News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by binary132 on Thursday November 27, 2025 @10:47PM (#46075333)
Huh. I don’t know if I’m picking up what they’re putting down here, but it kind of sounds like suppressing fever e.g. with Tylenol would actually be bad for (normal) flu progression.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by kruffalon on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:41PM (#46075564)
Well, yes?

Very simplified... It is a suppressor of symptoms like pain and fever which are the bodies way of letting you know something is damaged and killing off unknown foreign bodies respectively.

Suppressing symptoms does not remove the cause and is not a cure.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by Dusseldorf on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:18AM (#46075739)
I think what they're saying here is that you're not just suppressing a symptom, you're suppressing a sickness fighting mechanism.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by parineum on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:36AM (#46075807)
He said that.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by dboreham on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:50AM (#46075872)
Fever isn't just a symptom. It's a defense mechanism. The idea is that use of antipyretic drugs may make the infection worse.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by querez on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:47AM (#46076465)
The sentence is constructed, weirdly, but it's meant to say that fever is "killing off unknown foreign bodies"
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by jibal on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:46AM (#46076829)
Pain being a way to let you know that something is damaged is close to true--close enough not to quibble with. But fever is not a way to let you know that foreign bodies are being killed off--that's his claim, and it's wrong.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by Ukv on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:30AM (#46078457)
> But fever is not a way to let you know that foreign bodies are being killed off--that's his claim, and it's wrong.

querez's point is that the sentence is meant to be parsed as:

> pain and fever which are the bodies way of <<letting you know something is damaged>> and <<killing off unknown foreign bodies>> respectively

So the claim is that fever is the body's way of killing off unknown foreign bodies, not the body's way of letting you know something is killing off unknown foreign bodies.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by kruffalon on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:44AM (#46078570)
Correct!

I will edit my previous comment to make it more clear.

(Edit: Nvm, I'm not able to edit that comment any more, I've still not understood the edit-function here)

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by jibal on Saturday November 29, 2025 @06:36PM (#46091900)
The fact that one can ferret out what someone perhaps meant to say from what they did say doesn't change the fact that what they did say was wrong, and can be rightly criticized for being wrong. Someone else responded to such a criticism by writing "He said that" -- but that is false.

And I would make the point that these two things are not analogous, so they shouldn't be mentioned together in any case. The response to the misstatement that started this subthread was "I think what they're saying here is that you're not just suppressing a symptom, you're suppressing a sickness fighting mechanism", which is exactly right, along with a subsequent statement "Fever isn't just a symptom. It's a defense mechanism. The idea is that use of antipyretic drugs may make the infection worse" and which the misstatement completely muddies. It's weird how some people who didn't even make the misleading misstatement are so desperately trying to defend it for no good reason, while others are rationally pointing out how the statement is off the mark. Even with the edit, the statement serves no purpose, mixing up symptoms like pain that guide us psychologically with autonomic immune system responses.

I will say no more about this dead horse.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by Ukv on Saturday November 29, 2025 @08:10PM (#46092518)
> The fact that one can ferret out what someone perhaps meant to say from what they did say doesn't change the fact that what they did say was wrong, and can be rightly criticized for being wrong.

kruffalon said something ambiguous, with the intended interpretation (of that ambiguous part) being true and a secondary unintended interpretation being false - both interpretations grammatically valid.

querez tried to clarify the misinterpretation being made, but it looked as though their point was missed so I made it more explicit.

