> Denmark is primarily a country for the Danes, Britain primarily a united kingdom for the Brits, and Japan primarily a set of islands for the Japanese.
That is a white supremacist rhetoric and fascist rhetoric. Looking for racial purity based on geography was a core tenant of the Nazis [1], some of the most famous white supremacists (white german supremacists. Nobody is at their level.)
It's not libel if it's true.
America should be a country for Americans.
Which race am I talking about here?
If you don't believe that's the case, then tell me exactly what that phrase means other than to exclude some group. To claim "these are not real Americans".
> who isn't American?
Is this a trick question? People who were not born in America are clearly not American, save for naturalized citizens and a handful of other caveats. If you were born in Iceland, Greenland, Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark (just picking some traditionally/predominantly-white countries to really drive it home) and are not the child of a diplomat or even a citizen: you are not American.
Seriously: do you believe you are Japanese? If you actually are Japanese, do you think you're Peruvian, too? Are you also a Liechtensteiner? People are citizens of specific nations, believe it or not - this is not some new, misunderstood concept.
> means other than to exclude some group
Why is it a foregone conclusion that exclusion is automatically unjust?
Are countries not permitted to exclude people? Again: this is not based on race. Does one have an automatic right to immigrate wherever they please?
I'm done, you aren't been honest in this exchange.
But let me spell it out.
When someone says "America for the Americans" they are saying "not the Latinos or Muslims or brown people I don't like". This is crystal clear with how ICE is currently operating and by the number of Latino citizens they've arrested.
Also, yes, someone that naturalizes is American. We're a melting pot nation. You can be two things. American and Japanese. American and Peruvian, American and Mexican. Where you or your parents were born does not take away from you being American.
Feel free to write more about how "actually no, it's just a patriotic call".
> When someone says "America for the Americans" they are saying "not the Latinos or Muslims or brown people I don't like".
Strawman / circular reasoning. People can want less immigration in their country from everywhere and have it not be about "brown people" - you are the only one commenting about race. Countless legal immigrant Latinos don't want people "cutting in line," either, but that doesn't mesh with your diatribe.
> Also, yes, someone that naturalizes is American
Naturalization is subject to laws of the nation granting citizenship: and nations are allowed to exclude people based on criteria of their own design - not yours. We're not all "citizens of the world" with unlimited rights to immigrate under all circumstances: deal with it.
> not take away from you being American
Sure, but you might not be allowed to naturalize in the first place if you do not meet the criteria - or - gasp! - the country wants fewer new citizens!
I'm positively thrilled with the what the $30B+ invested into ICE is buying - years worth of illegal activity are being corrected as we speak.
You may not think that nationality is equivalent to race, but DHH does in the article you're referencing.