News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by adrr on Thursday October 23, 2025 @09:43PM (#45689806)
Gambling mechanics for anyone under 18 should be banned. Children can't buy lottery tickets or hit tables in Vegas. Its crazy they can buy loot boxes that real life value.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by mrheosuper on Thursday October 23, 2025 @10:48PM (#45690201)
But children can buy a cereal box that has some "rare" card.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Retric on Thursday October 23, 2025 @11:00PM (#45690286)
Being virtual or not doesn’t matter here, ban it all.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by smt88 on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:21AM (#45691040)
Close to 0% of children do their own grocery shopping and buy their own boxes of cereal
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by jimmydorry on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:53AM (#45691261)
And close to 0% of children have credit cards to buy these virtual lootboxes. These mechanisms prey on getting children to beg their parents to spend money.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by smt88 on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:00AM (#45691689)
They don't have to ask their parents first. The parents can link cards. One example, of many: https://www.techspot.com/news/98980-13-year-old-spent-64000-...
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lanfeust6 on Friday October 24, 2025 @08:07AM (#45693784)
This just another way of saying their parents allowed it
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by smt88 on Friday October 24, 2025 @09:33AM (#45694457)
It's completely different in practice. A child can't buy $50,000 of cereal in an afternoon.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lanfeust6 on Friday October 24, 2025 @10:55AM (#45695291)
In practice a parent can easily forego allowing their children to make unsupervised purchases linked to the parent's card! That seems absolutely crazy.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by mrheosuper on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:38AM (#45691561)
And 0% of children having credit card to buy lootbox (My country requires you to be over 18 to have one)
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lurk2 on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:03AM (#45692108)
A lot of gas stations and retail stores sell prepaid credit cards as well as gift cards that you can buy with cash.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lanfeust6 on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:00AM (#45695360)
Why should kids be walking around with large bills? Any parent worth their salt knows this could be exchanged for drugs and alcohol just as easily.

None of this makes sense. Some parents aren't doing their jobs.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by leoedin on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:20AM (#45691827)
You can have a debit card in the UK as a fairly young child. I think I got one at 12? I don’t know if there’s specific restrictions on buying in-game currency with them? I don’t know how they’d know though.

The first thing I did when I got a debit card was buy the 18 rated GTA Vice City!

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by trinix912 on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:26AM (#45691862)
Ever heard of PaySafe "cards"? Every single kid here uses that.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lanfeust6 on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:01AM (#45695367)
Who gave them the money for the cards?
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by trinix912 on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:33PM (#45697018)
Grandma for Christmas? Really, have you never been a child? They obviously didn’t get it for that specific purpose, that’s for sure.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lanfeust6 on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:35PM (#45698776)
Yes, and I never ran around with cash. Supposing I did get a cash gift before my teens, it would just sit in the "bank" i.e. a box in the dresser. Of course there were no gift cards or any of that crap back then, which is what you'd expect to receive today. I mean, as an adult now, what are you likely to receive: a gift card from a relative, or cash?

There's zero reason for a child to carry cash for no purpose. At any rate their lives are so structured usually that this notion that they're going to run to some store to convert it to prepaid cards is far-fetched to begin with.

I see a failure of parenting that some don't want to give credence. I'm not sure why.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by trinix912 on Saturday October 25, 2025 @04:41AM (#45702271)
So we should be locking kids out of the entire cash economy instead of just banning gambling microtransactions in games?

Btw. here they might need cash to take the bus home. And yes, people here let kids do that alone. Maybe because we live in a civilized society, who knows.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lanfeust6 on Sunday October 26, 2025 @09:26AM (#45711686)
> So we should be locking kids out of the entire cash economy instead of just banning gambling microtransactions in games?

Yes, but not "instead". Regulate microtransactions, as we do any form of actual gambling.

> Btw. here they might need cash to take the bus home.

Bus pass.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by msh on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:17AM (#45691807)
Where I am from kids can get a debit card that can be used online at age 13.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by smt88 on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:59AM (#45691682)
Their parents link the cards. Kids can buy things without consulting a parent each time.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by mrguyorama on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:01PM (#45696600)
Steam has giftcards you can buy at any store with your birthday cash.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by matwood on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:59AM (#45691299)
When I was a kid it was baseball cards.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by shlant on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:27AM (#45691483)
can't tell if this is sarcasm
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Xss3 on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:10AM (#45692543)
That should be banned too. Why are you defending it with a 'but'?
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by TheRoque on Thursday October 23, 2025 @10:28PM (#45690082)
FYI, this is already the case in some countries. In Belgium or Netherland, it's straight up banned, and in France we get an adapted case opening that looks less random (X-Ray: you see what's in the box before opening it, but you have to open it to X-Ray the next one)
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by gruez on Thursday October 23, 2025 @11:00PM (#45690288)
>and in France we get an adapted case opening that looks less random (X-Ray: you see what's in the box before opening it, but you have to open it to X-Ray the next one)

