Oh, I know, that's the destabilization I mentioned in the first case.
I don't think you do this in isolation. Ideally you rationalize the property tax while compensating for its progressive/welfare effects with other policies at the same time; certainly you don't just naively lower property taxes and hope for the best. (MAGA would never.)
I would speculate this would lead to a feedback loop of neighborhoods pushed into poverty or out of their homes by higher premiums, creating incentives for crime, leading to even higher premiums.