"Today’s real chain: React → Electron → Chromium → Docker → Kubernetes → VM → managed DB → API gateways."
Like, yes, those are all technologies, and I can imagine an app + service backend that might use all of them, but the "links" in the chain don't always make sense next to each other and I don't think a human would write this. Read literally, it implies someone deploying an electron app using Kubernetes for god knows why.
If you really wanted to communicate a client-server architecture, you'd list the API gateway as the link between the server-side stuff and the electron app (also you'd probably put electron upstream of chromium).
API gateways -> Java servers -> JVM -> C/C++ -> Assembly -> machine code -> microprocessors -> integrated circuits -> refined silicon -> electronics -> refined metals -> cast metallurgy -> iron tools -> copper tools -> stone tools
Anyway, my take is that everything after copper is evil and should be banished.
Writing this as someone who likes using em dash and now I have to watch that habit because everyone is obsessed with sniffing out AI.
Cliched writing is definitely bad. I guess I should be happy that we are smashing them one way or another.
I've always liked the HN community because it facilitates an intelligent exchange of ideas. I've learned a lot trawling the comments on this site. I don't want to see the energy of human discourse being sucked up and wasted on the output of ChatGPT. Aggressively flagging this stuff is a sort of immune response for the community.
And it's the employers problem, if you don't react too much emotionally
Also, what's the deal with all the "The <overly clever noun phrase>" headlines?
Smells a lot like AI.
Also, what's the deal with all the "The <overly clever noun phrase>" headlines?
Adding "The" to the beginning of an opinion is a mental manipulation tactic that makes the reader believe it is a well-known established fact that everyone else knows.It's almost worse than Twitter.
These hot-take/title patterns "X is about Y1" are exploiting the difficulty of disproving them.
I often see it in the pattern of "Behavior of Group I Dislike is About Bad Motive."
I don’t use LLMs.
That's not the only price society pays. It makes sense for us to develop the heuristics to detect AI, but the implication of doing so has its own cost.
It started out as people avoiding the use of em-dash in order to avoid being mistaken for being AI, for example.
Now in the case of OP's observation, it will pressure real humans to not use the format that's normally used to fight against a previous form of coercion. A tactic of capital interests has been to get people arguing about the wrong question concerning ImportantIssueX in order to distract from the underlying issue. The way to call this out used to be to point out that, "it's not X1 we should be arguing about, but X2." Combined with OP's revelation, it is now harder to call out BS. That sure is convenient for capital interests.
I wonder what's next.
X1 is bullshit to argue about, it’s about X2.
Since the models are so censored and “proper” in their grammar, you can pretty easily stand out
Would you like me to generate a chart that shows how humans have adopted AI-speak over time?
You're missing the point. In the past bad writing was just bad writing, and it was typically easy to detect. Now the main contribution of AI is bad writing that can masquerade as good writing, be produced in industrial-scale quantities, and flood all the channels. That's a much different thing.
IMHO the main achievement of LLMs will be to destroy. It'll consume utterly massive quantities of resources to basically undermine processes and technologies that once created a huge amount of value (e.g. using the internet for wide-scale conversation).
I mean, schools are going back to handwritten essays, for Christ's sake.
If AI generated text were well written, would it matter to you? Is it bad to use Grammarly?
I don't see anything inherently wrong with using AI tools to write, as long as writers take the responsibility to ensure the final result is good. Fighting against use of LLMs seems like a fool's errand at this point. Personally I've been using Google Translate for years to help with writing in German, little knowing at the time that it was using transformers under the covers. [0] I'm pretty sure my correspondents would have thanked me had they known. Same applies for text written in English by non-native speakers.
[0] https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.03762
edit: fixed typo. Just proof this is not an LLM.
Yes, of course.
1) I don't want to waste my time with slop pumped out with a mindless process by someone who doesn't give a shit. That includes turning half an idea into a full essay of bullshit.
2) You have to distinguish between "good writing" and (lets call it) "smooth text construction." One of the big problems with LLMs is they can be used to generate slop that lacks many of the tells you could previously use to quickly determine that you're reading garbage. It's still garbage, just harder to spot so you waste more time.
> I don't see anything inherently wrong with using AI tools to write, as long as writers take the responsibility to ensure the final result is good.
Yeah, but what about the writers who don't? That's what I'm talking about. These tools benefit the bad actors far more than the ones who are trying to do things properly.
> Personally I've been using Google Translate for years to help with writing in German, little knowing at the time that it was using transformers under the covers. [0] I'm pretty sure my correspondents would have thanked me had they known.
Honestly, I think Google Translate is a lot harder to misuse than an LLM chatbot. These things aren't all the same.
If you read something from Simon Willison, it's generally worth reading. [0] (Actually pretty great a lot of the time.) Everything else is the literary equivalent of spam calls. Maybe it's time to stop answering the phone?
I think we're in violent agreement, I just have a less sanguine attitude towards it. LLMs will "undermine processes and technologies that once created a huge amount of value" (to quote myself above). We'll adapt to that, as in life goes on, but major things will be lost.
In the 70's we had Environmental Pollution - the 2000s will be defined as a fight against Social Pollution.
I’d like to delve into the crucial topic of whether AI generated slop is respectful to the innovative entrepreneurs of Hacker News. If they won’t assert the value of their time, who will?
In this digital age, can we not expect writers to just keep it brief? Or heck, just share the prompt, which is almost certainly shorter than the output and includes 100% of the information they intend to share?
Or is true 21st century digital transformation driven by the dialectical tension between AI generators and AI summarizers?
In essentially every situation, you cannot expect readers to read.
And what's with that diagram at the start? What's the axis on that graph? The "symptoms" of the "collapse" are listed as "Calculator", "Replit AI" and "AI Code". What?
Later in the post, we see the phrase "our research found". Is the author referring to the credulous citations of other content mill pieces? Is that research?
Our collective standard for quality of writing should be higher. Just as experienced devs have the good "taste" to curate LLM output, inexperienced writers cannot expect LLMs to write well for them.
/s
Accept that we will going to see more and more of these to the point that it's pointless to point out
1. Stop []!
It's become so repetitive recently. Examples from this post alone:
1. "This isn't about AI. The quality crisis started years before ChatGPT existed."
2. "The degradation isn't gradual—it's exponential."
3. "These aren't feature requirements. They're memory leaks that nobody bothered to fix."
4. "This wasn't sophisticated. This was Computer Science 101 error handling that nobody implemented."
5. "This isn't an investment. It's capitulation."
6. "senior developers don't emerge from thin air. They grow from juniors who:"
7. "The solution isn't complex. It's just uncomfortable."
Currently this rhetorical device is like nails on a chalkboard for me.
Anyway, this isn't a critique of your point. It's pedantry from me. :)