That still feels like gambling, but rather than gambling on what the current case contains you're gambling on the second one might contain.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by TheBicPen on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:03AM (#45690955)
And in France specifically, the first case you open is guaranteed to not be a good item. So it's essentially the same system but with an additional $2,50 entry fee
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Fade_Dance on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:36AM (#45691153)
I propose any company that flagrantly violates the intent of a ruling like that is sent to a special judge who operates in the same manner - bring forth a penalty while explicitly looking for every violation and arcane loophole to punish the company with.

It's "technically" just, after all.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by teiferer on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:01AM (#45691312)
You mean "special prosecutor". Judges don't try to find things, they only decide which of the parties before them claiming different things is right.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by pdw on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:08AM (#45691749)
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by jimnotgym on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:04AM (#45692491)
To save people opening the link...in France it would be a judge not a prosecutor. France has an Inquisitorial rather than the Adversarial legal system the UK and US have. Put simply, a judge doesn't merely decide between the two cases presented to them, they try and establish the facts

Edit: I said 'UK' where I should have said 'England and Wales'. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own legal systems, although I believe both have Adversarial systems they are different in some ways. The US system could, however, be seen as a continuation of the English system.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Fade_Dance on Friday October 24, 2025 @12:27PM (#45696217)
This is why HN is great. An immediate pivot to the technicalities and semantics of the French judicial system, off of a pithy comment.

eats baguette

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by sintax on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:21AM (#45691453)
I'll bet apple fan boys will agree to this statement for Valve or any other company, but when it comes to apple having to open up their walled garden in EU and then using every dirty trick in the book to make it impossible, oh boy...
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by rightbyte on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:21AM (#45691446)
Ye seems like not going with the spirit of the law. But the indirection has to remove alot of the gambling thrill though?
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by tdeck on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:29AM (#45691502)
This sounds like that betting game in the Stormlight Archives books that's meant to circumvent the religious prohibition on predicting the future.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by gquere on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:03AM (#45691712)
It doesn't "feel" like gambling, it's straight 100% the exact same thing but it's designed in a way that bypasses the legal words.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Xss3 on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:14AM (#45692566)
This. Valve won that case.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by modo_mario on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:25AM (#45692630)
I'd say it's designed to diminish the pyschological draw somewhat. Gambling is addictive precisely because that "the next one could be the one" element. I wouldn't be surprised if it has a big impact on sales.

That said i think it's still better to just ban it.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by beeflet on Thursday October 23, 2025 @10:11PM (#45689979)
they can buy pokemon cards. To be honest, I don't think CS:GO or TF2 or the like are pro-gambling. You learn pretty quickly as a kid that the best way to get good items is through trading, not gambling.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by episteme on Thursday October 23, 2025 @10:34PM (#45690113)
With the second best way being gambling. Doesn't really change anything.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by vincnetas on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:04AM (#45691721)
Where do the items used in trading come from? I guess Gambling.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by voidUpdate on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:05AM (#45691730)
I'm honestly really not a fan of the collectable trading card type of games (MtG, Pokemon TCG, yu-gi-oh etc). You have to pay to have a chance of getting a good card, which makes the whole thing pay to win. It should be perfectly acceptable to print off the cards at home ("proxies") so you can actually make a set that works for you, without having to pay more for having specific cards that you want to complete your ideal deck.

I personally often go to the huge bins of "shit tier" cards that my local game stores have, because I like to have some pretty cards (I often use them as bookmarks), but I don't play the game itself, so the actual mechanical value of the cards is meaningless to me

EDIT: I feel the same way about things like Warhammer. I don't know about other games, but in Warhammer at least there is a limit on how powerful an overall army can be, so sure it may not look as visually good, but just having tokens that say "squad of soldiers" or "mega death tank of doom" should be perfectly acceptable too

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by sjw987 on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:09AM (#45692528)
> It should be perfectly acceptable to print off the cards at home ("proxies") so you can actually make a set that works for you

Unless you play Pokemon TCG or MTG competitively at a national/international level, proxy cards are mostly accepted in the community.

