News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by dwedge on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:12PM (#45474843)
I'm yet to be convinced that the removal of privacy has any effect on the level of crime, nor do I believe that to be the primary motivation for it
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by codr7 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:03PM (#45475286)
Nor a viable solution to the problem.
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by roamerz on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:39PM (#45475105)
That’s a good point. I can tell you from firsthand experience that the abundance of cameras in our society absolutely have a profound effect on the ability of law enforcement to solve individual crimes. To the point you are making how do we transfer those successes into reducing the level of crime?

My thoughts on that are probably not very popular on here and those are to just build larger jails and equip those with drug rehabilitation options. The larger jails allow us to not just kick the people back on the streets immediately but compel steps that help eliminate recidivism. Another source of criminal behavior is mental illness. I have no clues on how to fix that except perhaps concentrate on the causes.

All these cameras and recording devices exist for that same reason Advil exists in that it helps a toothache. Doesn’t really solve the problem but fights the symptoms.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by codr7 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:05PM (#45475315)
If you think prisons turn criminals into law abiding individuals, or that that's even their purpose, you've got some more figuring out to do before teaching.
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by idiotsecant on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:18PM (#45475412)
Your cure is worse than the disease! Our risk of violent crime is lower now than almost any point in history. We make crime better by improving the lives of the average person. Jails don't fix socioeconomic issues, they in fact make them worse.
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by AngryData on Saturday October 04, 2025 @06:18PM (#45477216)
The US already has the largest prison population in the world and yet still has extremely high crime on par with countries that lack functioning goverments. So how exactly are more prisons and arrests going to lower crime when it has failed to do so for decade after decade?
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by janice1999 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:06PM (#45475788)
If that was true, there would be no crime in London.

The current system is all downsides - no privacy while the police ignore crimes like bike thefts despite ample CCTV coverage. Worse, CCTV and other surveillance tools are used with glee to target protestors who the government dislike.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by isubkhankulov on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:38PM (#45475565)
Completely agree. Generally speaking, America’s homicide closure rate isn’t great compared to other western countries and is unfortunately trending downward in recent years.

I can certainly understand concerns about privacy but the other sides of this discussion should not be ignored.

https://www.npr.org/2023/04/29/1172775448/people-murder-unso...

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by Rygian on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:12PM (#45474840)
Before discussing trade-offs between those two, what about prevention of crime?
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:22PM (#45474947)
How would that work? Assume that I'm willing to bribe the underclass with welfare to prevent crime (hell, assume I'm only worried about the worst types of crime)... how much bribery for how much reduction?
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by tredre3 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:34PM (#45475072)
Flock won't prevent you from being stabbed by a homeless junkie. It might help catch the guy and prevent him from stabbing someone else (until he's released three months later).

Knowing this, wouldn't you prefer that we spend the money on crime prevention programs that "bribes" the underclass, instead of in a system that won't prevent crime at all but will rob all of us of privacy?

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by adventured on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:54PM (#45475214)
The single best resolution to crime is to dramatically reduce poverty.

The single best way to reduce poverty is to pay (bribe) the poor to stop having children, which ends the cycle of poverty (which is extraordinarily difficult to break and tends to trap generations). That should go hand-in-hand with free birth control, free day-after pills, free abortions, comprehensive sexual education, etc.

A large share of the bottom 1/3 in the US will never step foot outside of poverty, most of them will never hold a job on a sustained basis. Pay them to not have children, which simultaneously benefits their lives in the here and now, while preventing the mistake of bringing children into poverty. It's one of the most humane things the US could do as a society. It would very rapidly improve poverty (and reduce crime) in the US.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by ShrimpHawk on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:04PM (#45475294)
Paying an entire class of people to not have children is eugenics. There is a massive line between that and increasing (free) access to reproductive services.
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by malfist on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:26PM (#45475475)
How about helping them out of poverty instead of subjecting them to eugenics?
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by ActorNightly on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:53PM (#45475201)
Barring any massive mental illness, humans are great optimizers. Crime is basically the optimal policy within environmentm where illegal activites with their added risk have a potential much greater reward than leading your life normally and doing things by the book.

