News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday October 03, 2025 @06:30PM (#45468592)
https://www.crowdsupply.com/open-tools/open-printer

> Open Source

> Open Printer will use the Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license for all of its files, including electronics and mechanical design files, firmware code, and the bill of materials. We hope that people will be able to repair, upgrade, and contribute improvements to their printers.

It's a nice hope, but they've conveniently banned being able to pay someone else to make parts for you, which will make it harder. Also, not Open Source. (Shared Source is still better than proprietary, but it's not F/OSS.)

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by slow_typist on Friday October 03, 2025 @08:10PM (#45469229)
In my understanding it should be fine to make parts to order and charge for that, but I may be wrong. What definitely isn’t covered is making parts in advance (anonymously) and sell them later with a profit.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday October 03, 2025 @10:35PM (#45470041)
Okay, but as someone who would have wanted to buy parts, that's a downside.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by slow_typist on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:54AM (#45470858)
Absolutely
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by terribleperson on Friday October 03, 2025 @08:37PM (#45469425)
While I think NC is a terrible license, hasn't it been settled in court that you can hire someone to produce CC-BY-NC material? You can't run a business selling the material, but you can be hired to produce it.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday October 03, 2025 @10:36PM (#45470049)
> You can't run a business selling the material, but you can be hired to produce it.

I'm not a lawyer, so it's not that hard to imagine that I'm missing nuance, but... what's the difference?

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by VTimofeenko on Friday October 03, 2025 @11:59PM (#45470390)
I could order a 3d print of a part from somewhere; that somewhere's core business is not printing that specific thing.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by nine_k on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:30AM (#45471034)
I cannot offer and advertise this specific service. I can produce the part if somebody orders it.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by terribleperson on Saturday October 04, 2025 @09:26PM (#45478160)
Also not a lawyer, but here's what I recall: If you are a shop, and you produce copies of something with the intent to sell it, that's commercial use. If you offer some kind of production service, and someone hires you to make produce something, you are acting as their agent. If they have the right to make copies themselves, you can make copies on their behalf.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by goda90 on Friday October 03, 2025 @08:49PM (#45469490)
So what workarounds could be had? Contractor business where you hire someone for a few hours to make it for you? Business that sells something else at an elevated price but gives a CC-BY-NC material gift with every purchase?
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by TheJoeMan on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:07PM (#45469570)
You run 3D printers and they email you the files?
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by thayne on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:41PM (#45469755)
That would probably depend on the jurisdiction?

Just because there was a court ruling in one country, doesn't necessarily mean it is legal in another country.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by abracadaniel on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:12PM (#45469592)
Seems like a reasonable license for someone who wants to sell their printer, but also publish the designs to allow for repair and for modifications to be shared by the community.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by mindcrime on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:14PM (#45475390)
It's totally a reasonable license. It just isn't an Open Source license. There's nothing wrong with that. Not everything needs to be Open Source. But it's a little bit misleading to label something as such and then use a license that very explicitly isn't.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by thayne on Friday October 03, 2025 @09:58PM (#45469869)
Well, that's unfortunate. That means another company couldn't, say, make and sell a variant of this that uses US letter sized paper instead of A4.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by waterproof on Friday October 03, 2025 @10:33PM (#45470035)
Since the printer takes flexible roll sizes and cuts its own pages, probably it would work out of the box with letter right?

I do get your point though, it would be nice if this was not an NC license

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by thayne on Friday October 03, 2025 @10:57PM (#45470143)
Ah yes, looking at the actual specs, it looks like it does support 11 inch rolls as well.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by dheera on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:26AM (#45470738)
It would be awesome if one could craft a FOSS license that allows all FOSS uses of the project except creating a US letter variant.