More and more people recognise Nintendo and Wizards of the Coast (Hasbro) have money in their eyes in the card games. Pokemon cards are becoming more full-art because that's what sells for crazy markups on third party websites, and MTG are doing crossovers with whoever will sign them a license. They're both playing a risk by moving from old time players (many of whom are now leaving the hobbies) for the sake of some nostalgic "investors".

I just wish I had a local shop with a shitbin. The shops around me just sell packs (when not out of stock) and they're all marked up beyond MSRP. I just want to play the game. I don't care about art, holographic patterns and the like.

On the other hand, whenever people open packs just looking for collectable cards, they flood the market with job lots of regular cards at dirt cheap prices. I managed to get a joblot of 2500+ Pokemon TCG cards for around £20 (lots of duplicates, all regular).

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by gquere on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:17AM (#45691811)
Look at the "meta-"game mechanics: you play a few games, you get a guaranteed case drop. This circa $3 case could contain anything, a $0.2 skin or a rare $2500 knife. When you open it a casino-like wheel goes over all the items and selects one randomly. There are hundreds of YT/twitch channels that open cases all day long and their target audience is children. It's gambling, and it's gambling for children.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lurk2 on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:04AM (#45692118)
> You learn pretty quickly as a kid that the best way to get good items is through trading, not gambling.

Not if your dad is the one buying you the cards.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by alberth on Thursday October 23, 2025 @10:20PM (#45690037)
Would you consider old school coin operated arcades as something that should be banned?

Just curious.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by zharknado on Thursday October 23, 2025 @10:48PM (#45690207)
Not OP, but I would ban the tickets/prizes mechanism.

Depending on how old is “old school” for you, every game in an arcade might be fine.

If we’re talking 90’s Chuck E. Cheese, maybe half the games would be potentially interesting to play without a token payout. The others round to “roll the dice,” where there is no payoff other than a gambler’s variable reward.

I think this also covers whether skill is involved. Like for me, beating my buddy at basketball shots is mildly rewarding, but smashing a button at the right time is not very interesting even if it requires a lot of skill.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by vharuck on Thursday October 23, 2025 @11:00PM (#45690287)
I would like to see a ban on allowing children to play machines like the Wizard of Oz ones, where you drop the coin on a shelf in the hopes it'll push off other coins or cards you need to collect. It sounds like a skill game, and I liked them when I first saw them. But then I saw how people play them with vacant faces, like slot machines. They're casino games, not arcade.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by ad_hockey on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:22AM (#45692224)
They're an institution in the UK. They're in the arcades at every seaside town, and every kid plays them. Now that I have kids I actually think they're brilliant; for £2 each they taught mine everything they need to know about gambling.

- You sometimes win a bit along the way, but eventually you lose everything.

- The jackpot prizes are only there to lure you in, and you never win them. Towards the middle of the shelf are things like £20 notes. We noticed that one of them was getting quite near the edge, and might actually become winnable, but then the following morning its position had been reset to the back of the shelf.

- It's still fun as long as you're just playing with money you don't mind losing, and not expecting to come out ahead.

They even learned something about company scrip, from the tickets that come out of the machines and the ridiculous exchange rate between tickets and the actual rewards at the prize shop.

I asked my son on the way home if he'd put all his Christmas money and savings into the machine if I let him, and the answer was hell no - maybe a pound, but he didn't want to lose all of his money. Valuable lessons all round.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Ekaros on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:13AM (#45691387)
Pinball and video games I think are something that can be allowed. Even if the model is slightly predatory in this age. At least you only win game time.

Other types of partly fake skill games surely should be banned from kids. Like crane games where there is some hidden variable. And well anything in same category.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by trinix912 on Friday October 24, 2025 @03:29AM (#45691888)
It's not about banning paying to play games, it's about banning the gambling mechanics done through microtransactions.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by dandanua on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:18AM (#45691429)
Gambling mechanics is everywhere nowadays, especially in mobile games. It's almost like an industry standard. I think the only solution is to ban all in-game purchases completely.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by atraac on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:18AM (#45692203)
So we're against checking IDs cause privacy but we also want to limit kids from accessing certain parts of the internet because gambling/porn? Have a cake and eat a cake?
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by mosselman on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:26AM (#45692252)
How about no gambling at all? That would work for me.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Xss3 on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:09AM (#45692532)
This. It's predatory in every implementation.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by throwaway290 on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:50AM (#45695847)
but what about freedom
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Xss3 on Friday October 24, 2025 @09:25PM (#45700675)
It should only be criminalised as a business. Not between individuals participating in friendly wagers.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by walkabout on Friday October 24, 2025 @08:28AM (#45693945)
Yeah I used to be for it on grounds of liberty but having seen a little of the actual industry it’s just purely corrosive, evil shit. It should be fought.