> It's weird how some people who didn't even make the misleading misstatement are so desperately trying to defend it for no good reason

I just saw some confusion so chimed in to try to clear it up. Only motive is that I feel like it's useful in a discussion for people to know what others mean, rather than arguing against a phantom point caused by miscommunication.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by throwaway290 on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:50PM (#46075609)
I know someone who doesn't get fever. When he gets sick with regular cold or fly it's much longer and worse than for anyone else I know.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by nradov on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:57AM (#46075906)
Most people don't get a significant fever when infected with most common cold viruses.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by throwaway290 on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:52AM (#46077213)
"Regular cold or flu"

if I wasn't clear he basically does not get fever that's just it, the body don't do it.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by Tor3 on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:59AM (#46076538)
You usually don't get a fever from a cold (except in Japanese anime), if there's a significant fever it's more likely to be a flu. Or, these days, could be Covid.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by wombatpm on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:34AM (#46075795)
Our pediatrician didn’t want us to give Tylenol unless the fever was over 99.5 and not to bring them in unless it was over 101 with Tylenol.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by jeroenhd on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:04AM (#46075946)
Fever helps against all kinds of illnesses but it can also be deadly, so having fever reducting medicine around is a smart precaution IMO. If you're otherwise healthy and are dealing with a mild seasonal infection and have got something important going on, I can see why people would choose to reduce symptoms at the cost of taking longer to recover.

Lots of people go overboard with this, though, like taking flu reduction medicine with every single cold or using medication to go to work sick. American media seems especially accepting of people taking "flu medicine" over rest and recovery.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:58AM (#46076902)
> Lots of people go overboard with this, though, like taking flu reduction medicine with every single cold or using medication to go to work sick. American media seems especially accepting of people taking "flu medicine" over rest and recovery.

This is not specific to America; it's a thing in the entire Western world, and probably beyond. Because it's not like we have any other choice.

There is no slack in the system. Most people can't afford to have more than a few sick days in a year, and they prefer to save those up for when painkillers and cough medicine don't cut it anymore. Same with children, because a sick child staying home is usually equivalent to the parent taking a sick day themselves - either way, they're not at work.

We can talk about media or people going overboard once it becomes acceptable to skip work for a week because of sick kid, or in order to not get everyone in the office sick too.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by kace91 on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:53AM (#46077224)
>Most people can't afford to have more than a few sick days in a year

Sick days are unlimited in my country (and of course don’t count as vacation or similar).

I think this is relatively standard for European countries, though not 100% sure.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:13AM (#46078813)
They may be on paper, but I can't imagine taking one every time you have a runny nose or a sore throat. Everyone from your employer to social insurance[0] will start looking at you funny. It's just unexpected, even though it's how you're supposed to be handling infectious diseases to prevent spread.

--

[0] - Or whoever is backing the free healthcare in your country.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by kace91 on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:40PM (#46082053)
Yes, that much is true. Remote working for those in between cases is accepted, but it does reduce the practice to the luckier subset of office workers.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by tarsinge on Friday November 28, 2025 @06:50AM (#46077817)
But flu isn’t just a cold, it’s a serious disease. If they are sick to the point they have fever then they can’t really afford to not rest as it has a cost in the form of longer health debt. And even short term, by letting the fever run and resting and being 100% operational can be more productive than being a zombie on medications for weeks.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by m4rtink on Friday November 28, 2025 @07:40AM (#46078131)
Not to mention it is an infections disease that they will spread to other people if they go to work.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:11AM (#46078794)
By the time they can tell it's "the flu" and not just "a cold", they've been infecting everyone for days already.

Not to mention, cold is an infectious disease too (it's literally the same disease, just a weaker variant caused by strains that evolved their potency away), it too will spread to other people if they go to work.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by dragonwriter on Friday November 28, 2025 @11:52AM (#46080335)
> Not to mention, cold is an infectious disease too (it's literally the same disease, just a weaker variant caused by strains that evolved their potency away)

“The cold” is actually any of a wide variety of different viral diseases (caused by various forms of rhinovirus, coronavirus [0], and, I think, a few other kinds of viruses), none of which are flu (influenza virus). It is not a less potent flu.

[0] so calling COVID-19 “a bad cold” is correct from a certain point of view, despite being substantively misleading.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:46PM (#46080899)
Fair, I was under the impression that some strains of influenza viruses are in the mix too, but apparently they're distinct and not part of the cocktail (surprising, given how the other viruses found themselves bucketed like this - they evolved to lose potency over time; I'd expect influenza strains would be on the same trajectory).