Its not hard to inject money in the right places to either decrease the reward, or increase the risk.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Sunday October 05, 2025 @01:53AM (#45479135)
>Crime is basically the optimal policy within environmentm where illegal activites with their added risk have a potential much greater reward than

An interesting theory. But there exists a class of criminals who commit crimes not because the tradeoffs come out with the crime ahead of the lawfulness, but because they are impulsive, malicious, bored, and apathetic. Some of them continue to commit crime even after they are well out of poverty, even when the tradeoffs have shifted in the other direction. And this isn't some tiny fraction of crime, I suspect it is the majority of it. Crime has become their culture, and no one casually gives up culture and adopts a new one. More importantly, while one single person might do that, an entire group does not do this because they reinforce each other's continuation of that culture.

This makes it difficult or impossible to inject money anywhere and have measurable results. It makes it difficult or impossible to do anything at all about it. And for that reason, I'd prefer we not pursue a trillion dollar boondoggle.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by ActorNightly on Monday October 06, 2025 @01:10PM (#45493561)
>And this isn't some tiny fraction of crime, I suspect it is the majority of it.

Nope.

Lets take the famous example of low income area gang activity. They have examples of everything from local powerful people in charge having enough money to buy nice cars, to things like famous rappers with origins in same gangs. The reason why they commit crime is because the alternative actually sucks - you have to put up with boredom, lack of money, poverty, lack of any social support, all into a system that is going to discriminate against you even if you do everything right. This is where proper money injection with adequate policing can easily fix the problem.

As for people continuing to do crime after being financially off, this is still just a matter of tradeoff still favoring the crime side. The crime that most of these people commit is stuff like illegal firearms, drugs, and/or financial fraud - i.e stuff that is really not that relevant to society, with potentially a big payoff instead of investment. At the worst, some people get scammed. Meanwhile, the perpetrator gets usually punished financially or minimal jailing.

There are always going to be mentally unwell people who end up being serial killers, but the risk to society from those people is minuscule.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @03:17PM (#45507525)
>Lets take the famous example of low income area gang activity.

That's the perfect example! Street drug dealers make less than minimum wage. Why bother with the risk of prison, death, and on top of it get paid the equivalent of $4/hour when you could go make $14/hour at a fast food job?

Because you actually like the sheer hell of what you're doing.

>you have to put up with boredom, l

And how the fuck are we supposed to solve that problem for them with welfare? You'll notice you even list that first, poverty and lack of social support come, in your mind, second to boredom. I think we're actually in agreement here on the problem, just you want to pretend that there is a solution to this problem.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by mzajc on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:16PM (#45474874)
When do we start removing white-collar crime?
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by mordae on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:46PM (#45475153)
What crime? The system is working as designed. /i
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by odie5533 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:05PM (#45475776)
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by IlikeKitties on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:14PM (#45474864)
Holy false dichotomy Batman. The amount of crime you can reduce by funding decent law enforcement training and a working law system and just by having a general halfway welfare system dwarfs the effects these privacy invading solutions could ever produces. Absolute lunacy to believe that.
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by ActorNightly on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:59PM (#45475260)
"Never give power to authorities that wouldnt want them to have if someone you didnt like was in charge"

While I fully agree with your statement, until we as a society learn to self regulate and prevent things like orange man happening, its best that we live in a world where people in charge have as little power as possible.

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by Muromec on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:06PM (#45475326)
But we want to build fancy tech and not listen to those annoying humanists, so no
Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by stri8ed on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:29PM (#45475031)
Having adequate law enforcement training and funding, is not mutually exclusive with leveraging technology for more effective enforcement. In fact that's where some of the funding goes. I would be interested in seeing some data reflecting a reduction in crime as a result of increasing the welfare system, as you claim.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flock_Safety#Efficacy

Re:Flock's gunshot detection microphones will start listenin... by IlikeKitties on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:37PM (#45475094)
I mean compared to corporate written Wikipedia articles from privacy invading dystopian nightmare companies the evidence that welfare reduces crime is so obvious that even a quick google search drowns one in 3rd party validate studies:

https://academic.oup.com/qje/article-abstract/137/4/2263/658... https://news.uchicago.edu/does-welfare-reduce-crime https://law.yale.edu/sites/default/files/documents/pdf/Intel... https://pp.ethz.ch/news/2025/03/higher-welfare-payments-redu... And probably a gazillion more

But again, by the time we did all the non privacy invading stuff that doesn't target me as a law abiding citizen the discussion about these devices becomes moot because crime isn't that much of a problem anymore.