News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rododecba on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:49PM (#44997195)
I recently launched Libre , a small side project and social experiment. It’s not a social network, but kind of the opposite:

No profiles, usernames, or followers

No likes, trending topics, or algorithms

No ads, no data collection

Just anonymous thoughts from people around the world. Curious to see how it evolves and what kind of conversations happen when metrics are removed.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by roscas on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:55PM (#44997242)
To be anonymous you cannot use gstatic.com because this way you're just telling google I was there. Also tailwindcss and unpkg call sell data to others and there you go zero anonimous. I'm sure you can fix this.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by Hoodedcrow on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:28PM (#44998009)
Thankfully, Ublock Origin in advanced mod can block those requests by default. It's just very irritating and I'd say disrespectful when you HAVE to unblock them for the site to work.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rododecba on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:09PM (#44998311)
i dont know any other way to show where the msg was sent if not
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by dragonwriter on Sunday August 24, 2025 @01:32AM (#45001664)
"I don't know how to do this while maintaining anonymity" is not an excuse to do it in a way which does not maintain anonymity while claiming it does.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by colesantiago on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:27PM (#44998000)
You might as well not use the web / internet at this point.

Unless you use busybox or an esoteric OS to browse the web, almost every browser or OS (macOS, Linux, Windows) will ping to Google or some other bad spyware website.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by sebastiennight on Sunday August 24, 2025 @10:15AM (#45004412)
FYI this statement is wrong. You don't need an "esoteric OS". Just a firewall (such as Little Snitch on MacOS) and one of several browsers (such as Firefox) will enable you to browse the web without constantly calling home to Google.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by colesantiago on Sunday August 24, 2025 @04:55PM (#45007689)
Firefox is funded by Google. By using it, Google is still benefiting from it, use a different browser.

Google is known for trying an assortment of IPs and DNS addresses to get around blockers such as Little Snitch on popular software.

But that isn't enough to get around Google's tracking hence you would need an esoteric OS.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by sebastiennight on Sunday August 24, 2025 @05:17PM (#45007869)
> Firefox is funded by Google. By using it, Google is still benefiting from it, use a different browser.

1. You're moving the goalposts here. We were talking about avoiding tracking/pinging Google

2. Google pays Firefox to be the default search engine. If you change the search engine, how are you benefitting Google? They're paying for eyeballs that you're not providing, so you're technically making them spend money in vain.

> Google is known for trying an assortment of IPs and DNS addresses to get around blockers such as Little Snitch on popular software.

If we assumed that this was true, I don't see how switching out the OS makes any difference to the tactic of Google "trying an assortment of IPs and DNS addresses" from a 3rd-party website, which is where this conversation started.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by colesantiago on Sunday August 24, 2025 @06:49PM (#45008507)
> If we assumed that this was true, I don't see how switching out the OS makes any difference...

Because we want absolutely zero Google tracking here and an esoteric OS has zero Google tracking. Not in source code not in network requests, zero.

No amount of "Little Snitch" will help you here.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by sebastiennight on Sunday August 24, 2025 @07:32PM (#45008770)
I'm not even sure you're being serious here, but I'll assume good faith.

What Google tracking is there in, for instance, vanilla MacOS?

I have my traffic logs, so please let me know and I'll check it for myself.

Edit: and please don't say "Safari has Google as the default engine", since we've covered that above. What else is there?

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by colesantiago on Sunday August 24, 2025 @07:50PM (#45008869)
> What Google tracking is there in, for instance, vanilla MacOS?

Mail > Google

Internet Accounts > Google

As I said:

> Absolutely zero Google tracking here and an esoteric OS has zero Google tracking. Not in source code not in network requests, zero.

Even with the mere integration of Google this deep into the OS is enough for those respect their privacy to not want to use MacOS.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by sebastiennight on Sunday August 24, 2025 @08:34PM (#45009106)
Well I don't know what "Internet Accounts" are, and your claim that Apple Mail uses Google tracking seems like an extraordinary claim that requires some sources (I couldn't find anything about that), so I think we should leave this conversation at that.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by colesantiago on Monday August 25, 2025 @05:12AM (#45011851)
Well, maybe you don't know your computer / OS as much as you think you do.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by hackrmn on Monday August 25, 2025 @05:39AM (#45012018)
This isn't accurate. I mean in generally you're pointing in the right direction. Your vague statements on "esoteric OS" are not helpful, and in fact I think that it is maybe _you_ who don't know your computer as well as the person you were replying to, do -- after all they bring up relevant and actual details while you point at generalities like "Mail > Google".