A4 is awesome, and should become the US standard.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by satiric on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:30AM (#45471383)
It would be annoying for me to use paper with such strange dimensions. 8.5 x 11, 11 x 17, etc are much easier measurements for me to remember. The root 2 thing with European paper is pleasing though.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by ruszki on Saturday October 04, 2025 @04:59AM (#45471853)
As a European, I have no clue what's the dimensions of A4, A5, etc. We just say A4. I don't think that laymen, like me, know anything about their real size, and I never had a problem not knowing it.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by snibsnib on Saturday October 04, 2025 @07:32AM (#45472552)
Its mathematically derived. A0 is exactly 1m2 in area. The side lengths are at a ratio of sqrt(2), that means you can cut any A paper size in half and get the size below it. B series are the same ratio, but B0 has a width of 1m instead.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by greggsy on Saturday October 04, 2025 @08:16AM (#45472761)
Interstate, TIL
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by miduil on Saturday October 04, 2025 @05:16AM (#45471936)
148x210 A5 297x210 A4 297x420 A3

Agree, I had to look it up as well. I can memorize A4 and A3 easily, but A5 is already counter-intuitive. It's an aspect ratio that's kept, so that's why the numbers don't add up easily.

With the paper in front of me it's easier, fold, double, you can navigate across all levels of A(n) quickly. All it takes is seeing this single graphic for a split second and you know all the DIN A-sizes, but the US sizes not. I enjoy the US Letter format though as a size, it feels somehow better than A5 as it's more square.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_size#/media/File:A_size_...

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday October 04, 2025 @06:11AM (#45472212)
You cut an A4 to get A5, wasting 1mm ...; two sheets of A4 in an A3 ... there's only one pair of dimensions to remember.

Write the sizes in binary and bit-shift them?

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by e12e on Saturday October 04, 2025 @07:12AM (#45472472)
Wasting one mm?
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by wizzwizz4 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:32PM (#45475514)
They're rounded to the nearest mm because the tolerances are about a millimetre, so there's no point specifying the paper size better than that.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by dheera on Saturday October 04, 2025 @12:54PM (#45474701)
If you fold A4 in half you get A5, and if you double up A4 you get A3. They are all the same exact proportions.

US sizes don't work like that; the closest thing to A3 here doesn't have the same proportions as the closest thing to A4. Which absolutely sucks if you are designing a poster and need to make it bigger or smaller.

With international A sizes you can reuse the same design for any size. That's why I like them.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by hamandcheese on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:47AM (#45471118)
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by dreamcompiler on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:46AM (#45471487)
Binary Charles and Ray Eames would like a word.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by me-vs-cat on Sunday October 05, 2025 @06:11PM (#45485741)
> It would be awesome if one could craft a FOSS license that allows all FOSS uses of the project except creating a US letter variant.

That can't happen, because your desired exclusion is incompatible with FOSS.

You could do that with a non-FOSS license.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by snvzz on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:22AM (#45470729)
I was thinking "where do I order?" but then realized it's not actual OSH (Open Source Hardware) but just a publicity stunt.

This is a textbook case where the headline should be editorialized as it contains misinformation, and many are only ever gonna read the headline.

Once, a long time ago. Richard Stallman was pissed off at an hostile printer. We got Free Software just because. Yet the printer problem remains unsolved.

I still hope somebody, somewhere, will eventually get it done and commoditize printing forever, riding us of the mafia which is printer makers.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by nine_k on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:37AM (#45471066)
Inkjet printer makers sell printers way below cost of production, making the money on the ink.

There will always be enough people who would buy a $129 printer and postpone the reckoning in ink, instead of buying a $329 printer that can print reams using cheap bulk ink.

(Laser printers are superior anyway, unless you print photos.)

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by hakfoo on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:12PM (#45475376)
What keeps the production cost high?

A new inkjet-- especially if you're not getting a photo-optimized one-- isn't doing that much technically different from a 20-year-old one. You don't need 4800DPI and rich six-ink photo finishes if all you're asking for is one four-colour pie chart in a 20-page report, so you don't need to be at the edge of premium technology here.

So why can't they just keep manufacturing a 20-year-old DeskJet, using long-amortized tooling and fully-worked-out mechanicals, but with a new controller board to replace parallel with USB/Ethernet/Wi-fi?

