This would probably make it more palatable to MAGA, but also I think to most other people too. It would probably destabilize municipalities: I have to imagine that most properties are dramatically over- or under-priced at present; on net I'd guess overpriced wins.
School districts are particularly tricky, though, for all the usual reasons.
For police, specifically because law and order is a core function of the state and to be provided to every resident regardless of ability to pay. If the state can't do that, it's called a failed state.
For fire, because just like car insurance there will be people who will evade the requirements, endangering others' lives and property. And we don't want firefighters to decide whether or not to save lives or neighboring properties based on coverage.
But it would be economically devastating to homeowners if they do not have fire coverage.
This isn't meaningfully different from property taxes, many break out costs by service anyway, but I find it compelling to view these as insurances.
I would speculate this would lead to a feedback loop of neighborhoods pushed into poverty or out of their homes by higher premiums, creating incentives for crime, leading to even higher premiums.
I don't think you do this in isolation. Ideally you rationalize the property tax while compensating for its progressive/welfare effects with other policies at the same time; certainly you don't just naively lower property taxes and hope for the best. (MAGA would never.)
Let's "unbundle it" from the property tax in the way you suggest. How do the police and fire departments set the fees? Are they fixed for everyone in their area, which is extremely regressive, or do they set a variable fee based on your property value?
What about people who don't own property. Do they not get police services? Does the state pay if a park is on fire? The federal government if it was public land? Where does that revenue come from?
How do the police and fire departments assess your property value? Does someone make a fortune building a software system for police and fire departments to manage all of this?
Does your private insurance actually pay the local police and fire department, kind of like escrow? What about people who don't get any kind of insurance and pay no fees? Does the state now step in and take the property from them, effectively enforcing a monopoly that the state doesn't benefit from?
When a derelict building begins to burn on a block and threatens in-use buildings around it, who pays the firefighters for stopping the derelict building's fire?
Let's go back to the fixed fee idea - what stops the new police and firefighter businesses from raising the price every year on every constituent? Will there be competing police and fire departments that offer lower rates (for lesser service?)?
When grandma on fixed social security's fire fighting fees go up too much for her to afford to live there any more, and now the state comes to take her home from her, what has changed from property taxes?
Once you really sit down and think about it, the idea that you "own" any real estate is kind of a joke. Your ownership is fully dependent on the operating paradigm of the government and society which has a monopoly on socially accepted force to establish and defend your property boundaries for you. For that, you pay rent to the state. Every discussion I've ever had with a "true" libertarian about this has had them eventually twisted up in circles to reinvent the state, with the only difference being that money (which the state currently makes meaningful) or willingness and ability to use force matters more than votes, both of which create winner-take-all feedback loops.
I'm not sure the case for one-big-bundle-of-property-taxes is any better, though. Where does THAT number come from?
> Every discussion I've ever had with a "true" libertarian about this has had them eventually twisted up in circles to reinvent the state
Same!
It isn't some mysterious, unknowable thing made up out of thin air. You can, in fact, dig into your local budget and find out what these things cost, how much you are paying for them, and the history of decisions that led to them being what they are.
1. Also apply to the present day pricing of property tax:
- "How do the police and fire departments set the fees?"
- "Are they fixed for everyone in their area"
- "how do the police and fire departments assess your property value?" - "Does someone make a fortune building a software system for police and fire departments to manage all of this?"
- "Does the state now step in and take the property from them, effectively enforcing a monopoly that the state doesn't benefit from?"
- "When a derelict building begins to burn on a block and threatens in-use buildings around it, who pays the firefighters for stopping the derelict building's fire?"
- "what stops the new police and firefighter businesses from raising the price every year on every constituent?
- "When grandma on fixed social security's fire fighting fees go up too much for her to afford to live there any more..."
2. Or pertain only to a version of my proposal where the insurance is not effectively required, and people can freely opt out - "What about people who don't get any kind of insurance and pay no fees?"
3. Or, are irrelevant to the specific question of how private property is taxed - "What about people who don't own property."
- "Does the state pay if a park is on fire?"
- "Will there be competing police and fire departments that offer lower rates (for lesser service?)?"
- "Functionally, the state is in the best position to capture the necessary revenue to support these services." (The state simply can be the insurer! I did not even propose *private* insurance.)
Literally every single one! It's like you were arguing with someone else who proposed something entirely different--the libertarian you cite, perhaps, someone you argued with in the past?I think in fact a well-executed insurance-like system would be functionally equivalent to the status quo, except that it would be far more efficiently priced.
I suspect the only real difference is that property tax, due to the path-dependent history by which it got this way, has wound up being substantially progressive as a tax, compared to what you would get if you tried to rationalize it. And it therefore feels impossible to replace it, because you'd set back all that progressive taxation, only to run into the problems that lead to the status quo in the first place. We really don't like to admit what it is what we're the govt paying for; the lump sum of taxes is a way of protecting the revenue streams that support public benefits from too much individual scrutiny.