Let me try to steer this in a constructive direction -- you're implying use of "GMail" with your "Mail > Google". That is fine -- it's certainly possible to set up a Google account with Mac OS X through the "Accounts" feature, implying SSO and/or reusable credentials API.

But that does not come as default with the OS, and it requires active user participation, which makes your argument a bit of shifting the goal posts indeed -- Mac OS X does not send any data to Google by default, not out of the box. You do not need an "esoteric OS", and such an OS set up with something like described above for Mac OS X, or to demonstrate the simplicity of your argument, a Google Chrome binary blob (e.g. Ubuntu) makes the OS much less "esoteric" since it's now too a "Google vehicle". Point being that Mac OS is not a Google vehicle by default. Neither is Windows, for that matter. And this for a very simple reason -- normally both Apple and Microsoft are _competitors_ to Google, and they would very much prefer the data they would have been able to collect on the user, is sent upstream to Apple and Microsoft respectively, not to their competitor. But that is tangential, again -- the primary point is that by default Internet is not Google, not with e.g. Firefox on Windows.

Let me be perfectly clear -- there's zero tracking by Google unless you use one or multiple of a) a Google provided Web browser, e.g. Chrome, and b) use Google's Web services. By using e.g. Firefox (which is indeed funded by Google) your data are _not_ sent to Google by default, and a Web extension like uMatrix also nips attempts by sites to send data to Google, in the bud. None of this is an esoteric OS.

I have nothing against warning us against Google monopoly, but I find your follow-up replies to be deflections and doubling down when the person is making it perfectly clear that their network does not contain data being sent to Google (in as far as they can trust their packet logs, I would say, but if you were to contest that, you'd need to try harder indeed).

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by colesantiago on Monday August 25, 2025 @07:47AM (#45012819)
Unfortunately you are 100% wrong and highly naive.

> But that does not come as default with the OS, and it requires active user participation, which makes your argument a bit of shifting the goal posts indeed -- Mac OS X does not send any data to Google by default, not out of the box ... There's zero tracking by Google unless you use one or multiple of a) a Google provided Web browser, e.g. Chrome, and b) use Google's Web services.

I have been perfectly clear about this:

> Not in source code not in network requests, zero.

You do realise that gstatic.com is a web service right that can be used for tracking.

The OP does not any Google requests, this includes gstatic, connectivitycheck.gstatic.com, Google owned IP addresses, DNS addresses and anything that can or could connect to or is affiliated with Google in anyway possible.

This includes Google baked into the source code that nobody asked for that can connect to Google for their own purposes. You have no clue what could change in an OS update with MacOS that you didn't ask for, and now with Apple is trying to work with Google to try and bake Google Gemini into their OS to power a voice assistant, an upcoming privacy nightmare nobody asked for. (0)

The fact that macOS is has Google integration baked into the OS with Mail, Calendar, Search, etc makes me not recommend it for anyone that cares about privacy.

> Your vague statements on "esoteric OS" are not helpful.

Here is a concrete example:

You can use the base Linux kernel as an example, there are zero sources of Google in there which can be used as the basis of an "esoteric OS" so it is a good practical starting point to base a proper "ZeroGoogle" OS. Not any standard distro.

I even said busybox at one point, but you chose to ignore that.

Windows has its own different tracking which the OP also doesn't want so that is a complete moot point.

If you are serious about privacy and don't want any Google tracking, you would use an esoteric OS.

(0) https://techcrunch.com/2025/08/22/apple-is-in-talks-to-use-g...

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:48PM (#44998124)
No value--people want content that is focused, accurate, curated, reliable, relevant, high quality, etc.

Also no freedom, with all your content restrictions.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by petralithic on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:01PM (#44998224)
To the first point, could there not be an algorithm that nevertheless still works without followers, likes or ads? TikTok seems kind of similar, at least when it initially started. It seems its core algorithm doesn't need likes, it can detect whether you engage with a video via other metrics like time spent watching the video.

I suppose you'd want to allow people to self select based on topics, and then, well, you essentially get Reddit.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by mindcrime on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:06PM (#44998288)
people want content that is focused, accurate, curated, reliable, relevant, high quality, etc.