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by bityard on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:22PM (#45475447)
In the mid 2000s, there was a model of inkjet printer that came with full size ink cartridges. It was usually priced "on sale" for less than the price of a new set of ink cartridges. Meaning if you did a normal amount of printing, it was more economically viable to buy a new printer every every few months and throw the old one away than it was to buy replacement cartridges.

It revealed a lot about the incentive structure of the inkjet printer market.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by me-vs-cat on Sunday October 05, 2025 @06:34PM (#45485899)
Are you thinking of a specific model? What model?

All models I personally experienced came with ink cartridges containing less ink than replacement cartridges. I participated in a ton of ink cartridge refilling during 1998-2007.

For most consumers back then, I could easily imagine that it was still more cost effective to buy new printers (with partial cartridges) than it was to buy replacements.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday October 04, 2025 @06:14AM (#45472227)
@dang - edit the title?
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by rixed on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:38AM (#45471070)
They say:

  Built with standard mechanical components and modular parts, it’s easy to assemble, modify, and repair.
So for all those standard pieces this would not be an issue.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by Someone on Saturday October 04, 2025 @03:05AM (#45471221)
It still would mean a company cannot really offer to do repairs for you, wouldn’t it? They’d have to be able to prove that none of their employees looked at the design documents, ever.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by wizzwizz4 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:37PM (#45475555)
CC licenses aren't viral in that way. I can write a CC BY-NC instruction and repair manual for a Ford Prefect, and a professional mechanic can use the information contained within to help them fix Ford Prefects. The NC aspect of the license just means they can't sell the repair manual, charge for entrance to a dramatic reading of the repair manual, etc: it doesn't apply constraints beyond an All Rights Reserved design doc from any other manufacturer.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by fc417fc802 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @06:38PM (#45477379)
So if Ford were to publish full schematics for the Perfect under a CC-NC license would it be permissible for a third party to use that in order to offer (commercial, for profit) manufacturing and assembly? Honest question, because I'm not clear where the line for these printers sits.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by wizzwizz4 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @07:18PM (#45477613)
Off the top of my head (keeping in mind it's years since I last researched this), patent and trademark law are what prevents people cloning someone else's machine from the spec. So unless there are patents, I don't think you'd have a problem.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by theamk on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @09:19PM (#45510987)
Yep, so you they replace the stepper.

But if the cartridge holder breaks, a repair service cannot print a new one.

And if PCB breaks, a repair service cannot order a new one either.

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by RobotToaster on Saturday October 04, 2025 @02:59AM (#45471182)
>Also, not Open Source.

Even CC highlights this

>NC licenses do not qualify as “open licenses” under the Open Definition, and works licensed under an NC license are not considered Free Cultural Works

https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/NonCommercial_interpre...

Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by zelphirkalt on Saturday October 04, 2025 @05:55AM (#45472127)
Kind of silly to name it Open Printer then, or at least ignorant of existing customs in this space of open hardware and software.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by brudgers on Saturday October 04, 2025 @07:44AM (#45472611)
Calling it open source got the vaporware onto the HN front page.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by yapyap on Saturday October 04, 2025 @06:53AM (#45472389)
and even more than that they literally use “open source” in their crowdsupply description
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by remix2000 on Saturday October 04, 2025 @05:25AM (#45471976)
Lots of beneficial and spiritually open licenses are not recognized as OSS by OSI, so I wouldn't care much about what they think at this point.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday October 04, 2025 @12:22PM (#45474466)
That's fine, it's also not recognized by the FSF, DFSG, any BSD, or anyone else credible. Mostly because those "beneficial and spiritually open licenses" are in fact not beneficial or spiritually open, existing specifically to limit what users can do and cripple the community's ability to do anything the original vendor doesn't like or that might undercut their ability to make money.
Re:Open Printer is an open source inkjet printer with DRM-fr... by remix2000 on Sunday October 05, 2025 @08:40AM (#45481076)
I actually meant stuff like OQL that benefits the community while preventing corporations and other ill-behaved entities from abusing said community. I don't know much about the implications of CC-BY-NC specifically, but I guess it's unlikely to have been conceived with that in mind…?