News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by ourmandave on Sunday September 28, 2025 @04:42PM (#45407806)
...anyone above 75 is not all there, plain and simple.

Yeesh, ageism, plain and simple.

But yeah, Grassley needs to hang up the spurs.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by serf on Sunday September 28, 2025 @07:38PM (#45409034)
>Yeesh, ageism, plain and simple.

we take it for granted that someone below the age of 15-ish in the United States shouldn't be behind the wheel of an automobile, but that's not universally true. We try 18 year olds as adults, and that's not universally true, either.

It isn't a far leap to presume that people past a certain age meets the same psychological and mental/cognitive decline as the average person that age without testing.

You wouldn't expect a 95 year old to be eagle-eyed and athletic, to presume that their age isn't a deficit whatsoever is ageist from another perspective.

If I saw a person using a wheelchair I wouldn't wait for them to tell me that they needed a ramp for the staircase at the restaurant -- this too is -ist, but I see no real problem with it as a wheelchair user myself.

Somewhat similarly : the amount of 'with-it' and sober 95 year olds that I have met in real life makes me really question their fitness as an important member of a government group. Just like the presidency, these roles should probably be qualified into by participants with more than just votes.

If you're a 95 year old that passes the mental health and physical health examinations, more power to you , welcome to <government group>.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by bearjaws on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:19PM (#45408124)
Totally fair to call out blanket “anyone 75+ isn’t all there” as ageist. But the governance point still stands: even sharp octogenarians are often out of sync with modern life (platforms, tech norms, digital risks). Only 8% of adults 65+ say they’re online “almost constantly,” vs 48% of 18–29 a proxy for how different the information environment is that shapes decisions.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by daveguy on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:31PM (#45408230)
The word would be a better place if everyone was offline more often. They wouldn't be as subject to the propaganda oligopolies.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by frmersdog on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:10PM (#45408042)
"Muh ageism" is not a get-out-of-jail-free card for these kinds of conversations. You have to make an effort to actually argue against the statements you disagree with. Are people 75-and-older agile and flexible enough, mentally, to perform in these positions? To connect with the constituents they represent? If the incidence of the requisite acuity does indeed drop with advanced age, are the individuals in government disproportionately among those who avoid issues? And, if so, how do you know?
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by leptons on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:17PM (#45408105)
>Are people 75-and-older agile and flexible enough, mentally, to perform in these positions?

All of them? No. But I also could introduce you to plenty of 25 year old's that aren't "agile and flexible enough, mentally to perform these positions". And it's often not even "mental agility" that is the problem with people in power, it's corruption, greed, and just plain old hate that is the problem. Those things don't have any age limits except maybe below 6 years old, and even then I've met some pretty nasty, spoiled toddlers.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by frmersdog on Sunday September 28, 2025 @07:35PM (#45409010)
>But I also could introduce you to plenty of 25 year old's that aren't "agile and flexible enough, mentally to perform these positions"

There are vanishingly-few 25-year-olds in national office, certainly not in proportion to their chunk of the overall population. But bringing them up at all is beside the point. The contention at hand is that there are too many elderly people, who are beyond their ability to perform adequately, in positions of power. If you would like to address that, feel free. But please stay on topic.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by leptons on Monday September 29, 2025 @01:31AM (#45410591)
>There are vanishingly-few 25-year-olds in national office

Well thank [deity] for that, because many of them aren't fit for it. Neither are 75 year olds, but age doesn't really play that much of a factor - it's the people voting to put shitheads in positions of power no matter their age that are causing this damage in the first place.

>> "Muh ageism" is not a get-out-of-jail-free card for these kinds of conversations.

>There are vanishingly-few 25-year-olds in national office, certainly not in proportion to their chunk of the overall population. But bringing them up at all is beside the point.

Yes, it is the point - you made it the point with your "muh ageism" quip. I simply pointed out that age doesn't make a difference, but greed, corruption, and hate do.

>The contention at hand is that there are too many elderly people, who are beyond their ability to perform adequately, in positions of power.

There are also old people in power that are not "beyond their ability to perform adequately", and that's also a very subjective goalpost you're setting. Some of those shitty old politicians are doing exactly what their shitty constituents want them to, even if they are just holding the pen while someone younger moves their hand.

>But please stay on topic.

You made this about "muh ageism" not me, so all ages are fair to comment about. Shitty 25 year olds are actually worse than shitty 75 year olds, because shitty 25 year olds will be around much longer doing much more harm than a shitty 75 year old politician could. And again, it has nothing to do with age, and everything to do about corruption, greed, and hate. Those things are ageless.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by navane on Monday September 29, 2025 @07:11AM (#45412335)
Ok so then you compare the numbers and you see that one group is worse than the other. Just because you found one black pixel in a grey area doesn't mean its not white.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lm28469 on Sunday September 28, 2025 @04:54PM (#45407911)
It's not ageism, people deciding the future of your country shouldn't already have a foot in the grave

Just look at Trump and Biden speeches VS Bush or Obama

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:03PM (#45407979)
That’s like literally saying someone going off on someone because of their skin color (exclusively) isn’t being racist.

It’s in the definition. Words have meaning.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lm28469 on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:10PM (#45408049)
Not being able to drive, drink or vote before being adult is also ageism then I guess? It's weird I thought that was the law, hmmm
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:13PM (#45408073)
It is, literally. Just because it’s legal doesn’t change what it is.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lm28469 on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:19PM (#45408120)
OK so let's say it's ageism, why should I care again?

