Re:Vibechart
by I_am_tiberius on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:06PM
(#44830963)
It would be interesting to know how this occurred. I assume there may have been last-minute high-level feedback suggesting: "We can't let users see that the new model is only slightly better than the old one. Adjust the y-axis to make the improvement appear more significant."
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Vibechart
by yoyohello13 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:16PM
(#44831050)
It’s genuinely terrifying that people this incompetent have so much money and power.
It’s more terrifying that no one cares about the truth it seems anywhere. Vibeworld, we are all selling vaporware and if you don’t build it who cares move into the next hype cycle that pumps the stock / gets VC funding. Absurd industry.
We're feeling the effects of living in a post-truth society more and more every day. It's pretty terrifying.
Re:Vibechart
by m_herrlich on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:17PM
(#44831068)
It might not incompetent to assume the audience is not very discerning
OpenAI is currently getting dunked on, on all major platforms. It is incompetent.
Re:Vibechart
by throwawayoldie on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:21PM
(#44831605)
People reading Hacker News are the target audience, and here we are, discerning.
Speak for yourself!
Re:Vibechart
by throwawayoldie on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:25PM
(#44831639)
I only ever do. But I rephrased my post to make my meaning clearer. Nice discernment there.
Re:Vibechart
by 01HNNWZ0MV43FF on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:46PM
(#44831338)
Hey, could be malice
Re:Vibechart
by ElijahLynn on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:22PM
(#44831620)
The magic that is ChatGPT is definitely not incompetence.
They may not be perfect, but they provided a lot of value to many different industries including coding.
Re:Vibechart
by AdieuToLogic on Thursday August 07, 2025 @08:55PM
(#44832208)
> The magic that is ChatGPT ...
Any sufficiently advanced technology is
indistinguishable from magic.[0]
0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarke%27s_three_laws
Re:Vibechart
by burnt-resistor on Thursday August 07, 2025 @10:06PM
(#44832669)
In the US political sphere, this is why legitimized corruption must be eliminated before it eliminates us.
Maybe they asked GPT-5 to update slides.
Re:Vibechart
by qustrolabe on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:58PM
(#44831430)
GPT-5 would've caught this mismatch for sure
Re:Vibechart
by datadrivenangel on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:06PM
(#44831501)
Claude and ChatGPT actually took me several prompts to get them to identify this. They recognized from a screenshot that labeled axes that start at zero can be misleading, but missed the actual issue.
thats hilarious actually. gives credence to the gpt theory haha
How hard would it be for the model to be like: "Okay, there's a bar chart in the picture, the left bar is 350 px in size and the right bar is 120 px. Meanwhile, the labeled values are X and Y, which doesn't seem to match those relative sizes due to this math I ran thanks to all the cool deterministic tools I have."
Apparently quite a bit.
That seemingly depends a bit on how hard you ask it to think, or how hard it decides to think based on your question.
"ChatGPT, this slide deck feels a bit luke warm, help me make a better impression"
I could completely believe someone who is all-in on the tech, working in marketing, and not really that familiar with the failure modes, using a prompt like this and just missing the bad edit.
Re:Vibechart
by outside1234 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:24PM
(#44831638)
There is a smell of desperation around OpenAI, so I wouldn't be surprised if this level of hypevibing came from the top.
I mean this is the industry standard. For example every time Nvidia dumps a new GPU into the ether, they do the same thing. Apple with M series CPUs. They even go a step further and compare a few generations back.
Re:Vibechart
by datadrivenangel on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:19PM
(#44831080)
It's dishonest and the multiple examples in the same presentation tell you what you need to know about the credibility of the presenters
There's only one error, bar height for o3. Somehow height uses value from 4o, which seems like some sort of copy paste error.
EDIT: I was looking just at the first chart. I didn't see there's more below.
Did you miss the picture below where the bar for 50% is lower than the bar for 47.4%
And even if it’s just one chart. There are 3 or 4 bars (depends on how you count) so they screwed up 33%/25 % of the chart.
Quite an error margin.
Oh, I did miss it. Thanks!
> Did you miss the picture below where the bar for 50% is lower than the bar for 47.4%
That one was added later, if I interpret the attribution at the bottom correctly. And I'm also pretty sure it wasn't there when I first saw it pop up.
Re:Vibechart
by andrewstuart2 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:46PM
(#44831337)
The other chart on that slide was actually to scale. My suspicion is that it was super rushed to the deadline for this presentation and they maybe didn't use excel or anything automatic for the charts, so they look better, and they missed the detail due to time pressure.