News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by Apreche on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:37AM (#4548178)
Just add maps.google.com to your home screen. I was doing that even before the new iOS. It's better than the new Maps app or the old one. Bicycle directions!

Also, FYI, the previous Maps app did use Google Maps, but the app itself was written by Apple. I once was at a Google event and asked a Googler who works on Maps about it. They have been frustrated for years that they could not update that app when they added new features to Google Maps. I expect within a short time we will see an iOS Google Maps that is on par with the Android app.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by holtr94 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:44AM (#4548195)
The only problem with any maps app written by Google is it cannot be the default. Friend texts you an address? It will always open in Apple Maps.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by zyb09 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:23AM (#4548666)
Also every 3rd party app using MapKit is stuck with Apple's maps. Google would need to release a GoogleMapKit iOS-Library for 3rd Party apps. iOS limitations are really showing now, it 's so disappointing to see Apple making things worse (new Maps, new AppStore), without providing proper 3rd party access to core functions and better cross-app communication. Instead of getting baked-in Facebook-Sharing with iOS 6, they should've made that an API, something every service can plug into, like Android's Sharing System. It's a shame, the hardware is so awesome, but the software is going down the drain, it desperately needs to be opened up more. For the record, the iPhone is now the only modern device I know of, that you can't access Google StreetView. No app, not through Safari, you just can't. I think it should be clear that something is wrong, when such an advanced device, can't do something as simple as that.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by mitjak on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:21PM (#4551284)
> proper 3rd party access to core functions and better cross-app communication

That right there is, to me, the biggest miss in iOS and why I am quite ready to move to Android entirely: it is very convenient to be able to share data between apps. Take a picture with the camera, share it out of the gallery into an editor, then just the same share it out of the editor into an SMS, Twitter status, an Evernote, or anything else that registered itself for that filetype. I love it so much I actually miss the functionality on all the desktop operating systems. iOS, by comparison, forces one to use either the predefined list of sharing services, or to keep saving things and opening them in each app one by one.

I can see that Apple has noticed the omission, judging by the 'arrow out of the square' share buttons showing up everywhere from desktop Safari to Mail.app, but it's still very limited and by comparison.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by TheBindingVoid on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:12AM (#4548317)
That's an iOS design flaw, not Google's problem.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by rmc on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:19AM (#4548338)
Yes, Android's intents are nice for allowing users to change that.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by Simucal on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:22AM (#4548980)
I've been using my Nexus 7 for several weeks now. I still think Android has a way to go in the UI/UX area but it seems a lot better in Jelly Bean compared to older versions of Android I have tried.

However, the number one feature I wish I had on my iPhone is the Android intents system. It is seriously great. I'd love to be able to set the default application for different actions. When I tell my Nexus 7 to play a particular song it will now launch Spotify to play the song I requested. I should be able to do this with Siri. This would be a huge feature for me.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by daleharvey on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:45AM (#4548200)
And a word of warning, at least for those outside the US, you are probably still better using cyclestreets.net than googles cycle directions, They sent me down a dual carriageway last weekend (and generally got every part of a 50 miles journey wrong)
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by hesselink on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:04AM (#4548283)
For those in the Netherlands, I can recommend the planner by 'de Fietsersbond': http://www.fietsersbond.nl/fietsrouteplanner/
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by grimborg on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:12AM (#4548611)
Interesting. I use a regular GPS with the maps of OpenFietsMap. It's mostly accurate, and pretty awesome.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by prof_hobart on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:41AM (#4548458)
Don't know what country you're in, but cycling down a dual carriageway is not particulary uncommon where I live.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by rmc on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:19AM (#4548342)
I expect within a short time we will see an iOS Google Maps that is on par with the Android app.

I wonder if Google will do that. Surely they want people to use Android, and "better maps on Android", would be a nice selling point.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by anextio on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:28AM (#4548383)
No. Google want people using their services. They don't care if people are using Android or not - Android is simply a platform upon which they can get users to use their services. That is their only vested interest.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by kls on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:16AM (#4548951)
Right Android exist because Google feared that people could be locked out of Google services. Google services and access to them, is their first priority.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by nicholassmith on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:26AM (#4548371)
Google wants people to use Google, not specifically Android even if it is a handy portal into the world of Google Apps and Services.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:34AM (#4548414)
>I wonder if Google will do that. Surely they want people to use Android, and "better maps on Android", would be a nice selling point.

