> In 2000, more than sixty percent of the city were native Brits. By 2024, that had dropped to about a third.
He then uses a statistic that "only a third" are native brits in 2021, which roughly lines up with the "White British" line in the chart.
You can argue that "white supremecist" is a charged and problematic term, but I'd say that "Here he complains about too many brown people in London." is a fairly accurate representation of the article. I'd say "disgraceful slander" is a bit too strong as a rebuttal.
I got pointed to the blog post, and it was such a strikingly-bad hot take that I had to write a response: http://paulbjensen.co.uk/2025/09/17/on-dhhs-as-i-remember-lo...
In my opinion, initially I thought "Oh David's been sucked into some kind of social media bubble (on X) or disinformation space", but then as I read the post, down to the bit where he started talking about "demographic replacement", I came to the view that this is who he is a person.
It's shocking and disappointing.
Unfortunately not - the page is a html export from a markdown editor (Typora), not a blog engine.
Where EU countries (I know this excludes the UK but it didn't for a long time) allow easy long-term immigration by EU policy. Even with Brexit, I don't think that culture of easy immigration is going to just up and disappear. So having a culture and/or policy of easy immigration alongside "well, actually, not those guys" where "those guys" includes anybody who's not already culturally/ethnically part of the nation is, minimally, counter-productive and perhaps a bit hypocritical.
Hasn’t been correct for at least the past decade, if you post here there’s a good chance you would be able to relocate to Japan and have permanent residency within 1-3 years.
Japan has one of the most generous immigration policies in the developed world at the moment.
In Canada here, we have land acknowledgements and it's politically correct to say we stole the land and should give it back to the natives. Then when native Europeans want to keep their land, it's white supremacy...
It's a very obvious double standard.
can we clarify... by whom? just kidding :) whether a country is "allowed" to do something is probably a red herring.
spitballing here, i think folks who engage in criticism of ethnonationalism are most likely to criticize the ethnonationalism they see close to home, as opposed to what might be happening on the other side of the planet.
there are valid critiques of japan's treatment of its nondominant ethnicities, and lots of anecdotal experiences covering the same, but it's a lot easier to discuss the nuances of an issue like this when you're more intimately familiar with the culture and sociopolitical history of a region.
> Denmark is primarily a country for the Danes, Britain primarily a united kingdom for the Brits, and Japan primarily a set of islands for the Japanese.
That is a white supremacist rhetoric and fascist rhetoric. Looking for racial purity based on geography was a core tenant of the Nazis [1], some of the most famous white supremacists (white german supremacists. Nobody is at their level.)
It's not libel if it's true.
America should be a country for Americans.
Which race am I talking about here?
If you don't believe that's the case, then tell me exactly what that phrase means other than to exclude some group. To claim "these are not real Americans".
> who isn't American?
Is this a trick question? People who were not born in America are clearly not American, save for naturalized citizens and a handful of other caveats. If you were born in Iceland, Greenland, Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark (just picking some traditionally/predominantly-white countries to really drive it home) and are not the child of a diplomat or even a citizen: you are not American.
Seriously: do you believe you are Japanese? If you actually are Japanese, do you think you're Peruvian, too? Are you also a Liechtensteiner? People are citizens of specific nations, believe it or not - this is not some new, misunderstood concept.
> means other than to exclude some group
Why is it a foregone conclusion that exclusion is automatically unjust?
Are countries not permitted to exclude people? Again: this is not based on race. Does one have an automatic right to immigrate wherever they please?
I'm done, you aren't been honest in this exchange.
But let me spell it out.
When someone says "America for the Americans" they are saying "not the Latinos or Muslims or brown people I don't like". This is crystal clear with how ICE is currently operating and by the number of Latino citizens they've arrested.
Also, yes, someone that naturalizes is American. We're a melting pot nation. You can be two things. American and Japanese. American and Peruvian, American and Mexican. Where you or your parents were born does not take away from you being American.
Feel free to write more about how "actually no, it's just a patriotic call".
> When someone says "America for the Americans" they are saying "not the Latinos or Muslims or brown people I don't like".
Strawman / circular reasoning. People can want less immigration in their country from everywhere and have it not be about "brown people" - you are the only one commenting about race. Countless legal immigrant Latinos don't want people "cutting in line," either, but that doesn't mesh with your diatribe.
> Also, yes, someone that naturalizes is American
Naturalization is subject to laws of the nation granting citizenship: and nations are allowed to exclude people based on criteria of their own design - not yours. We're not all "citizens of the world" with unlimited rights to immigrate under all circumstances: deal with it.
> not take away from you being American
Sure, but you might not be allowed to naturalize in the first place if you do not meet the criteria - or - gasp! - the country wants fewer new citizens!
I'm positively thrilled with the what the $30B+ invested into ICE is buying - years worth of illegal activity are being corrected as we speak.
You may not think that nationality is equivalent to race, but DHH does in the article you're referencing.
Overtime I gave him so much benefit of the doubt, and steelmanned his arguments because I really respected him as a Software Engineer and I aligned with him on his views in technology... But that blog post was the last straw. It's clear-as-day racism. No room for misinterpretation.