But surely there is some other approach to keep moral-upside public goods in tact than this "security through obscurity". Surely.
> Once you really sit down and think about it, the idea that you "own" any real estate is kind of a joke.
I agree with this! It would be far better to model property ownership outright as renting from the public. People are awfully attached to the fiction of "ownership", though, and I think that deserves some credit.
No I didn't.
> I think in fact a well-executed insurance-like system would be functionally equivalent to the status quo, except that it would be far more efficiently priced.
I argued against this. Taking the principals of HN and assuming good faith here, I think you're missing my points, so I will try and connect them to your arguments more clearly.
> All your objections either:
> 1. Also apply to the present day pricing of property tax
No they do not. Property tax rates are transparent, insurance prices are not. I know what was voted on and who chose what to set my property taxes, I do not know why my insurance is half the price at one insurance provider compared to another.
Is the cost of American Healthcare more transparent in the US with mixes of public and private options or in single payer countries?
> 2. Or pertain only to a version of my proposal where the insurance is not effectively required, and people can freely opt out
No, my point is that this cannot be successfully enforced (we try, all the time), so the world where it is "effectively" required is one that does not exist, thus the arguments must be made for a real world where X% will not pay for private insurance, and X% is >0 and probably <15% of uninsured motorists.
> 3. Or, are irrelevant to the specific question of how private property is taxed
We are talking about paying for policing and firefighting. If you include policing, then you must include people who do not pay the local police simply because they are traveling, unhoused, passing through, visiting a friend, or otherwise. How exactly does this work for them to pay for the services rendered?
> The state simply can be the insurer! I did not even propose private insurance.
> It seems like you could straightforwardly unbundle the property tax into a bunch of specific fees and insurances. We're comfortable requiring car insurance, why not fire and police?
This is what you said, the state does not provide car insurance so I made the assumption you meant private insurers.
If you meant the state provides the insurance for all of these things then you have simply reinvented the existing taxes. Literally nothing has changed.
> I think in fact a well-executed insurance-like system would be functionally equivalent to the status quo, except that it would be far more efficiently priced.
It would be *exactly* the status quo - the sate is the monopoly provider of these services, and they are required. Why would renaming them make them more efficiently priced? It would still be a monopoly, it would still be subject to both politics and the bureaucracy. I feel as if you are trying to argue both points simultaneously - that it should be a private competitive market (so it is priced efficiently) and that it should be a state enforced fee that goes to the state and pays for services provided by the state.
There is no such thing as efficient pricing for public services because...
> I suspect the only real difference is that property tax, due to the path-dependent history by which it got this way, has wound up being substantially progressive as a tax, compared to what you would get if you tried to rationalize it. And it therefore feels impossible to replace it, because you'd set back all that progressive taxation, only to run into the problems that lead to the status quo in the first place. We really don't like to admit what it is what we're the govt paying for; the lump sum of taxes is a way of protecting the revenue streams that support public benefits from too much individual scrutiny.
You cannot "rationalize" policing by the value it provides, public goods have benefits beyond the immediate receiver of those benefits. Who is getting more benefit from police officers, a person in a bad neighborhood who has to call every week over a disturbance or violence or someone who has a lot of property in a wonderful neighborhood whose entire life is propped up by the state's monopoly on force to defend them?
Okay, so firefighting isn't quite the same as policing and let's say you go with something like risk pricing. You're going to end up with a bimodal distribution - the poor tend to live in higher risk neighborhoods or zones and the wealthy have lots of assets to protect. So you've effectively shifted the burden away from the middle class to the poor and wealthy. What benefit did that give?
> We really don't like to admit what it is what we're the govt paying for; the lump sum of taxes is a way of protecting the revenue streams that support public benefits from too much individual scrutiny.
This is where you keep really losing me. Public taxes are transparent, you can find something like this at almost any level: https://kingcounty.gov/en/dept/assessor/buildings-and-proper.... The budgets are public. The history of decisions are piublic. You've probably even voted for a bond proposal that would be paid for with property tax changes, meaning you had a direct say in how much they are!
The gist of the argument I have read is:
1. Rename the revenue the state collects for some public services from "tax" to "insurance payment."
2. Send individual bills for those different services.
3. ???
4. Efficiency goes up.
I can guess that this would not change the cost of those services because of mass revolt, but I can guarantee that the billing systems alone would cost so much more that whatever efficiency you think would be gained would be eaten up by a private provider of billing software and call center services :)
And that is exactly why any service that is universally required is best handled as a "tax". I put tax in quotes because it might be literally paid from taxes, or could be a mandatory fee charged by the government under some other name, but still looks and quacks like a tax, so same thing.
So yes, car insurance should be simply part of the registration payment. No use making it more complicated since everyone is better off if every car has insurance. Anything that is unconditionally mandatory is best paid from taxes.