That is trivially disproven by observing that massive numbers of people use Twitter, Facebook, etc.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by incone123 on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:17PM (#44998385)
You can follow accounts which is a form of curation. I dropped all social media except this one because it was a time-sink but I did used to find following resulted in a useful feed on Instagram.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:13PM (#44998358)
It's a fact so it can't be disproven. Your response is a fallacy of denial of the antecedent.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by sebastiennight on Sunday August 24, 2025 @10:19AM (#45004442)
Adding "it's a fact" to claims does not make them impossible to disprove. You made a wild generalization (with the assumed meaning that ALL people want X) and the GP shared examples of people consuming "not X".

You can also see, on this same thread, people explicitly building experiments of uncurated content, which means they want it so much that they are willing to spend much effort building it themselves.

What would it take for you to consider that listing what you want does not necessarily imply a "fact" that all people want the same?

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Thursday August 28, 2025 @11:35AM (#45053520)
P.S.

> You made a wild generalization (with the assumed meaning that ALL people want X)

Assumed by whom? Only by your obviously false assumption did I make a wild generalization. i.e., the charge is a lie.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rododecba on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:05PM (#44998281)
i cant make a site with 100% freedom, beacuse of obvious reasons, that would be like utopic i think
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:12PM (#44998334)
Then don't call it that.

There's nothing about your site that grants me the sort of freedoms I want, including the freedom to locate useful content.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by buynlarge on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:40PM (#44998548)
Nah, disagree. I feel more free on this site than all the others so I back the name.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rododecba on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:22PM (#44998418)
i think that maybe you are looking in mi site something thats already in others
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:25PM (#44998440)
P.S. I'm not looking for anything in your site, I'm just saying that it's not what you're presenting it as.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by atoav on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:02PM (#44998239)
Ah the good old "freedom to" that totally forgets that freedom also should contain a "freedom of". Free like in a chaotic war zone, where you can commit any kind of horrible attrocity, but if you just want to have a nice time, that isn't an option, because everybody behaves like an idiot. No thanks.

Freedom in reality isn't just a thing that you increase by reducing the rules. There comes a point where less rules result in less freedom. So it is always a balancing act between your freedom to do X and others freedom to not have to be subjected to X. Example: Giving up the freedom being able to murder random people is a little price to pay, if it means reducing the risk to be murdered yourself – especially since decent people wouldn't have the actionable urge to murder each other anyways. If you're a murderer however that may reduce your freedom in ways you dislike. But then, maybe, your freedom shouldn't matter as much.

Maybe I would care more about that specific idea of active freedom if I routinely wittnessed a real repression of any idea that isn't just the mean bullshit of egocentrics who have lost all touch with humanity and just want to see the world burn.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:17PM (#44998383)
I didn't say that I wanted a "freedom to" site, I'm just saying that the site is mischaracterized.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by atoav on Sunday August 24, 2025 @02:53AM (#45001963)
And I saw a ton of racist, genozidal, sexualized and otherwise unhinged content that the worst people would think call "freedom".

So again, tell me what you're unfree to write there?

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Sunday August 24, 2025 @09:56AM (#45004283)
I already said. And again, I'm not seeking that sort of freedom ... the one sort of freedom the site offers is freedom from moral consequence.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by sebastiennight on Sunday August 24, 2025 @10:23AM (#45004476)
It's not, sadly, because technological choices are ethical choices.

Your site uses technologies that make it trivial for large entities (like Google) to know that person X living in Atlanta just posted a certain racially-charged diatribe.

This might come back to bite them in the rear-end in the future, in ways that they don't suspect today, because this data is never getting deleted and might be available to untold numbers of private and state actors in the future.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by neilv on Saturday August 23, 2025 @04:05PM (#44998704)
> No ads, no data collection [...] Just anonymous thoughts from [...]

It currently leaks cross-site user tracking information to Google (www.gstatic.com).

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jandrese on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:00PM (#44998216)
So you launched /b/?
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by guerrilla on Saturday August 23, 2025 @04:12PM (#44998761)
This is what I thought too. It'll go full Nazi in less than 5 hours from now. Anyone want to place bets?
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by Xevion on Sunday August 24, 2025 @02:24AM (#45001859)
Haha, have you checked on it lately? You had it right on the money dude. The thing allowed HTML injection. It went from the N word and a couple emojis to downright ear-piercing multitudes of fascist /b/ propaganda over the course of an hour.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by guerrilla on Sunday August 24, 2025 @05:11AM (#45002683)
And now it's completely broken this morning...
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by politelemon on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:54PM (#44998166)
The first message is from July 2022. Is it really recent?
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rododecba on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:08PM (#44998302)
i launched it 1 month ago aprox
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by riidom on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:19PM (#44997956)
Could you look into your dark mode please? Thank you!:)
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by ranger_danger on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:29PM (#44998015)
I highly suggest the Dark Reader extension.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by textadventure on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:09PM (#44998308)
As some who loves dark mode, I hate that extension. I get the appeal of forcing every website to be dark mode, but that ends up breaking half of them or just making them look like trash. People need to custom design their dark modes for whatever each design is.