Still, my main point holds - you usually can't tell by symptoms alone, whether it's a common cold or a flu. In case you get severe symptoms, by the time you can, you've already been infectious for some time. So either way, the right time to call in sick is when you first notice the early symptoms - stuffy/runny nose, cough, headache, elevated body temperature. But obviously nobody does that, because it would mean calling in sick at random a dozen or more times per year.

Post-lockdown COVID was the only time I know of in the last few decades, and a brief time indeed, when it was socially acceptable to react to potential symptoms at the right time.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by andor on Friday November 28, 2025 @11:41AM (#46080207)
Some people colloquially call a cold "the flu", but the common cold is very different to influenza. Please don't spread misinformation.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:08AM (#46078772)
"Common cold" is what we call flu/COVID/bunch of other stuff when symptoms aren't severe enough to bother checking. There is no "cold virus", as cold isn't a specific sickness but a destination; it's a catch-all for respiratory pathogens that evolve their potency away.

By the time someone is able to tell they have "the flu", they should've been on a sick leave for 2-3 days already.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by helij on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:30PM (#46080735)
People mix common cold with flu all the time. If you have the flu you usually can't even go out of bed, even with medication.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by benterix on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:49AM (#46078619)
> Most people can't afford to have more than a few sick days in a year

I believe it's true in the USA, but not necessarily in Europe. It's quite normal that you have two infections a year, plus sometimes your kid catches something at a completely different time, so the law protects you in these situations.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:02AM (#46078720)
Yes, but there's what the law says, and there's process, and there's expectations.

You can't just take a legal sick day each time you have a runny nose (good luck finding a doctor that fast), and even if you could, you'd quickly stand out. "Two infections a year" is an average for adults who power through remaining ones with painkillers and cough meds; if they didn't, we'd be talking 5+, probably closer to 10 if they have kindergarten-age kids.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by basisword on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:02PM (#46080444)
It sounds like you just have a terrible employer. If I get the flu, I'm taking a few days off. If I feel poorly, I'm not working. Never been a problem with any employer. 5-10 sicks days a year is completely normal. You cannot be fired for this.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:51PM (#46080939)
If you get the flu, and know it's a flu, you're a few days too late to take sick leave for it to be useful at preventing infecting your co-workers.

5-10 days of sick leave a year is perfectly normal, because that's how much people need to cover serious infections that cannot be easily powered through with meds.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by jeroenhd on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:05PM (#46081705)
Sounds like you have a pretty terrible employer. Of course there's an expectation that you're not taking sick leave for every minor cough or sniffle, but "powering through" infections is pretty absurd to expect from your employees.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by tayo42 on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:21AM (#46076046)
> like taking flu reduction medicine with every single cold or using medication to go to work sick.

Basically how I grew up. I took painkillers and throat lozenges in my backpack to school.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by ehnto on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:36AM (#46076116)
Due to a condition I was born with, I was raised the opposite. No over the counter medication my entire life, with some exceptions. I usually decline pain management in ER, for things like broken bones, but for surgeries and stuff of course I have no choice as I go under.

I will take what the doctor orders though, to treat illness and conditions though thankfully at this stage there hasn't been many instances. Usually that's antibiotics.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by srean on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:08AM (#46076961)
Broken bones? A broken femur or a shin is hell.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by ehnto on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:40AM (#46077139)
Yeah it was pretty painful at first and at different times. Never like in tears pain though, just very distracting. I have broken two fingers and two collarbones, at different times, and a toe! Both collarbones were fully smashed to bits but did not pierce the skin, I had bruising for months.

I have an above average tolerance but I think what really helps is pain management techniques, which I believe can help all of us at different times of need. Chronic pain is a bitch, which I have, and not everyone has pain that is reasonably manageable, but even prescribed pain meds are really going to mess with you and I think it is worth avoiding if possible and not inhumane.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by srean on Sunday November 30, 2025 @08:30AM (#46096486)
Is higher tolerance to pain even a real thing ?