If your president can barely finish a coherent sentence and literally pisses in a plastic bag strapped to his leg I don't care how you call it but I want none of it

Same reason I don't leave my newborn baby alone with my 95 years old grandma who has dementia, call it ageism if you want, I call it basic common sense

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Monday September 29, 2025 @05:47AM (#45411888)
Ageist is thinking the reason it’s a bad idea to leave a baby with your grandma is because she’s 95 - not because she has dementia.

Which she could also have had at 50. Or even 35. Yes, early onset dementia is a thing.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lm28469 on Monday September 29, 2025 @08:56AM (#45413122)
Cognitive functions start to slowly decline after 50, and rapidly after 70

All I'm saying is that people in charge should have their full cognitive capabilities, see it's not ageism anymore!

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Monday September 29, 2025 @09:39AM (#45413651)
Make a test, and I bet you more folks than you expect would pass. then it’s not ageism.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by tjwebbnorfolk on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:21PM (#45408136)
Congratulations, you've labeled something. What's your point?
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:32PM (#45408249)
That words have meanings. I thought I was pretty clear about it?
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by tjwebbnorfolk on Monday September 29, 2025 @12:40AM (#45410388)
Ok so you're saying it's "ageist" to point out that marriage between 7-year-olds is a bad idea. Fine.

But is saying that's "ageist" have any purpose in that context? None whatsoever.

Words don't always have meaning. Sometimes they are just stuck in places where they serve no purpose in order to irritate people.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Monday September 29, 2025 @05:51AM (#45411909)
Straight to pedophilia/child abuse? You alright dude?
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by tjwebbnorfolk on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:15PM (#45446013)
ah, "pedophilia". Good job, you labeled a second thing!

Given your attempt to change the subject to my personal emotional state, I take it that you have no actual thoughts or insights to offer.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by prewett on Sunday September 28, 2025 @11:07PM (#45410018)
It's usually used as a slur, though. Not letting 3 year olds drive is changing behavior based on age, but sometimes you should be treating people differently based on some external attribute they cannot help. If most people a certain age do not meet the minimum requirements for the task (such as being able to see over the steering wheel and having a good judgement about rapidly changing situations), it is not "ageism" to say they cannot do something. Banning 3 year olds from driving is different than only hiring under-40 software developers.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Monday September 29, 2025 @07:21AM (#45412378)
I bet plenty of managers/owners could make arguments about the over-40 group, like unwillingness to work stupid hours, whatever random tech stack they want, etc.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by navbaker on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:25PM (#45408174)
The difference for purposes of the conversation happening here is skin color absolutely does not affect cognition where age definitely does.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Sunday September 28, 2025 @05:42PM (#45408347)
Plenty of 12 year old morons, and 90 year old razor sharp professors, as counter examples.

Either way, those same old folks are the ones who’d need to sign off on the rules banning their existence and I don’t see them doing that.

So who are the idiots exactly?

Personally, I think it’s the folks who think more rules will make a difference against someone who is explicitly great at violating rules and getting away with it. While pretending to be a moron.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lm28469 on Monday September 29, 2025 @09:01AM (#45413171)
Ah alright, let's not do anything about anything ever then. Criminals still do crimes, so obviously laws are useless am I right ?
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Monday September 29, 2025 @09:23AM (#45413455)
My point is actually enforce the god damn rules instead of making more bullshit rules that only get enforced against people without power.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by CamperBob2 on Monday September 29, 2025 @11:23AM (#45414968)
Mother Nature has made this particular rule, and you can only fool her for so long. 80+ year old people do not belong in positions of power, any more than 8-year-olds do. They should step aside and let the next generation take responsibility for their own future.

(Or rather make them take responsibility, in the case of voters who insist on electing Trumps, Reagans, Bidens, and Feinsteins simply because those are the candidates they've heard about, due to their having been around the longest.)

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by lazide on Monday September 29, 2025 @12:50PM (#45415935)
As I said in another comment - good luck!

If no one can unseat the king, they’re still the king.

And after all, if they really are as dumb and incompetent as you say that should be easy eh?

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by CamperBob2 on Monday September 29, 2025 @12:52PM (#45415958)
If no one can unseat the king, they’re still the king.

Well, in theory, we weren't supposed to have kings here, but it appears that the voters are going to insist on one.

And after all, if they really are as dumb and incompetent as you say that should be easy eh?

That's my usual response to Trumpers complaining about Democrats in my own state's legislature. I have to say, though, that it doesn't work any better for me than it will for you.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by seanmcdirmid on Sunday September 28, 2025 @11:37PM (#45410112)
Trump is about the same age as Bush and Clinton, oddly enough, but they were presidents in very different times.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by leptons on Monday September 29, 2025 @02:43AM (#45410954)
It has nothing to do with age, and everything to do with corruption, greed, and hate. And that is what a lot of people keep voting for.
Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by CamperBob2 on Monday September 29, 2025 @12:36AM (#45410368)
If you're too old to staff an airport control tower, you're too old for Congress and especially the Oval Office.

Not just because your faculties aren't what they once were, but because you have no stake in the outcome of your decisionmaking.

Re:China Is Run by Engineers. America Is Run by Lawyers by linhns on Monday September 29, 2025 @09:22AM (#45413441)
How can you expect them to legislate for the nation when they know they won’t be around when the policies come to fruition?