If you don't care about breaking design and stuff looking the way its supposed to, I guess the extension is fine but I rather use something like Stylus where you can use people's custom designed stylesheets for most known sites.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by ranger_danger on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:13PM (#44998344)
I love it and I've never had a problem with it... I don't get the hate at all /shrug
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by riidom on Monday August 25, 2025 @10:13AM (#45014080)
I have Dark Reader. I think it wasn't working properly for me. Right now the site is 404, can't check.

But I agree with other commentors, Dark Reader isn't the solution. There is not really an excuse for not doing a builtin darkmode nowadays, imo.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by cxr on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:11PM (#44998321)
What are algorithms?
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by mattigames on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:53PM (#44998159)
No way to filter by subjects one may be interested, no way to find likeminded individuals, no way to mute people, so yeah, not much value could be derived from it; I think that there is space for some pseudo-anonymous social network but this is not it, at least not in its current state.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by ranger_danger on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:10PM (#44997905)
> Curious to see how it evolves

being a haven for sharing very illegal content is probably how it's going to evolve... unfortunately

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by PaulHoule on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:13PM (#44997918)
Some kind of trouble one way or the other.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by gsf_emergency_2 on Saturday August 23, 2025 @11:00PM (#45000944)
Strong link trouble or weak link trouble :)?

In any case..

I hope TW Körner doesn't have that last footnote on the topic..

(Fwiw left/right (meta-)division seems to me to encompass all the moral taxonomies of the day, TWK just happened to settle for rich/smart vs social wrt UK)

>Social Darwinism applies the Darwinian doctrine of survival of the fittest to human society. Rich social Darwinists take wealth as the best indication of fitness to survive, academic social Darwinists take intellectual achievements as the best indication and so on. They are often haunted by the fear that the unfit do not understand this and may outbreed the fit.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24154247

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by PaulHoule on Saturday August 23, 2025 @11:04PM (#45000962)
God that guy might turn up close to me by an embedding search.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by gsf_emergency_2 on Saturday August 23, 2025 @11:19PM (#45001044)
;)

(For some reason the algolia DB wasn't properly normalised)

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rododecba on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:08PM (#44998304)
hopefuly not, thank you
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by jibal on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:27PM (#44998450)
Why wouldn't it? How would you prevent it?

You talk about evolution ... that's change over time. How it evolves is how you decide to change it.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by majorchord on Saturday August 23, 2025 @03:14PM (#44998362)
it's inevitable with any anonymous service
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by ranger_danger on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @09:39PM (#45034504)
so.. how's that working out for you
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by krapp on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:31PM (#44998030)
>Curious to see how it evolves and what kind of conversations happen when metrics are removed.

I've seen a ton of projects like this. It will get deluged with spam and shitposts and people will stop caring once the novelty wears off and leave once it becomes a cesspool. Probably for 4chan which at least has a culture and established userbase. And porn.

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by listic on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:02PM (#44999112)
There's no way of ever hearing back; being responded to, right?
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by 48terry on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:47PM (#44999401)
Your site about "pure freedom of expression" and "raw thoughts" stops me from posting about buying new golf balls because of a badwords.js word filter.

Why are your Terms of Service and Privacy Policy a collection of empty bullet points?

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rkomorn on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:49PM (#44999409)
How can you comment this without including the post content that triggered the filter?
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by 48terry on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:52PM (#44999428)
Literally just try it: "golf balls".

The badwords.js isn't even particularly hidden if you check the page's source: https://libreantisocial.com/badwords.js

Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rkomorn on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:58PM (#44999467)
I'll add that, based on the other posts I saw on the site, it certainly didn't occur to me that there was any filtering in place.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by 48terry on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:59PM (#44999475)
Well, badwords.js is client side, so if you just block it from loading you can post about balls and butts and slurs as much as you like. Absolutely incredible stuff.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by rkomorn on Saturday August 23, 2025 @05:56PM (#44999455)
I... did not think you were being quite so literal.
Re:Libre – An anonymous social experiment without likes, fol... by heavensteeth on Sunday August 24, 2025 @01:29AM (#45001654)
Did you vibe code this by any chance? It's clearly insecure.

Oh, yes, you did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44656840