Another murder last month, this one they killed for the crimes of attending protests and funerals: https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/mde23/0239/2025/en/
Two years ago they sentenced this man to death because he tweeted something they didn't like to less than ten followers: https://www.uscirf.gov/religious-prisoners-conscience/forb-v...
Ironic in the most morbid of ways.
Maybe the narrative changes when their approaches towards human rights does?
Remember when the current leader of Saudi Arabia lured a Washington Post journalist into a Saudi consulate, had him tortured to death, and cut into pieces to dispose of the evidence? What a bunch of merry pranksters. We really should lighten up.
Awful people run the world.
Clo$e. The narrative change$ whenever the $audi$ decide that they want it to. U$ually, thi$ involve$ $omething, but I can't figure quite what that "it" could be.
My man, they can kill you for drawing a stick figure.
Let that sink in.
SA is still a single-export economy, and those who are smart enough to get out of SA, do so. From personally having very close relationships with a few folks who worked on the NEOM project, the Saudi locals are not prepared to do any work at all, just spend money and export the work to consultants. It's about posturing, not rolling up their sleeves.
Before anyone thinks I'm Islamophobic, I equally detest and mock all religion.
I do find it funny that if there is an afterlife, Abraham is there, and absolutely befuddled as to why all of his disciples seem to hate each other and want to kill each other.
We all have skin in the game when there's an actor on the world stage that kills its critics buying up huge orgs in our society.
Citation very much needed. It's still a country where you can be executed for being gay, protestors against government projects get murdered in the streets, and anyone vaguely critical against the government (that includes being critical for things which have since been allowed, like women driving) being imprisoned for long periods of time. Oh, and did they not execute a dissident in a consulate? Did they not bait various government detractors living abroad to return to Saudi under threat of harm to their families?
It's still a reactionary theocracy. It has liberalised, socially, in the years since MBS has had de facto control, there is no denying that; but they're nowhere near "westernly".
> At what point does the narrative about their investments on the larger stage become less pejorative?
When their sportswashing and investmentwashing ends up entirely working. It will probably take years, Khashoggi's murder was still only 7 years ago. It will also depend a lot on how their World Cup works, a lot of the world will be watching that one closely and it will have big ramifications.
I think that's what they meant by "moved westernly".
Even for Britain, France, Germany, the countries with the biggest far right/reactionary political groups, where there are legitimate chances for them to end up in power, none of them are religious. Or even that socially reactionary for that matter.
1) There is the climate sect. There are many young followers with strong believes - but nobody has ever read any book on atmosphere science. And nobody has read any recent paper on the subject. Once you do, you'll find it very surprising how little substance is behind their dogmas.
2) There is the COVID sect. They even masked themselves outdoors in public - like the women in Iran back in the day. Without any evidence - and they did it even against evidence. It was a very religious thing.
3) Another group now shouts for war - and if you listen to them they're about as intelligent as the worst kind of crusaders back in the day.
Not religions in the classical sense, but all the classical churches still play a role in this game - for every modern nonsensical cult I've seen a preachers of a fundamentalist Christian organisation fuelling it with a public hate speech. Common to all them is that they blindly follow some propaganda - and are absolutely immune to any data and science. Europe has a really big problem with Cult and Sect movements...
Bloody hell are we still at this nonsense today?
Public health authorities, across multiple continents, said to mask up. Did it limit spread? Yes, it did, and studies proved so. What the hell is your problem there? May I remind you the initial heavy weeks with makeshift morgues in ice rinks and refrigerated trucks, and military hospitals being deployed? Lockdowns and masking and vaccine mandates were reasonable, and reasonably effective, remedies for how horrific things could get (and did get, at the start, in multiple countries).
> There is the climate sect. There are many young followers with strong believes - but nobody has ever read any book on atmosphere science. And nobody has read any recent paper on the subject. Once you do, you'll find it very surprising how little substance is behind their dogmas.
Aha, so trusting the scientific consensus is "a sect". Do enlighten us, how is climate change not real? Or is it real, but God given? Or what is your deal?
> Another group now shouts for war - and if you listen to them they're about as intelligent as the worst kind of crusaders back in the day.
What war? Putting Russia back in its place? Si vis pacem, para bellum. The only thing a bully would understand is strength.
1) Study some math - get a clue about Epidemiology - get some numbers. You'll learn that you're very wrong about COVID. Compare contries with masks and without masks. Take a look at places that peaked before any masking happened. Take a look at some curves, where parameters of the curves got slightly worse after masking...
To be not too hostile to you I'll admit here that I underestimated masks. They in fact can suck up a lot of moisture for 30 minutes. But what really happens after that? The absorption coefficient of the relevant particle size is pretty much Zero. If you don't handle the mask professionally - and don't change it in time, you're going to put a magnet for a lot of bad stuff into your breathing path. If you're note careful the Epidemiological result is a slightly worse result - which you can find in the data - if you're willing to look.
To sum it up: The masking was more stupid than the stuff in Iran... But if you use masks professionally, I think you could get some benefit from them.
2) Study some physics - read some papers. How does the absorption spectrum of CO2 look like? What does saturation mean? What is HITRAN? How do the numbers add up? How much CO2 was in the atmosphere a few million years ago? What happened then? Currently even Microsoft Copilot knows the answer - if you ask him the right questions.
3) Reading your last line I think you're pretty lost. Study some history. Seek help!
Phrases like "You've bought into multiple cults" and "I think you're pretty lost. Study some history. Seek help!" are never acceptable on HN, no matter the context.
And, really, are we still arguing about masks in 2025? Nobody is changing their mind about it now. Please just let it go.
Discussion like this is not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.
If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
But let's not ignore the danger from the Left. Sure, a transcendant, self-sacrificing God is out of the picture, but enthroned in his place is My Self-defined Sexual Identity, or depending on the variety, Those We Define to be Oppressed. In the new atheist Puritanism, dissent will get something worse than wearing a scarlet letter. The problem isn't theocracy, per se, its the fact that dissent is not tolerated, and the Left isn't any better here.
At what point does the narrative about their investments on the larger stage become less pejorative?