The more difficult problem will be getting the app past Apple when it so clearly 'duplicates functionality in iOS.' My understanding is that one of the main drivers behind the change on Apple's part is that they wanted to collect user location data (and deprive Google of it), which doesn't do the job if 95% of the user base switches to the Google app straight away.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by LVB on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:07AM (#4548579)
But it would also be a huge marketing win if Google Maps became the go-to mapping application despite Apple's version being a core application and one of the most trumpeted new features in iOS.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by robk on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:31AM (#4548706)
Why? Google Maps is excellent. I'm not sure they need "marketing" in any way.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by LVB on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:15AM (#4548947)
I'm talking about negative press towards Apple being a relative positive for Google. If in 6 months the first thing new iPhone users do is install the Google Maps app and hide the built-in Apple solution, then at least that portion of iOS 6 will be deemed a failure.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by ben1040 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:23AM (#4548356)
On the other hand, they are trying to monetize the Android Maps app by including paid local offers and the like. There's nothing stopping them from trying to make money from the iOS user base the same way.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by nachteilig on Thursday September 20, 2012 @12:07PM (#4549219)
I can't find the link just now, but Google has stated previously that they're working on one.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by twism on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:17AM (#4548639)
Why would Apple allow a native iOS maps app by Google, that competes with their core Maps app, in the AppStore?
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by dailyrorschach on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:23AM (#4548664)
They already allow turn-by-turn navigation apps, and allow applications for GMail, Chrome (thought they don't get the full baked in system feel). For the most part the duplicated functionality requirements aren't as strict as they were from 2008-2010.

I think they'll definitely allow a Maps app from Google if they submit one. I also think that Google very likely wanted more updates and possibly more money for their map data. Apple likely viewed this as something that was always going to be painful but something they needed to just do and get behind them. I also wonder/hope/suspect that they may already be adding more data based on reports of landmarks that weren't appearing, now appearing.

This is also a nice point: http://blog.lumatic.com/post/31863865686/ive-been-using-ios-... Usage data is what improves maps, which they'll now have a lot of. Though I am surprised they haven't picked a better provider then just TomTom, perhaps that's also in the works.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by wpietri on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:37AM (#4549064)
Because that would be better for users.

There are two basic attitudes a company can have. A) We exist to create value for our customers. B) Our customers are our property and exist for our benefit.

Basically, the company's there either to serve or to exploit. Most businesses are of the former sort. Many monopolists and oligopolists hold the later view. E.g., cable companies and cellphone carriers.

If Apple were smart and user focused about this, they would have launched their own maps in beta as an add-on. Then they would have revved it until it was just as good as Google Maps for most people. Only then would have they turned dickish and kicked Google Maps off the platform.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by stephen_g on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:24AM (#4548672)
Why wouldn't they? In the App Store there are all sorts of browsers that compete with Safari (I know that they still have to use the built in WebView, but still), mail apps (including Gmail), that compete with Mail, camera apps that compete with the Camera app, to-do lost apps that compete with Reminders, and even many existing navigation apps, etc.

There's no reason it wouldn't be allowed in if Google complies with the guidelines...

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by ChuckMcM on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:28AM (#4549015)
Reasons:

Maps is expected to be the key monetization engine in mobile, sharing mobile ads with Google is anathema.

Maps 'replicates substantially similar content' in IOS. This one has been used quite a few times.

Apple can be pretty arbitrary about apps as we've seen but by and large from a business perspective its one of their core capabilities they will want to own.

Of course I could be completely wrong here, we'll see as this plays out of course.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by brown9-2 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:36AM (#4549053)
Seems like rejecting a native Google Maps app would be an acknowledgement of Apple's inability to compete.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by chmars on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:06AM (#4548289)
I would be very happy about such an app although the new YouTube app made me rather pessimistic. It's for example not available on the iPad and you cannot send links to videos by mail.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by mgw on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:52AM (#4548221)
Google is surely working on a native iOS maps app, but (when) will Apple approve it?
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by hopeless on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:31AM (#4548402)
When will Google submit it? I suspect Google will let Apple (and us users) stew in this for a while. Just long enough so everyone feels the pain but not long enough for them to forget Google Maps

Personally, StreetView down every little single-lane road in Ireland is a big deal for me (landscape photography) whereas 3D flyovers are like the Coverflow of mapping (looks pretty but ultimately not very useful)

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by mbesto on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:54AM (#4548235)
No joke, I would switch to Android in a hear beat if they don't. I am 100% reliant on my map app and therefore am willing to pay for anything with the best experience.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by diptanu on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:58AM (#4548259)
Same here. Used iPhone since the day it was released. But I can't survive without a functional map, buying an Nexus One tonight. Good Bye iPhone :(
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by fpgeek on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:09AM (#4548301)
Might I suggest getting a Galaxy Nexus instead of a Nexus One? The Nexus One is pretty dated at this point...
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by Angostura on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:35AM (#4548729)
You could just pay the for the Tom Tom app for iOS.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by Karunamon on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:35AM (#4549049)
Less responsive updates (I've gotten things personally corrected on Google maps in 3 days or less, while as of 2012, one of the streets in my hometown on TT is STILL wrong despite this being reported multiple times more than five freaking years ago), very high resource usage (phone seems to slow way down if TT is open or backgrounded), it also uses a ton of your storage memory for map data, and doesn't have the same amount of addon data (street view, reviews, that kind of thing) as Google.

