A lid sensor is just so peripheral. Where do the vendor lock-ins end?
How'd we get to tyrannical government oversight from shitty corporate control? Sorry, I think I slipped on that slippery slope.
The better analogy would be "door lock vendor requires you to buy their door frame to make their door lock work with the security guarantees you chose to buy into."
Government should stay out of our private lives, but this kind of jumpy fear-mongering is what makes people lose focus, and when people are run by fear that's when the real psychopaths start taking advantage. Your fear mongering is creating the very government tyranny you're mongering about.
A more accurate analogy, is like a lock installed on your door by a locksmith that uses proprietary parts available only through locksmiths. Which is exactly how a lot of locks work.
Proprietary technology exists in a lot of places, Apple didn't invent this.
Yet, somehow, when it comes to technology products, we accept the manufacturer butting in to tell us how not to use them, and how not to repair them.
I can't name a single product in my house that uses any sort of open hardware design, except for the things, I've 3D printed or built myself.
There’s a whole repairability movement going on to maintain access to third party replacement parts for cars and appliances. This is a recent design choice that is being enforced by manufacturers. Historically, people have been able to repair everything they owned. Locking everything down is bad for consumers.
I understand arguments for repairability, and in most cases, I agree with them. But these things aren't boolean situations where things are either repairable or they are not. There's a lot of nuance in how things are designed and how repairable they are as an inherent part of that design. Ultimately, I agree that artificial lock-in for no reason other than that lock-in is a bad thing for consumers. But not everything is really that simple.
> Historically, people have been able to repair everything they owned.
It all depends on how you define "able". Most people lack technical ability to repair most things for thousands of years. And most things that you own today you are permitted to repair to the best of your ability.
Apple is worse than a government. They have more money and reach than many governments and unlike many government officials, the public doesn't have the power to vote the heads of apple out of office or vote for who they want as a replacement.
Apple didn't invent proprietary technology, but they leverage the shit out of it in consumer hostile ways just to take even more money from people.
Your relationship with Apple is very different. If you don't like Apple, you can just simply not buy or use their products. You have a choice and they have no way of compelling you otherwise.
And unlike my (technically democratically elected government), corporations do not have to answer to the people they exert their power over.
There’s a secondary argument you could make here whereby because the replacements must be valid Apple parts that have uniform behavior and tolerances, the strength of the secondary market is stronger and Apple products have a stronger resale value as a result, because you’re not going to encounter a MacBook with an arbitrary part replaced that you as the second-hand buyer know nothing about (this is why the secondary market for cars doesn’t work without the ability to lookup the car history by VIN).
These sorts of things are exactly the types of problems that exist in the used car market, for exactly the same reasons.
You can do whatever you want with your computer. But nobody has to design it the way you like it.
When I replace a wheel bearing assembly in my driveway, you still can't see that by looking up my VIN. Nobody knows except myself and the person I bought the parts from.
Was it a dealer part? An OEM part? A poor quality replacement? Can't tell without looking.
This might actually support Apple's side of the argument, although I do not. I don't think we need some Carfax equivalent for MacBooks.
In some ways, Apple's scheme is better than Carfax. In other ways, it's worse.
It's worse because you can't get access to the repair history of a device.
It's better because you can actually have a reasonable degree of confidence that no "driveway repairs" have taken place since Apple's scheme is not known to be broken.
I want Apple to lock down my device to customization, repairs, etc..
I know I am never going to install an app through means other than the app store, even if I could. I know I'm never going to repair my device through anyone other than Apple, even if I could. I want to know that my device will be a $1,000 paperweight to anyone who steals it.
I want to pay Apple to ensure there are no "driveway repairs".
A number of years ago I accidentally ended up with a second hand iPhone with a shitty "fake" screen repair. I had no way of knowing it wasn't an Apple screen. But it fucked me over as soon as it started failing a couple months after I bought it.
I get tired of the people demanding that a company, with willing, paying customers, isn't allowed to protect their customers because they want something the company doesn't offer. Fuck right off with that shit and buy from a company that does offer that.
They butchered your repair, you demand a fix or a compensation for a new phone. That's what customer protection laws are for.
Laws are how society operates.
If you need traffic rules (those are defined by laws fyi) then clearly individual's ability to drive isn't worth much. Let's abolish car ownership, make Apple operate all ground transportation and prohibit anyone else from deciding where Apple-operated cars go, what are operational hours and where the stops are.
Shhhhhh! Don’t give them any more bad ideas or they might actually do it.
If they could get away with it, they’d likely prevent resale entirely.
Apple already will give you discounts if you upgrade some things.
So the resale value will continue albeit at a fixed price
Kind of scary how "repairing your own things yourself" has fallen so far out of fashion. We should be applauding and encouraging people to build these kind of skills, not insulting them.
All four bearings are part of an assembly that bolts in. 8 or 12 bolts depending on position. I'm lucky that I don't even need a press.
The wheel comes off (5 bolts), the brakes come off (2 bolts), the axle/hub bolt comes out (1 bolt), and then on the front there are four bolts holding the assembly to the car. On the rear, nothing holds it on except that hub bolt.
Use a torque wrench to get them to spec. The kits came with new bolts. The axle bolts go on tight tight.
It's not so cut and dry though. The "user" and the "owner" of a product are not always the same person, but hardware security impacts the "user" more than the "owner".
The noise made about security is absolutely ridiculous.
Another answer, mine, is that one grandmother flew bombers, jets, spitfires, etc. in WWII and ran a post war international logistics company after that. The other did "stuff" with math.
ie. Both capable of understanding a security posture.
How about your grannies?
You might want to ask well formed questions in future, on a site such as HN the set of all grandmothers is hardly homogeneous.
The sensor in her macbook lid does not matter! Get real.
If you were a journalist reporting on russia or the UAE it would certainly matter.
Not to mention that it’s not that hard to imagine an AI tool being paired with 24/7 surveillance that reports back private information it hears.
It’s also not hard to imagine your average hackers getting their hands on a tool like that after a couple years of governments deploying it.
This laptop lid threat is fantasy. Get fucking real.
1984 references may have seen farfetched but after the suppression of rights using covid as an excuse people have little to no recourse to claim control back. Apple was always famous for their walled garden and tight control, but we have Google becoming like apple (can't install things in your device unless you go to them with your private details), ID to track your movements because "protect the children" (effectively blocking news even), chat control (very similar to installing a camera in your home and recording all your conversations).
Corps and governments are relying on each other to strengthen their control and it's not a surprise.
As the user and owner of the product, I should be the sole decider about my own security posture, not some company who doesn’t know my use case or needs.
It’s crazy how we’ve managed to normalize the manufacturer making these kinds of blanket decisions on our behalf.