I have been told that I have that, but I don't think it feels any less painful. It's not possible to know. I feel I am just a little accepting of it.

Broken femur is almost a different league though.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by ehnto on Monday December 01, 2025 @10:49PM (#46117292)
I have the same thought, it must be as it's accounted for in medical practice, but also how would I know? I only have my subjective experience to go by.

I think it is important to accept everyone's own experience of their pain though, I have no idea what someone else is feeling even if I have experienced the same event. Their experience and what they feel could be vastly different, our nervous systems behaving vastly different. It is not a morale failing to feel and be affected by pain.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by srean on Tuesday December 02, 2025 @04:41AM (#46119437)
Indeed.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by lqet on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:59AM (#46076231)
It may go further than that:

> Fever is used by organisms as diverse as fish, amphibians, reptiles and mammals (see for reference Basu and Srivastava, 2003). Since fever is metabolically expensive, it must provide substantial advantage to the host. Surprisingly little is known about immunological effects mediated by fever, a lack of understanding that might be attributable in part to the common ignorance in clinical practice with respect to benefits fever might provide. Post-operative infections can be prolong survival: patients developing empyema after lung cancer surgery have improved 5-year survival (50% (n = 18) vs 22% (n = 411)) (Ruckdeschel et al, 1972). In this light, it seems unfortunate that fever is usually suppressed in hospital routine.

> The phenomenon of spontaneous regression and remission from cancer has been observed by many physicians and was described in hundreds of publications. However, suggestive clues on cause or trigger are sparse and not substantiated by much experimental evidence. [...] At least in a larger fraction of cases a hefty feverish infection is linked with spontaneous regression in time and is investigated as putative trigger.

> Professor Busch in 1868 introduced the infection of cancer patients by purpose as a novel strategy to treat cancer. He achieved a dramatic regression with his first patient using live Streptococcus pyogenes bacteria, the pathogen leading to erysipelas, published in the German Journal ‘Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift’ (Busch, 1868). Beginning in 1891, this strategy was exploited by Coley, who had some reading knowledge of German (Hall, 1998). Coley systematically applied Streptococcus pyogenes extracts – later called ‘Coley’s toxin’ – to cancer patients and achieved a remarkable rate of regressions. A retrospective compilation of cases considered inoperable at the time of treatment between 1891 and 1936, which was conducted by Wiemann and Starnes (1994, Table 2), determined a remission rate of 64% (108/170) and a 5-year survival rate of larger than 44%. Coley used to inject his extract once or twice a week over a period ranging from a few weeks to several months. His method became quite famous and was tested on hundreds of patients by him and contemporary physicians, but overshadowed by the development of X-ray treatment which was regarded to be much more powerful and of broader applicability.

> Since cancer is usually a slowly progressing disease with occasionally long periods of dormancy, putative beneficial fever effects should also precipitate as preventive efficacy. This can indeed be found. In a cohort of 603 melanoma patients compared to 627 population controls, an inverse correlation was found between melanoma risk and number of recorded infections on the one hand and between melanoma risk and fever height on the other hand, leading to a combined reduction of melanoma risk of about 40% for people with a history of three or more infections with high fever above 38.51C (Koelmel et al, 1999). Mastrangelo et al (1998) report a striking inverse correlation between the number of infections and mortality from tumours in Italy in the period 1890 –1960: every 2% reduction in the number of infectious diseases was followed by a 2% increase in tumours about 10 years later.

https://www.nature.com/articles/6602386.pdf

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16444847/

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by bee_rider on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:12AM (#46076286)
It is, as others have pointed out.

Although, we’re very unusual humans in the grand scheme of things. So using medication might be reasonable. The brain might start taking damage around 104F. That was probably a good tradeoff for a peasant farmer (our ancestors, on average). Most of us nowadays just think for a living, not such a good tradeoff for us. Take the fever suppressant, what’s the worst that’ll happen if you miss an extra day of work?