I was willing to overlook his remarks about DEI, Trump, Kirk, etc.... because there were nuggets of truth and genuine pain points.. but it turns out he was a racist, white supremacists all along. Sigh...
Do you not think that the article says that or do you not think that is white supremacy?
No, he didn't say that.
That's what you guys on the woke left always do: create a straw man and pretend he said the most appalling things you can think of.
The real DHH did not say that.
Are you saying that the blog did not say that he wants fewer non-white people in London? I picked out the specific parts in [1].
In addition there is this quote:
> I thought I might move there one day. That was then. Now, I wouldn't dream of it. London is no longer the city I was infatuated with in the late '90s and early 2000s. Chiefly because it's no longer full of native Brits.
He wouldn't dream of moving to London now because it now has a large proportion of non-"White British" people[1]. Is that not saying that he "wants fewer non-white people in London"?
Which part do you think is incorrect? The post reads quite clearly to me. I don't think he's being oblique.
He never said "I want fewer non-white people".
Every rational person knows what happens to a city when there's a massive influx of immigrants. So we all know what he is talking about, and it's not what you wrongly assumed.
> Why do the maintainers have a problem with this? I thought the stated reason was about RC removing everyone's access with no warning.
I seem to remember some of DHH's controversy due to banning politics at basecamp or something. Is it related to that?
I wouldn't be surprised. The presence of this quote in the linked document:
> A person’s character is determined not only by their actions, but also the actions they stay silent while witnessing.
Suggests that the person who wrote it is deeply obsessed with political activism.
Claiming otherwise is just a roundabout way of saying "you must actively support my agenda at all times, otherwise I will consider you my enemy, even if you take a neutral stance" that political activists love to use to pressure normal people into supporting them.
I think this is what we are discussing. Please share your viewpoint on this.
Under which of these categories would you classify the following assertion:
> As much as I've learned about subject X, I still feel that neither I — nor most people who are already acting, for that matter — truly have enough information to take an informed stance here, as the waters are being actively clouded by propaganda campaigns, censorship, and false-flag operations by one or both sides; and I believe that acting without true knowledge can only play into someone's hand in a way that may damage what turns out to be an innocent party I would highly regret damaging, when this all shakes out a decade down the line. I find myself too knowingly ignorant to conscientiously act... yet I also do not highly prioritize gaining any more information about the situation, as I have seemingly passed the threshold where acquiring additional verifiable and objective information on the conflict is cheap enough to be worth it; gaining any further knowledge to inform my stance is too costly for someone like me, who is neither an investigative journalist, nor a historiographer, nor enmeshed in the conflict myself. So I fear I must opt out of the conflict altogether.
I find myself increasingly arriving at exactly this stance on so many subjects that other people seem to readily take stances (and allow themselves to be spurred to action) on.
I suppose I may differ from the average person in at least one way — that being that, if I were tricked into harming innocent parties, I would hold myself to account for allowing myself to be tricked, rather than externalizing blame to the party responsible for tricking me. After all, only by my learning a lesson in avoiding being manipulated, do I actually lessen the likelihood of the next innocent party coming to harm. Which is a lot more important to me, in a rule-utilitarian sense, than is avoiding social approbation for not taking a stance.
You acknowledge your ignorance and then refuse to remedy that.
This is an act. Perfectly acceptable and understandable. But what is more important it's deliberate and you accept responsibility for any and all consequences.
> I suppose I may differ from the average person in at least one way — that being that, if I were tricked into harming innocent parties, I would hold myself to account for allowing myself to be tricked, rather than externalizing blame to the party responsible for tricking me.
Very commendable. I wish more people held themselves to this standard. It is one of the foundations of learning after all.
They did not say this. They said they would not highly prioritize it. Which is, of course, reasonable: given two topics, I have little metric to prioritize learning about one over the other. I have no way to know that I am prioritizing my research adequately.
I would like to put the emphasis on doing this consciously. This is the important point. Too many people just do not think or know what introspection is.
If someone doesn't know enough about an issue to care and also doesn't know the things that would motivate them to find out more about the issue that would make them care, that is true ignorance.
If someone doesn't know about an issue and deliberately avoids exposing themselves to things that would care, then it's a deliberate choice.
It just reads like thinly veiled racism.
Thinly veiled? What veil - it's completely naked, one can clearly see all the constituent parts, including the repugnant bits.
The Ruby Central that dropped him is not the same people running Ruby Central today.
Ehh, what?! Basically 0 developers in the US have quit as a protest against literal totalitarianism, major and obvious corruption, the end of vaccines (will kill countless) and the end of USAID (already killed.. how many kids?).
But, sure, DHH.. that's where we draw the line!
FFS
Edit: maybe I misunderstood why they quit, quite confused. Still..
Edit 2: Unclear if this has anything to do with DHH? And it turns out I also disagree with some of his views. But, it still stands, he's writing a blog, not literally killing kids. Where's the mass quittings for those people?
Can someone expand on what this means? Is it a continued relationship between Ruby Central and DHH, or the maintainers and DHH? Why does the other party have a problem with that?
EDIT: It seems the post was clarified since I copy/pasted this, and it's RC and DHH. Why do the maintainers have a problem with this? I though the stated reason was about RC removing everyone's access with no warning.