And you have to shell out $50 for it, last I checked.

Google's offering is better in every way.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by adgar on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:12AM (#4548316)
Android's google maps have been better by features than iOS's google maps for a couple years now, since Google could update the Android app. Vector graphics since 2010, local integration (reviews, including zagat now), more advanced directions options, and so on.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by rmc on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:20AM (#4548345)
Apple aren't completly stupid. I doubt they'd delibrately hobble the iPhone by leaving this as the best maps you can get.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by hahainternet on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:34AM (#4548416)
They have.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by arrrg on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:56AM (#4548527)
maps.google.com regularly crashes Safari on my iPad. I really hope for a native app from Google – and given recent trends, that’s not unlikely. (Google has some great apps on the App Store and they seem to want to cover all bases.) It just might take some time (I’m guessing several months).
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by spitx on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:09AM (#4548300)
This bothers me to no end. One of the major things beside the odd dimensions of the iPhone 5 screen, that prevent me from switching from Android. However the screen is clearly a bigger let-down for most Android users who are used to larger screens.

Jobs would never have allowed such an atrocity to occur. The sub-par Gmail integration is another pain point.

Roger McNamee expressed the same misgivings on Bloomberg the other day. He said Apple is starting to act like a bad monopolist.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by rimantas on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:16AM (#4548329)

  > Jobs would never have allowed such an atrocity to occur
iPhone 5 is more likely to be blessed by Jobs than not. I am not sure how long Apple product pipeline is, but I seriously doubt they had iPhone 4S ready for production, but not iPhone 5 in the advanced design stage.

On the other hand I don't give a damn about "odd" dimensions. There is nothing odd in them for me.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:38AM (#4548442)
>iPhone 5 is more likely to be blessed by Jobs than not. I am not sure how long Apple product pipeline is, but I seriously doubt they had iPhone 4S ready for production, but not iPhone 5 in the advanced design stage.

Yes and no. Jobs may have signed on to the idea of replacing the maps with an in-house solution, but the implementation wouldn't have been finished until shortly before launch. And when it turned out to be as bad as it seems to be then he might very reasonably have reverted to the previous maps app for at least this version of iOS (if not scrapping the idea entirely).

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by spitx on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:41AM (#4548464)
The tall-narrow screen is just a case of classic Apple orthodoxy.

There is nothing in the dimensions of the iPhone 5 that make it inherently a better viewing experience over a wider configuration. If Apple had convinced itself to be less parsimonious and obtained larger (width wise) screens at better margins I'm sure they would have made that one of their USPs. Instead they cheap-ed out on the acreage.

That screen is dumb and in a sea of larger and similarly fabulous screens (including the upcoming Nokia Lumia 920 which incidentally has some stellar mapping alongside other great features) it just doesn't cut it.

Tim Cook and his core team seem to be a bunch of frugal zealots. He bungled the layoffs at the Apple stores too. Upon a backlash he had to hire some of them back. This launch is probably the first one where nearly every detail leaked well ahead of time. The screen, the connector, the no-NFC, the LTE and several other parts. It certainly is all down-hill from here. There is no longer that halo around the Apple experience. Unless of course people want to accessorize their attire with glass-slab jewelry which the iPhone 5 has been likened to. The first-on-iPhone apps are the only draw.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by philwelch on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:53AM (#4548518)
The narrow-but-tall screen isn't meant for viewing experience; it's meant for holding-in-your-hand experience.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by vidarh on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:08AM (#4548584)
The iPhone is uncomfortably small to me. I don't think my hands are that abnormally large, but my 4.3" HTC Desire HD is a much better size fit. Even so, my next phone might very well be one with an even larger screen - I use my phone flat in my hand with screen facing me about ten times more than I hold it up in any way that requires a great grip.

It's not a coincidence that the top selling Android phones have gradually been ones with larger and larger screens.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by CamperBob2 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @04:46PM (#4550589)
The only valid answer to this debate would be for Apple to acknowledge that not everyone has the same size hands, and release two different iPhones.

They don't appear to be interested in doing the obvious right thing here.

Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by philwelch on Thursday September 20, 2012 @05:27PM (#4550814)
That's not the "only valid answer". Maybe people with big hands can just buy Androids, and Apple can cater to the small-to-medium-size-hand market. I don't know if Apple has a problem with that, but I don't.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by CamperBob2 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:03PM (#4551212)
Wild guess: you have small-to-medium-size hands.
Re:New Apple maps app under fire from users by philwelch on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:48PM (#4551391)
If you love Apple products so much that you feel personally slighted that they don't fit comfortably in your big hands, I guess that's just your cross to bear.