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by Amezarak on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:47AM (#46078606)
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by euroderf on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:47AM (#46076466)
You want your immune system to simmer, not to boil.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by beAbU on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:15AM (#46076639)
It's a fairly common notion to "sweat out" a flu. Stay in bed, wrap yourself up in lots of blankets and just sweat the damn thing out. High body heat kills the virus.

So it would make sense that drugs like tylenol/paracetamol would make you feel better, but would keep the flu alive in you for longer.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by adrian_b on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:42AM (#46076804)
Anecdotally, I have used this technique many times, also drinking hot tea besides being wrapped in blankets, and at least for me it has worked much better than when taking any kind of antipyretics.

There are cases when the fever is dangerously high and antipyretics are necessary. But when the fever is supportable it certainly accelerates the healing.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by 01100011 on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:22AM (#46076683)
Copying Google AI's response here as it's at least as good as what I was going to recall:

> Fever is a key part of the innate immune system, acting as a protective response to infection by raising the body's temperature. This increase in temperature inhibits the growth of many pathogens, enhances the activity of immune cells like leukocytes, and improves the effectiveness of the adaptive immune response.

My Vietnamese in-laws commonly make a sweat tent to shorten the duration of sickness. I can't say if it works, but it's something I intend to try next time I'm sick.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by dabber21 on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:04AM (#46076933)
When I feel like I have a virus I usually put on my hoody which I only wear when I feel ill and a scarf and before going to bed I drink a lot of herb or ginger tea (like two cans)

this is will heat up your body and you get some night sweats, this usually helps reducing the sick time.

I can't say if it actually helps, but its become a ritual for that occasion

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by rkuska on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:00AM (#46077252)
That's what we do here (Czech republic), we don't take meds until the fever goes over 39°C (above 40 you are looking for trouble). You lay in bed and drink enough to compensate for sweating. My grandma would make you onion tea.
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by tarsinge on Friday November 28, 2025 @06:28AM (#46077697)
Isn’t it common knowledge that adults heal quicker with higher fever, and that suppressing fever is needed only if it reaches dangerous levels (in contrast to children where fever can be dangerous at lower levels)?
Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by Amezarak on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:43AM (#46078565)
This is common old wive's tale. Fever itself is not dangerous in adults or children.

https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/127/3/e20103...

> There is no evidence that children with fever, as opposed to hyperthermia, are at increased risk of adverse outcomes such as brain damage.10,12,24–26 Fever is a common and normal physiologic response that results in an increase in the hypothalamic “set point” in response to endogenous and exogenous pyrogens.12,26 In contrast, hyperthermia is a rare and pathophysiologic response with failure of normal homeostasis (no change in the hypothalamic set point) that results in heat production that exceeds the capability to dissipate heat.12,26 Characteristics of hyperthermia include hot, dry skin and central nervous system dysfunction that results in delirium, convulsions, or coma.26 Hyperthermia should be addressed promptly, because at temperatures above 41°C to 42°C, adverse physiologic effects begin to occur.10,12,27 Studies of health care workers, including physicians, have revealed that most believe that the risk of heat-related adverse outcomes is increased with temperatures above 40°C (104°F), although this belief is not justified.7,26,28–30 A child with a temperature of 40°C (104°F) attributable to a simple febrile illness is quite different from a child with a temperature of 40°C (104°F) attributable to heat stroke.

You cannot get a dangerously high fever. You can get a dangerously high body temperature from heat stroke, or I suppose you could have some rare hypothalmic disease. But fever as an immune response is not dangerous to adults or children.

Re:Bird flu viruses are resistant to fever, making them a ma... by amypetrik8 on Friday November 28, 2025 @10:54PM (#46085067)
kind of sounds like suppressing fever e.g. with Tylenol would actually be bad for (normal) flu progression.

you're just the tip of the iceberg my friend - did you know "horse dewormer" ivermectin has long been given to humans - for decades - to treat parasitic infections?