I suspect people don't really notice this as much because if you are familiar with regular manufacturers you are used to the price (well, the MSRP at least) staying rock steady for a year at a time. Tesla moves their prices around quite a lot by comparison, which can be very detrimental to the used market when it drops quickly.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1F5IQOynIawoXiJPVarLD...
This is definitely true, but it's funny how much hand-wringing is being done about those people, who already bought EVs and really don't need to replace them like 3-4 years into ownership (they might want to for vanity, but if so they're either rich or love wasting money).
"Destroyed resale value" is just another word for "provided amazing prices to a great used market." These "destroyed value" cars are great almost-new cars available at prices competitive with gas cars. In California with horrific electric rates, if I charge my used EV at the "non-peak" time it's like buying gas for my old car at 2.50/gal. In places with much better rates it's more like $1 a gallon. And these are cars that are now available for the same price as a comparable gas car. I'd say this is a huge win for everyone.
Electricity is around 18c/kwh overnight.
I can’t understand how gas cars get sold here anymore at all.
In the UK, you can get really cheap EVs because the china ev and battery market is open to them and their importers.
Further, because of the nature of both public transport and the city layout of the UK, there's much less of a need for long range EVs. Almost everything there is both walkable and within walking distance. It's very unlike the US.
I survived in the UK for 2 years on foot. It was really not that bad.
The Hyundai Kona Electric starts at £32,400. Which is ~$43,500 freedom bucks.
But there's very little reason why the majority of brits couldn't survive with the Dogood Zero which starts at £5,500 (and has a 50 mile range).
I ended up going with the RAV4. I just looked and the gas powered RAV4 is $29k, while the plug in hybrid model (toyota doesn’t do full EV) is $45k, so there is still a very big difference in price.
They do in other (non-US) markets, without subsidies.
PHEVs are a bad deal, always were. Only make sense if there's subsidies or tax advantages for buying them over pure combustion cars (unfortunately a thing in some markets). Most PHEVs are never charged and PHEV batteries are roughly 4x more expensive per kWh than EV batteries, so there is no cost benefit in the electric drivetrain.
It's true that I could choose more luxury or spaciousness on my ICE vs... well, everything else being better on the EV. But I wouldn't.
Much cheaper if you get a much smaller EV (which are much more available in the UK).
For example, the Dogood Zero uses 95Wh/mile which means $0.02/mile.
Most of EU cities have the same issues. Due to appartment density an EV makes sense only if you own your house, run a cable from your flat to the street, or win the charging lottery and/or fight for a spot at some shared location.
Alternatively you can make it a routine to charge at a public spot while you go shopping, but it means you're double annoyed when it doesn't work out for whatever reason (spots already taken etc)
Jan 2023 was when prices were slashed, and the $7,500 tax credit came in.
If I sell the car anytime soon it will definitely be the most I've ever "lost" on a car purchase. Oh well.
Fast forward to now it’s worth about 30% less but thats what I saved on fuel.
But in 2024 I bought a brand new Model Y for about $33k, after factoring in all the incentives/rebates. So if anything that $33k used price sounds high.
Reality is, prices came down a lot, and also depending on how incentives/rebates are factored in, the "sale price" might be fiction.
Same with other brands too. Back then you saw some companies like Hyundai claiming their EVs were really worth like $60k MSRP, and then turning around and leasing them for $300/month with $0 down. In some states people were leasing brand new EVs for $100/month with $0 down, or less.
Now with the federal rebate gone and states removing at least some of their incentives, the numbers might start to look a little more normal.
has TSLAQ ever been right? Maybe short term but never long term.
Any rational view of TSLA's business and future prospects suggests that TSLAQ is right, but that the timeline for proving it out may be extended (and there's a saying about that, right? Something about the market staying irrational longer than you can remain solvent). TSLA is a meme stock at this point. I wish it were not part of the S&P500, because I hate to be exposed to that volatility.
But I'm often wrong, so maybe this is yet another example.
I also love the excuse: “I’m right. I’m just not putting any money behind my conviction because the market might deviate from my truth.”
What is that “insight”, that “prediction” worth, if you can’t put money on it without going broke?
"Premium brands consistently retain higher resale value than mass-market brands, for both ICE vehicles and EVs. No one knows what entirely new Chinese marques will cost in the secondary market – for instance, what a 5-year-old Omoda will fetch"
Everything concrete in the article is about how Teslas, specifically, have precipitously declined in value, except for one paragraph about how nobody wanted to buy used vehicles from BluSmart (an Indian company that "collapsed in April amid financial fraud allegations").
I have been telling people, though, on the Model 3 forum that they should be leasing unless they are extremely sure they'll keep the car for a lot of years. Tesla's residuals have been way more optimistic than what the used car market suggested reality would look like. Only a problem if you sell at about three years, but maybe worth hedging your bets.
All the power to the people who love their Teslas, you do you.
Fortunately that has subsided a bit, I haven't heard as much chatter about it in the last few months. And anecdotally, there are still quite a lot of "just got my new Tesla" threads on the Model 3 subreddit -- I think sales totals have still been a disappointment, but they haven't tanked.
(hint: if even a small majority of them felt that way, there would have been many many orders of magnitude more incidents. more than any gap in reporting could cover. figure out where that narrative was born though.)
There a many (many) more people who are vocally anti-Tesla and not willing to damage cars, again, evidenced by the ratio of vocalized anti-Tesla sentiment to real incidents.
I don’t see what the Volkswagen Beetle has to do with EV reselling.
