last 4-5 iPhone purchases in my family have all been due to dying batteries (plus a couple of off-brand battery replacements by local cellphone techs).

Nothing else on iPhones really ever breaks, provided you keep some sort of case on it. The only non-battery failure I've ever had was a corroded lightning port (on a iPhone that was regularly used in a salt-chlorine swimming pool). And of course a couple of replacements due to critical banking apps that have drop support for old iOS versions...

Re:New Pebble Device by losvedir on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:33AM (#46217522)
And what did you do with them? Throw them away? I bought and used an iPhone 11 for a year last year, and it came with a perfectly functional, replaced battery.

People on HN have such a blind spot around old, used phones which thrive in secondary marketplaces. You'd think iPhones are filling dumpsters with the rhetoric here but they actually hold their value remarkably well, which means they have a much longer useful life. A replaceable battery is different from a user-replaceable battery. The former is a sustainability concern, the latter is just a feature.

Re:New Pebble Device by swiftcoder on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:35AM (#46218871)
> And what did you do with them? Throw them away?

The ones that aged out of running needed software are still sitting in a cabinet somewhere. A couple of the others were killed off when their battery pack swelled, and another didn't survive a local tech's efforts to replace the battery...

With batteries that could be replaced without delaminating the whole device, (and ideally, an open boot loader), I'd be able to make use of most of them.

Re:New Pebble Device by dangus on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:14AM (#46217311)
I’m playing my tiny violin right now for your pain.

It’s so tragic that people can’t buy your product that will end up in a landfill.

Maybe we don’t have to focus society so much on buying products? What a wild concept.

Re:New Pebble Device by embedding-shape on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:17AM (#46217340)
Yeah, reading this part:

> We want to help people in the EU, but with laws like replaceable batteries, it's going to push us further and further away from being able to do that.

All I could think of was "Wow, the regulation works better than expected".

It's incredible the other side think of themselves as "We want to help people in this environment we don't understand, but receiving pushback" and yet they don't want to adjust, no, it's the environment that is wrong, even if it's built up by people.