I’d maybe be OK with some kind of well-thought-through thing that still allowed friendly poker matches or sports brackets between people who actually know each other, but got the big money out of it. Maybe just ban corporations from having anything to do with it so limited-liability and serious investment is taken off the table? Something along those lines? But it’s also bad enough that I’d definitely vote for an outright ban if it came up. Complete switch-around for me on this topic, from where I was on it for years.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by pessimizer on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:49AM (#45695835)
No casino gambling. Casino gambling is not gambling. It's putting $1.00 into a machine and getting $0.80 back, but the exact refund amount after every dollar put in is arbitrary. There's absolutely no risk to the casino, the casino is not gambling. The only gambling being done is by individual bettors, and they have an expected massive loss.

I don't care very much if people gamble with each other, and expect $1 back for every $1 they put in.* But casino games and lootboxes are specifically designed for consistent losses to the house. It's simply another tax, but on the addicted, desperate, and/or innumerate. The weakest people at their weakest moments; and if we're not protecting them, the government has no purpose.

* I actually think that it is good for people who have the same wealth levels to gamble with each other, as long as the outcomes are largely random. The problem is with vigs, and with pots that get too large to cover against a house that can endlessly extend itself.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by walkabout on Friday October 24, 2025 @01:38PM (#45697080)
Yeah, I think you nailed it. A ban on playing against "the house" would do it. Taking a fixed amount from each pot (as at poker tables) for play among patrons would still be allowed, but slot machines wouldn't. Your solution's much better than a full ban because it wouldn't drive as much illegal betting (a problem no only because it circumvents the law, but because for gambling in particular but for any black market, really, it tends to become connected with other criminal activity)
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by DonHopkins on Friday October 24, 2025 @05:23AM (#45692620)
The cake is a lie.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by lunar_rover on Friday October 24, 2025 @09:24AM (#45694372)
There are better ways to do this.

Enforce 18+ age rating and mandate platform parental controls. If the parents decide to let their child pay for adult content freely that's unfortunate and on them.

Going stricter isn't effective, ID check will become tools for whatever ulterior motives they have.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by mminer237 on Friday October 24, 2025 @10:00AM (#45694736)
CS:GO is already rated 18+, and Steam already has parental controls. That has done essentially nothing to prevent it as children sometimes lie about how old they are and don't have their parents set up parental accounts to oversee themselves.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by tonyhart7 on Friday October 24, 2025 @07:17AM (#45693415)
"Gambling mechanics for anyone under 18 should be banned."

its not gambling when you "can't" withdraw the money

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by SwtCyber on Friday October 24, 2025 @08:02AM (#45693750)
And it's more dangerous because it's targeting kids who don't fully understand the value of money
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Mistletoe on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:15AM (#45695522)
Even worse it creates adults that don't understand the value of money. Maybe that's why the laws against it are lax now that I think about it.
Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Der_Einzige on Friday October 24, 2025 @09:18AM (#45694322)
Where’s all the pearl clutching over scam ticket “games” at Dave and busters and chuckle-cheese?

The ticket conversion rate at these establishments is a worse scam than TF2 knife trading was until this update.

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by Waterluvian on Friday October 24, 2025 @10:51AM (#45695243)
There's something funny about how some countries try to enforce this and how Valve "solved" it, which I think demonstrates how silly "there ought to be a law!" thinking can get.

I believe for some regions, Valve just shows you what's in the "lootbox" (case, whatever), and you have to pay to acquire it before you're shown the next one.

This isn't to say I don't fully agree that this kind of thing is probably predatory and probably unhealthy. But I find most discourse on the topic starts and ends at the shoreline with a version of "there ought to be a law..."

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by llama_boy on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:25AM (#45695626)
As someone who moved to the UK I find it crazy that 2p machines exist. You put 2p in, and hope to get more out. It's literally child gambling. Where I come from we had arcades with tickets for stuff, but to me that's a whole different level to money in -> money out.

I still enjoy them though, but I enjoy gambling responsibly!

Re:Counter-Strike's player economy is in a multi-billion dol... by giobox on Friday October 24, 2025 @04:31PM (#45698749)
These machines exist a lot in the USA/other countries too, typically called a coin pusher:

> https://bhmvending.com/collections/coin-pushers

While it won't be true for all kids, personally I felt coin pushers taught me an important lesson about the drawbacks of gambling at a young age - it's obvious even to many children how rigged the penny pusher is. My own son had similar thoughts after a quick try of one too.