I didn't miss it. I said "just like car insurance there will be people who will evade the requirements" (meaning: not buy insurance). Maybe you missed that? :-)
I don't see the point of criticizing a policy idea with an argument like "it will be implemented badly so it will be bad". Like, obviously, yes, if you do it badly it will be bad. That applies to anything, including the status quo.
If you need additional taxes, I recommend piguovian taxes on road congestion, pollution, and other bad stuff. This cut down on bad stuff within your environment and reduces incidences like fire. Cars catches on fire all the time.
Code enforcement and insurance coverage also helps with cutting down on fire and such.
Also, local government services encourages or protect economic growth. I don't like paying taxes based on usage, because public education benefits me whether I use it or not. I'll gladly pay for public education regardless.
"House value always go up" is a relatively recent invention.
It's a tax system to create economic incentives for density.
> "House value always go up" is a relatively recent invention.
Everyone wanting to live in a few economically hot cities is also a recent invention. If you price the LVT in those cities appropriately, then only the most income generating projects are going to be viable, and that means the lower class is basically not going to be living in those cities anymore.
It's not a recent invention that people wants to live in cities. It's the suburbanization and sprawling that's odd.
The lower class already can't live in those cities anymore in the first place. You need to expand the supply of housing to make this possible, which means more efficient use of land which is what urbanists has been advocating for years to fix the housing crisis.
If most efficient usage means most profitable usage, and LVT pushes to penalize any usage that isn’t as profitable as it could be, then the market will deliver exactly that and all other use cases are screwed.
There's no reason not to satisfy the core's demand for infill development. This means increased tax revenue for the cities relative to infrastructure cost, thus more budgetary capacity to throw at problems..
Mandating affordable housing is an expensive proposition and developers will drag their feet unless subsidized. They don't build things out of the goodness of their heart after all.
While subsidies are a useful tool, I am not sure if it's useful to allocate to affordable housing as opposed to incentivizing developers to take on more projects and urban renewal projects.
You're also discouraging adding housing stocks by discouraging new construction. This is a nonsensical approach advocating for a normal property tax.
No, it's both.
People correlate to things like schools. Buildings correlate to things like the fire department, precisely because -- as you put it -- an empty apartment building will catch fire too. And construction regulation, and the courts, and all sorts of stuff. There are a lot of government services that really are building-oriented as opposed to person-oriented.
IMHO schooling ought to be funded entirely at the state/federal level, not the local level, just for greater economic equality and opportunity. But since it is funded at the local level, and people don't like high sales taxes (and taxing visitors buying stuff to pay for local schools is weird), and local income taxes often don't exist, it ends up being property taxes. Still, there are some states that do have local income taxes, which is generally a much better solution.
If an arsonist sets fire to an apartment building this is a bigger problem (bigger fire, harder to fight) than if they set fire to a house.
This will only be true in a world where nobody moves, which is not the world we live in. Like, if all jobs are in California and New York, one would expect house prices to rise there (while collapsing everywhere).
Remote would have made this much less bad, but it turns out that's not going to happen to the extent people expected during Covid (mind you, lots of people did naive extrapolation during Covid which basically hasn't worked out anywhere).
As Mason Gaffney notes in his article, "Containment Policies for Urban Sprawl"
"Consider water distribution. If demand doubles within a fixed service area by doubling density, we need simply expand all pipe diameters—and not by double, but by the square root of two, since cross-sections increase with the square of the radius. But if demand doubles by doubling the service area, at constant density, we must, (a) double our pipe mileage; (b) double the cross section of our old system at its base, and more than double it elsewhere, to transmit the extra load through to the new extension; (c) increase pressure at the system load center to maintain it at the fringes (especially if the new lands are higher); and (d) upgrade our pipe-joints to hold the extra pressure.
Actually those four simplest considerations understate the case a good deal. We should add the factor of peaking. The fewer customers on a given line, the higher is the usual ratio of peak demand to mean daily demand because there is less pooling of offsetting demand patterns, and more lawn sprinkling. There is also a factor of planning expansion.
"Containing urban sprawl" does not imply halting growth, but holding it inside compact increments, whose ultimate density is known in advance and will be reached quickly, saving utilities from the waste of under- or oversizing their lines in the face of uncertainty. Urban sprawl as known today not only reduces density but breeds extreme uncertainty of future density."
We need both.
We need land value taxation to reflect that land is a limited resource, and incentivize building tall apartment buildings downtown instead of wasteful parking lots.
On the other hand, we still need to tax houses and buildings because they correlate to usage of local government services. Whether it's the fire department where 20 apartments are 20x more likely to catch fire than a single tiny home, or the police where a large rich mansion is more likely to be targeted by theives than a tiny home, or schools where the larger a building is, the more likely it is to have more kids needing education (or more adults who once benefited from public schooling and are now paying it forwards).
Taxes are for allocating originally public resources efficiently (whether radio spectrum or land), and for paying for mandatory government services which you're not allowed to opt out of.