You may not like a lot of Elon's opinions (myself included), but he is far from a Nazi.
He is very much a Nazi sympathizer just like Ford was.
lmao no he hasn’t. Unbanning racists and being a free speech “absolutist” are mutually exclusive concepts here.
try not to overdose on that copium!
Regardless if you believe he actually believes in free speech absolutely... (what happened to the account that tracked his plane in real time? or if you want to move the goal posts, please define absolutist?)
He's parroted enough dog whistles that nazis love that it's fair to group him with the rest of the people who overly espouse nazism.
There's a difference between tolerating people who advocate for nazi ideals, and taking action to host, and more importantly amplify them. He proudly amplifies them. (and then tactically refuses to denounce them, please explain that behavior?)
When someone tells you who they are, you should believe them... and if they don't, you should judge them by the company they keep. I will gladly disavow anyone that advocates for racism or other bigotry, why won't you?
Is it in the public interest to know where his plane is? Given the recent high profile assassinations and attempts there's good reason against it at least.
> He's parroted enough dog whistles that nazis love that it's fair to group him with the rest of the people who overly espouse nazism.
> When someone tells you who they are, you should believe them
That was my point I was trying to deliver before...let people say what they want, then they can be challenged. There are plenty of platforms, including X where you can voice opposition. Unpleasant people aren't going to stop being unpleasant just because they are stopped from voicing their opinions.
Lmao, so he's a free speech absolutist but only if there's a public interest in it? And who gets to make that decision? I would gladly make the argument that as someone in control of a government agency, the public does have an interest.
But I don't even need to make that argument, anyone with the capability to act on up-to-date information isn't gonna get it from Twitter. Flight information is public, you can look up flight plans by tail number. Everyone else is just going to wait for a local public event, and the flight details become secondary to that.
But the point is he's not a free speech absolutist, defending him using that shows either a complete break from reality, or is itself a dog whistle.
> That was my point I was trying to deliver before...let people say what they want, then they can be challenged. There are plenty of platforms, including X where you can voice opposition. Unpleasant people aren't going to stop being unpleasant just because they are stopped from voicing their opinions.
There is a social cost to tolerating such behavior. A good society stops broken people from inflicting psychic damage on others. There's a huge difference between, it should be illegal to express some idea/meme, and everyone should happy to enable toxicity and bigotry, and host the content of those who want to hurt others.
That toxicity is what you're defending after all. With transparent ignorance to the specific behaviors and actions that occurred leading to rise of nazism in the past, you object to calling someone a nazi who protects them without overtly denouncing them, while also leaning in really hard into the coded language and dog whistles.
What do you call someone calls for the mistreatment of others based on some identity? A nazi. You might want to reserve that term only for overt attacks against a specific named religion, but to agree would demand ignoring reality. The poem "First they came", doesn't start with jews.
And what do you call someone who not just protects, but amplifies and eagerly aligns with the culture of racism and people who gladly accept the epithet of nazi? Most people would call them a nazi.
It's weird to object to someone calling him a nazi, while also trying to defend him using the free speech absolutist argument. You want people to be able to be freely judged based on their behavior, but then object when they're judged for said behavior?
There's an old saying: "If you're not outraged, you're not paying attention."
And you don't sound too outraged.
https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/06/ev-sales-slump-hertz-dump-ta...
Which is really weird isn't it? He did his best to help reduce America's debt while the Democrats do everything they can to increase it. Instead of showing appreciation, far left assholes attacked the Tesla brand, factories and Musk himself...for trying to help us get out of the deep debt hole we are in.
Folks really need to quit looking at these things in such a heavily politicized light. Because when we are biased toward thinking something is definitely good or definitely bad based purely on the party affiliation of the person who proposed the idea, that fundamentally undermines our ability to discern what is and is not actually working.
And also, frankly, all this stupid name calling is fucking stupid.
I’m so glad I managed to sell mine during Covid frenzy for $74k lol, in 2021
I’ll never buy a Tesla again. Only Ferrari and Mazda for me.
The reason they are getting killed, is because their products are now worse than the competition. They had a huge lead on everyone for years, then everyone caught up. Now you can get a car with the same range, with a HUD, with massaging chairs, with swivelling 360 seats... or you can get the same tesla car they've been making for 10 years.
Basically everyone I am close with is in the demographic Tesla targeted pre-rightening-of-Elon. All of them would’ve considered a Tesla at that point in time.
Now, none would. And of those with Teslas - very satisfied with their cars - none are replacing them with Teslas.
I just bought an Honda Pologue and didn’t even test drive a Model Y or X. We recently got solar installed in our house (also the right demographic for that…) and didn’t even look at quotes for Tesla systems.
Sure, I live in a left wing bubble, but it’s that same bubble that was (enthusiastically) Tesla’s prime demographic ten years ago.
Don’t forget to also deduct tax incentives from the original retail price. It’s not surprising that the used market would require that the used price be below the net original price.
> A U.K.-based study found 3-year-old EVs lost more than half of their value compared with 39% for gas cars.
so the difference isn't so stark as the F150 comparison
I want to suggest that there are recent reasons why Tesla, as a brand, has specifically gotten a bit less popular that are unrelated to the entire EV category. (It's Elon. He's the reason.)
That said, to the extent the result holds true for the entire category, I'd suspect it's because EVs are still fairly immature. It's like "resale value of desktop PCs falling rapidly" back in the 90s, when the field was advancing quickly enough that buying used was genuinely a bad idea.